Transcript Hearts and Minds’: developing inclusion through initial
‘Hearts and Minds’: developing inclusion through initial teacher education
Dr Des Hewitt University of Derby Dr Helen Taylor Northumbria University Dr Glendra Read Institute of Education
Focus of presentation
Background to the SEN/ disability training materials and placements;
Case studies in the use of the TDA primary undergraduate SEN/ disability training materials and extended special school placements.
NQT Survey
Newly Qualified Teacher survey 2009
49% of training rated good/ very good for SEN training 85% of training rated good/ very good for overall training TDA (2009): Results of the NQT survey 2009 Enhanced Placement Opportunity very worthwhile. Had prior experience already.
Useful placement within a special setting. Not much practice in Uni. Exit survey (University of Derby 2009)
Overview of SEN regional HE clusters
Trial of TDA SEN disability training materials (18 taught sessions) and four week extended placements in special provision: Eight regional clusters to support ITE providers in SEN/ disability Professional development for ITE tutors in SEN/ disability Student and tutor outcomes
East Midlands Cluster partners and aims
Aims Trial TDA SEN materials and extended placements Support each other through a collaborative approach Professional development for ITE tutors
• • • • • •
Universities Bishop Grosseteste Derby Hull Leeds Metropolitan Leeds Trinity Nottingham Trent
• •
Primary undergraduate initial teacher education Secondary undergraduate from 2009 Develop sustainability in the cluster
How the cluster worked
Three (termly) meetings of ITE tutors at different institutions: review of progress and professional development through invited speakers; Visits by lead institution tutors to each of the other institutions: Observation of teaching (University and schools); Discussion with tutors and students Written feedback following visits
What helped the cluster work
Dates for the
year ahead
; Regular and timely
communication
;
‘Sensitive’
direction from the lead institution; Recognition that we are at
different points on the journey;
Open dialogue
with all colleagues to identify the best ways of
adapting to
and
adapting training materials and placement experiences
;
Professional development
for ITE colleagues
Northumbria University
Strengths and weaknesses of the SEN placement:
The students were extremely enthusiastic about the experience. ‘It’s really good – a new opportunity’. ‘It’s amazing – you’ve got to do everything right’. ‘You really get to know the children’. ‘I’ve really enjoyed it – I felt part of the team’. ‘I’ve picked up lots of strategies’. ‘Brilliant!’ There were no weaknesses mentioned about the placement experience.
See detailed feedback in additional handout
East Midlands Cluster outcomes
Student views
‘Special school experience was
transformational
’ ‘Essential to have a
direct experience
of special education’ ‘Whilst I learned strategies which will inform my practice in mainstream, the experience has
changed the way I think
about inclusion’ ‘Inclusive and creative learning and teaching:
Multi-sensory, purposeful, concrete, cross-curricular with over teaching….’
‘My
future
lies in special education’
ITE tutors
‘SEN/ disability training materials can be used
throughout our B.Ed and PGCE courses
.’ ‘We value the
pragmatic and supportive approach of the TDA’
‘We have to move beyond a
simplistic view of impact
.’ ‘SEN experience develops
student beliefs
teaching for all’ about learning and
The link between training, values and practice
AVRAMIDIS, E, BAYLISS, P. & BURDEN, R. (2000):
A Survey into Mainstream Teachers’ Attitudes Towards the Inclusion of Children with Special Educational Needs in the Ordinary School in one Local Education Authority. Educational Psychology, Vol. 20, No. 2, 2000 (p.207)
Training
The importance of training has been stressed in a number of surveys (Bowman, 1986; Center & Ward, 1987; Leyser
et al.
, 1994) and, in particular,
the importance of training in the formation of positive attitudes towards inclusion
was supported by the findings of Beh-Pajooh (1992) and Shimman (1990), based on teachers in a tertiary college. Both studied the attitudes of tertiary college teachers in the UK towards students with SEN and their inclusion into ordinary college courses.
Attitudes
Their findings showed that
such training.
college teachers who had been trained to teach students with learning difficulties expressed more favourable attitudes and emotional reactions to students with SEN and their inclusion, than did those who had no
Our study supports these findings because it not only revealed that teachers with substantial training were more positive to inclusion, but also indicated that
their training
.
their confidence in meeting IEP requirements was boosted as a result of
Attitude and skills
Another finding of our study is that the means of all the three components of attitude (cognitive, affective and conative) are significantly correlated with the mean of the skills. That is, respondents who perceived themselves as competent enough to cater for SEN pupils, appear to hold positive attitudes towards inclusion. This reinforces our finding about the importance of training; if skills arise out of skilled based training courses as well as out of careful and well-planned INSET courses where practitioners have the opportunity to discuss and plan collaboratively, then it can be anticipated that the more effective programmes on inclusion are offered to teachers, the more favourable will be their attitudes about inclusion.
Year 2 East Midlands Cluster
Develop approaches to evaluation and impact of SEN training; How can mentor training be improved to support trainees in this area?
How do we assess relevant aspects of QTS?
What are the outcomes in QTS cluster standards relating to SEN?
How can inter- and intra-provider moderation support improvement in QTS outcomes?
Issues
Apprenticeship model of ITT tends to be reproductive of placement school/ mentor strengths and weaknesses in relation to inclusion Majority of primary and secondary ITE is by PGCE route- surely there is no space left for an SEN placement on a PGCE course SEN special schools are very different to a mainstream context: challenge of transferring/ generalizing practice from one to the other.
Managing trainee perceptions: trainees can have a polarized view of ITT SEN provision – “Have we had a session on inclusion?” Placement experiences, values and views of inclusive learning have a strong impact on trainees. These can be positive and emancipating or negative and destructive.
Assumption that University tutors have sufficient subject knowledge.
Need for ITE sector and SEN charities/ NASEN to establish a stronger dialogue.
Need for stronger dialogue between ITE providers in relation to inclusion: What is it and how can we best work together to promote inclusive education for all learners?