Language development of four-year

Download Report

Transcript Language development of four-year

A framework to bridge theory and practice in work with parents

Peter Hannon

School of Education University of Sheffield, England

Why work with parents?

• children spend more time at home than in ECE settings • parents can offer more one-to-one interaction • home activities often more meaningful • parents have flexibility to exploit learning opportunities • parents highly committed to children’s development How can Early Childhood Educators support and enhance parents’ role?

Take ideas from Vygotskyan theory . . .

• Development is about acquiring cultural tools • Learning is social - in dyads and groups • ZPD learning facilitated by those more expert

Relevance to work with parents

• Families transmit culture • Family is a key social context for young child • In families, parents are the more expert • Parents can recognise child’s unique ZPD

Some related concepts ……..

• Scaffolding (Wood, Bruner & Ross, 1976) • Informal learning (Rogoff & Lave, 1984) • Successive approximation (Newman, Griffin & Cole, 1989) • Modelling, managing contingencies, feedback (Tharp & Gillmore, 1991)

ALL ADDS UP TO SOCIO-CULTURAL VIEW

Working with parents

I suggest that a socio-cultural view highlights 4 ways parents help development

1. Opportunities

for children’s learning

2. Recognition 3. Interaction

of their progress – various forms

4. Model

of an expert practitioner O-R-I-M 

ORIM

framework

The ORIM framework

A way of recognising what parents already do A way of understanding what we are trying to change in early childhood work with parents

1. Opportunities All learning requires appropriate opportunities.

Parents can provide opportunities through materials, space, time, permission.

No opportunities, no learning.

2. Recognition

Learning is facilitated by someone who recognises where the learner is in the ZPD Parents can recognise the lower and upper limits of child’s ZPD.

They can recognise child’s successive approximations to expert performance (sometimes noticing first small steps)

3. Interaction

Learning occurs through interactions, e.g.

recruitment to tasks scaffolding marking critical features frustration control managing contingencies providing feedback direct instruction

4. Modelling

Learners are helped by having role models.

Models can help children understand the purpose of expert performance and encourage them to learn.

Parents can provide powerful models

See development in strands - example of literacy SOME EARLY LITERACY STRANDS

See development in strands - example of literacy SOME EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Print Environmental print Packaging Adverts Street signs TV texts Junk mail

See development in strands - example of literacy SOME EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Print Books Environmental print Good quality children’s books Packaging Picture books Adverts Story books Street signs Non-fiction TV texts Junk mail

See development in strands - example of literacy SOME EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Print Books Writing Environmental print Good quality children’s books Packaging Picture books Adverts Story books Street signs Non-fiction TV texts Early mark making Invented spellilng Writing to communicate Junk mail

See development in strands - example of literacy SOME EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Print Books Writing Oral Language Environmental print Good quality children’s books Packaging Picture books Adverts Story books Street signs Non-fiction TV texts Early mark making Invented spellilng Writing to communicate Storytelling Vocabulary Phonological awareness Talk about written language Junk mail

The ORIM framework

Relates concepts of

O

pportunities,

R

ecognition,

I

nteraction and

M

odel to strands of development.

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

What do parents already do in each cell in framework?

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

Can we add to what parents do?

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

The ORIM framework

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

Can we affect all cells?

Print EARLY LITERACY STRANDS Books Writing Oral Language Opportunities PARENTS PROVIDE Recognition Interaction Model

Research questions – two studies 1. Do early childhood educators find ORIM comprehensible and useful?

2. Can ORIM be used to generate a parent involvement programme and, if so, does it affect children’s development?

Research carried in collaboration with Cathy Nutbrown, also at Sheffield.

• • • • Study 1: Educators’ use of ORIM Qualitative study of 24 early childhood education settings using ORIM Staff from settings attended six 2-hour professional development sessions Developed work with parents over a 10 month period Data: range of written self reports Hannon, P. & Nutbrown, C. (1997) Teachers’ use of a conceptual framework for early literacy education involving parents. Teacher Development , 1 (3), 405-420

Study 1: Findings • Educators find ORIM comprehensible “It helps to get thoughts and ideas clearer” • Educators find ORIM useful “It has focused my mind on exactly how parents can work with their children” “It lends value to what parents already do and invites them into a partnership”

Study 2: An intervention

Preschool family literacy programme.

Low intensity, long-duration (12-18 months) Offered to parents in disadvantaged areas.

Some families bilingual (9%) Parents of 3-year-olds invited to join programme before school entry Nutbrown, C.E, Hannon, P., & Morgan, A (2005)

Early literacy education with families

. London: SAGE Publications

Programme, based on ORIM framework, consisted of

 Home visits by programme teachers  Provision of literacy resources  Centre-based group activities  Special events (e.g. group library visit)  Postal communication  Optional, literacy-related adult education for parents Teachers given half a day per week to work with a group of 8 families

Programme evaluation

• Qualitative and quantitative • Practitioner reflections and peer interviews • Analysis of activity records • Post-programme interviews of parents • Post-programme interviews of children • Randomised control trial to determine effects on children’s literacy (N=176

)

Measures of children’s development

• • • Pre-programme:Sheffield Early Literacy

Development Profile

(1997); (SELDP) – Nutbrown

British Picture Vocabulary Scale

– Revised (BPVS – II); Letter Recognition – Clay (1985)

End-of-programme:

As for pre-programme

School follow-up:

Aggregate score of national assessments in literacy

Implementation of programme • High take-up • Low drop-out • Generally high participation profile (92% of families participated ‘regularly’; 45% at highest possible level)

Parents views of programme • Overwhelmingly positive views • ‘Sad’ about programme ending • Difficult to elicit any negative views • Reported ‘global’ and specific literacy benefits for children • Would recommend it to other parents

Children’s experience • According to parent and teacher reports, children enjoyed programme • Children in programme group reported greater range of literacy experiences than those in control group

Teachers’ views • Strongly welcomed the opportunity to work with families • Cautiously positive view about benefits to children and parents

Effects on parents • Parents reported more confidence, particularly in helping children, but few reports of gains in own literacy.

• In 10% of families, parents (all mothers) took accredited course based on ORIM.

Impact on children’s literacy, measured in ‘effect size’

A way of expressing the difference between the programme group and control group mean scores in terms of the standard deviation of control group scores.

A way of judging the educational, rather than the statistical, significance of difference.

Seeking effect size ≥ 0.3

1.2

Impact on children’s literacy, measured in ‘effect size’

Whole sample 1 Low family income 0.8

Boys 0.6

Father lower SES 0.4

Mother lower SES 0.2

0 Mother without any educational qualifications -0.2

Pre programme End-of programme School follow up

Study 2: Findings

     ORIM helps generate preschool literacy programme Socio-cultural view of development can be shared with parents Parents welcome programme Children’s development can be affected (Note that impact is

indirect

) Most impact is for families with poorly educated mothers

Overall conclusion

ORIM could be a useful conceptual framework to bridge theory and practice in work with parents.