Transcript Document
The NFA Examination Process
March 5, 2015
Patricia Cushing, Director, Compliance
Michael Braden, Manager, Compliance
J.P. Bruynes, Partner, Akin Gump Strauss
Hauer & Feld LLP
Risk-Based Exam Selection
2
Commenced development of NFA’s Risk Management
System in 2006
System analyzes the risk factors associated with each firm
Generally, NFA examines IBs, CPOs and CTAs every 3-5
years
More frequent exams if risk factors deem necessary
Risk Factors that May Prompt an Examination
3
Customer complaints
Business background of principals
Concerns noted during a review of the firm’s promotional
materials, disclosure documents and/or financial filings
Referrals received from other agencies/members
Time since registration or last exam
Use of PQR and PR Data in Risk Analysis
4
Funds under management
Degree of leverage
Types of investments
Performance Returns
How to Prepare for an NFA Exam
5
Self-Examination Checklist
First step toward a successful NFA exam
General operations checklist
Supplemental checklists for FCMs, IBs, CPOs and CTAs
Signed attestation required
Other Available Resources
6
Publication: NFA Regulatory Requirements for FCMs, IBs, CPOs
and CTAs
NFA Podcast (10 minutes): “Preparing for an NFA Audit”
NFA Podcast (10 minutes): “Registration Issues – Principals, APs
and Branch Offices”
Appendices to Self-Exam Checklist: ethics training, privacy policy
and disaster recovery
NFA Exam Process
7
Pre-exam
“Fieldwork”
Planning Interview
Opening and Exit
Initial Record Request
Interviews
Document
Review/Testing
Additional Record
Requests
Completion of Exam
Report
Corrective Action
Areas of Focus
and Common Deficiencies
Areas of Focus
9
Renewed Focus on Internal Controls
Policies and Procedures
Separation of Duties
Access
Backgrounds of Key Personnel
Due Diligence
Risk Management
Areas of Focus
10
Registration of APs and Principals
Promotional Material
Account Opening
Trading
Bunched Orders
Supervision
Category-Specific Areas of Focus
11
CPOs and CTAs
FCMs, FDM and IBs
Disclosure and Performance
Anti-Money Laundering
Reporting
Handling of Pool Funds
Financial Reporting and
Valuation of Assets
Procedures
Automated Order Routing
Systems
Financial Statements (Net
Capital and Seg)
Bylaw 1101: Due Diligence
12
Does the account appear to require registration?
If not, why not (exemption, offshore)
If yes, why and is it registered?
Is the pool operator an NFA member?
Annually, review exempt entities (exemption affirmation)
Bylaw 1101: Where to Look
13
BASIC-Registration Status
Part 4 Exemption Look-Up in ORS and BASIC
Ask client for copy of exemption
In all cases, document findings
Areas of Focus on All Categories
14
Promotional Materials and Sales Practices
Procedures, review and approval
Balanced presentation
Registration, Common Deficiencies
Unlisted principals and branch offices; unregistered APs; APs not terminated
Failing to update registration records
Tape Recording Requirements
FCMs, IBs and certain CTAs
Anti-Money Laundering Program
15
Applies to FCMs, FDMs and IBs
Establish appropriate red flags
Monitor for suspicious activity
Provide training every 12 months
Conduct an independent AML audit every 12 months
Other IB Areas
16
Commissions Receivable
Can only be current for 30 days
Current Financial Books and Records
Net capital computations are required to be prepared and maintained on a monthly
basis—requires current general ledgers and reconciliations
Haircut Charges
Balances held in foreign currencies are subject to a haircut charge against
capital
Bunched Orders
17
Procedures for allocating split fills or partial fills
CTA must conduct a quarterly review of accounts to
ensure that bunched orders are allocated in a nonpreferential manner
Pool Financial Reporting, Valuation of Assets
and Handling of Pool Funds
18
Common Deficiencies: Incomplete Account Statements
Information only included for the individual pool participant
Statements must include information for the pool as a whole
Statements do not properly itemize all required information
Pool Financial Reporting
19
Required information is missing beneath the oath on each
account statement:
The name of the individual signing the account statement
The capacity in which he or she is signing
The name of the commodity pool operator for whom he or she is signing
The name of the commodity pool for which the statement is being distributed
NFA Compliance Rule 2-45
20
Prohibition on Pools loaning money to the CPO or an
affiliate:
Interpretive Notice outlines permissible transactions
Receivables from General Partner may be deemed “loans” in certain
circumstances
Disclosure Documents
and Performance Reporting
21
Operations inconsistent with disclosure
Fees
Redemptions
Trading strategy
Conflicts of interest
Banks, carrying brokers, custodians
GP and/or CTA ownership interest
Performance Recordkeeping
Supporting worksheets
Partial funding documentation
Thank you.