Transcript Slide 1
SAMI Consulting, St Andrews Management Institute Scenario Planning Why it is needed and how it works Gill Ringland CEO & Fellow, SAMI Consulting CIMA 5th May 2011 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 1 Agenda The world is turbulent Financial crisis Systemic forces No return to Business As Usual How scenarios help organisations Forecasts and scenarios Communicating scenarios Scenarios as part of renewal Three case studies Public engagement Visioning Strategy 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 2 Its not going as it should ---- Debt Financial crisis Bank bailouts Ongoing effects 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 3 US Consumer debt 3000 2500 2000 (money of the day: US GDP grew by 8 times in the period) Consumers 1500 1000 Commerce 500 1952 1962 1972 1982 1992 2002 ‘09 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 4 Bank bailouts Expenditure $US bn 2008 2009-12 Obama stimulus plan Louisiana purchase Marshall Moon plan shot S&L crisis Korean war The New Deal Iraq war 2008 tranche of the bank bailout Viet Nam NASA, less moon shot 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 5 Outcomes by country? Slow return to health; US consumer stage centre Banking crisis remain chronic, as does state intervention Japan UK US Economic situation develops independently of the banking crisis Slow grind to expunge debt; some deliberate use of monetary inflation Prolonged depression, growing statist environment Euro zone Middle income industrialising India The economic situation is completely predicated on the banking crisis China Banking crisis is settled relatively quickly 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 Business grows as before 6 What else could be happening? Population Demographics Systemic forces Education Values Energy Environment Interconnectedness 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 7 Population & Education levels 9 World population (billions) 9 Total world population Secondary education Graduate-level education 6 6 Asia 3 3 Africa Latin America Europe North America 1950 1975 2000 2025 1850 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 1900 1950 2000 2025 8 Demographics 3.5 3.0 2.5 Ratio of people under 16 years to people over 45 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 Africa S America Asia 1988 Oceania 1998 N America 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 Europe 2008 Time 9 Values Relevance to a moral decision Harm Fairness Affiliation Authority Purity Decreasing traditionalism 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 10 Energy pressures Gigajoules per capita 400 USA 300 200 Europe, Japan, Korea 100 China, India 0 0 17/07/2015 10 20 GDP per capita www.samiconsulting.co.uk 30 40 11 Environmental pressures The logarithm of the ratio of the current situation to the probable long term sustainable limit: these have been breached already Carbon dioxide Change in land use Species extinction rate 0 Freshwater use Nitrogen cycle Sustainable limit Ocean acidification Phosphorus cycle Stratospheric ozone depletion 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 12 WEF Global Risks 2011 Perceived impact US BN $ 1000 100 Perceived likelihood in next 10 years 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 13 Interconnectedness Rich nations 15% world population 90% world wealth Poor nations 60% world population < 1% world wealth 17/07/2015 ©2009 Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow Industrialising nations 25% world population 9% world wealth www.samiconsulting.co.uk 14 Here be dragons ------ 17/07/2015 ©2009 Ringland www.samiconsulting.co.uk 15 How can scenario planning help? Forecasts Scenario planning Scenarios How it works Cycle of renewal 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 16 London population forecasts 9 8 1991 forecast 7 6 5 Actual Forecast now 4 3 2 1 0 1951 1971 1991 2006 2016 A trend is a trend until it bends 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 17 Forecasts miss the point Single point forecast Today Range of other uncertainties Trends Uncertain timing 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk ©Beyond Crisis, Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow, John Wiley 2010 18 Scenario planning Number of Possible Future Worlds Scenario planning attempts to describe what is possible. The result of a scenario analysis is a group of distinct futures, all of which are plausible. They are mental models. B C A D Future Present 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 19 How scenario thinking works Ingvar, a neurobiologist, found that the human brain is constantly attempting to explore options for the future even while we are asleep Mental models of the world provide a context for these explorations “memories of the future” act as a filter to signals. Scenarios provide several alternative model future worlds for the brain to explore increases the range of “what we have experienced” and “what is relevant to our future” increases the ability of the brain to perceive. . Source: D. Ingvar, “Memory of the Future”, Human Neurobiology, 4(3), p127-136, 1985 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 20 Communicating scenarios Scenarios are mental models - artifacts Communication method depends on audience Engineers & scientists – comparator tables Managers – brief “Public” – visualisation & stories All audiences helped by early indicators Newspaper headlines now if this scenario is developing Plus All audiences need discussion time to internalise, eg “What are the implications for me/the organisation? “ “How would I/the organisation manage in this scenario?” 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 21 Scenarios & the renewal cycle Road maps Innovation Policy and strategy Asset allocation Internal Audit of scanning capability Horizon scanning 17/07/2015 © 2009 Lustig, Ringland, Sparrow Organisational & leadership development Scenarios Review Narrative www.samiconsulting.co.uk 22 Three examples Public engagement Seattle Visioning Natural England Strategy 17/07/2015 Scotland www.samiconsulting.co.uk 23 Seattle 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 24 Public Engagement - Schools White “flight to the suburbs” leaving Seattle Seattle public schools had problems Enrolment dropped Voters refused to support education bonds Schools decayed & staff leaving Teachers Union with GBN set up a project team from a diverse set of stakeholders Old/young Male/female White/black Employers/students/teachers Asked questions for the future of the schools Will changes to the social fabric be turbulent or healthy? Will the rate of change be slow/resistant or rapid/embracing? 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 25 What future do we want? Rapid Turbulent Social Rio The Change Rate of change Mosaic Healthy fabric Tweaking the Edges Slow/resistant 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 26 What happened next The City agreed with the team after wide consultation and town meetings etc that The Change was the desirable scenario Schools as community centres Use of ICT Pre-school & adult education Students rather than schools funded Business took an active role Unemployed adults as classroom assistants On the basis of The Change scenario as a vision, Seattle City passed two school bonds to get funding Revision of governance of schools & teachers seniority rules Use of ex-military as Headmasters Seattle became a beacon for educationalists across the US 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 27 Natural England 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 28 Visioning to 2060 for NE Project took from September 2008 to September 2009 Natural England & stakeholders formed team with SAMI Feedback to NE Board and Senior Management Team 3 workshops to develop scenarios 50 people at each Natural England pro-actively involved other agencies Test with 6 groups of stakeholders & Board experts on uplands, woodlands, marine, ---- Engage with “not the usual suspects” in the public School children, inner city, small business, prosperous rural Create Vision for the English natural environment 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 29 Natural England scenarios Continuing as we are: present trends extended Focus on consumption, ignore limits Environmental and financial crises force protectionist worldview. Head in the Sand 17/07/2015 Protect and Be Damned Focus on productivity, ignore long-range consequences. Global competition forces innovations for sustainable efficiency. Focus on ICT, ignore disruptive effects of social networking Digital people connect to web of life & leave national power brokers powerless. So Far, Environmental So Good Guardians www.samiconsulting.co.uk Policy emphases and dangers Backlash Possible future outcomes 34 Contribution to Vision Findings “the most important thing we have done” (from a Board member) include: Importance of marine environment Young people assume technology will fix the environment Outside London found great engagement with “Protect and be Damned” Balance food needs vs “the environment” The Scenario Report and related documents are on http://naturalengland.etraderstores.com/NaturalEnglandShop/NERR31 ditto NECR030 Ditto NECR031 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 35 Scotland 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 36 Strategy – Scotland & Napier Scenarios for Scotland (S4S) project Set models for new devolved administration Analogies with ? Norway? Finland? Use of S4S at Napier University Set strategy for new team Five year plan Five years later Use of SAMI global drivers to plan for next 5 years 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 37 Scenarios for Scotland (S4S) Purpose: set agenda for new devolved government – what sort of country should Scotland aspire to be? Timing as new Scottish Parliament set up 10 sponsors, from private sector & Government, managed by SAMI plus St Andrews and Strathclyde Universities, 1,000 interviews, 50 + focus groups Launched on St Andrews Day 1999 High Road scenario, “can do” Low Road scenario, “government’s fault” Used by Scottish Enterprise, Scottish Executive & politicians to formulate policy and strategy eg focus on entrepreneurs, capacity building and new enterprises eg attracting students and keeping graduates in Scotland 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 38 Scenarios for Scotland Economy and Quality of Life High Road scenario - “can do” possible upward triggers between scenarios Graduate education Entrepreneurs Natural advantages Low Road -“government’s fault” – Business as Usual 2000 17/07/2015 2005 2010 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 2015 39 Using scenarios New University Principal and new Senior Management Team (SMT) at Napier University in 2003 Needed to create a common language and strategic plan Used the Scenarios for Scotland to frame a discussion What scenario for Scotland? Did the University need to share the Scotland scenario? Two day workshop discussion led to 37 actions and new Strategic Plan To change from technical college with mostly local, undergraduate engineering students Target: Use positives of Edinburgh brand to become global Use positives of Edinburgh Festival to connect with Arts Develop Masters courses with global focus 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 40 Path for Napier? the University Global ? ? New courses, University new students Local Graduate education X ? Scotland Low Road 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk High Road 41 Five years later Phone call to SAMI in 2008 We’ve done that, met our targets Will you help us with a plan for the next five years? Used the SAMI five global drivers of change Globalisation Climate change Raw materials Technology People Workshop discussion allowed SMT to calibrate what was achievable, desirable, and to set targets for the next five years Changed name to Edinburgh Napier University. 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 42 Summary The world is turbulent Financial crisis Systemic forces No return to Business As Usual How scenarios help organisations Forecasts and scenarios Communicating scenarios Scenarios as part of renewal Three case studies Public engagement Visioning Strategy 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 43 Thank you! Some of this is covered in the book “Beyond Crisis” – there is a sample on the table. If you would like to get our monthly enewsletter eSAMI ---- please give me your business card! And if this has whetted your appetite to learn more there are flyers with details of Futures Coaching courses that SAMI runs for the Government Office for Science, also on the table. 17/07/2015 www.samiconsulting.co.uk 44