Transcript Document
The Public Health Knowledge Base
Using Public Health Data
Ron Bialek
Public Health Foundation
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
1
Preview
Essential Public Health Services Does anybody really use these things?
Healthy People 2010 - Our nation’s
prevention agenda
Data and Information - The friends of
public health
Using Data - Getting from here to there
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
2
Essential Public Health Services
Monitor health status to identify
community health problems
Diagnose and investigate health problems
and health hazards in the community
Inform, educate, and empower people
about health issues
Mobilize community partnerships to
identify and solve health problems
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
3
Essential Public Health Services
Develop policies and plans that support
individual and community health efforts
Enforce laws and regulations that protect
health and ensure safety
Link people to needed personal health
services and assure the provision of
health care when otherwise unavailable
Assure a competent public health and
personal health care workforce
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
4
Essential Public Health Services
Evaluate effectiveness, accessibility,
and quality of personal and
population-based health services
Research for new insights and
innovative solutions to health
problems
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
5
Public Health Scenario
substance
abuse
sexual assault
clinical depression
nutrition
suicide
pre-natal care
sexually transmitted
diseases
cardiovascular disease
domestic violence
environmental hazards
unintended injuries
family planning
post-partum
depression
infertility
HIV/AIDS
TB
eating disorder
breast cancer
communicable diseases
chronic diseases
cervical cancer
Quality Improvement
National Health Objectives
Performance Standards
Accountability
Workforce Competencies
Expenditures
Research
Evidence Base
National Healthy People
Initiative
The nation’s
prevention agenda
Set of measurable
objectives to improve
health of Americans
A health improvement
framework that states
may adopt or adapt
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
8
State Plans are All
Custom Made
“Taking the national Healthy People
framework and customizing it for local
needs is one of the hallmarks of this
initiative.”
— Dr. David Satcher
Surgeon General
June 24, 1998
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
9
Significance of Healthy People
2000
46 states created Healthy People plans
or used objectives in plans
Data systems
Community involvement
Benchmarking
Monitoring & reporting progress
Funding
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
10
6/00 Status of State*
Activities
*Based on PHF contact with 50 states, D.C., 3 territories
Not yet active
~25%
In planning process
~55%
(many preparing to plan)
Draft stage
~10%
Completed final plan
~10%
Opportunities for more
comprehensive plans
States and territories that have or plan to have
2010 objectives in…
Mental Health
46%
Substance Abuse
53%
Environmental Health
52%
Occupational Health
37%
Many left out these objectives in their 2000
plans (see “Chartbook”)
It’s like the lotto slogan...
“You can’t win
if you don’t play.”
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
13
New Directions for 2010
Sustain initiative beyond the plan
Share responsibility, define accountability
Capture and evaluate action
Market achievements
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
14
A Framework to Bring
Together ...
Policy
Science
Data
Data and Information
Health indicators
Denominators
Demographics
Assets/Services
Statistical methods
Comparability
7/17/2015
“Best practices”
Stories
Focus groups
Tools
Technical reports
MLA CE 2001
16
Who needs science anyway?
Science contributes to advances in public
health practice
We need to know what and how things
work
- Make the right choice the first time
Science influences policymakers
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
17
How do we get good science?
…..good data certainly help!
Health, social, and infrastructure
data from communities
Sound research methods
Descriptive research and “best
practices”
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
18
A Dime a Day on Public Health
That’s way too much money!!
Can you prove otherwise???
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
19
Connections with
Healthy People 2010
Determining effective interventions for
attaining health objectives
Identifying and learning from “best
practices”
Involving the practice community in
population-based research
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
20
Healthy People 2010 Objectives Categories
Essential Public Health Services
(Source: Public Health Functions Steering Committee)
Promote Health
Behaviors
Promote Healthy
and Safe
Communities
Improve
Systems for
Personal and
Public Health
Prevent and
Reduce Disease
and Disorders
Chapters
Objectives (singular or grouped)
1.
Monitor health status to identify community
health problems
2.
Diagnose and investigate health problems
and health hazards in the community
3.
Inform, educate, and empower people about
health issues
4.
Mobilize community partnerships to identify
and solve health problems
5.
Develop policies and plans that support
individual and community health efforts
6.
In each box….
Enforce laws and regulations that protect
health and ensure safety
7.
Link people to needed personal health
services and assure the provision of health
care when otherwise unavailable
8.
Assure a competent public
personal health care workforce
9.
Evaluate effectiveness, accessibility, and
quality of personal and population-based
health services
10.
health
Research for new insights and innovative
solutions to health problems
and
What do we need to know to be effective — interventions, causes,
methodological research?
What do we know?
Info being used?
Need to better disseminate?
Need to better translate?
What do we not know?
What specific questions need to be answered?
What research is underway and when will it be completed?
Priority setting…
Take key dimensions of columns and rows
How important to know to deliver EPHS?
How doable? How easy to answer question?
New and improved
opportunities for 2010
10 Leading Health Indicators
- Opportunities to focus systems on cross-cutting
issues, data needs
Business and community partners
- Partnership for a Healthy Workforce
- Healthy People Consortium
Commitment to eliminate disparities
- Broader players and strategies
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
22
Leading Health
Indicators
Physical Activity
Mental Health
Overweight & Obesity Injury and Violence
Tobacco Use
Environmental Quality
Substance Abuse
Immunization
Responsible Sexual
Behavior
Access to Health Care
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
23
Healthy People Data
Tracking Healthy
People 2010
In Healthy People 2010
Conference Edit., Vol.II
DATA2010
Online - HP 2010 site
CHSI data sets
Online, print
Other State/Local
Sources
“Chartbook” on PHF
web site, HP 2010
Assistance
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
24
Resource Web Sites
Healthy People 2010
www.health.gov/healthypeople/
Healthy People 2010 Toolkit
www.health.gov/healthypeople/state/toolkit
State Healthy People 2010 Tool Library
www.phf.org/HPtools/state.htm
Healthy People 2010 Partners
www.health.gov/healthypeople/partners
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
25
Community Health Status
Indicators (CHSI) Reports
www.communityhealth.hrsa.gov
3,082 reports/counties
Source information
Peer counties
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
26
CHSI...
Profiles County Health
Population characteristics
Vulnerable populations
Overall health
Leading causes of death
Important measures of birth and death
Environmental health
Preventive services use
Risk factors
Access to care
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
27
CHSI...
Baseline for the Next Decade
3, 5, or 10 Year period depending on
size
Year 2000 standard for ageadjustment
Period: 1988-98
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
28
CHSI...
Where do the Data Come From?
National Sources
-
Census
NCHS
CDC
HRSA
SAMHSA
EPA
State and Local Health Departments
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
29
CHSI Enumerates
Vulnerable Populations
7/17/2015
<H.S. education
Unemployed
Severe work-disability
Major depression
Recent drug use
No health insurance
Medicare eligible
(elderly and disabled)
MLA CE 2001
30
CHSI Includes HP 2010
Goals and Objectives
Selected
objectives
- Birth measures
- Infant mortality
- Cause-specific
mortality
7/17/2015
HP 2010 target
US rate
Peer range
Icon
- Favorable
- Unfavorable
MLA CE 2001
31
CHSI...
Peer Communities
88 Peer groupings
Average of 34
peers
7/17/2015
Peers designated using:
Frontier status
Population size
Poverty
Age composition
Density
MLA CE 2001
32
Relative Health
Importance
Some Desirable Indicators
Are Not Available
–Children
• Indicators of children’s
preventive services use —
such as immunizations,
dental caries, and
prevalence of lead
screening — must be
obtained locally.
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
34
CHSI…
Sparks a Conversation
Discussing with Health Official
Helping to engage leaders and
other members of the community
Creating a forum with the media
Providing support and resources
for filling data gaps
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
35
CHSI Helps Engage
Several Audiences
Policy makers
Program managers
and planners
Assessment and
evaluation staff
Advocates and
consumers
Other partners
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
36
CHSI...
Who’s Using It?
Local Boards of Health
Community Hospitals
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
Anthem Alliance Health Insurance
Company
Universities
General Accounting Office
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
37
“Best Practices”
“Best judgment” has served us well
“Best practices” will serve us better
Rigor can be applied to
determination of “best practice”
There is an immediate need to
identify and communicate successful
strategies
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
38
The Catch
You have to know the practice
before you can know
the best practice
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
39
Determining “Best Practice”
Establish criteria
Search literature, the Internet, and
query experts
Apply criteria to identify “best
practices”
Analyze and synthesize information
Disseminate findings
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
40
Health Improvement Progress
-- Breast Cancer, 1993-97
Improving
HP 2010 Met
HP 2010 Not
Met
Exemplary
350
11%
Progressing
928
30%
Not Improving
Maintaining
256
8%
Static
1548
50%
Toolkit - 7 Action Areas
- Building the Foundation: Leadership and Structure
- Identifying and Securing Resources
- Identifying and Engaging Community Partners
- Setting Health Priorities and Establishing Objectives
- Obtaining Baseline Measures, Setting Targets, and
Measuring Progress
- Managing and Sustaining the Process
- Communicating Health Goals and Objectives
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
42
Each Action Area Includes...
a brief explanation & rationale
a checklist of major activities
tips for success
national and state examples
recommended “hot picks" of resources
planning tools - easy to adapt
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
43
State Healthy People 2010
Tool Library
EXAMPLES: Setting
Health Priorities...
EXAMPLES:
Setting Targets...
Priority Setting Options
handout and
presentation (DE)
Process Guidance (MD)
Facilitator “Survival Kit”
and Meeting Ground
Rules (IA)
Target Setting Algorithm
and Worksheets (DE)
Missouri Resource
Guide for Community
Assessment
“Tools of the Trade”
data guides (PA)
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
44
Mass Communication
Campaign for STD Prevention
Key Words - “sexually transmitted
diseases” and “media”
Healthy People 2010
Information Access Project
….an easy way to search
PubMed to find effective
strategies.
Partners in Information Access for Public
Health Professionals
National Library of Medicine, National
Network of Libraries of Medicine, and
Public Health Foundation
PIAPHP Home
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov:80/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=PureSearch&db=PubMed&details_ter
m=%28%28%28%28%28%28%28%22united%20states%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%20AND
%20%28%28%28%28%28%28%28%22education%2C%20medical%22%5BMeSH%20Major%2
0Topic%5D%20OR%20%22education%2C%20dental%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%
29%20OR%20%22education%2C%20nursing%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%20
OR%20%22education%2C%20pharmacy%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%20OR%
20%22students%2C%20health%20occupations%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%2
0OR%20%22schools%2C%20public%20health%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%2
0OR%20allied%20health%20personnel/education%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%20
OR%20physician%20assistants/education%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%29%20AN
D%20%28%28%28%22minority%20groups%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%20OR%20
%22hispanic%20americans%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%20OR%20%22blacks
%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%20OR%20%22indians%2C%20north%20america
n%22%5BMeSH%20Major%20Topic%5D%29%29%20AND%20%28%28%28%28%28%28%28%
28%28%28%28%28%22education%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%20OR%20%22curriculum%2
2%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20OR%20%22student%20dropouts%22%5BMeSH%20Terms
%5D%29%20OR%20%22educational%20measurement%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20
OR%20%22career%20choice%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20OR%20%22training%20su
pport%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20OR%20%22school%20admission%20criteria%22
%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20OR%20%22cultural%20diversity%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%
5D%29%20OR%20%22mentors%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20OR%20%28affirmative
%5BAll%20Fields%5D%20AND%20action%5BAll%20Fields%5D%29%29%20OR%20%22preju
dice%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20OR%20recruitment%5BAll%20Fields%5D%29%20
OR%20%22staff%20development%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%29%20NOT%20%22pati
ent%20education%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20NOT%20%22transcultural%20nursing
%22%5BMeSH%20Terms%5D%29%20AND%20English%5BLang%5D%29%20AND%20%28%
221996/03/24%2014.29%22%5BEDat%5D%20%3A%20%222001/03/23%2014.29%22%5BEDat
%5D%29%29
Search PubMed
Six Focus Areas/Chapters
Access to Health
Services
- Mary E. Ryan
Food Safety
- Marcia Zorn
- Mary E. Ryan
PH Infrastructure
- Mary E. Ryan
7/17/2015
Disability/Secondary
Conditions
- Ron Gordner
Respiratory Diseases
- Anne Maria Baxter
Environmental Health
- Stacey Arnesen
- Lucie Chen
- Deena Pers
MLA CE 2001
49
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
50
7/17/2015
Source:
HUD
MLA CE 2001
51
Rural Empowerment Zones & Enterprise Communities
Round I EZ
Round I EC
Round II EZ
Source: USDA
Round II EC
January 1999
Health Capacity Factor 1:
Interest and commitment to health
Half of EZ/ECs would
use their own staff
and more than a
quarter would use
both staff and
financial resources for
health improvement
activities
Interested but not top
priority
Interest level
Many EZ/EC
respondents (88%)
reported interest in
health issues and 39%
consider them a top
priority
Figure 9. Interest in addressing health issues
in the EZ/EC (n=119) Q7.
49%
Interested and among top
priorities
39%
4%
No opinion
1%
Not interested
7%
No response
0%
10%
20%
30%
Percent
40%
50%
60%
What is the Science Base?
Apply scientific rigor
to quantitative and
qualitative
information
Apply reasonable
and appropriate
scientific standards
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
54
Yogi Berra New York Yankees
“90% of this game is half mental”
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
55
"The
time has come. The time is
now. Just go. Go. GO! I don’t care
how.”
7/17/2015
MLA CE 2001
56