Transcript Yikes
Presentation of
But Your Honor…the Nurse Said… or I was only doing my job.
Fall Conference September 22, 2013
Lisa Zokas Kindy, JD
Use by Permission
ANNA Long Island Chapter 122
Presented by
Michael P. Luna, RN, DNP, MPA, NC-BC, CNN
Nurse Manager
Stony Brook Kidney Center, DCI
East Setauket, NY
Number of Malpractice Allegations
Against NP’s by year.
350
300
250
Series 1
200
Column1
150
Column2
100
50
0
2007
2008
2009
2010
Legal Actions
The Parties
Civil Negligence
Plaintiff (patient) v Defendant (doctor, nurse, hospital
etc.) for money damages.
Criminal Action
State (Prosecutor) v Defendant (Perpetrator) for punishment.
A nurse was too good at predicting when patients would
expire. The hospital notified the police who came to the
hospital and to the nursing unit and arrested and handcuffed
the nurse. She was crying as she was led away. Fortunately,
there were no basis to the allegations and she was released.
2009 CNA Health Pro & Nurse Service
Organization: Malpractice Claims 1998-2008
Steady Trend Upward:
Wrongful Death 40.5% of claims caused by infection.
Incorrect failure to diagnose 39%. Medication Error 18%.
Correlation with greater patient work loads,
handwritten medical records, and physician orders.
Top 3 Legal Problems Involving
Nurses.
Employment contract Issues-Non-compete clause
Firing/Termination Issues-Social Network comments,
Medical Record Issues, Prescription Error.
Improper Incident to Billing-Physician fee or NP fee.
Medical Malpractice Law Suit
Date of Occurrence
Statue of Limitations
Complaint and Summons
Answer
Discovery
Identification of Experts
Settle, Mediate, Trial
Appeal
Aftermath
Law Suit Summons and Complaint
Summons –Invitation, limited time to answer.
Complaint, Plaintiff (Patient) versus Defendant(s)
(Doctor, Nurse and Hospital)
Service of Process
Contact your liability carrier immediately and they will
assign an attorney who will file your answer.
Settle, Mediate or Trial
Elements the plaintiff must prove:
Duty to deliver Standards of Care.
Breach of duty
Damage
Proximate Cause
Standards of Care– what a reasonable Nurse would
have done in like or similar circumstances.
Statue of Limitations
The period of time from the date of the loss the patient
has to file the law suit, otherwise they are time barred.
Varies 1-3 years for an adult and 18 years for a child.
Identification of Experts
If specialized knowledge will assist the jury (trier of
fact) to understand the evidence a witness qualified as
an expect may testify in the form if an opinion.
It’s generally held that a nursing expert witness testify
about the standard of nursing care.
Help your attorney find an expert on your behalf, and
assist in critiquing plaintiff’s expect.
$Damages
Economic—lost wages, cost of medical care, life care
planning
Non-economic—pain and suffering, loss of
consortium.
Punitive—deterrent or punishment amount for willful
reckless conduct.
Deposition Set Up
Attorneys
Deponent
Plaintiff
Court Reporter
Videographer
Medical Record
Your personal documents.
Discovery Documents
Requests for Medical Records
Are you familiar with the documentation guidelines
for your dialysis clinic?
Documentation by Exception
If it wasn’t documented it wasn’t done.
Forms, Blanks
Habit and Training.
Discovery Deposition
Reading the Medical Record
Discussion of other documents
Independent Recollection
Explanation of your job, medical knowledge and
actions
Other participants with knowledge
Your Demeanor
Seeing the Plaintiff
Range of Emotions
Anxiety
Confusion (Why did they include you in the suit.)
It is important to keep your anxiety in check.
Your Resume
They may request your Resume
They will ask you if it is current.
They will ask you to explain what your responsibilities
were in the various jobs you held.
To establish your knowledge and experience.
Education
Certifications.
Dialysis Clinic Operations
What was your role in the dialysis clinic?
Who was your supervisor
Did you have a job description
What were your responsibilities
Is there any in-service training?
What were the responsibilities of the Medical Director,
Nurse Practitioner, PCT’s.
Event Testimony
Do your recall treating Mr. Patient?
No I do not.
So you have no independent recollection of Mr. Patient?
Your entire memory of Mr. Patient is contained in the record?
Yes, I do
Tell me about what happened.
How long had you treated Mr. Patient?
How did he appear to you.
Specific Questions-Discussion Not
Legal Advice
When do I buy my own malpractice insurance?
Could I be responsible if someone else did not chart what
they were supposed to do?
What do I do if the patient is non-compliant or has
unrealistic expectations?
The equipment malfunctions all the time, who do I call?
I think I need to call someone but what do I do?
How do I document my phone conversations with a
patient?
How do I document that I called the MD, or my supervisor?
How do I report an unexpected outcome?
Flow Sheet
Do you recall going over the flow sheet? Is this
something you ordinarily do?
How would you know how much volume was taken
off? Where is that determined?
Where is the section that shows the vital signs?
Where is the section that shows weight?
What is the translation from kg to pounds?
What is wet weight? What is dry weight?
What is the weight goal you are trying to achieve?
Who decides the goal weight?
Risk Management-Education and
Training
Work in an environment that is proactive.
Job training. Orientation and updates.
Keep abreast of new medical knowledge and
Guidelines. (Societies and Meetings).
Take a class. Teach a class. Give a presentation.
Document in your CV and update.