Transcript World Conservation Congress and Protected Areas – an

World Conservation Congress and Protected
Areas – a compendium of activities
Jeju 2012
What came out of the Call for Contributions ?
Proposals
Entered in the System
Eliminated at User’s request
Review process – phase 1 (cleaning and tidying)
Test proposals
Empty proposals
Incomplete proposals
Duplicates
Total valid proposals
Nb.
Proposals
Available
slots
Workshop
469
120
Knowledge Café
99
160
Poster
138
200
Conservation Campus
61
50
Total
767
530
Type
Nb.
1057
94
963
35
12
65
84
767
Note: 127 proposals were still in draft format
in the system, on the 31 October midnight. It
was decided to consider these proposals as
submitted if all the fields were completed
and the proposal appeared to be ready for
submission.
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
How the review and selection were done ?
Technical Review Team
•
Forum Strategic Panel
100+ reviewers from all IUCN Constituents;
•
10+ IUCN Senior Managers (HQ + Regions) and 2
Host Country rep.
•
Decision based on:
(Commissions, Council, Members, Scientific Advisory
Board, Secretariat, Partners, Host Country)
•
1 proposal  3 reviewers
(around 22 proposals per reviewer);
•
Technical review based on the 12 criteria endorsed
by CPC in April 2011;
•
Comments & recommendations based purely on
technical aspects.

Advice from Technical Review Team;

Strategic aspects;

Thematic/geographic spread.
Double-check on strategic aspects
•
All groupings were checked with Global Directors and Heads of Programme;
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
How the review and selection were done ?
Technical Review Team
•
Forum Strategic Panel
100+ reviewers from all IUCN Constituents;
•
10+ IUCN Senior Managers (HQ + Regions) and 2
Host Country rep.
•
Decision based on:
(Commissions, Council, Members, Scientific Advisory
Board, Secretariat, Partners, Host Country)
•
1 proposal  3 reviewers
(around 22 proposals per reviewer);
•
Technical review based on the 12 criteria endorsed
by CPC in April 2011;
•
Comments & recommendations based purely on
technical aspects.

Advice from Technical Review Team;

Strategic aspects;

Thematic/geographic spread.
Double-check on strategic aspects
•
All groupings were checked with Global Directors and Heads of Programme;
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
How the review and selection were done ?
Technical Review Team
•
Forum Strategic Panel
100+ reviewers from all IUCN Constituents;
•
10+ IUCN Senior Managers (HQ + Regions) and 2
Host Country rep.
•
Decision based on:
(Commissions, Council, Members, Scientific Advisory
Board, Secretariat, Partners, Host Country)
•
1 proposal  3 reviewers
(around 22 proposals per reviewer);
•
Technical review based on the 12 criteria endorsed
by CPC in April 2011;
•
Comments & recommendations based purely on
technical aspects.

Advice from Technical Review Team;

Strategic aspects;

Thematic/geographic spread.
Double-check on strategic aspects
•
All groupings were checked with Global Directors and Heads of Programme;
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
What came out of the review & selection process ?
1. Basics statistics
Nb.
Number of proposal reviewed
767
Commission reserved slots
Korea reserved slots
Framework donors reserved slots
Other reserved slots
Total reviewed proposals
Number of Technical reviewers
Number of proposals reviewed by each reviewer
Number of reviews per proposal
Highest ranking
Lowest ranking
Average ranking
Number of proposals accepted as “standalone”
Number of proposals clustered into groups
Number of proposals moved to another category
Number of proposals in b-list
Number of proposals rejected
24
10
9
3
721
103
22 (max. 53; min. 4)
3
99,3
16,3
70,4
234
175
145
22
145
33%
24%
20%
3%
20%
80% of the proposals received have been given a space in the Forum !!
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
What came out of the review & selection process ?
Workshops
Nb. Proposals
Accepted workshops
(standalone)
39
Nb.
clusters
Accepted workshops
(merged)
129
51
Total accepted workshops
90
Reserved slots
52
Available
slots
Total
142
140
Rejected workshops
100
Rankings
Workshops
Lowest
Average
Highest
61
81
99.3
b-list
56.5
71.2
82.5
Rejected
16.3
59.6
90
Accepted
Note: 3 organizers preferred to withdraw
their proposal rather than accept the
proposed grouping.
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
What came out of the review & selection process ?
Knowledge Cafés
Nb. Proposals
Accepted KC (standalone)
70
Nb.
clusters
Accepted KC (merged)
2
1
Total accepted KC
72
Moved to KC
69
Available
slots
Total Knowledge Café
140
160
Rejected KC
17
Rankings
Knowledge
Café
Lowest
Average
Highest
Accepted
41.7
71.9
89.7
Rejected
34.3
57.6
80
Note: 6 organizers preferred to withdraw
their proposal rather than accept to be
moved to the Knowledge Café.
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
What came out of the review & selection process ?
Posters
Nb. Proposals
Accepted Posters
(standalone)
119
Nb.
clusters
Accepted Posters
(merged)
4
2
Total accepted Posters
120
Moved to Poster
56
Available
slots
Total Posters
177
200
Rejected Posters
18
Rankings
Posters
Lowest
Average
Highest
Accepted
32
66.2
91.3
Rejected
29.7
56.2
73
Note: 12 organizers preferred to withdraw
their proposal rather than accept to be
moved to Posters.
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
What came out of the review & selection process ?
Conservation Campus
Nb. Proposals
Accepted Campus
(standalone)
33
Nb. clusters
Accepted Campus (merged)
19
9
Total accepted Campus
42
Moved to Campus
8
Available
slots
Total Conservation Campus
50
50
b-list
6
Rejected Campus
8
Rankings
Campus
Lowest
Average
Highest
Accepted
41.7
78.6
96.7
b-list
62.3
71.7
87
Rejected
28.3
63.6
88.3
Note: 6 proposals are still on the b-list for
the Conservation Campus.
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
Regional & thematic breakdown…
Oceania
26
4
15
Commission reserved slots
24
n/a
24
West Asia
8
4
1
Total
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
69
Jeju 2012
Link with the proposed IUCN Programme 2013-2016…
All proposals
Thematic area
Workshops
One area
Several areas
One area
Several areas
Valuing and conserving nature
148
284
29
105
Governing nature’s use and sharing its benefits
26
230
7
90
Deploying nature-based solutions to global challenges – Climate
change
19
172
3
65
Deploying nature-based solutions to global challenges – Food
security
14
148
5
56
Deploying nature-based solutions to global challenges – Green
economy
26
132
5
52
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
One word about the “One Programme” rule…

Members have been identified as partners in 76,5% of the proposals;

Commissions are partner in 91.5% of the proposals;

Secretariat units are partner in 90.5% of the proposals;

IUCN Partners are involved in 84% of the proposals
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
What about the Forum programme?…
8:30
Thu. 6
Fri. 7
Sat. 8
Sun. 9 Mon. 10
Tue. 11
Fri. 14
Sat. 15
Excursions
Assembly
Forum
opening
10:30
11:00
Wed. 12 Thu. 13
13:00
14:30
Closing
16:30
17:00
18:30
19:00
Openi
ng
WLD
WLD
WLD
WLD
WLD
21:00
Jeju, Korea– Septembre 2012
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Jeju 2012
What about the Forum programme?…
Forum opening
Nature + climate
Can nature save us?
Forum opening:
-
Nature + food security
Can we feed the
world sustainably?
Nature + economy
Green economy: myth
or reality?
Nature + people
Can conservation
tackle poverty?
Nature +
Saving nature,
why bother?
1h30/2h session on the 7 Sept.
Technical opening, short and crisp! (no political or protocol speeches)
1 keynote address (Rachel Kyte, Vice-president and Network Head – World Bank)
Introduction to the Forum:
- Structure, types of events and localization;
- World Leaders Dialogues
- Themes
World Leaders Dialogues:
-
5 high-level / high-exposure sessions of the Congress (no event in parallel)
Will bring external perspectives to the debate
Moderated by professional TV moderators and journalists
Innovative participation tools for the audience
Forum closing:
- The 5th World Leaders Dialogue (Saving nature, why bother?)
will also be the closing of the Forum.
IUCN’s Global Protected Area Programme
Summary Statistics by Lead Commission
Commission
Number of Forum Events
Commission on Ecosystem management
51
Commission on Education
53
Environmental Law Commission
50
Species Survival Commission
118
World Commission on Protected Areas
118
No Affiliation
71
Total
469
Note: there are many joint commission sponsorships
Ranked Summary of All WCC Forum
Sessions By Keyword Search
Keyword search
All - total events
Biodiversity
Climate
Protected Areas
Forests
Governance
Ecosystem Services
Marine
Restoration
Tourism
Law
Red List
invasive or exotic
species
Fresh water
Equity
Drylands
Posters
Workshops
Knowledge Café
155
44
24
32
27
8
6
14
17
10
6
3
138
66
41
31
20
27
27
14
11
7
12
9
127
51
28
23
21
10
14
11
9
7
4
4
Conservation
Campus
49
24
10
14
11
11
5
3
2
5
5
2
5
5
2
0
2
3
3
0
6
0
3
0
2
1
1
0
Note: categories are not exclusive
Total
469
185
103
100
79
56
52
42
39
29
27
18
15
9
9
0
Summary of Sessions on “Parks and
Protected Areas”
Knowledge Conservation
Café
Campus
Topic / Areas of Interest
Posters
Workshops
Global methods, or policies
Regional initiatives
Local case studies
Education
Marine
Geodiversity
Connectivity C Conservation
Business - Tourism
CCAs/Participation/Governance
Private land conservation
Climate
Human Health
4
9
6
2
3
1
16
2
5
4
6
1
3
1
3
1
1
5
3
1
1
1
23
14
Total
3
3
1
2
34
1
3
3
4
1
1
1
31
Keyword search on abstracts for “Protected Areas” or “Parks”
WCPA - Sponsored Workshops
Organizer
Lopoukhine, Nikita
Lopoukhine, Nikita
Working Title
IUCN Commissions
Shaping the Future of IUCN's Protected Area
WCPA; CEC
Capacity Development Programme (WCPA
official session)
Beyond targets: protected areas as life insurance WCPA
for the planet (WCPA official session)
Lopoukhine, Nikita
Building Awareness of Nature through Parks and WCPA
Protected Areas (WCPA official session)
Charles Besancon
Our Protected Planet: Achieving Aichi
biodiversity targets through constituency
building, science and action (WCPA official
session)
SSC; WCPA
WCPA - Program Workshops (Task Forces and Programs)
Organizer
Soyoung Park
Marc Hockings
Karen Keenleyside
Working Title
IUCN Commissions
World National Parks CEOs Forum
WCPA
The IUCN Green List of Well-Managed Protected WCPA
Areas
Putting Natural Solutions to Work: Mainstreaming WCPA
protected areas into climate change responses
Thaddeus (Ted) Trzyna Urban Dimensions of Nature Conservation: Roles WCPA
for IUCN
Stephen Woodley
Rethinking Protected Areas Systems: evidenceWCPA; SSC, CEL
based solutions for a positive conservation future
Tom Brooks
Identification of Sites of Global Biodiversity
SSC; WCPA
Conservation Significance: defining global
standards and mobilizing standardized biodiversity
data - Real-World Applications
Brent Mitchell
Protecting diversity through effective and
WCPA, CEP
equitable governance: Lessons from a diversity of
protected areas
The Biodiversity and Climate Imperative to Protect WCPA
Primary forests: Implications for Climate Policy
The World Heritage Convention at 40: Engaging
WCPA
the IUCN constituency for conservation and
communities
Brendan McKay
Tim Badman
WCPA - Protected Area Workshops
Organizer
Working Title
John Parks
Size Matters: Scaling Up Marine Protection Efforts WCPA; CESP
Across the Globe
Fernanda Barbosa
Conservation Finance: gaps, comparative analysis WCPA; CESP
and alternatives in a dynamic debate
Preserving nature for both conservation and
WCPA; CESP
human health outcomes
John Senior
Ian Walker
Aracely Pazmiño
Mariana Bellot Rojas
Robyn Bushell
Barbara Lassen
IUCN Commissions
Connectivity Conservation, Law and Beyond: for WCPA; CEM; CESP; CEL
an environmentally and socially resilient planet
Participatory governance arrangements for
WCPA; CEM; CESP;
important conservation areas: common principles,
diverse realities and complexity in Latin-American
and the Caribbean
Monitoreo biológico como herramienta para
WCPA; CEM
conocer cambios en el patrimonio natural
afectado por cambio climático
Sustainable practices and approaches: good
WCPA
conservation outcomes from tourism and
visitation to protected and environmentally
sensitive areas.
Access and Benefit Sharing and Protected Areas CEM; CEESP
Related Non IUCN - WCPA Sponsored Workshops
Organizer
Gonzalo OVIEDO
Shawn Peabody
Fanny Douvere
Kristina Gjerde
Working Title
Biospheres and World Heritage: engagement with
extractive industries
Locally managed marine areas, towards a global
learning network
Marine World Heritage: Protecting The Crown Jewels
of the Ocean
High Seas Conservation: how can we manage our
common oceans responsibly?
IUCN Commissions
WCPA; CESP
WCPA; CEESP; SSC
WCPA; CEM; CEESP;
WCPA; CEM; CEL; CESP;
Víctor Hugo Inchausty
PROGRESS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE AMAZON WCPA; CEM
ECOSYSTEM BASED CONSERVATION VISION
Marjo Vierros
Community-based marine management in the AsiaPacific in the context of international conservation
targets
Sharing benefits and efforts from transboundary
conservation
Barbara Engels
WCPA; SSC; CEESP;
SSC; WCPA, CEM
WCPA - Key Knowledge Cafes
Organizer
Anna Spenceley
Working Title
Tourism visitation and value
generated for protected areas:
Options for ProtectedPlanet
•Jonathan Davies
Mobilising Action to Conserve
Drylands Biodiversity through
Sustainable Land Management
Nigel Crawhall
African Indigenous Peoples and
improvements to World Heritage
nominations
Timothy BADMAN Supporting Indigenous Peoples and
Local Communities in World
Heritage Site Management through
Rights Based Approaches
Robyn Bushell
Indigenous Community Engagement
in Tourism & World Heritage
IUCN Commissions
WCPA
•WCPA,
CEM; CEESP
•WCPA;
CEESP
•WCPA;
CEESP
•WCPA;
CEESP
WCPA - Knowledge Cafes
Organizer
Working Title
IUCN Commissions
Jean-Pierre Briot
Creative participatory methodologies for WCPA; CEM, CESP
protected areas management: New
approaches and challenges
Florence PALLA
Expériences de la gestion des complexes WCPA; CEM, CESP
transfrontaliers en Afrique Centrale :
Leçons apprises et défis
Andrew MacLean
World Heritage Areas as learning
WCPA; CEM, CESP
landscapes - turning research results into
management action
Mochamad Indrawan IDENTIFYING CHAMPIONS IN THE POLICY WCPA; CEM, CEL, CESP
QUARTERS: PRIOR TO THE PROTECTED
AREAS ISSUES AND APPROACHES
Mariana Bellot Rojas Information, Monitoring and Evaluation WCPA, CEM
System for Conservation of Protected
Areas
Safiétou SALL
Une nouvelle vision de la gouvernance
WCPA
des aires protégées au Sénégal
Teppei Dohke
What is Asian system of Marine Protected WCPA
Area? -Is there any MPA with no no-take
zone? –
Jae-Hoon Jang
Enlarging and Connecting Protected Areas SSC; WCPA
for Ecological Corridor of North East Asia
WCPA - Key Conservation Campuses
Organizer
Working Title
Sue Stolton
Understanding and Implementing the IUCN
WCPA
Protected Area Management Categories
Storytelling with Ocean in Google Earth. Case WCPA
studies with National Geographic, Mission Blue
& UNEP.
Governance of Protected Areas
WCPA;CEL;CEESP
Jenifer Foulkes
Grazia BorriniFeyerabend
Soyoung Park
Bas Verschuuren
Timothy BADMAN
Tony Varcoe
Upgrading Education for Sustainable
Development (ESD) through National Park
Experiences
Learning from Sacred Natural Sites: Amplifying
Guardian voices in working with National
Governments.
How to get invoved in the World Heritage
Convention: A Users Guide for IUCN Members
Applying Tools to Assess Management
Effectiveness of Protected Areas- The Global
Experience
IUCN Commissions
WCPA; CEC
WCPA;CEM;CEL;CEESP
WCPA;CEM;CEL;CEESP
WCPA
WCPA - Conservation Campuses
Organizer
Working Title
IUCN Commissions
Jane Smart
•IUCN's Flagship Knowledge Products: working
towards technical and operational linkages
Intensive course on geoheritage and
geodiversity: new concepts and applications in
nature conservation
Management planning of protected areas
incorporating local people´s livelihoods. For PA
managers and stakeholders.
Creating Resilient Eco-Travel Destinations in
Protected Areas
Management planning of protected areas
incorporating local people´s livelihoods. For PA
managers and stakeholders.
Upgrading Education for Sustainable
Development (ESD) through National Park
Experiences
•SSC; WCPA; CEM
Enrique Díaz
Martínez
José COURRAU
Pamela Lanier
José COURRAU
Soyoung Park
James Watson
The SMART, Results-based Approach to Saving
Tigers, Elephants, Great Apes and Other
Threatened Species
WCPA
WCPA;CEM; CEESP
WCPA
WCPA, CEM, CEESP
World Commission on
Protected Areas –
WCPA;Commission on
Education and
Communication - CEC
SSC
WCPA - Posters (1)
Organizer
Mariana Bellot Rojas
Mariana Bellot Rojas
Julia Miranda
Anvar Buzurukov
James Hardcastle
Working Title
IUCN Commissions
Participación de los pobladores locales en el manejo sustentable WCPA; CEM
de las áreas protegidas
Management effectiveness, connectivity and resilience of
WCPA
protected areas to protect biodiversity from climate change
Resilencia en las Áreas Protegidas deLatinoamérica: Soluciones WCPA
naturales al cambio climático.
Establishing Yagnob Natural Ethnographic Park: resources, risk WCPA
and opportunities for sustainable livelihood.
Participatory action for climate resilience: case studies from
WCPA
Choiseul and Manus provinces (Solomon Islands; PNG)
Soyoung Park
Long-term Monitoring on Marine Ecosystem before/ after Hebei WCPA
Spirit Oil Spill
Thales Do Carmo
The Importance of Transfer Tax to Increase Protected Areas in
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
WCPA
Deanne Adams
Well trained Rangers are critical to healthy ecosystems and
healthy communities
WCPA
Tara Teel
Capacity Building to Enhance Protected Area Management
Effectiveness and Wildlife Conservation in the Asian Context
WCPA
Young Rae Choi
A Spatial Analysis of Korean Marine Protected Areas (MPAs)
WCPA
Carlo Franzosini
ISEA - Standardizing the Effective Management of MPAs in Italy WCPA
WCPA - Posters (2)
Organizer
Working Title
IUCN Commissions
Mike Baltzer
Management Effectiveness Standards for Protected Areas as a
tool to protect the Tiger
Protected Areas and Biodiversity Conservation in Asia
SSC, WCPA
The Preservation of the Ecology of the Korean Demilitarized
Zone (DMZ)
SSC
Hag Young Heo
JAEIL KO
SSC, WCPA
Conclusions –
Protected Areas and The WCC
Protected areas well represented as a theme
in Jeju
Good coverage of global protected areas
program and themes
Good interaction between commissions and
between secretariat and commissions
Complied by Stephen Woodley