Transcript Death and rebirth of the oxidative damage theory of aging
MULTIFACTORIAL HORMESIS PART 2 - CONTINUED
AN IMPORTANT CONTEXT FOR HEALTH AND LONGEVITY ON THE ROAD TO A GRAND UNIFIED THEORY (GUT) FOR BIOLOGY
Investigating the Future of Medicine
Symposium and Webcast Hawaii institute for Molecular Communications March 16, 2013 Presentation by: Vincent E. Giuliano, Ph.D.
Agingsciences.com
The adaptive immune system ROS-mediated pathways The heat shock response The cold shock response The unfolded protein response (UPR) The mitochondrial UPR The hypoxic response
The system in vertebrates that confers immunity to a pathogen once you are exposed to it The system that makes vaccines work
A well-developed and well understood area of medical science Taught to every medical and nursing student 15,296 publications in PubMed since 1927 Image source
At high doses ROS create damage At low dose levels, ROS act as signaling molecules triggering hormesis
◦ Probably this is the main mechanism acting in radiation and many other forms of hormesis Image source
ROS have a dual character
A key pathway involved in ROS-mediated hormesis seems to be the keap1/NRF2 axis Nrf2 ◦ ◦ When activated, Nrf2 turns on hundreds of natural antioxidant and other protective genes Nrf2 seems to be strongly protective against many diseases and aging 3038 Pubmed publications since 1994 ◦ ◦ Many phytochemicals as well as other substances turn on Nrf2 Nrf2, a relative newcomer, is being intensely studied in the literature-
Nrf2 is a stress-sensing genetic transcription factor that is part of the cap’n’collar family. Nrf2 appears to be a master regulator of cellular responses to oxidative damage and other stressful conditions.
Nrf2 is normally held in the cytosol by a protein called Keap1 which sends Nrf2 off for ubiquination and proteolysis breakdown In the presence of stress signals including 0xidative stress, Keap1 releases Nrf2 into the cell nucleus where it activates multiple stress responsive genes
Nrf2 and antioxidant response elements (AREs) Nrf2 and Nrf1 are transcription factors that bind to over 240 ARE genes and and activate them.
These genes produce enzymes that exercise anti inflammatory, anti-stress, detoxifying and antioxidant effects.
involved is the Phase II detoxification of xenobiotics to reduce cellular stress include glutathione transferases, quinone reductase, epoxide hydrolase, heme oxygenase, UDP glucuronosyl transferases, and gamma-glutamylcysteine synthetase. Expression of these genes protects cells from oxidative damage and can prevent mutagenesis and cancer.
Nitric Oxide (NOS) – e.g. vasodialation, Carbon monoxide (CO) – e.g. bronchodilation Hydrogen sulfide (H2S) regulation of cardiac injury responses e.g. Superoxide (O2) - e.g. a growth signal via the ras-NAD(P)H oxidase MAPK signaling pathway, All of these involve the Keap1/Nrf2 pathway among others These are important signaling molecules at low doses. And, they and can kill you at higher doses.
Watson JD, 2012
Image source
Seems to be mediated by reactive nitrogen species (RNS) via mitochondria Image source Image source
Don’t be confused: heat stress activates multiple pathways and the heat shock response is triggered by more than heat “The cellular response to heat shock includes the transcriptional up-regulation of genes encoding heat shock proteins of the cell (HSPs) and chaperone proteins as part ‘s internal repair mechanism.
[1] “ This is called The heat shock response “ They are also called stress-proteins.
[2] to heat, cold and oxygen several cascade pathways .”( ref ) and respond deprivation by activating HSPs have many biological effects. ◦ E.g. they induce T-cell regulation of chronic inflammation HSP 90 Image source
Inducers of HSP proteins and hormesis Image source
“HSPs are present in cells under perfectly normal conditions.
[2] Some HSPs, called time.
[1][2] chaperones , ensure that the cell’s proteins are in the right shape and in the right place at the right HSPs help new or misfolded proteins to fold into their correct three-dimensional conformations, which is essential for their function.
[2] Heat shock proteins are also believed to play a role in the presentation of pieces of proteins (or peptides ) on the cell surface to help the immune system recognize diseased cells.
[3] The up-regulation of HSPs during heat shock is generally controlled by a single transcription factor ; in eukaryotes this regulation is performed by heat shock factor (HSF) –( ref )” Pathways can be complex. E.g. HSP hormesis can be induced by small doses of SIRT1acting through activation of HSP70. This keeps the protein HSF1 active via deacytelation. ”( ref )
Image source Image source
Cold shock such as from taking a cold shower can also induce a hormetic response.
This pathway involves the c
& RBM3.
old inducible RNA binding proteins: CIRP The cold shock hormetic response has been recognized as something going on in lower organisms for some time. It is now known to be evolutionarily conserved in humans. 1042 Pubmed publications since 1955
For cold shock, hypoxia, UV Image source
The hypoxic stress response pathway. This is the pathway activated when there is insufficient oxygen, such as at high altitudes.
“The hypoxia response leads to the activation of multiple cellular signaling pathways involved in regulation of respiration, metabolism, cell survival, etc.
16313 PubMed.org publications since 1946 The Hypoxia-Inducible-Factor (HIF) pathway plays a central role during the hypoxia response Its expression and activity are regulated in an oxygen dependent manner and it also regulates the expression of multiple hypoxia responsive genes.
Inhibition of cancers • Protects against cerebral ischemia and neurological disorders • Important for survival plants, e.g
citrus crops • Response potentiated by acute anxiety • Repeated immersion in cold water leads to habituation • This habituation can be fairly permanent, lasting 7-14 months in humans Image source
Image source Image source
Heat, ROS, RNS, RSS, UV, and aging alter proteostasis resulting in the accumulation of unfolded or misfolded proteins.
These stressors can up-regulate stress coping mechanisms or induce cellular damage and apoptosis. The UPRs sense and deal with accumulation of unfolded proteins, protecting the cell and blocking apoptosis.
Image source
The UPR plays a role in a number of diseases of aging including cancer, heart disease, cerebrovascular disease, arthritis, osteoporosis, neurodegenerative disease like Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s and Type II diabetes.
One of the UPR pathways involved in hormesis is the heat shock response pathway (HSP) mentioned above.
There are two other UPR pathways to be considered: ◦ the mitochondrial UPR and the ◦ endoplasmic reticulum UPR.
All these pathways have been extensively researched
Cytoplasm
E.R.
Image source
Image source The mtUPR occurs through both JNK2 and AKT signaling Image source Both the cell nucleus and mitochondria are involved as a result mtUPR signaling
Example, formulation of stress granules (SGs) ◦ “Cells respond to different types of stress by inhibition of protein synthesis and subsequent assembly of stress granules (SGs), cytoplasmic aggregates that contain stalled translation preinitiation complexes. ◦ ◦ ◦ Global translation is regulated through the translation initiation factor eukaryotic initiation factor 2α (eIF2α) and the mTOR pathway. -- cold shock is a novel trigger of SG assembly in yeast and mammals. Whereas cold shock-induced SGs take hours to form, they dissolve within minutes when cells are returned to optimal growth temperatures.” ( ref )
A publication relating to infantile hemangioma showing that “short exposure of the endothelial cells to hypoxia resulted in increased cell survival and proliferation, accompanied by occurrence of autophagy. Prolonged hypoxia induced autophagy, correlating with increased cell death, ( ref ) A publication Xenohormetic and anti aging activity of secoiridoid polyphenols present in extra virgin olive oil: A new family of gerosuppressant agents . “the "xenohormesis hypothesis," which states that stress-induced synthesis of plant polyphenols and many other phytochemicals provides an environmental chemical signature that upregulates stress-resistance pathways in plant consumers, can be explained in terms of the reactivity of the AMPK/mTOR-axis to so-called xenohormetins. “ A publication related to wound healing. Of particular interest were the observations “that wound healing could be accelerated in the 30-50% range with the dose response displaying biphasic characteristics consistent with the hormesis dose-response model. Such findings set the stage for the hormetic dose response revolution that is occurring within the biological and biomedical sciences, including wound healing,” ( ref )
Kolb et all, 2012
1.
2.
◦ ◦ Dose response is critical – the general curve seems to always apply though its quantitative parameters will vary widely Timing and duration of stressor is critical. Cannot be for too long. Works best when synchronized with circadian time windows 3.
For hormetic behavior, stressors must be pulsed; cannot be constant. Periods of rest and recuperation essential.
4.
5.
◦ Stress responses are limited by stress pathways activated; Multiple stressors may produce no better responses than single ones Repeated cycles of hormetic stress changes parameters of stress response curve and makes organism capable of handling higher and higher levels of stress 1.
E.g. exercise training, hypoxic accommodation
6. Hormesis applies to hundreds or thousands of situations ◦ Via a large multiplicity of pathways ◦ In some cases, dominant pathway shifts at hormetic curve crossover point 7 . Hormetic affect can be highly dependent on the state of the system effected ◦ ◦ ◦ E.g. state of inflammation in an organ 8. Hormetic effects can be seen across the entire spectrum of biology Applies on multiple levels to multiple systems Ranging from molecular pathway effects to whole-organism behavior and social behavior 9. Yet, despite its universality, hormesis is not generally embraced by many in the biological community It is known mainly by a number of different names for different applications
If an environment gradually shifts the pattern of stresses normally encountered by the organism (e.g. climate change or change in predators), the organism evolves through repeated hormetic exposure to accommodate to the new pattern of stresses. Therefore I speculate that commonly occurring stress pathways in any successful species.
hormesis applies to all
Image source
Hormesis can also lead to negative results, e.g. the stress survival of cancer cells E.g. via the Nrf2 pathway Therefore a number of cancer researchers are looking for ways to turn hormesis stress survival pathways in cancer cells off Pathogens adopt to the stresses of antibiotics and become antibiotic resistant – a major problem
Taking antioxidants can be very important for control of ROS and inflammation and are very important for health Antioxidants can inhibit the body’s endogenous antioxidant defense system and can be unhealthful IGF1is a pro-aging, pro-inflammatory pathway (Most scientists studying aging) IGF1is essential. It induces neurogenesis and reduces brain and muscle deterioriation and combats aging (Some endocrinology researchers)
All radiation exposure is dangerous, creating damage proportional to dose (official radiology establishment view) Radiation exposure can produce health effects (multiple studies of radiation hormesis) Carbon monoxide is a dangerous poison absolutely to be avoided (everybody knows that) Carbon monoxide is an important signaling molecule (691 research publications in PubMed)
Beta-amloid protein is a toxic substance responsible for the onset of Alzheimer’s disease ◦ Billions of dollars have been spent on developing drugs that clear out beta-amloid to treat AD, and they have not worked Beta-amloid is an essential signaling molecule in a hormetic feedback pathway that controls cellular cholesterol levels* ◦ When the chosterol-related stress in that pathway is greater than in the hormetic range, excess beta-amloid is produced that can lead to AD.
◦ Getting rid of all beta-amloid is NOT a good idea * 2013 publication Rational heterodoxy: Cholesterol reformation of the amyloid doctrine
It is time to stop thinking of stressors like ROS, heat, cold, various hormones and pathways as “good” and “bad,” and instead to start thinking of how they work in terms of the hormetic dose-response curve.
The hormesis pathways have a lot to do with longevity of individuals and of species Experiments with lower species indicate that lifespans of lower species can be enhanced via inducing hormesis, e.g. • Multiple stressors in Caenorhabditis elegans . Up to 40% life extension due to heat shock • Multiple species via calorie restriction • Multiple species via radiation • Drosophila via repeated application of mild heat stress Image source
A large number of other stimuli can promote hormetic pathways and longevity in lower species E.g. a current studies shows that feeding C-elegans a bacteria that produces nitric oxide promotes hsf-1 and daf 16 , resulting in a high resistance to stress and a 15% longer life, Image source
Bristle cone pines is the world’s longest-lived non-clonal species, with livespans of up to 5,000 years • Grow on mountains between 5,600 and 11,200 feet, White Mountains, California • Subject to strong and highly variable stresses: cold temperatures, dry soils, high winds, short growing seasons, and constant hypoxia • Water/moisture stress a major factor • Very disease resistant • Needles alone may last 40 years
• • At least four stress-response pathways are involved in (hormetic) pre-conditioning to drought in the Loblolly Pine.
• one cycle of mild stress followed by two cycles of severe stress creates a "photosynthetic acclimation to water deficit". • Consecutive cycles of severe drought up-regulates mitochondrial heat shock proteins.
Gene networks involved in drought stress response and tolerance Image source
The naked mole rat lives eight times as long as comparable-size mice and can live up to 30 years Lives in conditions of hypoxia, high carbon dioxide, acidification, excrements, urine, wars between colonies • • Shows little decline due to aging, maintains high activity, bone health, reproductive capacity, and cognitive ability throughout its lifetime. • Never get cancers, the main killer of mice • Has incredible hypoxic response. Can withstand brain oxygen deprivation for more than 30 minutes Exhibits mutation in the specificity of HIF1a • Has six times the amount of endogenous expression of the hormetic anti-oxidant defense protein Nrf2.
• Has high endogenous levels of NRG-1, P16
Compared with other mammals of similar size, bats live a long time, with lifespans of between 20 and 40 years. Rats live between 2 and 3 years, on average Despite living in dank, dark, dung-filled caves, bats only rarely get sick or are debilitated by infections Out of more than 5,000 types of mammals on the planet, bats are the only one capable of sustained flight and some species can fly more than 1,000 km in a single night. Such exertion entails great free radical stress Bats have evolved to have powerful free radical defenses and DNA repair systems
◦
Raises the question:
What role do repeated hormetic stress experiences play in the longevity of very long-lived species?
Or, lack of stress?
Then, there is the whole area of practical personal stress management to keep it hormetic Image source
In the course of a typical day, we have numerous minor hormetic experiences, e.g. me Feb 13, 2013 • Cold semi-naked in bedroom and bathroom morning – cold shock pathway • Blueberries, walnuts and hytosubstances supplements for breakfast– Nrf2 pathway • Frustration stress related to a computer help line conversation – cortisol, multiple pathways • Minor fight with my wife - same pathways • Exercising/shoveling snow/treadmilling – PGC1 pathway
In the course of a typical day, we have numerous minor hormetic experiences, e.g. me Feb 13, 2013 (continued) • • • • • Chain sawing, fumes, gas spilled on my hand – Nrf2 pathway - phase II detoxifying enzyme genes via AREs.
Pepperoni snack containing nitrites – same pathway More plant-based supplements during day Supper included salmon with olive oil, garlic, ginger, oregano and a touch of pepper sauce, broccoli and mixed greens – After supper, for desert I munched on 80% coco chocolate – Nrf2 path again Bedrom/bathroom icy cold again at night – cold shock again
From the Aging Hormesis project, the National Institute of Shows the impacts of broccoli, garlic, hot peppers, turmeric, grape skins and numerous other phyto-substances on the Nrf2, Sirt1, FOXO3 and NF kappaB pathways to create positive hormetic reactions in the nucleus of cells.
Pathological stress and over-expression of the stress hormone cortisol can block the good benefits from happening.
Dynamic systems, no matter how simple, need feedback systems to keep them in normal safe ranges of operation – e.g. a boiler requires a pressure release valve to blow off steam if the pressure gets too high Biological systems consist of complex networks of interacting dynamic sub systems embodying multiple points of positive or negative reinforcement. Biological systems are subject to constantly changing external stresses as well as ones due to normal operation, stresses that can easily drive the operation of one or more subsystems out of its safe normal operating range So, for example, is a nuclear power plant, with its complexity of feedwater, boiler, heat and pressure management, radiation control, reactor and electrical grid subsystems.
Containment spray Servicewater Safety injection Emergency feedwater
If a critical subsystem in either a human body or nuclear power plant starts operating out of its normal and safe operating range, disaster can quickly ensue So, the system must employ rapid feedback control mechanisms to ensure that operation of each critical subsystem is always within acceptable ranges of stress.
Further, there must be learning and adaption from each experienced stress event to make sure the system can better handle the event next time.
◦ ◦ In nuclear plants, chemical plants, refineries and other complex industrial situations it is called Dynamic Systems Control
For highly complex systems such as biological ones to keep functioning in dynamic operation, mechanisms are needed for detecting when a subsystem is being stressed out of its dynamic safe operational range and for generating corrective measures.
In biological systems, because of the complexity powerful and rapid corrective actions are often required to correct imbalances, ones that overcompensate. This results in the health-producing effects of stresses instead of damage . This overcompensation only works within specified amounts of stress. Constant learning and adoption to changing stresses is also part of the picture in biological organisms. Thus hormesis not optional. Its necessary existence can be inferred from systems dynamics considerations, independently from detailed knowledge of biology.
Hormesis – toward a Grand Unified Theory for biology Decades of research have seen over a trillion dollars spent on research on cancers, Alzheimers Disease, Diabetes and other degenerative diseases Yet, real progress in curing such diseases has been very slow the most important progress has been due to public health measures like clean water and air and anti smoking campaigns The NIH research budget alone is $31 billions a year The US ranks 30 pre-eminence.
th to 45 th among countries in the world in key health indicators despite our research
Hormesis – toward a Grand Unified Theory for biology
Hormesis – toward a Grand Unified Theory for biology
One of many factors is the extreme complexity of biology and the siloing of knowledge into sub-disciplines, associated with the absence of a unifying scientific framework .
Where we mostly have been on the road to understanding biological phenomena is burying ourselves in indefinitely more and more complexity
The situation in biology is a little like it was in physics in the 19 th century when more and more phenomena were being observed in more and more detail (optics, electromagnetism, radiation, radioactivity, gas dynamics, etc,) The Grand Unifying Theories of Quantum Physics and Relativity developed and fine tuned in the late 19 th and early 20 th century have stood up for well over a 100 years, They have provided the basis for technology and our current society (all electricity and electronics, computers, atomic energy, lasers, TV and Internet, space travel, etc. etc.). They still appear to be solid. These theories have lent themselves to constant updating and are mathematically descriptive as well as predictive.
A Grand Unifying theory for biology should have explanatory and predictive power across all biological systems and apply to subsystems and pathway phenomena as well. Further, it should lend itself to quantitative verification and behavior prediction.
Multifactorial hormesis seems to satisfy these properties It should suggest many practical applications that benefit people, particularly their health and longevity Above all, it should raise many specific questions for further exploration and validation There are likely to be additional components to a complete GUT for biology , such as an updated view of evolution taking epigenetics into account, roles of key molecular processes like acetylation, phosphorylation , methylation, etc.
Hormesis is a required property of biological systems for them to operate with dynamic stability Hormesis exists at multiple levels, ranging from the function of the individual in its environment society down to the functioning of cellular components such as mitochondria Wherever important stress are encountered, one form or the other of hormesis comes into play. Nature and evolution set it up that way for biological survival to be possible.
Many of the molecular pathways that activate hormesis are well understood now, others less-so. A given stress can act through multiple pathways Certain key properties of hormesis can be identified, including a need for stresses to be limited in intensity and pulsed, need for rest between periods of hormetic stress, and stress-accomadation whereby organisms develop better and better capabilities to respond to a given kind of stress
Hormesis is deeply related to the main processes of aging. Hormetic interventions could possibly be employed to extend lifespans Many dietary substances can be used to induce positive hormetic effects.
Many health producing applications of hormesis are in common use now, others are being developed, and others probably remain unimagined.
We do not yet understand the limits to which hormesis can be exploited to create public health, fight specific diseases or create longevity
New hormetic interventions may be designed to prevent disease processes, improve surgical outcomes, enhance general health and delay aging.
Understanding the multifactorial nature of hormesis is very important for understanding health and disease processes and aging Effectively designing hormetic applications requires an ability to understand and quantize the parameter of the hormesis curve in specific instances, and this entails the development of specific stress-related biomarkers Multifactorial hormesis is a universal principle in biology, likely to be a central aspect of a GUT for biology
There is still much to be learned about hormesis
Hormesis is a required systems property of any self-regulating system that consists of a complex of feedback loops with positive and negative reinforcement.
Hormesis is a widely applicable context for understanding biological systems and for creating health-producing interventions.
Far from being an arcane concept, hormesis is deeply grounded in both traditional health practicses and modern research.
Hormesis can be used as a guide for day-to-day management of normal stresses by ordinary people, so as to enhance their wellbeing.
◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ HORMESIS ◦ Multifactorial hormesis - the theory and practice of maintaining health and longevity , Sarcopenia - the Age-related Los of Muscle Mass and Function - Part I: Pathways and factors , The Hormetic Wild Animal Zoo and Their Zookeepers, Mitohormesis , Radiation hormesis , Mitochondria Part 2: Mitochondrial Responses to Stress: Mitochondrial Signaling: Survival and Death Pathways , ◦ Hormesis and age retardation NRF2 PATHWAY ◦ ◦ oxidative damage and generation of hormetic effects , The pivotal role of Nrf2: Part 2 - foods, phyto-substances and other substances that turn on Nrf2 , ◦ ◦ PHYTOSUBSTANCES AND HORMESIS ◦ The pivotal role of Nrf2. Part 3: Part 3 - Is promotion of Nrf2 expression a viable strategy for human human healthspan and lifespan extension?
, Plant polyphenols - six epigenetic knockout punches against cancers HORMESIS PATHWAYS HSP70 to the rescue ,
Acknowledgement
Many of the ideas in this presentation emerged in the course of an ongoing series of e-mails and conversations with James P. Watson Presentation by: Vincent E. Giuliano, Ph.D.
Agingsciences.com
MULTIFACTORIAL HORMESIS
ON THE ROAD TO A GRAND UNIFIED THEORY (GUT) FOR BIOLOGY
Investigating he Future of Medicine
Symposium and Webcast Hawaii institute for Molecular Communications March 16, 2013 Presentation by: Vincent E. Giuliano, Ph.D.
Agingsciences.com