Presentation Four: Identifying and Attacking Legal Arguments
Download
Report
Transcript Presentation Four: Identifying and Attacking Legal Arguments
The Five Types of Legal
Arguments:
Presentation Four: Identifying and
Attacking Legal Arguments
Wilson Huhn
Professor of Law, The University of Akron School of Law
© 2013
1
Presentation Four
Identifying and Attacking
Each of the Five Types of Legal Arguments
2
Identifying the Types of Legal
Arguments
People v. Gibbons, 215 Cal.App.3d 1204,
263 Cal.Rptr. 905 (4th Dist. 1989)
3
Famous Legal Arguments
• 1. John Marshall demonstrates how to
attack an argument based upon plain
meaning by proving that the word is
ambiguous.
4
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 2. Marshall makes an intratextual
argument by comparing the word
“necessary” in the Necessary and Proper
Clause with the words “absolutely
necessary” from Article I, Section 10.
5
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 3. Marshall makes an intertextual
argument comparing the language of the
Constitution to the language of the Articles
of Confederation to prove that the framers
of the Constitution intended to confer
broader implied powers upon the
Congress.
6
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 4. Brandeis makes an intent argument
regarding the Framers’ views on Freedom
of Expression.
7
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 5. Holmes rejects text and intent in favor
of tradition in arguing that the nation’s
experience over a century should prevail
on the question of whether Congress has
power to legislate in this matter.
8
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 6. Warren rejected the intent of the
framers of the 14th Amendment as a guide
to decision because their intent was
unclear and because conditions had
changed so much that their specific views
regarding separate schools were no longer
relevant.
9
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 7. Warren cites both precedent and policy
arguments in favor of overruling the
precedent of Plessy v. Ferguson.
10
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 8. Burger makes a straightforward
tradition argument in favor of a law
criminalizing homosexual behavior.
11
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 9. Kennedy finds a number of ways to
rebut the tradition arguments regarding
sodomy laws. He says that these laws
were never enforced, that our traditions
are changing, that foreign countries have
declared these laws to be inconsistent with
human rights and that because of
globalization our traditions must come
under closer scrutiny. At the end he
makes a policy argument for striking down
this law.
12
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 10. In the Youngstown case, Black
decided against the President on textual
grounds.
13
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 11. In the same case Frankfurter found no
tradition of allowing a President to
exercise this type of power.
14
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 12. Robert Jackson rejected text, intent,
tradition and precedent in this passage.
15
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 13. Instead, Jackson composed an
intricate policy argument, built upon what
he regarded as the purposes of the
doctrine of Separation of Powers.
16
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 14. Abraham Lincoln rebuts the intent
arguments of Roger Taney and Stephen
Douglas regarding the phrase “all men are
created equal.”
17
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 15. Kennedy, O’Connor, and Souter
identify the four factors to consider in
deciding whether to follow or overrule a
case, when they considered whether to
reaffirm Roe.
18
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 16. John Harlan explains that “tradition is a
living thing,” and that there have always
been conflicting traditions.
19
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 17. John Paul Stevens rebutted President
Clinton’s policy argument, in effect saying
that it was no big deal to require a sitting
President to give a deposition in a civil
case. How wrong he was!
20
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 18. Blackmun’s casual reference to
constitutional text and his passionate
policy argument from Roe v. Wade.
21
Famous Legal Arguments,
continued
• 19. Thurgood Marshall’s rebuttal policy
argument from Kras, finding a $50 filing
fee to be a very big deal indeed.
22
B. How to Attack Each Type of
Argument
• Intra-type attacks – Attacking an
argument on its own terms – contends that
the argument does not have strong basis
in text, intent, precedent, tradition, or
policy.
• Cross-type attacks – Attack an argument
by contending that there is a different type
of argument that is stronger.
23
Intra-type and Cross-Type
Attacks
There are 28 different intra-type attacks
on legal arguments, and two basic forms of
cross-type attacks.
24
Intra-type Attacks on Textual
Arguments
A. Attacks on Arguments Based upon Plain
Meaning
1. The text is ambiguous
2. The text has a different plain meaning
B. Attacks on the Canons of Construction
3. The canon of construction does not apply
4. A conflicting canon of construction applies
C. Attacks on Intratextual Arguments
5. There is a conflicting intratextual inference drawn
from the same text
6. There is a conflicting intratextual inference drawn
from different text
25
Intra-type Attacks on Intent
Arguments
7. The intent of the drafters was different from
what the litigant says
8. The litigant’s evidence of the drafters’ intent is
not sufficient
9. The drafters of the law did not anticipate current
events, so their intent is not relevant
10. The person whose intent was proven does not
count as a drafter, so it is irrelevant
26
Intra-type Attacks on Precedent
11. The court’s opinion was not holding but rather obiter
dictum
12. The opinion did not command a majority of the court
13. The opinion was not issued by a controlling authority
14. The case is distinguishable because of dissimilar facts
15. The case is distinguishable for policy reasons
16. There are two conflicting lines of authority
17. The case has been overruled
18. The case should be overruled
27
Intra-type Attacks on Tradition
Arguments
19. No such tradition exists
20. There have been competing traditions
21. A new tradition is emerging
28
Attacks on Policy Arguments
22. The factual prediction is not accurate
23. The policy is not one of the purposes of
the law
24. The policy is not sufficiently strong
25. The policy is not served in this case
26. The policy is outweighed by a competing
policy
29
The Three Most Difficult Types of
Attacks to Master
14. The Case Is Distinguishable on the
Facts
15. The Case is Distinguishable For Policy
Reasons
16. There Are Two Conflicting Lines of
Authority
30
Group Exercises
• Please Discuss the Cases in your Group
31
Group Exercises
• Case 1
• Davis v. Davis, 842 S.W.2d 588 (1992)
• Are frozen embryos “children” or
“property”?
32
Group Exercises
• Case 2
• Akron case
• Is a gestational surrogate a mother giving
up her baby for adoption or is she a foster
mother to someone else’s child?
33
Group Exercises
• Case 3
• Denver Area Educational
Telecommunications Consortium, Inc. v.
F.C.C., 527 U.S. 727 (1996)
• Is a cable television operator more like a
newspaper publisher or more like a
telephone company in terms of its power
to censor programming?
34
Group Exercises
• Case 4
• Turner Broadcasting Co. v. F.C.C., 520
U.S. 180 (1997)
• Is a cable television operator more like a
newspaper publisher or more like a
telephone company for purposes of “must
carry” regulations?
35
Group Exercises
• Case 5
• McPherson v. Buick Motor Co., 217 N.Y.
382 (1916)
• Is an automobile more like a wagon or
more like scaffolding?
36
Benjamin Cardozo on the
Difference Between Factual
Analogies and Policy Analogies
“Some judges seldom get
beyond that process in any
case. Their notion of
their duty is to match the colors
of the case at hand against the
colors of many sample cases
spread out upon their desk.
The sample nearest in shade
supplies the applicable rule.”
37
Choosing Between Competing
Lines of Authority
John Dickinson, The Law Behind Law II
– Look to the comparative value of different policies in
choosing between analogies
– 29 Columbia Law Review 285 (1929)
Benjamin Nathan Cardozo
– “Conflicting principles were there in competition for
the mastery.” Riggs v. Palmer, 115 N.Y. 506 (1889)
38
The Incommensurability
Problem
How can you evaluate the relative strength
of arguments of different types?
39
Two Kinds of
Cross-type Attacks
One kind of cross-type attack questions
the “legitimacy” of an opposing legal
argument.
Another kind of cross-type attack
asserts that while the opposing argument
carries some weight, a different type of legal
argument is stronger.
40
Example of an Attack on the
Legitimacy of a Legal Argument
Robert Bork considered most types of
legal arguments to be “illegitimate.” For
Bork, the only “legitimate” type of legal
argument was one that was based on
“original intent.”
41
Another Example of a
Foundational Attack
Justice Antonin Scalia believes that the
only fundamental rights that Americans
possess are those that are “deeply rooted in
tradition.” If a right has not been traditionally
recognized, then it is not a constitutional
right.
42
Cross-Type Attacks
A cross-type attack on a legal
argument concedes, at least for the sake of
argument, that the opponent’s argument is
legitimate, but asserts that it is overcome by
an argument of a different type.
43
Examples of Conflicts Between
Different Types of Arguments
• Text v. Intent
– Rule of Evidence Inconsistent with Official
Comment
• Text v. Policy
– Are there unenumerated fundamental rights?
• Precedent v. Policy
– Virtually any famous opinion by Judge
Cardozo
44
The Values Served by the Different
Types of Legal Arguments
•
•
•
•
•
Text – clarity and objectivity
Intent – will of the people
Precedent – consistency
Tradition – coherence
Policy – flexibility, goal-orientation, justice
45
Solution to the Incommensurability
Problem
Evaluate which of the fundamental values of
the legal system is most compelling in the
context of the particular case – clarity,
popular will, consistency, coherence, or
goal achievement
46
Writing Persuasive Arguments and
Opinions
• Strengthen each argument within its type
• Make arguments of different types
• Weave arguments together so they
support each other – a cable not a chain
47
48
What sources of authority do you
find to be most persuasive?
Become aware of your own philosophy of
life, and understand how that affects your
interpretation of the law
49
Understanding Rules
The capacity to obey rules, to make and
apply rules, and to evaluate rules is
acquired progressively
50
The Stages of Cognitive and Moral
Reasoning
Formalism, analogy, and realism are
acquired in stage fashion
51
Concrete Analogies and Abstract
Analogies
The capacity to perform concrete analogies
is acquired before the ability to perform
abstract analogies
52
What Skills Are Necessary for
Policy Analysis
Realistic analysis involves the capacity to
consider hypothetical questions, the
capacity to apply the concepts of
conservation, reversibility and reciprocity
to rules and values, the capacity for
empathy, and the capacity to balance one
set of outcomes against another
53
Acknowledgements
• Artwork from Microsoft Clipart and www.clipart-free.com
• Judge Portraits from:
– http://www.portraitartist.com
• Portrait of Thurgood Marshall by Simmie Cox
–
–
–
–
http://www.multied.com
http://supreme.lp.findlaw.com/supreme_court/
http://whyjack.blogs.com/photos/judges
http://memory.loc.gov/ammem/index.html
• Picture of Alcohol obtained from National Heart, Lung,
and Blood Institute
• Permission Granted to Use Picture of River from
http://www.ambersoft.com/
54