School Readiness Indicators: Where Does Assessment Fit?
Download
Report
Transcript School Readiness Indicators: Where Does Assessment Fit?
School Readiness Indicators:
Where Does Assessment Fit?
Workshop Presentation at
NAEYC Annual Conference
November 10, 2004
Charles Bruner
Director
Child and Family Policy Center
and SECPTAN
The Why –
Kindergarten Assessments:
Reasons for Measuring
“What Children Know and
Can Do at School Entry”
• 1st National Education Goal still needs to be realized
• Need to answer policy maker questions on status of
reaching that goal
• Need to assess how policies and strategies we put into
place are working
• Federal and state actions moving in direction of
establishing measures and standards (need to do it in
an informed way)
• School readiness indicators initiative without indicator
of child’s school readiness is incomplete
The What –
Uses of a Kindergarten/
School Readiness Assessment
• Support Learning
• Identify Special Needs
• Evaluate Programs
• Track Trends, Build Awareness, and Support
Policy Development
• Allocate Resources
–target areas of need
–finance effective strategies
• Hold Actions Accountable
–incentives/sanctions and
teacher/school/district accountability
–not make decisions on child’s kindergarten
entry readiness
Uses of Kindergarten
Assessment for Awareness
and Policy Development
• Show the level of “school readiness” in the state
(districts, schools) and raise public awareness on
the need for strategies to improve it
• Track the progress made in the state (districts,
schools) over time in achieving school readiness
• Determine for what groups of children “school
readiness” represents an issue that requires
special attention
What We Know About
Children’s School Readiness
• Multidimensional
• Dimensions interact
• Serious gaps exist in children’s school
readiness that need to be addressed
• Children who start behind tend to stay
behind
• Only beginning to develop measures that
can describe the school readiness of
kindergarten children
Serious Gaps Exist
ECLS-K data and other data show we haven’t
achieved 1st National Educational Goal and a
“readiness gap” exists by:
Gender
Geography
Language
Race
Socio-Economic Status
[Child Trends reports and Economic Policy
Institute’s Inequality at the Starting Gate]
School Readiness
Multi-Dimensional and
Dimensions Interact
• Physical well-being and motor development
• Social and emotional development
• Approaches to learning
• Language development
• Cognition and general knowledge
National Status of Children:
ECLS-K Data and Percent of Children
Lagging on One or More Dimensions
0 44.2%
15.5%
Health
2 15.7%
7.6%
13.2%
5.0%
3 5.0%
8.1%
5.0%
Social and
Emotional
1 35.1%
Cognitive
6.4%
Source: Child Trends analysis of
ECLS-K, base year public-use data
for 1998-1999
Social/Emotional
vs.
Cognitive
Development
• Not Either/Or but Both/And
• Not Fuzzy and Unmeasurable, but Part
of Accountability/Continuous
Improvement System
Beyond the
Fuzzy/Academic Language
Language and Literacy/Cognition
•
•
•
•
Knowing a lot of words
Talking in sentences
Knowing sounds
Learning alphabet and numbers
Social and Emotional/Approaches to Learning
• Paying attention to teacher
• Working together in groups
• Not getting too frustrated doing new tasks
Teachers/Employers Value
Social and Emotional Skills
• Surveys of early elementary teachers rate
social and emotional developmental
challenges as biggest barriers to teaching
• Employers consistently state that
approaches to learning/”soft skills” (social
and emotional factors) more important
than content knowledge for most jobs
Challenge/Opportunity to States:
Federal and State Actions Moving in
Direction of Establishing Measures
and Standards for Early Learning
Head Start
National Reporting
Standards (NRS)
Kindergarten
?
Third Grade
No Child Left Behind
High Stakes
Accountability
The How –
Two Approaches to
Assessing Children’s
School Readiness
Reading/Language Literacy Tool: DIBELS,
etc.
validated instrument on a student population
basis
capable of broad-based implementation and
single measure interpretation
Work Sampling/Multidimensional Approach
(Maryland, Vermont, Minnesota, Missouri)
involves observation in natural settings, which
are needed to fairly assess multiple dimensions
is holistic and can be used as a teaching aid
Issues in Kindergarten
Assessment Development
• Most important distinctions likely to be
cross-population ones, including
geography
• Must be careful to guard against misuse
• Alignment with standards important
• Politics to date suggest proactive
approach that includes social and
emotional with language and cognitive
elements
Focus on Geography
Poor Neighborhoods:
Rich in Young Children
Very Young Children (0-4) as Percentage of Population
by Child-Raising Vulnerability
9.2%
7.7%
6.1%
No Vulnerability
Factors
6.4%
1-2 Vulnerability
Factors
3-5 Vulnerability
Factors
6-10 Vulnerability
Factors
Focus on Geography
Starting Behind: Staying Behind
Children from Des Moines Making Connections Areas
and Des Moines School District:
Mean Kindergarten Assessment Scores and
Mean Third Grade Composite Scores
54.95%
52.03%
44.23%
42.33%
Making
Connections
Areas
All Des Moines
School District
Mean Kindergarten
Assessment Scores
Mean Third Grade
Composite Scores
Focus on Geography:
Implications for Policy
and Practice
• Place matters and issues of place must be
addressed
• Color blind approaches (bringing credentialed
White, Non-Hispanic teachers in from suburbs to
teach preschools) won’t build community and can
do harm
• Place-based early childhood strategies (involving
staff and career development for people in
neighborhood) can improve school readiness, while
building community and economic opportunity
• Birth to five (and beyond) focus is essential
(preschool not a silver bullet for success)
SECPTAN
c/o Child and Family Policy Center
218 Sixth Avenue, Suite 1021
Des Moines, IA 50309-4006
State Early Childhood Policy
Technical Assistance Network
www.finebynine.org
Resources and Publications Include:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Measuring Children’s School Readiness: Options for Developing State
Baselines and Benchmarks
Beyond the Usual Suspects: Developing New Allies to Invest in School
Readiness
Child Welfare and School Readiness: Making the Link for Vulnerable
Children
Financing School Readiness Strategies: An Annotated Bibliography
Health and and School Readiness: The Health Community’s Role in
Supporting Child development
On the Path to School Readiness: Key Questions to Consider Before
Establishing Universal Pre-Kindergarten
Seven Things Policy Makers Need to Know about School Readiness
Up and Running: Compendium of Multi-Site Early Childhood Initiatives