Transcript Slide 1

Illinois Hospital Association
Illinois Hospital Association
METROPOLITAN CHICAGO
HEALTHCARE COUNCIL
Use of Color-coded Wristbands to
Communicate Alerts
in Illinois Hospitals
www.mchc.org
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Objectives
• Provide historical perspective on use of color to
communicate alerts to caregivers
• Provide overview of practice in Illinois
• Describe rationale for colors selected to alert
caregivers
• Provide recommendations for adoption and the
Work Plan to implement adoption
• Identify resources to support standardization of
color-coded wristbands
www.mchc.org
2
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Historical Perspective
www.mchc.org
3
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Why do hospitals use
color-coded wristbands?
Color-coded wristbands are used in healthcare
settings to quickly communicate a certain
healthcare status, condition, or an “alert” that a
patient may have. The wristband is used so every
staff member can provide the best care possible,
even if they do not know the patient.*
*New Jersey Department of
Health and Senior Services FAQs
www.mchc.org
4
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
The case for standardization
• In 2005, clinicians in Pennsylvania failed to
rescue a patient who had a cardiopulmonary
arrest because the patient had been
incorrectly identified with a “DNR” status.
• The source of confusion was traced to a nurse
who had incorrectly placed a yellow wristband
on the patient (which meant DNR at that
hospital)
• In a nearby hospital where this same nurse also
worked, yellow meant “restricted extremity,”
which was her intent as an alert
www.mchc.org
5
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Could this happen again?
In response to this near miss, the Pennsylvania Patient
Safety Reporting System (PA-PSRS) surveyed
Pennsylvania hospitals and found:
• 78% of the facilities used color-coded patient wristbands
• 45% used text on the wristbands
• Wide variation existed among the facilities regarding the colors
used to communicate information via wristbands
• Only 33% of responding facilities required patients to remove the
popular non-medical wristbands commonly used to show support
for charitable endeavors
www.mchc.org
6
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
An alert was issued
In December 2005, the Pennsylvania Patient Safety
Reporting System (PA-PSRS) released a patient
safety advisory making hospitals aware of the
inherent risks associated with the use of patient
colored wristbands, commonly used by hospital
staff to convey significant clinical information.
www.mchc.org
7
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Pennsylvania Patient Safety Reporting System
Identified Risk Reduction Strategies
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Limit the number and colors
Standardize the meaning of colors
Use brief, pre-printed text on the bands
No handwriting on bands
Educate patient/families re: bands
Remove “social cause” bands
Develop policies and procedures defining wristband
usage-authority/responsibility/maintenance
www.mchc.org
8
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Recommendations for
Pennsylvania Hospitals
August 2006
– Initiated the recommendations via distribution of the
“Color of Safety” manual
Follow-up Survey 2007
– 80% of hospitals reviewed “Color of Safety” manual
– 50% of hospitals initiated the recommended changes
www.mchc.org
9
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Practice in Illinois
www.mchc.org
10
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Illinois caregivers request guidance on the
standardization of color-coded wristbands
• Illinois Critical Access Hospital Network (ICAHN)
• Regional meeting of suburban Chicago hospitals
• Chicago area hospitals surveyed on the use of colorcoded wristbands by Metropolitan Chicago Healthcare
Council (MCHC)
• Illinois hospitals surveyed on the use of color-coded
wristbands by Illinois Hospital Association (IHA)
• Adjacent states favor standardization across borders
www.mchc.org
11
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
2007 Survey of Illinois Hospitals
Use of color-coded wristbands
Among Illinois hospitals responding to survey:
• 57 % use color-coded wristband to indicate Do Not Resuscitate
 Six different colors
 Most frequent color - blue
• 58 % use color-coded wristband to indicate an Allergy
 Six different colors
 Most frequent color - red
• 65 % use color-coded wristband to indicate Risk to Fall
 Six different colors
 Most frequent color – orange
IL Survey Data, 2007
www.mchc.org
12
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
2007 Survey of Illinois Hospitals
Results for Do Not Resuscitate
www.mchc.org
13
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
2007 Survey of Illinois Hospitals
Do Not Resuscitate
Should Illinois hospitals use a standard color on
wristbands to alert caregivers that a patient is not
to be resuscitated?
74 % YES
26 % NO
IL Survey Data, 2007
www.mchc.org
14
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
2007 Survey of Illinois Hospitals
Results for Allergies
www.mchc.org
15
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
2007 Survey of Illinois Hospitals
Allergies
Should Illinois hospitals use a standard color on
wristbands to alert caregivers that a patient has
allergies?
78 %
22 %
YES
NO
IL Survey Data, 2007
www.mchc.org
16
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
2007 Survey of Illinois Hospitals
Results for Risk to Fall
www.mchc.org
17
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
2007 Survey of Illinois Hospitals
Risk to Fall
Should Illinois hospitals use a standard color on
wristbands to alert caregivers that a patient is at
risk to fall?
78 % YES
22 % NO
IL Survey Data, 2007
www.mchc.org
18
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Next Steps
• Survey results presented to IHA Patient Safety
Task Force (PSTF), the Board of IHA, and MCHC’s
Clinical, Administrative, Professional, & Emergency
Services (CAPES) Patient Safety & Nursing
Subcommittees
• Formation of diverse workgroup:
– IHA Patient Safety Task Force
– MCHC
– ICAHN
– Chicago Patient Safety Forum
– Individual hospitals
www.mchc.org
19
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Charge to IHA / MCHC Workgroup
• Explore standardization of color-coded alerts
– Voluntary initiative
– Acknowledge risks and benefits
– Explore downstream effects among early
adopters
– Select alerts and associated color
• Formulate recommendation
• Develop toolkit for implementation
www.mchc.org
20
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Workgroup approach
• Reviewed current
standardization models in
use in other states
• Reached consensus on
color definitions and
wristbands
• Formulated
recommendation for
statewide voluntary
standardization of colorcoded wristbands
www.mchc.org
21
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
ALLERGY
FALL RISK
DNR
Recommendations for standardization
The following slides were developed as part of the Arizona toolkit
(copyright © 2007 Arizona Hospital and Healthcare Association), and have
been modified with the permission of the Arizona Hospital and Healthcare
Association.
www.mchc.org
22
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded Wristband Standardization in Illinois
Do Not Resuscitate
CALLING CODE BLUE!
Recommendation:
•
DNR - Purple
It is recommended that hospitals
adopt the color PURPLE for the
“Do Not Resuscitate”
designation with the words
embossed / pre-printed on the
wristband, “DNR”
www.mchc.org
•
•
23
Used by many Illinois
hospitals to summon
assistance for a patient
without adequate pulse or
respirations.
If Illinois selected the color
blue for the DNR wristband,
the potential for confusion
exists.
“Does ‘blue’ mean I code or I
do not code?”
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded Wristband Standardization in Illinois
Purple - Do Not Resuscitate
Recommendation - PURPLE for Do Not Resuscitate
1.
Why not blue?
– Should not be the same color that is used for calling a code
– Registry, turnover, travelers, etc
2.
Why not orange?
– Pre-hospital confusion with Advance Directives
3.
Why not green?
– Color blind
– “Go ahead” confusion
4.
If we adopt purple, do we still need to look in the chart?
– Yes!
– Code designation can and does change during a patients stay
www.mchc.org
24
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded Wristband Standardization in Illinois
Allergy
Recommendation:
Allergy - Red
Quick Adoption
According to survey
results, more Illinois
hospitals use red to alert
caregivers to allergies than
any other color.
It is recommended that hospitals
adopt the color RED for the
ALLERGY ALERT designation
with the words embossed / preprinted on the wristband,
“ALLERGY”Allergies
www.mchc.org
25
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded Wristband Standardization in Illinois
Allergy
Recommendation - RED for the Allergy Alert
1.
Why Red?
–
Currently associated with allergies by 55% of Illinois hospitals
that use color-coded wristbands
2.
Any other reasons?
–
Associated with other messages such as STOP! DANGER! due
to traffic lights and ambulance/police lights
3.
Do we write the allergies on the wristband too?
–
No because that may create new errors due to:
•
Legibility issues
•
Allergy list may change
•
Patient chart should be the source for the specifics
www.mchc.org
26
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded Wristband Standardization in Illinois
Fall Risk
Allergies
Recommendation:
Fall Risk - Yellow
It is recommended that hospitals
adopt the color YELLOW for the
Fall Risk Alert designation with the
words embossed / pre-printed on
the wristband, “Fall Risk”
www.mchc.org
27
Falls account for more than
70 percent of the total
injury-related health costs
among people 60 years of
age and older.
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded Wristband Standardization in Illinois
Fall Risk
Allergies
Recommendation - YELLOW for Fall Risk
1. Why Yellow?
– Associated with “Caution” or “Slow Down”
•
•
•
Stop lights
School buses
Hazardous intersections
– American National Standards Institute (ANSI) uses yellow to
communicate tripping or falling hazards
2.
All health care providers want to be alert to fall risks as they can be
prevented by anyone
www.mchc.org
28
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
According to AHA survey dated 7/22/2008, twenty-six states
have standardized color-coded wristbands associated with
Allergies (red), Fall Risk (yellow) and DNR (purple)
Alabama
California
Illinois
Michigan
Nebraska
New Jersey*
Oregon*
Utah
West Virginia
Arkansas
Colorado*
Iowa
Minnesota*
Nevada
New Mexico
Pennsylvania*
Virginia
Wisconsin
*Plus one or two additional colors
www.mchc.org
29
Arizona
Florida
Kansas
Missouri*
New Hampshire
Ohio*
Texas
Washington
Louisiana*
*Adopted late in 2008
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
American Hospital Association (AHA) Position
“America’s Hospitals are committed to delivering safe care. To alert
caregivers to certain patient risks, many facilities use color-coded
patient wristbands…. Standardizing the colors of the wristbands used
in hospitals is the sensible approach to improving patient safety, and
many state hospital associations have already engaged their hospitals
in this effort. As the national advocate for America’s hospitals, the
AHA is asking all hospitals to consider using three standardized colors
for alert wristbands. The colors, which have been adopted as a
consensus in numerous states, are: red for patient allergies; yellow for
a fall risk; and purple for do-not-resuscitate patient preferences.”*
*
American Hospital Association Quality Advisory, September 4, 2008
www.mchc.org
30
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Work Plan
www.mchc.org
31
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Suggested Work Plan for facility preparation,
staff education, and patient education
includes:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Organizational approval
Supplies assessment and purchase
Hospital-specific documentation
Staff and patient education materials and training
Following the work plan is a task chart for each element that
provides cues for methodical and successful implementation.
www.mchc.org
32
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Sample Work
Plan Document
www.mchc.org
33
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Sample Task Chart
www.mchc.org
34
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Tools for Staff Education
•
•
•
•
Poster announcing the training meeting dates/times
Staff sign-in sheet
Staff competency checklist
Tri-fold staff education brochure about this
initiative
• FAQs handout for staff
• Tri-fold patient education brochure about colorcoded wristbands
• PowerPoint presentation
www.mchc.org
35
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Tri-fold staff education brochure
includes:
•
•
•
•
How this all got started…the Pennsylvania story
Why this is recommended in Illinois
The national picture
What the colors are for: Allergy, Fall Risk, and
DNR
• Script for any staff person talking to a patient or
family about the wristbands
• “Quick Reference Card” cutout that lists seven
other risk reduction strategies (more on the
following slides)
www.mchc.org
36
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded “Alert” Wristbands/Risk Reduction
Strategies : A Quick Reference Card
____________________________________
1. Use wristbands with the alert message preprinted (such as “DNR).
2. Remove any “social cause” colored
wristbands (such as the yellow Lance
Armstrong “LIVESTRONG” wristband).
3. Remove wristbands that have been applied
from another facility.
www.mchc.org
37
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Color-coded “Alert” Wristbands/Risk Reduction
Strategies : A Quick Reference Card (cont.)
____________________________________
4. Initiate banding upon admission, changes in
condition, or when information is received during
hospital stay.
5. Educate patients and family members regarding the
wristbands.
6. Coordinate chart/white board/care plan/door signage
information/stickers with same color coding.
7. Educate staff to verify patient color-coded “alert”
wristbands upon assessment, hand-off care, and
facility-to-facility transfer communication.
www.mchc.org
38
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Why have a script for staff?
1. We know how we say something is as important as what we
say. This provides a script sheet so staff can work on the
“how” as well as the “what.”
2. Serves as an aid to help staff be comfortable when
discussing the topic of a DNR wristband.
3. Promotes patient/family involvement and reminds the
patient/family to alert staff if information is not correct.
4. By following a script, patients and families receive a
consistent message – which helps with retention of the
information.
5. The Patient Education brochure also is available for staff to
hand out.
www.mchc.org
39
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
SCRIPT for any staff person talking to a patient or family:
What is a color-coded “alert” wristband?
Color-coded “alert” wristbands are used in hospitals to quickly communicate a
certain health status, condition, or “alert” that a patient may have. This is
done so every staff member can provide the best care possible.
What do the colors mean?
There are three different color-coded “alert” wristbands that we are going to
discuss because they are the ones most commonly used.
www.mchc.org
40
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
SCRIPT for any staff person talking to a patient or family (cont.):
RED means ALLERGY ALERT
If a patient has an allergy to anything – food, medicine, dust, grass, pet
hair, ANYTHING – we want them to tell the healthcare team. It may
not seem important to the patient, but it could be very important in
the care the patient receives.
YELLOW means FALL RISK
We want to prevent falls at all times. Nurses assess patients throughout
their stay to determine if they need extra attention in order to prevent
a fall. Sometimes a person may become weakened during his/her
illness or following surgery. When a patient has this color-coded
“alert” wristband, the nurse is indicating this person needs to be
closely monitored because he/she may fall.
www.mchc.org
41
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
SCRIPT for any staff person talking to a patient or family (cont.):
PURPLE means “DNR” or Do Not Resuscitate
Some individuals have expressed an end-of-life wish and we, the
healthcare team, want to honor it.
www.mchc.org
42
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Policy and Procedure
www.mchc.org
43
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Policy & Procedure Information
• A template policy and procedure has been provided.
• Make modifications to it so it fits your
organization’s process and culture.
• Address how to respond when a patient refuses to
wear a wristband.
www.mchc.org
44
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Excerpt from Refusal Form
The above-named patient refuses to (check what applies):
•
Wear color-coded “alert wristbands.
The benefits of the use of color-coded wristbands have been explained to me by a member of the
healthcare team. I understand the risks and benefits of the use of color-coded wristbands, and
despite this information, I do not give permission for the use of color-coded wristbands in my
care.
•
Remove “social cause” colored wristbands (like the yellow Lance Armstrong “LIVESTRONG” and
others).
The risks of refusing to remove the “social cause” colored wristbands have been explained to me by a
member of the healthcare team. I understand that refusing to remove the “social cause”
wristbands could cause confusion in my care, and despite this information, I do not give
permission for the removal of the “social cause” colored wristbands.
Reason provided (if any):__________________________________
__________________
_________________________________________
Date/Time
_____________________
Date/Time
Signature/Relationship
________________________________________________
Witness Signature/Job Title
www.mchc.org
45
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
In Closing
The participation of each Illinois hospital in
standardization of colors associated with alerts
for Allergies, Risk to Fall, and DNR is strictly
voluntary. The use of color-coded wristbands as
a strategy to communicate Allergies, Risk to
Fall, and DNR remains the decision of the
individual facility.
www.mchc.org
46
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Resources
www.mchc.org
47
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Illinois Wristband Toolkit
Available for download:
Illinois Hospital Association
www.ihatoday.org
Metropolitan Chicago Healthcare Council
www.mchc.org
www.mchc.org
48
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Questions?
Dawn Niedner
Program Director
Clinical and Emergency Services
Metropolitan Chicago Healthcare
Council
312-906-6164
[email protected]
www.mchc.org
Becky Steward
Manager, Patient Safety Collaborative
Illinois Hospital Association
630-276-5585
[email protected]
49
www.ihatoday.org
Illinois Hospital Association
Additional Websites
American Hospital Association Quality Center
www.ahaqualitycenter.org/ahaqualitycenter/jsp/home.jsp
Arizona Hospital and Healthcare Association
www.azhha.org
Ohio Patient Safety Institute
www.ohiopatientsafety.org
Patient Safety Authority (Pennsylvania)
www.psa.state.pa.us/psa/lib/psa/advisories
www.mchc.org
50
www.ihatoday.org