LIS 571 Readings Reaction Assignment Topic 3

Download Report

Transcript LIS 571 Readings Reaction Assignment Topic 3

LIS 571 Readings Reaction
Assignment
Topic 3: Representation
and Metadata
by: Amanda Alessi
also by: David Salley
and Andrew Kloc
Thought Question:
Has the research and development of
metadata schemes designed for specific
users and/or collections moved the library
and information profession forward in our
task to provide the best access possible
for our users?
Readings:
Duval, E. et al. 2002 Metadata Principals and
Practicalities, D-Lib Magazine,
Schottlaender, B. 2003. Why metadata? Why
me? Why now? Cataloging and Classification
Quarterly, v.36 (3/4) pg.19-29
Taylor, A. 2004 Metadata in The Organization of
Information. 2nd ed. Westport CT. [Ch6, pg 139158]
Schatz, Bruce R. 1997 Information Retrieval in
Digital Libraries: Bringing Search to the Net
Science, v275 #5298 pg. 327-334
Article
Metadata Principles and Practicalities
by Erik Duval, Wayne Hodgins, Stuart Sutton,
and Stuart L. Weibel
Introduction
Rapid development of the World Wide Web
created information chaos.A
Metadata helps organize information. It is
broadly defined as data about data (Duval, etc.
2002).B
c
Principles
Concepts common in all metadata schema.
Schema—attribute/value or element set.
1. Modularity
—machine interoperability; Standards allow flexibility.
Lego metaphor D
Namespaces work with modularity
Formal collection of terms managed according
to policy or algorithm (Duval, etc. 2002).
Example: HTTP and LCSH E
Any metadata element set is a namespace
bounded by rules determined by its managers
(Duval 2002).
Namespaces allow metadata schema designers
to keep a term uniquely defined. Example:
Dublin Core metadata always starts with dc:
2. Extensibility
Some metadata elements are popular in
metadata schemas, while others aren’t.
Example: Creator vs. temperature F
A base schema is a goal with room for
additional elements that each unique
community can apply to itself.
3. Refinement
Level of detail is different for any given
purpose. G
Makes an element more specific.
Example: Composer vs. Creator.
Involves expression of dates and times.
Example: 04/07/03= April 7, 2003 or July
4, 2003. H
4. Multilingualism
Metadata must accept working with different
languages and cultures. J Example: <LI> K
Translate metadata standards into multiple
languages.
Metadata can describe the original resource’s
language and culture.
--can mention other available versions of the
resource and contact information for the
translator.
Other ways cultures communicate differently? L
Practicalities
“Rules of thumb, constraints, and
infrastructure issues that emerge from
bringing theory into practice in the form of
useful and sustainable systems” (Duval,
etc. 2002)
Principles above lead to these
practicalities.
1. Application Profiles
An assemblage of metadata elements
selected from one or more metadata
schemas and combined in a compound
schema (Duval, etc. 2002)
Means of expressing principles of
modularity and extensibility
Make rules such as this: required data
element=language, optional one=color. M
2. Syntax and Semantics
Semantics—meaning; syntax—form
HTML (hyper text markup language) is
simple. This is good and bad. N
XML is markup language of choice. O
3. Association Models
--ways to associate metadata with resources
Embedded metadata—created by the
author of the resource P
Associated metadata—kept in separate
files; change the metadata, not resource. Q
Third party metadata—filed by an
organization that may or may not have
control over the resource
4. Naming Metadata Elements
Each element set must have a globally
addressable name or URI (Uniform
Resource Identifier).
Makes machine processing of metadata
possible despite different languages or
cultures
5. Metadata Registries
“Important topic of digital library research at
this time”
Contain or link to controlled vocabularies from
which the values of metadata fields are selected
(Duval, etc. 2002)
“electronic dictionary” (Duval, etc. 2002)
Who will use a registry?



Application designers to identify schemas
Creators of metadata to get definitions for elements
End users to better understand the context of
metadata in hopes of improving their searches
6. Completeness of Description
Not every available element should be
used for every resource type. Example:
No scent field for a map.
Detailed Description



Improves searching precision
Requires higher investment in creation of
metadata (Duval, etc. 2002)
Makes it more difficult to promote consistency
(Duval, etc. 2002)
Simple Description



Easier and cheaper to make
May result in more false hits or more effort to
pick the most relevant results (Duval, etc.
2002)
Improves chances of interoperability
7. Subjective and Objective
Metadata
Metadata can be completely unbiased:
author, date of publication, edition or
version R
Fields become subjective when they come
to mean different things to different
cultures. Semantics is compromised.
Example: keywords, summaries, reviews
8. Automated Generation of
Metadata
Before the Web, there were librarians
cataloging
Cataloging metadata “remains the most
successful standard for resource discovery
of books and periodicals” (Duval, etc.
2002)
Costly
Impractical for Internet materials/resources
Web Search Engines
Index lots of the Internet
Low cost, advertiser supported model
Type of metadata
Advances in natural language processing,
profile and pattern recognition, data mining
Electronic paper like PDF allows authorsupplied attributes to simplify making
metadata S
Conclusion
Informationuseful if organized; organizer rolemetadata
Those who create metadata will have different motives, goals, and
techniques just like authors of books have different ways of writing
Communities must agree on rules and common procedures in order
to understand and share information across cultures
Schottlaender, B.
Why metadata? Why me?
Why now?
Reviewed by:
David Salley
Metadata Definitions
“a cloud of collateral information around a
data object”
“structured, encoded data that describes
characterization of information-bearing
entities to aid in the identification,
discovery, assessment and arrangement
of the described entities”
Metadata Schema
“A set of rules for encoding information that
supports specific communities of users”
-- Association for Library Collation and
Technical Service Committee on
Cataloging Description and Access Task
Force
Metadata Schema – 5 Years Ago
Only 4 types
Descriptive
Administrative
Technical
Rights
Metadata Schema – Today
Many more types, including:
Security
Personal Information
Commercial management
Content rating
Preservation Metadata
Etc.
Cataloging and Metadata
“Metadata is about access, cataloging is
about access” – Schottlaender
“The invisible process of order making” –
Kevin Butterfield
Four steps to each: find, select, identify,
obtain.
Relevant Quotations:
“I see an increasing confluence between the cataloging
and metadata communities, so much so, that the two
communities are becoming harder to distinguish, which
is exactly as it should be.”
“There is a growing recognition in the metadata
community of the relevance of the work that we in the
library cataloging community have been doing.”
“The Dublin Core ‘qualifiers’ … are … an attempt being
made now to enrich the Dublin Core Element Set by
referencing a variety of content standards: subject
thesauri; authority control systems; and classification
systems.
Metadata and
Representation:
Taylor, A. 2004. Metadata. In the
Organization of Information. 2nd
ed. Westport, CT.:Libraries
Unlimited inc. [Ch. 6: 139-158].
Definitions
“Data about data”

Simple definition, causes confusion
“Structured information that describes the
attributes of information packages for the
purposes of identification, discovery,
and…management.”
Why Metadata?
“Hot topic” in LIS in recent years

Stems from proliferation of electronic
resources
Major Significance:


“Concern that some kind of standardized
representation is needed for Internet
resources”
In order to locate the most “useful and
reliable” information available
Types and Levels of Metadata
3 levels of complexity:



simple format (found within resource itself)
structured format (ex: Dublin Core)
rich format (MARC, AACR2)
3 broad types:



administrative
structural
descriptive
Metadata Schemas
Def: sets of metadata standards designed
to meet the needs of particular
communities
3 Characteristics:



Structure - refers to data model and how
metadata statements are expressed
Syntax - encoding scheme
Semantics - refers to meaning of data
elements
Also use content standards and controlled
vocabulary
Special Characteristics of an
Electronic Environment
Interpolarity - ability of different systems to
interact with each other
Flexibility - ability to enter as much or as
little information as needed
Extensibility - ability to use additional
elements or qualifiers (more specified
elements) to meet specific needs.
Objectives for Implementing an
Information System
Find
Identify
Select
Obtain
Schatz, Bruce R.
Information Retrieval in Digital
Libraries: Bringing Search to
the Net
Reviewed by:
David Salley
“Organized collections of scientific materials
are traditionally called ‘libraries’ and the
searchable online versions of these are
called ‘digital libraries’. The primary
purpose of digital libraries is to enable
searching of electronic collections
distributed across networks, rather than
merely creating electronic repositories
from digitized materials.”
“The fundamental technology for searching large
collections is finally changing, so that information
retrieval in the next century [originally published
in 1997] will be far more semantic than syntactic,
searching concepts rather than words.”
“The ’document’ has changed from a citation with
descriptive headers to the abstract to the
complete multimedia contents, including text,
figures, tables, equations, and data.
Technology Timeline
1960’s Citations only [title, author, journal,
keywords] generating bibliographies
1970’s Inverted Indexes, full text storage,
proximity mapping
1980’s distributed personal workstations
1990’s The Internet, full multi-media
Vocabulary Switching
Example: A journal article that only
mentions ‘Unix’ would be tagged as being
about ‘operating systems’
Currently being done by human indexers
Hewlett-Packard, et al. currently working
on computer systems to do this working
with extensive ‘authority files’