Coal is America’s Best Friend!”*
Download
Report
Transcript Coal is America’s Best Friend!”*
Public Health Disparities in Appalachian
Coal Mining Communities
Michael Hendryx, PhD
Presentation for the
Kentucky Environmental Foundation
October 13, 2010
1
Industry Statements
“Within a few years, 10,000 replacement miners will be needed…For
every miner, 8 other workers are needed for support jobs. That’s
90,000 good paying jobs with good benefits.”
“Every coal mining job generates between 5 and 6 other jobs
somewhere in the local economy.”
2007 Charleston Gazette newspaper article
West Virginia Coal Association website, accessed 08-24-08
“It’s frequently noted that “every coal mining job creates another 5
to 8 jobs somewhere in the economy.” Anyone who has ever visited
a coal oriented community in West Virginia would have no hesitation
in believing that statistic.”
Friends of Coal, West Virginia Coal Association “Coal Facts 2007” report.
2
Downtown Whitesville, WV
3
Lindytown, WV
4
Number of Appalachian Coal Miners
1985-2008
140000
120000
Number
100000
80000
60000
40000
20000
0
Source: Annual Coal Reports, Energy Information Administration (*figures for
1986-1989 imputed)
5
West Virginia Coal Production and
Employment 1980 - 2008
60000
180000
50000
160000
140000
40000
120000
100000
30000
80000
Employment
Production in 1000 Tons
200000
20000
60000
40000
10000
20000
0
0
Production
Employment
Source: West Virginia Coal Association
6
Increase in Surface Mining as % of Total Mining in
West Virginia 1982-2008
50
40
30
%
20
10
0
Source: EIA, DOE
7
Independent Assessment of Coal
Economy
For every mining job, 2.38 other jobs are
created (not 5-8)
Coal mining accounts directly and
indirectly for 4.4% of Appalachian
employment
Direct, indirect and induced benefits: $8
billion in 2005 dollars
Source: University of Kentucky report, funded by ARC
8
Disparities in Mining Areas
Appalachian
Coal Mining
% college
education*
Median household
income *
Unemployment
rate*
Poverty rate*
Other
Rest of Nation
Appalachian
11.7
13.8
17.1
$28,054
$32,596
$36,753
7.4
6.2
5.2
19.6
15.6
13.1
* Group differences significant at p<.0001
Area Resource File 2006 adjusted for age, race/ethnicity and sex
9
Poverty Rates for Children 0-17 by Mining Activity 20002007 for KY, TN, VA, & WV
45
40
35
30
25
MTM
%
20
Other coal
No coal
15
10
5
0
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
Year
Source: Area Resource File 2008 and EIA
10
Median Household Income by County Coal
Production
> 4 mil tons
Up to 4 mil
tons
No Coal
$28,163
$29,883
$32,260
Figures on slides 11-16 based on WV coal production in 2001.
Sources: Area Resource File and WV Geological and Economic
Survey
11
Percent in Poverty by County Coal Production
20.1
> 4 mil tons
Up to 4 mil
tons
No Coal
16.9
15.5
Sources: Area Resource File and WV Geological and Economic
Survey
12
Percent High School Graduates by County Coal
Production
> 4 mil tons
Up to 4 mil
tons
No Coal
46.2
50.5
51.2
Sources: Area Resource File and WV Geological and Economic
Survey
13
Percent without Health Insurance by County Coal
Production
15.6
> 4 mil tons
Up to 4 mil
tons
No Coal
13.8
12.9
Sources: Area Resource File and WV Geological and Economic
Survey
14
Percent who Report Poor or Very Poor Health by
County Coal Production
11.82
> 4 mil tons
Up to 4 mil
tons
No Coal
9.24
8.46
Sources: West Virginia IHPR Survey and WV Geological and
Economic Survey
15
Percent Who Report No Usual Source of Health Care
18.2
> 4 mil tons
Up to 4 mil
tons
No Coal
15.2
15.9
Sources: West Virginia IHPR Survey and WV Geological and
Economic Survey
16
Evidence for Health Disparities…
I have “seen nothing to indicate any
greater incidence of disease near coal
mines. There’s a lot of allegation without
proof.”
Bill Raney, president, West Virginia Coal Association, Oct 2007.
17
Figure 1. Total Age-Adjusted Mortality per 100,000
for the Years 1979-2005, by County Group
19
79
19
81
19
83
19
85
19
87
19
89
19
91
19
93
19
95
19
97
19
99
20
01
20
03
20
05
1200
1100
1000
900
800
700
Coal mining counties
Hendryx & Ahern, PHR 2009
Other Appalachian counties
Rest of Nation
18
Age-Adjusted Lung Cancer Mortality per 100,000, years
2000-2004
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Coal-Mining
Other Appalachia
Nation
Hendryx, O’Donnell & Horn, Lung Cancer, 2008
19
Cardiopulmonary and kidney
disease mortality
Chronic heart, lung, and kidney disease
mortality rates are higher in coal mining
areas than the rest of Appalachia or the
nation
CDC mortality data 2000-2004
Adjustments for smoking, age, sex, race,
poverty, education, rural-urban setting,
insurance rates, physician supply, region
Hendryx, IAOEH, 2009
20
2000-2004 Total Heart Disease
Mortality per 100,000
350
300
250
200
Male
Female
150
100
50
0
Mining > 4 million
Mining up to 4 million
Non-mining
21
Self-Reported Chronic Illness
Survey in 2001 of ~16,500 adult West Virginians,
stratified by county
Greater coal mining is associated with higher rates of:
Cardiopulmonary disease
Respiratory disease
COPD
Hypertension
Kidney disease
Hendryx & Ahern, American Journal of Public Health, 2008
National 2006 BRFSS data show higher rates of heart attack and
coronary heart disease
Hendryx & Zullig, Preventive Medicine, 2009
22
Health-Related Quality of Life
People in Appalachian mining areas report
more days of poor health and activity
limitations
Men and women, young and old
Controlling for smoking, alcohol use, BMI,
age, gender, race/ethnicity, marital status,
income, education, rural/urban setting, doctor
supply
Zullig & Hendryx, PHR, 2010
23
Low Birth Weight
WV LBW adjusted OR=1.16 in heavy mining
areas; adjusted OR=1.14 in moderate
Ahern, Mullett, MacKay, Hamilton, MCHJ 2010
Appalachian coal mining is associated with an
additional 7.4 low birth weight babies per 1,000.
Ahern, MacKay, Carpenter & Hendryx, JEH, in
press
24
Birth Defects in MTM zones
Babies born in MTM zones have higher risk
of birth defects (OR=1.57, 95% CI 1.46 –
1.69)
Controlling for mother’s age, race/ethnicity,
education, prenatal care, infant sex, smoking,
alcohol use, co-morbid diabetes, and rural
setting.
25
Academic Performance
Students in mining counties of WV are
significantly more likely to fail
standardized tests
Grades 3,4,5,6,7,8,10
Controlling for low income, county high school
education rate, class size, teacher quality,
school size
Approximately 1,600 excess fails per year.
Cain & Hendryx, EJ, 2010
26
MTM-Specific Effects
Birth defects
HRQOL
Cardiovascular mortality
Total mortality
Others still to be tested
27
Age-adjusted mortality per
100,000 by MTM status
1100
1000
Rate
MTM
900
Other Appalachian
Non-Appalachain
800
700
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
Year
28
Appalachian Coal Mining Effects:
Become stronger as mining levels increase
Present for women, men, and children
Present across many data sources and health
outcomes
Become stronger in closer proximity to mining
activity
Concentrated in MTM areas (more to be done)
Hendryx, Fedorko, Anesetti-Rothermel, Geospatial
Health, 2010
Zullig & Hendryx, AJPH, in press
Ecologic designs; lack of direct exposure
assessment
29
Coal Extraction & Processing
Elements and compounds present in coal
and coal processing are linked to observed
health problems
59 trace elements in coal listed by WVGES
Explosives, cleaning and transportation
Arsenic, mercury, lead, beryllium, antimony,
selenium, cadmium, chromium, cobalt, nickel,
uranium, etc.
Benzenes, ammonia, CO, SO2, PAHs, DPM, etc.
Exposure to PM and toxins (eg mercury, lead,
arsenic, cadmium) increases risk of BD or LBW
30
Explosion over the town of Dorothy
31
Coal Prep Plant by Sylvester
32
33
Daily PM10 Means Near a Coal Processing Facility
80
70
PM10
60
50
Standard
40
Mean PM10
30
20
10
0
1/3/2008
2/22/2008
4/12/2008
6/1/2008
7/21/2008
34
Second Prep Facility
Figure 1. Daily PM10 Mean Values in Two
Locations
PM10
200
150
Standard
100
Mean PM10
50
8/12/2008
8/5/2008
7/29/2008
7/22/2008
7/15/2008
7/8/2008
7/1/2008
6/24/2008
6/17/2008
6/10/2008
0
Daily average significantly higher than the standard on 33 of 43 days
35
Well water in the town of Rawl, West Virginia
Photo: Antrim Casky, 2008
Photo: Nat Geographic, 2006
36
Tests of well and ground water
Arsenic in almost ½ of 179 wells in central
Appalachia, most at levels known to increase
cancer risk (Shiber)
Tests of 15 wells exceeded primary standards
for 5 metals: lead, arsenic, barium, beryllium
and selenium (Stout)
Secondary standards exceeded for iron, manganese,
aluminum, zinc
Ground water in mined areas of Appalachia had
higher sulfate, iron, manganese, aluminum, pH,
calcium, magnesium, turbidity, and zinc
(McAuley & Kozar, USGS report)
37
Stream Integrity, Mining, and
Cancer in WV
Mining and stream integrity r = -.62
(p<.0001)
Stream integrity and total cancer
mortality r = -.47 (p<.001)
Hitt & Hendryx, EcoHealth 2010
38
Impacts of MTM on Water and
Stream Life
Streams below valley fills have elevated sulfate,
magnesium, selenium and other chemicals
Increases ph, conductivity, dissolved solids
Biological health of streams is impaired as a
result
Mitigation efforts are not successful
MTM/VF should be stopped
Palmer, Bernhardt, Schlesinger, Eshleman, FoufoulaGeorgiou, Hendryx et al., Science, 2010
39
What is the Value of a Life
(statistically speaking)?
VSL research
If a person will pay $600 to reduce personal
mortality risk by 1/10,000, then 10,000
people, jointly, will pay $6,000,000 to save 1
life
To society, the value of that life is $6,000,000
EPA and FDA studies place VSL at $4.67 to
$7.74 million, in 2005 dollars
Hendryx & Ahern, PHR, 2009
40
Figure 1. Total Age-Adjusted Mortality per 100,000
for the Years 1979-2005, by County Group
19
79
19
81
19
83
19
85
19
87
19
89
19
91
19
93
19
95
19
97
19
99
20
01
20
03
20
05
1200
1100
1000
900
800
700
Coal mining counties
Other Appalachian counties
Rest of Nation
41
The Human Cost of Coal Mining
Cost estimate
in billions
compared to:
VSL in
millions:
Appalachia
1979-2005
Appalachia
1999-2005
Nation
Nation
1979-2005 19992005
3,975
4,432
8,840
$4.67
$7.74
Excess
annual
deaths:
10,923
42
The Human Cost of Coal Mining
Cost estimate
in billions
compared to:
VSL in
millions:
Appalachia
1979-2005
Appalachia
1999-2005
Nation
Nation
1979-2005 19992005
$4.67
$18.563
$20.697
$41.283
$51.010
$7.74
$30.766
$34.304
$68.422
$84.544
Excess
annual
deaths:
3,975
4,432
8,840
10,923
43
The Human Cost of Coal Mining:
Discounted
Cost estimate
in billions
compared to:
Appalachia
Nation
$3.83
$16.979
$41.846
$6.35
$28.141
$69.356
Discounted VSL in millions:
44
What We Don’t Know Yet: The
Links Between…
Air and water quality (ambient monitoring data)
to..
Contact and exposure (micro environment data)
to..
Entry into the body (biomarkers of exposure and
dose) to..
Altered structure and function (genetic
expression) to..
Adverse outcomes (morbidity/mortality)
45
The Need for Change
“We have more than 200 years of coal
remaining at current usage rates.”
Bill Raney, WVCA website, 9-26-10
“Bituminous resources remain in
[Appalachia] to last for the next one to
two decades at current production.”
Ruppert, USGS report 2001
46
47
Eliminate disparities based on
poverty and MTM
Tax revisions
Economic diversification
Jobs programs
Agriculture, alternative energy, ecotourism,
technology, sustainable timber, industry
Investments in education: K-12, college, adult
Environmental protection & remediation
48
“My tongue, every atom of my blood, form'd
from this soil, this air,
Born here of parents born here from parents the
same, and their parents the same,
I, now thirty-seven years old in perfect health
begin,
Hoping to cease not till death.”
Walt Whitman, “Song of Myself”
49