The Delaware Difference vs. Luxembourg
Download
Report
Transcript The Delaware Difference vs. Luxembourg
Trusts and Fiduciary
arrangements in Luxembourg
Carine Feipel
December 2nd ,2009
Luxembourg in a nutshell
2
Located in the heart of Europe
Founding member of the EU, as such submitted to EU legislation
One of the most important international financial centers in the EU
One of the smallest countries in the EU but one of the highest
incomes per capita in the world
Multicultural and multilingual population
Great political stability, high level of security
Well connected to the outside world with over 50 double tax
treaties
Money laundering: GAFI rules
Cooperation between foreign authorities even in tax matters
OCDE compliant - Luxembourg on no black/grey OCDE list
Agenda
1.
2.
3.
4.
3
Recognition of foreign trusts
Luxembourg fiduciary agreements
Family wealth management company as an alternative
Specialized Investment Fund as an alternative
Recognition of foreign trusts
4
Recognition of foreign trusts
5
Judgment of the Luxembourg Court of Appeal of 22 May 1996
Facts:
A settlor grants a guarantee to a bank on assets (cash) allocated to a
Jersey trust without any intervention of the 2 trustees
The bank exercises its guarantee on the assets of the trust
Issue
The trustees ask the Luxembourg court to force the reimbursement of
the guarantee by the settlor the settlor is not entitled to grant a
guarantee on the assets of the trust
The settlor challenges the authority of the trustees to act as
representatives of the trust before the Luxembourg court
Recognition of foreign trusts
Court
The trust is not a legal concept existing under Luxembourg law
Impossibility of establishing a trust in Luxembourg
But
The capacity of the trustees to act as representatives of the
trust exists in the law of the trust
The law of the trust is not contrary to Luxembourg law and
Luxembourg public policy
The action before the Luxembourg court introduced by the
trustees is admissible
6
Recognition of foreign trusts
The Hague Convention on the law applicable to trusts and on their
recognition
“…the legal relationships created - inter vivos or on death - by a
person, the settlor, when assets have been placed under the
control of a trustee for the benefit of a beneficiary or for a specified
purpose.” Article 2
Luxembourg law dated 27 July 2003 applicable to trusts and
fiduciary agreements (with effect in Luxembourg since 1st January
2004) recognition of foreign trusts
7
Recognition of foreign trusts
In « common law » jurisdictions : difference between legal and
economic property:
the settlor transfers legal property of assets to the trustee
the beneficiaries have the economic property of the assets
transferred to the trustee
Luxembourg law does not recognize this difference:
principle of unique and full ownership
no possibility to launch a Luxembourg trust but foreign trusts are
recognized
8
Recognition of foreign trusts
Judgment of the Luxembourg District Court of 12 December 2008
Facts
A US resident, Mrs. B, holds a real estate in Luxembourg
At the time of her death, the real estate is allocated to a US trust
The trustee is in charge of managing the assets of the trust during a
certain period of time
The beneficiary of the trust is the sister of Mrs. B and the French
foreign Ministry and a French association
9
Recognition of foreign trusts
Issue
The Luxembourg tax authorities consider that the real estate
has been allocated to the trust and that inheritance tax is due
at a rate applicable to non-relatives
Court
Principle of tax neutrality of the transfer of assets to a trust
Trusts do not have legal personality
Recognition by the Luxembourg tax authorities of the US trust:
no inheritance tax was due
10
Luxembourg fiduciary agreements
11
Luxembourg fiduciary agreements
Introduced in the Grand-Ducal regulation of 19 July 1983 modified
by the law of 27 July 2003
Innovation: introduction of the principle of segregation of assets
Fiduciary agreements may be used for various purposes:
Management purposes (fiducie-gestion);
Guarantee purposes (fiducie – sûreté);
Credit purposes (fiducie – crédit);
Carrying purposes (fiducie – portage)
Gift or inheritance purposes (fiducie – donation)
12
Luxembourg fiduciary agreements
Definition (Art 5, Law 2003)
“A fiduciary agreement is an agreement by which a person, the
principal, agrees with another person, the fiduciary, that, subject to
the obligations determined by the parties, the fiduciary becomes
the owner of assets which shall form a fiduciary estate”.
full transfer of ownership in favor of the fiduciary
separate patrimony held by the fiduciary on behalf of the settlor
(patrimoine d'affectation)
No registration requirements in Luxembourg, except when relating
to real estate located in Luxembourg, or aircrafts or vessels
registered in Luxembourg
13
Luxembourg fiduciary agreements
Eligible persons as fiduciary credit institutions and certain
professionals of the financial sector:
investment firms, investment funds (SICAV, SICAF), management
companies of collective investment funds (FCP), pension funds,
insurance or reinsurance companies, securitization vehicles.
Non-eligible persons:
Lawyers, notaries, domiciliation agents
14
Luxembourg fiduciary agreements
Functioning
Freedom of contract
In absence of defined rules set by the parties rules
governing mandates except for representation and dismissal
principle
The fiduciary arrangement may be irrevocable and
discretionary
15
Luxembourg fiduciary agreements
The fiduciary assets do not belong to the personal estate of the
fiduciary agent
This segregation survives even in the case of bankruptcy or
insolvency of the fiduciary agent
the fiduciary assets cannot be seized by creditors of the
fiduciary agent
the fiduciary assets will not form part of the insolvency
estate of the fiduciary agent
16
Family wealth management company as an alternative
17
Family wealth management company as an alternative
The law on family wealth management companies (“société de
gestion de patrimoine familial” - “SPF”) was adopted on 11 May
2007
The SPF is designed as an investment company intended solely for
individuals managing their private wealth. The level of wealth or
sophistication of the individual is irrelevant.
The SPF is a legal entity separate from its shareholders
18
Family wealth management company as an alternative
Shareholders of the company :
any individuals acting within the framework of the management
of their private wealth;
any wealth management entities acting exclusively in the
interest of the private wealth of individuals i.e. family offices,
trusts, private foundations or similar entities;
intermediaries holding shares in the SPF on a fiduciary basis
or in a similar capacity, on behalf of eligible investors
« Family » notion :
no need to be relatives
19
Family wealth management company as an alternative
Corporate form : any form of a capital company such as the private
limited liability company, the public limited liability company, the
partnership limited by shares, or the cooperative company in the
form of a public limited company
minimum registered capital
31,000 EUR for a public limited liability company
12.500 EUR for a private limited liability company
20
Family wealth management company as an alternative
purpose of the company
acquisition, holding, management and sale of financial assets,
to the exclusion of any commercial activity
The SPF cannot:
hold real estate directly, but it can invest in any kind of property
company
grant loans
subscribe to an insurance policy
21
Family wealth management company as an alternative
Subjective tax exemption
No Withholding tax
No benefit from Double Tax Treaty
0.25% subscription tax (with a cap)
22
Specialized Investment Fund as an alternative
23
Specialized Investment Fund as an alternative
Introduced by a law of 13 February 2007
Subject to a light supervision by the CSSF:
Ex post approval procedure
Requirement of a prospectus (issuing document) which needs to
be updated only if new shares or units are issued to new
investors
No promoter requirement but reputable and experienced directors
Principle based investment restrictions
Subject to an annual subscription tax (taxe d’abonnement) at the
rate of 0.01%
24
Specialized Investment Fund as an alternative
Eligible investors: well-informed investors
Institutional investor, or
Professional investor, or
Other well-informed investor, i.e.
having confirmed in writing that he/she adheres to
the status of well-informed investor, and
investing a minimum of 125,000 Euros in a SIF
25
Specialized Investment Fund as an alternative
All legal forms permitted:
FCP (common fund)
SICAV (investment company with variable capital) / SICAF
(investment company with fixed capital) under the form of an
S.A., S.C.A., S.à R.L. or S.C.S.A.
Umbrella structure possible
26
Specialized Investment Fund as an alternative
Risk diversification
No quantitative investment restrictions except CSSF Circular
07/309 of 3 August 2007 (possible derogation):
-
no more than 30% of the SIF assets in securities of the same kind
issued by a single issuer;
Master-Feeder structure possible
27
Thank You
28
Contact us
Carine Feipel
Partner
Tel :+1 212 554 3541
Email : [email protected]