Transcript Slide 1

Developing an Educational
Framework for Disaster Medicine
and Public Health Preparedness
Italo Subbarao DO, MBA
Director of Public Health Readiness Office
AMA Center for Public Health Preparedness
and Disaster Response
Defining a Disaster
Risk = Hazard * Vulnerability
Why do we need Disaster Education?
 Disasters impact the entire health
system
 Cut across all health professions
 Require unprecedented collaboration
from disparate professions in an
immediate way
 Need to mitigate against excess
mortality and morbidity
Why is there a need for specialization?
 Natural Disasters are increasing due to
Climate Change
 Globalization has increased the risk of
Communicable Disease such as
Pandemic Influenza
 Globalization has increased the threat of
Terrorism
Natural Disasters
http://www.em-dat.net/
Globalization: Flattening the World
Unintended Consequences of
Globalization
Globalization
Developing
Country
Unintended
Consequences
Rapid
Industrialization
Need for Energy
Deforestation
↑Consumption
Greenhouse Gases
Climate Change
↑Natural Disasters
Urbanization
Overpopulation
Denser Populations
↑Risk Infectious DZ
↑Risk of Pandemic
Trade and
Commerce
Lenient barriers to
production.
Lassiez-Faire
Defective Products
Toothpaste, Toys
↑Risk of Toxic Expo
↑Risk of Pandemic
Communication
Sharing of
Ideologies
↑Risk of Global
Terrorism
Spanish Flu Death Chart
Infectious Disease and Globalization:
 Urbanization (Developing Countries)
 Overpopulation
 Increased Travel
 Climate Change Impact
Travel projections until 2017
Challenges with
Disaster Medical Education
 Rare and infrequent events
 Require dynamic teamwork
 Difficult to measure long-term retention
 Defining the target audiences, specialty,
discipline (public health, nursing, prehospital, hospital, emergency management)
Physicans
80:20
20:80
Competencies
Geo-Climatic
100
1,000
Bio
10
Chem
N/R
MD/DO
RN
Paramedic
B
T
R
Time
Goals
 Create an educational framework that
would meet the practical needs of all
health system responders.
 Consistency and common lexicon among
all learners and level of responders.
 Create a framework that would allow for
scientific evaluation and assessment.
Change Paradigm
 Shift from specialty/ discipline/ target
audience to functional-specific
(proficiency)
 Define distinct level of proficiencies that
comport to escalation in knowledge in
accordance with Blooms Taxonomy
 Tiered levels of proficiency: awareness,
tactics, and strategic operations
Educational Framework
Competencies
Learning
Objectives
Curriculum
Design
Revision
Evaluations
Educational Framework
Target Audiences
Informed Student/Worker: These are health
professionals and students who require
awareness and understanding of particular
aspects of disaster planning, mitigation,
response, or recovery.
Practitioner: These are health professionals
who are required to apply clinical or public
health knowledge, skills, and values in
disaster planning, mitigation, response, and
recovery.
Target Audiences
Leader: These are senior executives (CEO,
COO, CFO), directors, managers, and
department heads with administrative
decisions making responsibilities, leadership
functions, and policymaking roles in disaster
planning, mitigation, response, or recovery.
Core Competencies Domains
1.
Preparation and Planning
2.
Detection and Communication
3.
Incident Management and Support Systems
4.
Safety and Security
5.
Clinical/Public Health Assessment and Intervention
6.
Contingency, Continuity, and Recovery
7.
Public Health Law and Ethics
Stakeholder Review
American Academy of Family Physicians
American Academy of Pediatrics
American College of Physicians
American College of Emergency Physicians
American College of Surgeons
American Nurses Association
American Osteopathic Association
American Psychiatric Association
Emergency Nurses Association
Medical Reserve Corps
National Association of County and City Health Officials
National Association of Emergency Medical Services Physicians
Uniformed Services University of the Health Sciences
Learning Matrix
Competency Domains
1.0 Preparation and
Planning
Core Competencies
Health System Level of Proficiency
Informed Worker/Student
Practitioner
Leader
1.1 Demonstrate
proficiency in the use of an
all-hazards framework for
disaster planning.
1.1.1 Describe the allhazards framework for
disaster planning.
1.1.2 Explain key
components of your
regional, community,
institutional, and
personal/family disaster
plans.
1.1.3 Explain the motives,
tactics, and reasons for
terrorism in modern society.
1.1.4 Summarize your
regional, community, office
practice, and institutional
disaster plans.
1.1.5 Explain the purpose
of, and your role in,
community and institutional
disaster exercises and
drills.
1.1.6 Conduct hazard
vulnerability assessments
for your office practice,
community, or institution.
1.1.7 Create, evaluate,
and revise disaster
plans, exercises, and
drills for your region,
community, or institution
to address identified
disaster risks and
vulnerabilities.
1.2 Demonstrate
proficiency in addressing
the health-related needs,
values, and perspectives of
all ages and populations in
community and institutional
disaster plans.
1.2.1 Identify individuals (of
all ages) and populations
with special needs who may
be more vulnerable to
adverse health effects in a
disaster
1.2.2 Delineate medical
and mental health issues
that need to be addressed
in community and
institutional disaster plans
to accommodate the
needs, values, and
perspectives of all ages
and populations.
1.2.3 Create, evaluate,
and revise policies and
procedures for meeting
the health-related needs
of all ages and
populations in
community and
institutional disaster
plans.
Methodological Solutions
 Learn from other fields who have encountered
similar issues
 Simulation

Large Scale Drills (expensive)
Table Top Exercises

Computer Simulation (video games, virtual reality)

 Real Time Cognitive Aids
 Required Training
 Required Educators
National Disaster Life SupportTM
(NDLSTM) Program
 Suite of Courses:



Advanced Disaster Life SupportTM (ADLS®)
Basic Disaster Life SupportTM (BDLS®)
Core Disaster Life Support® (CDLS®)
 National Training Centers: 72
 Trained 70,000 health professionals
 Guided by the National Disaster Life Support
Education ConsortiumTM (NDLSECTM)
National Disaster Life Support Education
ConsortiumTM (NDLSECTM) Mission
The mission of the NDLSEC is to achieve
and promote excellence in education,
training, and research related to disaster
medicine and public health preparedness
for all health professionals based on
sound educational principles, scientific
evidence, and best clinical and public
health practices.
NDLSEC Membership*
25
20
15
10
5
0
Training
Centers
Healthcare
Organizations
Public Health Professional
Organizations Organizations
Academic
Centers
Private
Organizations
Individuals
*As of October 2008
Course Revision Process
 Course educational framework.
 Ensure learning objectives are appropriate
to the course under revision.
 Validate course evaluation and test design.
 Determine course format appropriate to
adult learning principles.
Course Revision Process
Competencies
Learning
Objectives
NDLSEC
Curriculum
Design
Revision
Evaluations
NDLS Program
and Medical Education
NDLS Program integrated into curriculum:
Medical Schools: 27
(Curriculum or NDLS Training Center)
Colleges of Nursing: 3
Colleges of Dentistry: 2
Other Health Professions Schools: 11
(including 1 Technical College)
Medical Student Survey
Lead Investigator: Heather Kaiser MPH, MS
Sample: AMA-MSS, AAMC-OSR, AOA-SOMA
Survey: 82 question, web-based (Nov 2007 – Mar
2008)
Response: 523/863 with representative sampling
of students from all 10 FEMA Regions (61%
response rate)
Purpose: Assess perceptions and self-described
likelihood to respond to disasters
Medical Student Survey
100
75
Willingness
50
Ability
25
0
Natural Disaster
Pan Flu Outreak
Radiological Event
Recommendations
 Adopt disaster medicine/public health
preparedness as a core competency for
medical students.
 Include disaster response questions in
USMLE Step requirements.
 Conduct a follow-up study with Medical
School Deans to objectively assess
disaster medicine integration into medical
school curriculum.
REPORT 15 OF THE COUNCIL ON MEDICAL EDUCATION
Education in Disaster Medicine and Public Health
Preparedness During Medical School and Residency Training
1. That Policy H-130.949, “Organized Medicine’s Role in
the National Response to Terrorism, be reaffirmed.”
2. That our American Medical Association recommend
that formal education and training in disaster medicine
and public health preparedness should be
incorporated into the curriculum at all medical schools
and residency programs.
3. That our AMA encourage medical schools and
residency programs to utilize multiple methods,
including simulation, disaster drills, interprofessional
team-based learning, and other interactive formats for
teaching disaster medicine and public health
preparedness.
REPORT 15 OF THE COUNCIL ON MEDICAL EDUCATION
Education in Disaster Medicine and Public Health
Preparedness During Medical School and Residency Training
4. That our AMA encourage public and private funders to
support the development and implementation of
education and training opportunities in disaster
medicine and public health preparedness for medical
students and resident physicians.
5. That our AMA support the National Disaster Life
SupportTM (NDLSTM) Program Office’s work to revise
and enhance the NDLS courses and supporting course
materials, in both didactic and electronic formats, for
use in medical schools and residency programs.
6. That our AMA support involvement of the National
Disaster Life Support Education ConsortiumTM in the
newly created Federal Education and Training
Interagency Group (FETIG).
Additional Information
NDLS Program
www.ama-assn.org/go/ndls
NDLSEC
www.ama-assn.org/go/ndlsec
Every physician has a second
specialty and that is…
Public Health