Tank Cleaning - Grit Industries
Download
Report
Transcript Tank Cleaning - Grit Industries
CHOPS
(Cold Heavy Oil Production with Sand)
Alberta accounts for
55 per cent of Canada's oil production,
or roughly 893,000 barrels per day.
Natural gas heats about one-half of
Canadian households, and provides
about 45 per cent of the energy used
by the country's manufacturing industries.
Alberta accounts for just over 80 per cent
of the natural gas produced in Canada –
itself the world's third-largest supplier of the gas –
and exports about three-quarters of its production
outside the province's boundaries.
About half of the five trillion cubic feet of gas
produced each year in Alberta is exported to the United States,
and about one-quarter flows to other points in Canada.
LLOYDMINSTER OILFIELDS
Lloydminster oilfields
have been operating
since the 1930’s.
Today there are well
over 6,000 wells in the area
producing in excess of
250,000 boepd.
Dina Well 1937
LLOYDMINSTER OILFIELDS
Some oil associated with gas
Very clean formations
Poorly consolidated
Cretaceous sequence
Deltaic sandstones
Production almost always includes
large amounts of formation sand
Dina Well (1937)
Original heavy oil in place estimated to be over
20 billion bbls (3 billion m3).
Primary recovery is estimated to be between
10 and 20%; some thermal EOR projects are
achieving much higher recoveries.
A DELTAIC DEPOSITIONAL ENVIRONMENT
A satellite photo of the Ganges Delta in India
Region
Lloydminster, Canada
Area
10,000 sq.miles
Depth
400-600 m
Depositional Environment
Cretaceous Deltaic Sand
Oil Density
960-990 kg/m3
Oil Viscosity
Up to 131,000 mPa.s
Reservoir Porosity
25 - 35%
Reservoir Permeability
0.5 – 8.0 darcies
Original GOR
100-150 scf/bbl
Original Sw
15%
Reservoir Sorting
Moderate to well
COLD HEAVY OIL PRODUCTION WITH SAND
Working Definition
Aggressive production of sand along with heavy oil under primary
production process
Alternative Names
Cold Flow
Cold Heavy Oil Production (CHOP)
Cold Production
CHOPS
Cold production theory states that continuous sand production is required to
maintain and/or maximize oil production
Initial sand production rates can be in excess of 40% by volume – this
decreases over time and settles at about 1% by volume on a cold
production well
OPERATING COSTS
14
12
4
2
}
}
0
SAGD
6
CHOPS
8
CSS
10
Before 1990
Cost per Barrel ($)
16
cold
+ steam
Source ARC
RECOVERY EFFICIENCY
50
10
}
}
0
CSS
20
CHOPS
30
SAGD
40
Before 1990
Recovery (%)
60
cold
+ steam
Source ARC
COLD PRODUCTION
Field Oil Production Rates
25
with
sand
15
3
Oil Rate (m /day)
20
10
without
sand
5
0
0
360
720
Production Time (days)
1,080
1,440
Source – Dr. Ron Sawatzky - ARC
Production rate (bbl/d)
COLD PRODUCTION PERFORMANCE
250
Oil rate
200
150
Start CHOPS
100
50
Water rate
0
Jan-81
Jan-85
Jan-89
Jan-93
Jan-97
Jan-01
Source – Dr. Ron Sawatzky - ARC
FOAMY OIL
Large numbers of persistent gas
bubbles in oil
Generated by de-pressurization of live
heavy oils
Provide part of the drive for CHOPS
Photo courtesy Dr. Ron Sawatzky- ARC
SAND PRODUCTION
Reservoir Impact
long wormholes in preferred, high
permeability layers
short lateral drainage distances to
high permeability channels
provide paths for CHOPS products to
flow
Photo courtesy Dr. Ron Sawatzky- ARC
MECHANICAL PRODUCTION TREATER
WHAT IS THE
HEAT DRIVEN LOOP?
The Heat Driven Loop
A new adaptation of existing
thermosyphon heat pump
technology
Uses latent heat of evaporation
from an evacuated, closed
system to transfer heat
Consists of an evaporator section
and a condenser/exchanger
section.
Since the latent heat of
evaporation is large,
considerable quantities of heat
can be transported quickly,
efficiently, and safely.
THE HEAT DRIVEN LOOP
The vaporizer and heat exchanger are evacuated
The water boils at a low temperature (≈ 43°C)
No air in the system reduces the risk of corrosion
Operates at less than 15 psig and less than 120°C
Lower temperature means lower heat loss to ambient
Heat added beyond the boiling point creates low pressure, low temperature,
superheated steam
The steam expands into the 45’ long heat exchanger
The steam condenses on the flow tube and gives up its heat to the oil in the
flowtube
Condensed, the steam collapses in volume and feeds by gravity back to the
evaporator
The expansion of the water into steam and the collapse of the steam into
condensate provide the motive force
WHAT ARE THE ADVANTAGES?
Increased heat transfer efficiency so reduced fuel requirements
Lower fuel pressure at burner (< 14” WC)
Eliminates direct firing of firetubes (controlled flux) – no scale – no hot spots
Reduced hazards
Reduced environmental risk and emissions
Lower heat losses to ambient
B-149.3 compliant
HDL APPLICATIONS
Heavy Oil Production Tanks
Slop Oil Treating Facilities
Heavy Oil Heat Exchangers
Natural Gas Line Heaters
Heavy Oil Wellsite Treating
MECHANICAL PRODUCTION TREATER
45‘ heat exchanger (condenser)
between well and tank
10” flowtube inside a 14” shell
Auger/mixer/separator slowly
turning in flowtube (≈ 1rpm)
Heat supplied by the
Heat Driven Loop
Gas separated prior to the tank
Chemical injection upstream
of treater
PILOT 1 – LASHBURN AREA WELL
Pilot test in
“problem high sand,
foamy well”
30 m3/d @ 30% (2.5%)
Unable to heat past 60º
Short loads due to foam
Sales cut 25-30%
Sales cut 2% solids
High solids cut required delivery
to a more distant facility
12
/
12 1/2
/1 00
12 5/2 3
/2 00
9 3
1/ /20
12 03
1/ /20
26 04
/2
2/ 00
9 4
2/ /20
23 04
/2
3/ 00
8/ 4
3/ 20
22 04
/2
4/ 00
5/ 4
4/ 20
19 04
/2
5/ 00
3/ 4
5/ 20
17 04
5/ /20
31 04
6/ /20
14 04
6/ /20
28 04
7/ /20
12 04
7/ /20
26 04
/2
8/ 00
9 4
8/ /20
23 04
/2
9/ 00
6 4
9/ /20
20 04
10 /20
/ 0
10 4/2 4
/1 00
8 4
11 /20
/ 0
11 1/2 4
/1 00
11 5/2 4
/2 00
12 9/2 4
/1 00
12 3/2 4
/2 00
7 4
1/ /20
10 04
1/ /20
24 05
/2
2/ 00
7 5
2/ /20
21 05
/2
3/ 00
7 5
3/ /20
21 05
/2
00
5
Total BS&W (percent)
A3-7-48-25W3M Cuts (from the 12' tap)
35
15
10
Installed Treater
30
Started
Chemical
25
20
Installed
2" Gas
Vent Line
Removed Treater
for Modifications
Installed
6" Gas
Vent Line
Reinstalled
5
0
PILOT 1 – LASHBURN AREA WELL
Results
Significant device modifications during test – a learning process
Tank is now consistently over 80º
Foam problems resolved
Sales cut 0.4 – 1.5%
Sales cut trace solids
Fuel Consumption = 84% of conventional system previously in use
Oil to nearby facility
Dependable
Fluid Thermal Efficiency – 58% versus immersion tube efficiency of 32%
PILOT 2 – LONE ROCK AREA
Pilot test in good well
20m3/d @ 30% (trace)
Whole purpose of test was to
determine if the device could
consistently treat clean in a
single tank
9/16/2004
9/9/2004
9/2/2004
8/26/2004
8/19/2004
8/12/2004
8/5/2004
7/29/2004
7/22/2004
7/15/2004
7/8/2004
7/1/2004
6/24/2004
6/17/2004
6/10/2004
6/3/2004
5/27/2004
5/20/2004
5/13/2004
5/6/2004
6
4/29/2004
24
4/22/2004
8
4/15/2004
4/8/2004
4/1/2004
BS&W (%)
Tank Sales Cut
30
28
26
Installed on
April 9
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
Gas supply
problems
4
2
0
PILOT 2 – LONE ROCK AREA
Consistently treats clean (<0.5%
BS&W) in single tank
Has been dependable and easy to
operate but has had some
problems with wet gas on
location
SINGLE WELL INSTALLS
Location
Oil Production
Wellhead Cut
Tank Temp °C
Sales Cut
TWP - 46-27
12
30%
80
0.3%
TWP - 48-25
13
40%
84
0.3% to 1.5%
6-33-44-24 W3M
11
9%
73
0.3%
8-33-44-24 W3M
10
5%
70
0.1%
10-33-44-24 W3M
14
12%
70
0.1%
10-9-55-26 W3M
12
5% High Solids
75
0.1%
1-5-56-27 W3M
15
22% High Solids
75
0.2%
10-5-56-27 W3M
9
35%
85
0.4%
14-5-56-27 W3M*
11
50%
75
0.4%
ENCANA – PROVOST
Plant Evaluation Trial
2 MPT’s installed at a field header on a test/interim basis while waiting for
a cleaning plant to be completed
Test ran for ≈ 90 days
Typical Oil – 74 m3/d
Typical Water – 65 m3/d
Average input W/C - 46%
Demulsifier at 130 ppm
The MPT consistently produced clean oil from sales tank
ENCANA – PROVOST
PROCESS LAYOUT
Mechanical Production Treaters
CNRL – EAST TILL
Slop treating facility
Continuous once through process
Cleaning slop and cavern material to less than 0.5% by volume
Current rate is 35 m3/d (40% - 5% sand)
CNRL – EAST TILL
SLOP MANAGEMENT
WHY DOES AN MPT WORK?
Very efficient heat transfer.
Good chemical distribution
Short vertical travel distance for oil, water, and sand droplets while in
flowtube
Removes the gas prior to the tank (reduced turbulence in tank)
No firetube related convection in the tank
Augured tank cleaning reduces cleaning turbulence
10” flow tube reduces fluid velocity entering the tank
Quiescence in tank
MECHANICAL PRODUCTION TREATERS
High Efficiency
Thorough Separation
Reduced Fuel Costs
Reduced Chemical Costs
Reduced Emissions
Reduced Maintenance Costs
Safe
Dependable and Simple to Operate
SAND MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES
Objectives
Reduce waste volumes
Reduce waste handling costs
Reduce tank maintenance costs
Minimize slop oil generation
TANK CLEANING
Sand is recovered from the
production tank in one of
three ways:
Manual
Stinging
Augering
The recovered material is
trucked to disposal
SCS SERVICES
Grithog Machine – door pulls
GRS Permanent Waste Recovery Systems – in plant applications
and large tanks
PVA – “Penetrator” Mobile Augering Technology – various SWB
and pads in the field
GRS PERMANENT SAND REMOVAL SYSTEM
Best option for large, flat bottom, process tanks
Can clean tanks thoroughly without shutting down or contaminating the
process
GRS PVA – “PENETRATOR”
MOBILE AUGERING TECHNOLOGY
Economic means of tank cleaning for SWB and pads
Reduces waste volume by recovering sand – not water
Reduces tank upset
Increases firetube life
Can operate with and remove scale on the tank floor
E&P COMPANY STUDY CONCLUSIONS
40% reduction in waste volumes due to augering in field locations
Waste handling cost of $1.22/bbl versus $1.58/bbl with stinging
(23% reduction)
Better Water Quality – less disposal problems
Less Traffic
Reduced Tank Failures
Fewer cleanouts – fewer loads
TANK CLEANING IN HEAVY OIL
Sand Control Systems tank cleaning results in significant reductions
in operating costs relative to stinging.
More sand is recovered per tonne of waste
Less water is recovered and disposed of as sand
Heavier payloads
Less frequent cleanouts
TANK CLEANING IN HEAVY OIL
Sand Control Systems tank cleaning results in significant reductions
in operating problems
Less disruption of the tank separation process
Less fines in the oil – less slop
Better water quality – less problems at the SWD plant and wells
Reduced cooling by agitation
Less scale on firetubes – less failures