DOL Investigation Update: What to Expect in FY 2010
Download
Report
Transcript DOL Investigation Update: What to Expect in FY 2010
DOL Investigation Update:
What to Expect in FY 2010
Los Angeles Benefits
Conference
Virginia Smith, EBSA
R. Bradford Huss, Esq., APM
Introduction
Today’s Topics:
> Employee Benefits Security Administration
> National Enforcement Projects
> The Investigative Process
> Other Enforcement Issues
2
FY 2009 Enforcement Results
3,669 civil investigations closed
2,833 (77%) civil investigations closed with results
$1.36 billion in total monetary results
> Includes $73.6 million through the VFCP
287 criminal investigations closed
121 criminal investigations closed with guilty pleas
or convictions
115 individuals indicted
3
EBSA National Enforcement Priority FY10
Delinquent Employee Contributions
> Proposed safe harbor regulation
> ERISA Reg. 29 CFR 2510.3-102
> Advisory Opinion 2002-02A (May 2002)
> Field Assistance Bulletin 2003-2 (May 2003)
4
EBSA National Enforcement Projects FY10
Contributory Plans Criminal Project (CPCP)
REACT (Bankruptcy)
Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs)
Health Fraud/MEWAs
Consultant/Adviser Project (CAP)
5
Bankruptcy and Financially Distressed Plan Sponsors
Rapid ERISA Action Team (REACT)
> Preserve plan assets
> Determine whether the sponsor has made all required
contributions
> Ensure plan’s rights are protected
> Identify responsible fiduciaries
6
Employee Stock Ownership Plans
Potential ERISA Violations
Failure to properly value employer security
> Fraudulent valuations
> “Optimistic” valuations
> Dated valuations
Refinancing of ESOP loans
> Application of FAB 2002-1
7
Health Fraud/MEWAs
Civil Enforcement Actions
> Temporary Restraining Order (TRO)
> Pursue Monetary Judgments
> Bar from future Plan association
> Appointment of Independent Fiduciary
Criminal Enforcement Actions
> Seizure of Assets
> Forfeiture of Assets
> Criminal Penalties
> 13 year bar
• Knowing violation of bar causes additional criminal violations
8
Consultant/Adviser Project (CAP)
Focus: potential civil and criminal violations arising
from the receipt of improper, undisclosed
compensation
Expanded in FY 2010
Do plan fiduciaries understand the compensation
and fee arrangements they enter into?
> Plan investment guidelines
> Proper selection and monitoring of service providers
9
Contributory Plans Criminal Project
Target the most egregious and persistent violators
Protect the most vulnerable populations
Issues:
> Employers convert employee payroll contributions for
personal or business use
> Third parties gain access and use funds for their own
financial gain
> Identity theft or tampering with personal data records
10
Criminal Investigations
ERISA Criminal Statutes
> Section 411 – ERISA Bar
> Section 501 – Reporting
> Section 511 – Coercive Interference
11
Criminal Investigations
Title 18 – “The Big Three”
> 18 USC Sections 664, 1027 & 1954:
Embezzlement, False Records and Kickbacks
Health Care Penalties
> 18 USC Sections 669, 1035, 1347:
Embezzlement, False Records, Health Care Fraud
Other Relevant Criminal Statutes
> Mail, Wire, Conspiracy, Money Laundering etc.
12
Investigative Authority of DOL
Statutory grant of power
> ERISA section 504
> Comprehensive Crime Control Act of 1984
Subpoena authority
Disclosure of information by the DOL
13
Sources of EBSA Investigations
Participant complaints
Other government agencies
Service provider complaints
Forms 5500
Media
Other sources
14
Investigative Process
EBSA Investigative Procedure
> Enforcement Guidelines
• Nondisclosure of basis of investigation
EBSA Enforcement Manual
Start of the investigation
> See
> phone call from Investigator / Auditor
> Followed by confirmation letter
• Date & time of visit
• Plan(s) to be reviewed
• Records / documents needed
– Varies depending on issue
15
Potential Areas of Investigation
Fiduciary Duties
Co-fiduciary Liability
Plan Expenses and Operations
Plan Investments
Prohibited Transactions
Employer Securities
Real Estate Holding
Claims Procedures
Bonding, Reporting, Disclosure
16
Document Requests
Plan Document, SPD and Trust Agreement
Form 5500 (last 3 years)
Payroll/contribution records
Accountant’s Records
Service Provider Agreements and Contracts
Benefit Statements and Benefit Payment Records
Minutes of Meetings
Plan Asset Records, including appraisals
Fidelity Bond and Fiduciary Liability Insurance Policy
IRS Determination Letter
17
Interviews with Plan Fiduciaries
Explain fiduciary decisions
Describe processes
• Forwarding employee contributions
• Benefit payments
• Expenses
• Investments
Identification of service providers
False Statements
> 18 USC Section 1001
18
Resolution of the Investigation
No action
Voluntary out-of-court settlement
Civil litigation
Civil money penalties
IRS referral
Disclosure of investigative results
Criminal prosecution
19
Correction of Violations
General Rule
> The Plan must be made whole
> Prohibited Transactions
• DOL PTCE 94-71
Civil Penalties
> ERISA Section 502(l)
> Amount
> Waiver or Reduction of Penalty by DOL
> Penalty Offset by PT Excise Tax
20
Correction of Violations
Depending upon the circumstances, EBSA may seek
> Correction of prohibited transactions
> Restoration of losses
> Penalties
> Removal of fiduciaries
> Removal of service providers
> Appointment of independent fiduciary
> Implementation of new internal controls
> Supplemental benefit distributions
> Final accounting
21
IRS Referrals
IRS Coordination Agreement and Statute requires:
> referral of prohibited transactions to IRS
• IRC § 4975 excise tax
> referral of potential issues affecting
tax qualified status
22
Other Enforcement Issues
Pursuing settlement agreements
Prevailing wage plans
Financial fraud
23
Contact Points
EBSA website: www.dol.gov/ebsa
Technical Assistance nationwide:
1-866-444-EBSA (3272)
Publications: 1-800-998-7542
24
Helpful EBSA Publications
Understanding Your Fiduciary Responsibilities Under a
Group Health Plan - NEW
Understanding Retirement Plan Fees and Expenses
Automatic Enrollment 401(k) Plans for Small Businesses
- NEW
Selecting an Auditor for Your Employee Benefit Plan
Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibilities -UPDATED
Reporting and Disclosure Guide - UPDATED
Selecting & Monitoring Pension Consultants – Tips for
Plan Fiduciaries
Tips for Selecting and Monitoring Service Providers for
Your Employee Benefit Plan
25