DOL Investigation Update: What to Expect in FY 2010

Download Report

Transcript DOL Investigation Update: What to Expect in FY 2010

DOL Investigation Update:
What to Expect in FY 2010
Los Angeles Benefits
Conference
Virginia Smith, EBSA
R. Bradford Huss, Esq., APM
Introduction
 Today’s Topics:
> Employee Benefits Security Administration
> National Enforcement Projects
> The Investigative Process
> Other Enforcement Issues
2
FY 2009 Enforcement Results
 3,669 civil investigations closed
 2,833 (77%) civil investigations closed with results
 $1.36 billion in total monetary results
> Includes $73.6 million through the VFCP
 287 criminal investigations closed
 121 criminal investigations closed with guilty pleas
or convictions
 115 individuals indicted
3
EBSA National Enforcement Priority FY10
 Delinquent Employee Contributions
> Proposed safe harbor regulation
> ERISA Reg. 29 CFR 2510.3-102
> Advisory Opinion 2002-02A (May 2002)
> Field Assistance Bulletin 2003-2 (May 2003)
4
EBSA National Enforcement Projects FY10
 Contributory Plans Criminal Project (CPCP)
 REACT (Bankruptcy)
 Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs)
 Health Fraud/MEWAs
 Consultant/Adviser Project (CAP)
5
Bankruptcy and Financially Distressed Plan Sponsors
 Rapid ERISA Action Team (REACT)
> Preserve plan assets
> Determine whether the sponsor has made all required
contributions
> Ensure plan’s rights are protected
> Identify responsible fiduciaries
6
Employee Stock Ownership Plans
Potential ERISA Violations
 Failure to properly value employer security
> Fraudulent valuations
> “Optimistic” valuations
> Dated valuations
 Refinancing of ESOP loans
> Application of FAB 2002-1
7
Health Fraud/MEWAs
 Civil Enforcement Actions
> Temporary Restraining Order (TRO)
> Pursue Monetary Judgments
> Bar from future Plan association
> Appointment of Independent Fiduciary
 Criminal Enforcement Actions
> Seizure of Assets
> Forfeiture of Assets
> Criminal Penalties
> 13 year bar
• Knowing violation of bar causes additional criminal violations
8
Consultant/Adviser Project (CAP)
 Focus: potential civil and criminal violations arising
from the receipt of improper, undisclosed
compensation
 Expanded in FY 2010
 Do plan fiduciaries understand the compensation
and fee arrangements they enter into?
> Plan investment guidelines
> Proper selection and monitoring of service providers
9
Contributory Plans Criminal Project
 Target the most egregious and persistent violators
 Protect the most vulnerable populations
 Issues:
> Employers convert employee payroll contributions for
personal or business use
> Third parties gain access and use funds for their own
financial gain
> Identity theft or tampering with personal data records
10
Criminal Investigations
 ERISA Criminal Statutes
> Section 411 – ERISA Bar
> Section 501 – Reporting
> Section 511 – Coercive Interference
11
Criminal Investigations
 Title 18 – “The Big Three”
> 18 USC Sections 664, 1027 & 1954:
Embezzlement, False Records and Kickbacks
 Health Care Penalties
> 18 USC Sections 669, 1035, 1347:
Embezzlement, False Records, Health Care Fraud
 Other Relevant Criminal Statutes
> Mail, Wire, Conspiracy, Money Laundering etc.
12
Investigative Authority of DOL
 Statutory grant of power
> ERISA section 504
> Comprehensive Crime Control Act of 1984
 Subpoena authority
 Disclosure of information by the DOL
13
Sources of EBSA Investigations
 Participant complaints
 Other government agencies
 Service provider complaints
 Forms 5500
 Media
 Other sources
14
Investigative Process
 EBSA Investigative Procedure
> Enforcement Guidelines
• Nondisclosure of basis of investigation
EBSA Enforcement Manual
 Start of the investigation
> See
> phone call from Investigator / Auditor
> Followed by confirmation letter
• Date & time of visit
• Plan(s) to be reviewed
• Records / documents needed
– Varies depending on issue
15
Potential Areas of Investigation
 Fiduciary Duties
 Co-fiduciary Liability
 Plan Expenses and Operations
 Plan Investments
 Prohibited Transactions
 Employer Securities
 Real Estate Holding
 Claims Procedures
 Bonding, Reporting, Disclosure
16
Document Requests
 Plan Document, SPD and Trust Agreement
 Form 5500 (last 3 years)
 Payroll/contribution records
 Accountant’s Records
 Service Provider Agreements and Contracts
 Benefit Statements and Benefit Payment Records
 Minutes of Meetings
 Plan Asset Records, including appraisals
 Fidelity Bond and Fiduciary Liability Insurance Policy
 IRS Determination Letter
17
Interviews with Plan Fiduciaries
 Explain fiduciary decisions
 Describe processes
• Forwarding employee contributions
• Benefit payments
• Expenses
• Investments
 Identification of service providers
 False Statements
> 18 USC Section 1001
18
Resolution of the Investigation
 No action
 Voluntary out-of-court settlement
 Civil litigation
 Civil money penalties
 IRS referral
 Disclosure of investigative results
 Criminal prosecution
19
Correction of Violations
 General Rule
> The Plan must be made whole
> Prohibited Transactions
• DOL PTCE 94-71
 Civil Penalties
> ERISA Section 502(l)
> Amount
> Waiver or Reduction of Penalty by DOL
> Penalty Offset by PT Excise Tax
20
Correction of Violations
 Depending upon the circumstances, EBSA may seek
> Correction of prohibited transactions
> Restoration of losses
> Penalties
> Removal of fiduciaries
> Removal of service providers
> Appointment of independent fiduciary
> Implementation of new internal controls
> Supplemental benefit distributions
> Final accounting
21
IRS Referrals
 IRS Coordination Agreement and Statute requires:
> referral of prohibited transactions to IRS
• IRC § 4975 excise tax
> referral of potential issues affecting
tax qualified status
22
Other Enforcement Issues
 Pursuing settlement agreements
 Prevailing wage plans
 Financial fraud
23
Contact Points
 EBSA website: www.dol.gov/ebsa
 Technical Assistance nationwide:
1-866-444-EBSA (3272)
 Publications: 1-800-998-7542
24
Helpful EBSA Publications
 Understanding Your Fiduciary Responsibilities Under a
Group Health Plan - NEW
 Understanding Retirement Plan Fees and Expenses
 Automatic Enrollment 401(k) Plans for Small Businesses
- NEW
 Selecting an Auditor for Your Employee Benefit Plan
 Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibilities -UPDATED
 Reporting and Disclosure Guide - UPDATED
 Selecting & Monitoring Pension Consultants – Tips for
Plan Fiduciaries
 Tips for Selecting and Monitoring Service Providers for
Your Employee Benefit Plan
25