Transcript Test
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Integrated modelling of tokamak
plasmas :
the CRONOS code
F. Imbeaux,
J. F. Artaud, V. Basiuk, T. Aniel, J. Decker, G. Garcia, G.
Giruzzi, P. Huynh, G. Huysmans, R. Masset, Y. Peysson,
M. Schneider, G. Selig
CEA, IRFM, F-13108 Saint Paul Lez Durance, France
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
1
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Outline
cadarache
• Integrated Modelling : definition and motivation
• An example : the CRONOS suite
• Organisation and workflow
• Examples of applications :
• current diffusion, comparison to experiment
• coupled transport + free-boundary equilibrium calculations
• Numerical aspects : convergence loops : transport solver
• Conclusions and perspectives
• Limitations
• Perspectives for the future
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
2
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Introduction : what is
integrated modelling ?
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
3
i r f m
cadarache
Physics problems are strongly
coupled integration
Association
Euratom-CEA
Numerical tokamak : must include all physics coupling … and also
extend to technology : heating systems, magnetic field coils,
diagnostics
MHD limits
Edge plasma
Radiation, recycling,
…
Plasma facing
components
Heat load, erosion,
…
Core plasma
Transport equations
for particles, heat,
current, momentum
Sources
Transport
Particles, heat,
current,
momentum
Particles, heat,
current,
momentum
Fusion
reactions
Equilibrium
a-heating
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
4
i r f m
cadarache
Integrated Modelling : a
realistic numerical experiment
Association
Euratom-CEA
Fully coupled physics :
describe all interactions between various physical
phenomena
Fully self-consistent calculations
Cost : reduced dimensionality (mix 1-D / 2-D), use
often simplified models (e.g. turbulence, MHD, …)
Realistic configuration of sub-systems (mainly : heating,
magnetic field coils, diagnostics, wall, …)
Time and space scales of a tokamak experiment :
time : a few seconds to several minutes
space : full plasma, including edge and subsystems
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
5
i r f m
cadarache
Applications of Integrated
Modelling
Association
Euratom-CEA
Analysis of existing experiments (interpretation)
Data validation : multiple measurements put together to
check their consistency (mainly through current diffusion
simulations)
Testing the accuracy of models (e.g. transport)
Predicting future experiments saving the cost of a real
experiment !!
Experiment preparation
Extrapolation to future devices, scenario design
Develop feedback control schemes
Sub-system design (e.g. heating, diagnostic, …)
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
6
i r f m
Various levels of description
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
0D
No space dependence, purely based on 0D scalings
Basic device design (major radius, plasma current, …)
example : HELIOS
1D½
Core transport equations are fluid and 1-D in space,
Sophisticated source / equilibrium modules can be kinetic, 2-D or 3D in space
Detailed Integrated Modelling
example : CRONOS, ASTRA, JETTO, TRANSP, CORSICA, TOPICS, …
mix 0D/1D
Mix of scalings + 1-D description of profiles, simplified modules, fast
calculations (< 1mn CPU)
Flight simulator : preliminar scenario studies, pre-shot discharge
assessment, data consistency tests
example : METIS (included in the CRONOS platform)
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
7
i r f m
cadarache
Reducing the dimensionality
of the problem
Association
Euratom-CEA
Core plasma : 1-D fluid description for the transport
equations
•
•
Magnetic confinement : closed nested magnetic
surfaces, labeled by a radial coordinate. Transport
in the perpendicular direction.
Ip
(,,p||,p)
gyro-average
Toroidal axisymmetry
Kinetic description
Local description,
Not measurable
R
r
(,n,T)
Fluid moments +
flux surface
averaging
Fluid description
Semi-macroscopic quantities,
In some cases measurable
Macroscopic quantities,
In most cases mesurable
Some modules : heating,
equilibrium
Core transport equations
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
B
Thermal populations are Maxwellian, fluid
quantities such as density and temperature are
constant on a flux surface
(x,y,z,px,py ,py)
B
8
i r f m
cadarache
1D½ simulators usually organised
around core transport equations
Association
Euratom-CEA
Main loop : solve a set of radial continuity equations for
poloidal flux(current), energy, particles, toroidal momentum
Usual diffusive-convective form of the flux :
<A> = flux surface
average
Modular structure for self-consistent evaluation of
Flux-surface geometry
→ equilibrium solver
Source terms
→ source modules
Transported flux
→ neoclassical module
+
turbulent transport (the most simplified module)
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
9
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
The CRONOS Integrated
Modelling suite
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
10
i r f m
The CRONOS suite
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
•
Continuous development since 1999 at CEA-IRFM
•
Essentially core transport
•
Modern code design : high modularity, object-oriented data model,
dynamic generation of graphical interfaces and of data
management routines
•
Strong link to experiment : versatile interpretative / predictive
simulation platform
• Input : experimental database access, profile fitting
• Output : comparison to experimental signals, synthetised
diagnostics
•
Graphics : Matlab environment allows high flexibility in
visualisation / data edition / interactive simulation / debugging
•
Features sophisticated source and equilibrium modules, mostly
developed at CEA-IRFM : on-site expertise, avoid « black-box »
calculations
F. Imbeaux
et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
11
i r f m
cadarache
CRONOS : modular structure around
core transport equations
Input
parameters
Equilibrium solver
HELENA
Sawteeth,
ELMs, reconnections
MHD stability,
MISHKA
Linear stability,
gyrokinetics,
KINEZERO
Model of plasma
for edge+SOL,
(SOL-ONE)
Pellet
injection,
GLAQUELC
Transport
coefficients:
NCLASS...
Transport
solver tt+t
(1.5D)
Impurities,
radiations, ITC
Fusion power,a
particle dynamics,
SPOT
Association
Euratom-CEA
Selfconsistent
coupling
LH wave propag. &
absorp., el. distrib. func.
DELPHINE+DKE
ICRF wave propagation,
resonating ion distrib.
function, PION
NBI deposition &
distrib. function,
SINBAD
Simulation
output
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
ECRF wave
propagation, REMA
20-24 April 2008
12
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
General CRONOS workflow
cadarache
Input file
Initialisation
Equilibrium
convergence
Initial source
module calls
Main loop
on time
Postprocessing
Result file
« External » modules
Within one time
step
Transport coefficients
Transport equation solver
(finite differences, coupled
equations, convergence on
non-linearities of transport
model)
Equilibrium
Neoclassic
Equilibrium
convergence
Additional sources
Edge
Source module calls
Impurity content,
radiation
Determination of
optimal time step
(transport
equation
convergence)
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
Pellets
Plasma
events
MHD
20-24 April 2008
13
i r f m
Transport solver is the simplest part !
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
•
Core transport equations are 1D, fluid
(thermal plasma)
•
Other modules can be much more
sophisticated
•
Equilibrium : 2D
•
NBI, wave solvers : often 3D for the
propagation
•
Modelling of fast particles :
• Fokker-Planck solvers
3D configuration
of JET beam lines
• Monte-Carlo solvers
source terms to the thermal plasma
(transport equations)
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
14
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Coupling between source modules
cadarache
•
Parasitic absorption of LH waves by fusion
born alpha particles
•
Ray-tracing + Fokker-Planck for LH
propagation and absorption on electrons
(current drive)
•
Z
Orbit following code for fusion-born alpha
particles (orbit effects are important), Monte
Carlo operators for i) collisions and ii)
quasilinear interaction with RF waves
Passing orbit
Ray-tracing elements at
places of strong interaction
with alpha particles
Z
1.5
1
0.5
0
-0.5
Initial position
Element of
power Pp
-1
Trapped orbit
2
3
4 R
R
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
15
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Application : modelling of
current profile in tokamaks
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
16
i r f m
Current profile in tokamaks
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Current profile is an important quantity for confinement
properties. Turbulence sensitive on current profile
Safety factor : q-profile : magnetic field line topology ,
closely related to the current profile : number of toroidal
turns / number of poloidal turns
q = 2 surface/field line
B
R
Ip
r
B
High order rational values of q : closed field lines; MHD
activity can develop characterisation of q-profile
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
17
i r f m
cadarache
Determination of current
profile
Association
Euratom-CEA
Current profile not routinely measured useful to
calculate it from Integrated Simulations
MHD markers are extremely useful to validate the
simulation
Neoclassical resistivity describes well current diffusion
in tokamaks – plays the role of a diffusion coefficient
Current diffusion simulations are used :
To check data consistency (e.g. Zeff, Te in ohmic discharges,
total energy content versus magnetics)
To determine the current profile of an experiment
To determine the « experimental » transport coefficients (all
source terms calculated)
To test current drive models against experiment
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
18
i r f m
cadarache
Current profile shaping
experiment
Association
Euratom-CEA
Current ramp at the beginning of the discharge, modified
by the injection of a small amount of co-ECCD (r = 0.3)
Appearance time of sawtooth (MHD linked to q = 1)
delayed by 0.5 s
Sawteeth start @ t = 1.8 s Sawteeth start @ t = 2.3 s
Ip ramp,
stops at t =
1 s (0.9 MA)
ECCD
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
19
i r f m
Determination of current
profile
cadarache
Association
Euratom-CEA
Current diffusion + EC current source term calculated by
CRONOS
Calculated dynamics of current profile are in very good
agreement with MHD markers (time of sawtooth onset +
position of the q = 1 surface)
t=1s
t=2s
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
t=3s
20-24 April 2008
20
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Current diffusion simulation validated by
synthetised diagnostic comparison
cadarache
MSE angles (rad)
00.1
.10
0.05
0.05
M SE polarisat
ion
angles
JET shot
with
ITB
# 5 3 5 2 1 , t = 5 .5 s
#53521,measured
t = 5.5 s
simulat ed
0
M SE a ngle s [ ra0d. ]
-0.05
-0 . 0 5
-0.1
..⃝.. Measured
-- Simulated
-0 . 1 0
2.8
3.0
3.2
Rra
(m)
M a jor
dius [ m ]
3.4
[X. Litaudon et al., Nucl. Fusion 44 (2002)]
CRONOS includes synthetised
diagnostics + experimental data
visualisation tools
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
21
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Coupling transport equations
and free-boundary equilibrium
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
22
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Free-boundary equilibrium
cadarache
Equilibrium and pressure / current transport
are tightly coupled specific convergence
loop
Fixed-boundary : plasma separatrix is
prescribed, equilibrium solved only inside
separatrix
Free-boundary : plasma separatrix is
calculated by the equilibrium which uses :
ITER
PF1
CS3U
CS2U
Boundary conditions : poloidal field
coil currents
CS1
Constraint : j,p profiles in the plasma
CS2L
Application : realistic simulation of the
whole plasma including its boundary
(depends significantly on plasma profiles),
integrated simulation of poloidal field coils
circuits
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
PF2
PF3
PF4
CS3L
PF6
PF5
20-24 April 2008
23
i r f m
cadarache
Free-boundary equilibrium :
application to ITER ramp-up
Association
Euratom-CEA
CRONOS-DINA simulator : scenario optimisation of the current ramp-up in ITER
(scenario 2)
Application of LHCD decreases internal inductance (reduces vertical instabilities)
and saves flux
Plasma boundary controlled by prescribing « gaps ». Feedback control on the
poloidal coil voltages. Coil currents calculated, remain within operational limits.
X-point formation and shape evolution strongly depends on the plasma profiles
[S.H. Kim et al,
accepted
PPCF 2009]
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
24
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Transport
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
25
i r f m
Transport solver
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Though written as diffusive-convective, transport is in fact much
more complex :
transport coefficients feature parametric dependencies on the
transported quantities and their gradients
Coupling between transport equations
n,T, (t)
Transport equation using
n, T , q, n, T , q
n,T, (t+dt)
Anomalous transport models (turbulence) usually quite sensitive to
the transported quantities and their gradients (non-linear
dependencies, including threshold effects)
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
26
i r f m
cadarache
Association
Euratom-CEA
Convergence loop in transport
solver (e.g. heat)
p(t-dt), (t-dt) , S(t-dt)
p pressure
diffusivity
S source
1= (p1(t),…)
Convergence
Loop on time
First guess : adiabatic p1(t)
Solve transport equation pn(t)
finite difference scheme, implicit or Crank-Nicholson
NO
Convergence ?
n=α (pn(t),…) +(1-α) n-1
0 < a < 1 : damping non-linearities for faster convergence
YES
p(t), (t) S(t), …
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
neo, sources
can be adapted inside
convergence loop (optional)
20-24 April 2008
27
i r f m
Duration of a simulation
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Sophisticated source modules can be time-consuming. However,
source evolve usually much slower than transported quantities
source modules not called at each time step (user’s choice) !
For reasonable calling frequency of source models, the main
contributor to the computation time is the anomalous transport
model (turbulence), since it is called in the innermost loop : main
time loop + convergence on non-linearities loop
1-103 s
tsimulation tmodel
t plasma
tsolver
1-5
niterations
10-4 s
So for a 10 s plasma :
Acceptable tmodel should be ~ 1-10 s (in order to have the result
within ~ 1-12 days)
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
28
i r f m
cadarache
Simplified transport models
are used
Association
Euratom-CEA
Theoretical description of plasma turbulence : Vlasov +
Maxwell equations
Full non-linear treatment of these equations (either fluid
or gyrokinetic formulation) is orders of magnitude
beyond the requested computation time tmodel ~ 1-10 s
Need for an intermediate degree of complexity : quasilinear approximation :
1990’s models : Weiland model, GLF23
New generation : TGLF, Qualikiz more
sophisticated, require some parallelisation
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
29
i r f m
cadarache
Transport is the Achille’s heel
of Integrated Modelling
Association
Euratom-CEA
Simplified turbulence models are too simple : lack of
reliability for the prediction of core transport
H-mode pedestal still poorly understood from first
principles
All phenomena coupled in a
simulation fully predictive
transport modelling is highly
uncertain
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
(GLF23 :
prediction
inside r < 0.8
only)
[Imbeaux et al,
PPCF 2005]
30
20-24 April 2008
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Conclusions and perspectives
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
31
i r f m
cadarache
Integrated Modelling : what it
is and what it is not
Association
Euratom-CEA
Integrated Modelling is a sophisticated way of coupling
many physics modules, mandatory since physics
phenomena are coupled
Ideal framework for working :
Closest to realistic experimental conditions
With a guarantee of consistency of input/output
between physics modules
Sophisticated coupling gives an impression of global
predictive capability
Several individual models are far from 100% reliability (in
particular transport models, but not only) be aware of
the limitations !!
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
32
i r f m
cadarache
Perspectives for Integrated
Modelling
Association
Euratom-CEA
Progress in computer performances more and more
sophisticated modules
Main time loop cannot be parallelised, but sophisticated
individual modules can (already the case in CRONOS) :
Increase link with High Performance Computing
Present weaknesses in individual models must be
overcome
By closer interaction with First Principles
calculations and Theory
Extensive model testing against existing experiments
Present Integrated Modelling codes are built around core
transport equations
Build a fully flexible Integrated Modelling platform
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
33
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Since 2004, the ITM-TF aims at defining and setting up
the ideal Integrated Modelling platform
Unique data format, object-oriented, logically
structured to represent physics elementary problems
Fully flexible and modular workflow, connected to
HPC could be used even as a framework for First
Principles calculations
Transparent use of multiple programming languages
Transparent data access and unique representation
of any Tokamak
Synthetised diagnostics, technological modelling
ideal tool for model testing and improving our
understanding !
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
34
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
This is just the beginning of this endeavour
Many obstacles, large ressources needed in computer science for
the development of the platform
Graphical workflow design : prototype of the European Transport
Solver
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
35
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Final words
cadarache
CRONOS : a sophisticated and mature plasma core
Integrated Solver
Strong link to experiment
Versatile interpretative / predictive simulations
Ongoing developments : free-boundary equilibria, quasilinear transport models, impurity transport, basic plasma
edge modules …
Used for interpretation of existing experiments and ITER
scenario design
CRONOS development team strongly involved in the
preparation of the Next Step : support the ITM-TF with 10
years of CRONOS developments and experience
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
36
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Comparison to experiment :
synthetised diagnostic
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
37
i r f m
Direct determination of profiles
from measurement is ambiguous
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Physicists like to think in terms of radial profiles of fluid
quantities n, T, j, …
« Profile measurement » in tokamaks is Utopia
Non-local measurements : line-integrated diagnostics
(interferometry, polarimetry, radiation measurements),
global measurements with no spatial resolution (neutron
diagnostics) conversion to profiles not unique (Abel
inversion, dependence on multiple quantities …)
Local measurements : all require mapping on an
equilibrium. Some are localised by magnetic field (ECE,
reflectometry, …) even more dependent on equilibrium
assumptions
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
38
i r f m
Relevant comparison to experiment
requires synthetised diagnostics
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
•
Simulation codes provide profiles. All quantities are known and selfconsistent
Much more valid comparison to experiment is obtained by recalculating
the diagnostic measurements from a set of consistent profiles and
equilibrium
Instead of trying to obtain directly those profiles from the measurement.
• Application : data consistency, model testing, diagnostic design, feedback
control
Ambiguous
comparison
Set of consistent
profiles + equilibrium
(result of a simulation)
Diagnostic #1
Diagnostic #2
Diagnostic #3
Relevant
comparison
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
Diagnostic model
(CRONOS post-processing)
20-24 April 2008
39
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Current diffusion simulation validated by
synthetised diagnostic comparison
cadarache
MSE angles (rad)
00.1
.10
0.05
0.05
M SE polarisat
ion
angles
JET shot
with
ITB
# 5 3 5 2 1 , t = 5 .5 s
#53521,measured
t = 5.5 s
simulat ed
0
M SE a ngle s [ ra0d. ]
-0.05
-0 . 0 5
-0.1
..⃝.. Measured
-- Simulated
-0 . 1 0
2.8
3.0
3.2
Rra
(m)
M a jor
dius [ m ]
3.4
[X. Litaudon et al., Nucl. Fusion 44 (2002)]
CRONOS includes synthetised
diagnostics + experimental data
visualisation tools
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
40
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Quasi-static assumption
cadarache
Equilibrium : force balance between kinetic and magnetic pressure
magnetic field topology (magnetic surfaces)
Plasma equilibrium is established on much faster time scales
(Alfven, 10-6 s) than transport time scales (> 0.1 s)
Quasi-static assumption :
Transport equations are evolved at constant magnetic surface
topology
Equilibrium is recalculated when a significant change of the
plasma profiles (pressure and current density) has occurred
new topology for the subsequent evolution of plasma profiles
Difficulty : p(),j() topology.
j() must be conserved during the equilibrium recalculation, but
depends on the topology not guaranteed by a single pass in
the equilibrium module convergence loop on the topology
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
41
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Convergence loop on metric to
conserve j(Ψ)
cadarache
∂ Ψ/ ∂ t + DΨ = S(t), metric @ t-dt
Current diffusion t-dt t
Ψdiff(t)
Deduce J(Ψdiff,{metric@t-dt})]
2D equilibrium calculates
{new_metric}=Feq.[Ψdiff, Ptot, J(Ψdiff,{prev_metric})]
Ψeq(t) & {new_metric}
No
Deduce J(Ψeq,{new_metric)]
J(Ψeq,{new_metric}) =? J(Ψdiff,{prev_metric})
Yes
Use converged metric for next time
step of the transport equations
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
42
i r f m
Free-boundary equilibrium
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Key issue for coupling to
equilibrium : current diffusion
and topology must remain
consistent
No guarantee that the poloidal
flux is the same at separatrix
between i) the transport
equation and ii) the freeboundary solver specific
convergence loop needed
Current diffusion itself (and the
other transport equations) are
recalculated with the new
topology until convergence on
(r) between two iterations on
the topology
On-going work in collaboration
with Université de Nice
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
43
i r f m
Association
Euratom-CEA
Non-inductive current drive
cadarache
Tokamaks rely on toroidal current for confinement
Driven by inductive means current diffusion
Steady-state operation requires to drive current by noninductive means
Tore Supra : 6min 20 s of plasmas sustained fully noninductively, 85 % LHCD and 15 % bootstrap
TS#32299
BT = 3.4 T
Ip = 0.5 MA
PLHCD = 3 MW
Vloop = 0
RTC
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
44
i r f m
Test of current drive models
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Modelling of fully non-inductive discharge is challenging
Self-consistent and sensitive loop :
Non-inductive source current profile
A typical integrated modelling problem
LHCD : Delphine RT/FP solver
Calculated every 0.1 s
Coupled (indirectly) to
antenna solver SWAN to use
realistic injected wave
spectrum
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
[Imbeaux, Peysson
PPCF 2005]
20-24 April 2008
45
i r f m
Test of current drive models
Association
Euratom-CEA
cadarache
Integrated current diffusion simulation with comparison
to measurements show the limitations of the models
RT/FP simulation
LH driven current density assumed homothetic to Fast
Electron Bremsstrahlung measurements
MHD markers
and internal
inductance in
excellent
agreement for
the simulation
using FEB
MHD marker for qmin
[Imbeaux, Peysson
PPCF 2005]
F. Imbeaux et al – Numerical Models for Controlled Fusion
20-24 April 2008
46