SME Survey 2013

Download Report

Transcript SME Survey 2013

Characteristics of the Vietnamese Business Environment:
Evidence from the SME Survey in 2013
4 November, 2014
John Rand and Finn Tarp
Introducing the SME survey
•
Small and medium enterprises (SMEs) continue to be
central to the Vietnamese development process
• Contributing to economic growth and employment
•
Characterize business conditions under which Vietnamese
SMEs operate
• Firm dynamics: How do firms evolve?
• External environment: Does it bring challenges or
opportunities?
Overview
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
SME survey 2005, 2007, 2009, 2011 and 2013
Ten provinces
Approximately 2,500 non-state manufacturing
enterprises each year.
Four questionnaires:
Main (firm level)
Employee (sub-sample)
Economic accounts
Exit
•
The report provides descriptive statistics and
analysis of key trends in the 2013 data.
•
The report is a joint effort of CIEM, DoE
(University of Copenhagen) and ILSSA.
•
Research supported by Danida and UNU-WIDER
Topics covered in the 2013 SME survey report
Topic
Section
International economic crisis
3
Enterprise growth and dynamics
4
Bureaucracy, informality and informal payments
5
Investment and access to finance
6
Production, technology and labour productivity
7
Employment
8
Environment
9
Trade and sales structures
10
The 2013 survey (compared with 2011)
Interviewed in
2013
Interviewed in
2011
Change
Ha Noi
280
268
4.5%
Phu Tho
255
251
1.6%
Ha Tay
342
340
0.6%
Hai Phong
182
200
-9.0%
Nghe An
343
345
-0.6%
Quang Nam
160
155
3.2%
Khanh Hoa
88
94
-6.4%
Lam Dong
77
76
1.3%
HCMC
600
568
5.6%
Long An
134
122
9.8%
2,461
2,419
1.7%
Province
Total
Firm ownership structure
Legal form
2013
2011
Change
1,553
1,571
-1.1%
198
193
2.6%
55
65
-15.4%
Limited liability company
546
498
9.6%
Joint stock company
109
92
18.5%
2,461
2,419
1.7%
Household enterprise
Private/sole proprietorship
Partnership/ Collective/ Cooperative
Total
Note: State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) are not included in the
sampling frame
Firm size
Size
2013
2011
Change
1,660
1,763
-5.8%
Small (10-49 employees)
614
566
8.5%
Medium (50-300 employees)
145
132
9.8%
2,461
2,419
1.7%
Micro (<10 employees)
Total
The 2013 SME survey sample by size, location and ownership
80%
72%
70%
63%
60%
50%
40%
30%
24%
23%
20%
10%
0%
22%
14%14%
5%
11% 10%
7% 7%
5%
8%
4% 3%
4%
2%
The 2013 SME survey sample by sector
35%
31%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
5%
1%
0%
SME survival rates
Surveyed in 2011 Survivors
Exit confirmed
2013
1,988
431
Survival rate
82.2
Annual survival rate
90.6
Newly surveyed
473
Total surveyed in 2013
•
•
2011
2,419
(2,449)
2,461
Annual survival rate between 2009 and 2011 = 92.2%
Annual survival rate between 2007 and 2009 = 91.6%
Exit probabilities
Dependent variable: Firm exit
Small
-0.030
-0.035*
-0.060**
-0.072**
0.047
0.057*
Nghe An
-0.058**
-0.063***
Quang Nam
-0.084***
-0.086***
Long An
Partnership/Collective/Cooperative
Limited liability company
Sector dummies included
-0.100***
0.109*
0.051*
No
-0.102***
0.118*
0.050*
Yes
2,419
2,419
Medium
Ha Noi
Observations
•
•
•
•
•
Marginal effects
Small and medium firms are 3 to 6% less likely to exit than micro firms
Nghe An, Quang Nam and Long An have lower exit probabilities than HCMC
Ha Noi has the highest exit probability
356 SMEs (14.4%) temporarily closed their business in 2011-2013
24% exited in 2013; 19% changed sector in which they operate
Enterprise growth and dynamics
Number of employees
2013
2011
Change
23,589
27,509
-14.2%
11.9
13.8
-13.8%
Micro
3.7
3.8
-2.6%
Small
20.2
20.0
1.0%
Medium
92.1
101.2
-9.0%
Total
Average
Employment Transition Matrix, 2011-2013
Employment Transition Matrix (%)
Micro 2013 Small 2013 Medium 2013
Micro 2011
94.6
5.4
0
Small 2011
26.2
71.6
2.2
2.5
25.6
71.9
Medium 2011
•
•
•
•
More mobility in small and medium firm categories
None of the micro enterprises transitioned to the medium category, only to
small
2.2% of small firms became medium-sized
Around 25% of small and medium firms decreased in size
Employment growth
•
Mean employment growth rate was on average negative (-1.3%)
•
This holds for all provinces except: Quang Nam, Lam Dong and
Nghe An
•
Small and medium enterprises saw a negative growth in
employment that ranges from 9 to 13%
•
Micro firms increased the number of full-time workers by 3%
•
All sectors have experienced a decline in employment rates
between 2011 and 2013 except food, textile, rubber and chemical
industry
• The largest decrease (of more than 6%): leather
manufacturing, electronic machinery and motor vehicles
Regression analysis: Determinants of employment growth
Without sector
controls
With sector
controls
Small
-0.166***
-0.171***
Medium
-0.231***
-0.237***
Phu Tho
-0.057**
-0.051**
Hai Phong
-0.059**
-0.045*
Quang Nam
0.060**
0.074**
Long An
-0.073***
-0.067**
Private/sole proprietorship
Partnership/Collective/Cooperative
0.074***
0.083*
0.075***
0.069
Limited liability company
0.085***
0.082***
Joint stock company
Observations
0.070**
1988
0.065*
1988
Control variables
•
•
•
Micro firms have experienced 17 to 23% higher annual growth in full-time
regular workers than small and medium firms
Compared to Ho Chi Minh City, Quang Nam had 6 per cent higher annual
employment growth
Household firms contribute less to the employment generation than other
forms of manufacturing enterprises
Labour productivity
All
Micro
Small
Medium
Urban
Rural
South
North
Labour Productivity 1
2011
2013
Growth
77.3
61.5
0.95 [0.87]
65.8
54.3
0.96
92.2
75.8
0.95
151.3
99.6
0.96
93.4
70.4
0.92
66.2
55.4
0.98
82.9
65.5
0.96
73.2
58.6
0.95
2011
20.7
18.0
25.4
33.4
26.2
16.9
23.1
19.0
Labour Productivity 2
2013
Growth
16.5
0.96 [0.89]
14.1
0.96
21.7
0.94
27.0
0.98
20.1
0.93
14.0
0.97
18.6
0.97
15.0
0.95
Note: Million real VND. Mean labour productivity (LP) growth is defined as LP2013/LP2011. Median LP
growth in brackets.
•
•
LP1 = real revenue per full-time employee
LP2 = real value added per full-time employee
Labour productivity growth
Labour productivity level (log)
Firm size (log number of employees)
Diversification (Yes=1)
Innovation 1 (Yes=1)
Innovation 2 (Yes=1)
Household firm (Yes=1)
Urban (Yes=1)
South (Yes=1)
Sector dummies
Observation
Pseudo R-squared
Labour Productivity Growth (2011 to 2013)
dln(LP1)
dln(LP2)
Coef
t-stat
Coef
-0.477***
(-20.16)
-0.577***
0.124***
(5.82)
0.128***
0.064
(1.24)
0.089**
0.015
(0.19)
-0.018
0.021
(0.65)
-0.020
-0.066
(-1.35)
-0.070*
-0.054
(-1.47)
0.075**
0.052*
(1.65)
0.076***
Yes
Yes
1,861
1,861
0.27
0.33
t-stat
(-24.11)
(7.27)
(2.02)
(-0.27)
(-0.69)
(-1.79)
(2.30)
(2.73)
Note: OLS. Robust standard errors. *, ** and *** indicate significance at a 10%, 5% and 1% level, respectively. Base: Food processing
(ISIC 15).
•
Labour productivity growth is the highest among large firms in the
south and urban firms in the second specification
Informality
2011
2013
Per cent
Number
Per cent
Number
Formal (Total)
72.7
1,759
71.4
1,757
Formal (Balanced)
71.9
1,430
72.2
1,453
Note: Formal definition: Firm has an ECN or a BRC and a tax code.
Informal 2011
Formal 2011
Total
Per cent
Informal 2013
551
(90.2)
2
(0.2)
553
(27.8)
ECN or BRC + Tax code
Formal 2013
Total
60
611
(9.8)
(100.0)
1,375
1,377
(99.8)
(100.0)
1,435
1,988
(72.2)
(100.0)
Per cent
(30.7)
(69.3)
(100.0)
Note: Percentage in parenthesis.
•
Decrease in the speed of formalization compared to 2011 survey
Informality and firm dynamics
Firm Growth
Firm Size
log (number of employees)
Registration
Formal = 1
Location dummies included
Sector dummies included
Observation
Pseudo R-squared
•
(1)
-0.082***
(-13.22)
0.072***
(4.45)
No
No
1,988
0.09
(2)
-0.092***
(-13.12)
0.062***
(3.40)
Yes
Yes
1,988
0.12
Well determined positive registration effect on employment growth
Most important constraints to growth
Investments
2011
All
Micro
Small
Medium
Household firm
Non-household firm
Urban
Rural
South
North
Obs.
2,416
1,658
613
145
1,569
847
1,035
1,381
1,014
1,402
2013
Share
0.562
0.498
0.674
0.821
0.505
0.666
0.529
0.587
0.454
0.640
Obs.
2,461
1,763
566
132
1,553
908
1,062
1,399
1,059
1,402
Share
0.470
0.395
0.629
0.788
0.405
0.582
0.373
0.544
0.410
0.516
•
•
•
•
Lower share of investments compared to 2011
30% new investments compared to 2011
60% of investments are repeated
587 firms did not make any investment in the past four years
•
Tendencies to invest
• Increasing in enterprise size, for firms in rural and
Northern provinces
How was the investment financed?
•
•
•
•
Main source of finance for new investments are formal loans and retained
earnings
Higher share of new investments financed by informal loans
Micro and household-owned firms more likely to use retained earnings or
informal loans
Larger firms finance investments through formal loans
Diversification and innovation
All
Micro
Small
Medium
Urban
Rural
South
North
Diversification
(More than one 4-digit ISIC)
2011
2013
11.0
10.9
10.1
8.8
11.1
16.1
20.7
16.7
9.3
9.6
12.3
11.9
8.2
9.6
13.0
11.9
Innovation 1
(New product development)
2011
2013
4.0
0.6
3.4
0.4
4.6
1.2
8.9
0.8
5.2
0.6
3.1
0.6
3.3
0.4
4.5
0.8
Innovation 2
(Improvement of existing product)
2011
2013
38.4
16.3
32.9
12.7
48.8
24.2
57.9
30.3
46.9
18.5
32.1
14.6
43.1
15.3
35.11
17.0
Note: Numbers in percentages
•
•
•
•
•
An average Vietnamese SME is specialised
• Only 11% of firms produced more than one product
Similar to 2011, but declining diversification compared to 2009
But, urban and Southern firms show slight increase
Fabricated metal products (ISIC 28): increased level of diversification
Innovation: decreasing trend
• Firms producing furniture (ISIC 36) tend to innovate more than firms in other
sectors
Diversification and innovation characteristics
Firm size (log number of employees)
Household firm (Yes=1)
Urban (Yes=1)
South (Yes=1)
Year dummy
Sector dummies
Observation
Pseudo R-squared
Diversification
Coef
z-stat
0.014***
(2.67)
-0.060***
(-4.01)
-0.054***
(-5.13)
-0.026***
(-2.66)
-0.004
(-0.47)
Yes
3,961
0.06
Innovation 1
Coef
z-stat
0.002
(0.78)
-0.005
(-1.05)
0.003
(0.61)
-0.006*
(-1.77)
-0.030***
(-6.67)
Yes
3,896
0.11
Innovation 2
Coef
z-stat
0.072***
(8.36)
-0.007
(-0.35)
0.044**
(2.54)
0.011
(0.75)
-0.224***
(-16.02)
Yes
3,961
0.12
Note: Probit, marginal effects. Robust standard errors. *, ** and *** indicate significance at a 10%, 5% and 1% level, respectively. Base: Food
processing (ISIC 15).
•
•
•
Larger enterprises are shown to diversify and innovate (only Innovation 2)
Household-owned, urban and Southern firms are less likely to diversify
Time dummies confirm that firms innovate less frequently in 2013 than in 2011
International crisis and SMEs
Full sample
Balanced panel
Crisis No 2011
Crisis Yes 2011
Total
Per cent
Crisis No 2013
294
(38.0)
316
(26.0)
610
(30.6)
2011
2013
2011
2013
Obs.
(2,419)
(2,461)
(1,988)
(1,988)
Crisis Yes 2013
479
(62.0)
899
(74.0)
1,378
(69.4)
Per cent
Yes
61.9
68.3
61.1
69.4
Total
773
(100.0)
1,215
(100.0)
1,988
(100.0)
Per cent
(38.9)
(61.1)
(100.0)
Note: Percentage in parenthesis.
•
All types of SMEs feel affected by the crisis
• More severely perceived among small and medium than micro firms
• More commonly felt among urban and Northern firms
• 8% of firms in 2013 believe that the international crisis has brought
positive incentives (5% in 2011; 12% in 2009)
Conclusions and policy recommendations (1)
•
Firm size is, on average, decreasing
• Small and medium enterprises were reducing the number of full-time
employees at a higher rate than micro enterprises
• Labour productivity has declined between 2011 and 2013, and the
decline is especially driven by micro rural enterprises
• Decrease in the proportion of full time workers
•
Business environment
• Very few firms are facing no constraints
• Informality in payments and access to finance remain some of the
most serious problems
• Slow-down in formalisation
• Investment rate has declined, especially among micro-sized urban
firms in the south
•
•
Investment policies should address the declining investment trend
Policies should ease firm registration (formalisation) and formal credit
access, reflecting the fact that informality cannot assure an inclusive
growth path sustained by investments in the SME sector
Conclusions and policy recommendations (2)
•
Diversification and innovation
• More specialisation among SMEs (product diversification does not seem to
be a tool for risk reduction)
• Sharp decline in innovation, especially among rural micro firms
• This decline could be a problem for future dynamics, as innovation through
the improvement of existing products is positively related to firm
performance
• Policy focus on the improvement of the innovative capacity of SMEs
•
Effects of the crisis: aggravated compared to 2009 and 2011
• Around 70 per cent of surveyed enterprises stated that the international
crisis still had a negative effect on their doing business conditions
• Micro sized firms are less affected by the crisis than their larger
counterparts
• Firms in the northern part of the country sensed an increase in constraints
• Exit rates: 9.3% confirmed exits
• Temporary closures: around 17%, mostly among micro and small
household firms
Thank you!