Transcript DoDAF CADM ISO AP233 OMG UML Converter Interim Report

®
DODAF CADM/AP233
Interoperability Project
David Price
OSJTF
March 2006
Our Focus is on SE Standards
•System-of-systems engineering requires
Request
System
•Greater collaboration and tool interoperability,
and …
Model
Response
•Using robust modeling techniques for describing
systems architectures
• Enable communication between SAs/SEs and the
tools they use
– Approach described in white paper : Using Systems
Engineering Standards In an Architecture Framework
– Influenced by DoD, INCOSE, ISO STEP and OMG
communities
®
MoDAF or UPDM
Architecture ISO STEP-enabled
Repository Downstream Tool
Operational
DODAF
specifies requirements for
Any SE Tool
Request
System
Model
Response
DOD CADM
DoD Architecture
Repository System
®
ISO TC184/SC4 Industrial Data
®
AP233 Systems Engineering
• On-schedule for AP233 modules to go out for ISO ballot
starting in the summer
– Committee Draft ballot (July-October 2006)
– After ballot completes, workshops are held to address ballot
comments
– AP233 modules should be published 1Q2007
CriticalBusiness
TestingUse
• The complete AP233 Application Protocol that includes
Cases, etc. takes a bit longer
Happens Here
ISO Ballot
®
AP233 Scope
breakdowns
requirements
PDM
text-based
static
structure
system
sub-system
product
structure
config
control
property-based
functional
breakdown
WBS
security
person &
org
behaviour
link to analysis
rules
(moved to AP210)
verification &
validation
model presentation
risk
measurement
state-based
function-based
Legend
Complete
Edition 2
®
AP233 Testing
• AP233 Development Team is working strategy for
critical testing
– Includes internal team testing
– Includes approaching vendors to participate
• AP233 Team developing a “test harness”
– Fitting into the “test harness” is now the main focus for
the DODAF CADM/AP233 demo work
– Dwayne made significant contribution to the
architecture of this 
– The bad news though: Previous “cool CADM/AP233
demos” are broken into bits at the moment
®
AP233 Test harness
Test data creation tools
Visio
Freemind
XML
Excel
UML 2/SysML
CADM examples
…
®
Translate via:
XSLT
Ruby
Java
Web Viewers,
Graphical Viewers
and Available SE Tools
AP233 XML
Import/Export
Repository
DoDAF CADM/AP233 Project
®
DoDAF CADM/AP233 Project
• Purpose
– Evaluate feasibility of system architecture data
exchange using emerging ISO AP233 Systems
Engineering standard
• Not a fully validated design effort
– Provide a body of work that future efforts can build
upon
®
Proving
this path
®
CADM/AP233 Process Steps
Id CADM vs.
AP233 Gaps
Complete AP233
Modules for Gaps
Produce AP233
Draft
Define CADM/AP233
Mappings
Develop CADM/AP233
Translator
Create AP233
Test Cases
Demonstrate
CADM/AP233
Translator
®
TOOLS
DoDAF Views Coverage
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
XY
Z
X
Y
C
System Functionality
Description (SV-4)
Y
X
Systems Functionality
Sequence and Timing
Description (SV-10 a/b/c)
Systems Interface
Description (SV-1)
Physical Schema
SV-11
Activity to System
Function (SV-5)
System - System
Matrix (SV-3)
Systems Evolution
Description (SV-8)
Technical Architecture
Profile (TV-1)
Standards Technology
Forecast (TV-2)
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
NODE A
System 1
System 2
One-Way
Communications
Link
Two-Way
Communications
Links
System 4
System 3
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
Local Area Net
System 5
EXTERNAL
CONNECTION
(OUTSIDE THE
NODES OF INTEREST)
CONNECTION
TO NODE C
Systems Communications
Description (SV-2)
Operational
Systems Data Exchange
Matrix (SV-6)
Systems Performance
Parameters Matrix (SV-7)
Operational Concept
Description (OV-1)
Systems Technology
Forecast (SV-9)
Operational Activity
Model (OV-5)
• .....
• .....
• .....
Organizational
Relationships
Chart (OV-4)
®
Node Connectivity
Description (OV-2)
•
-
Logical Data
Model (OV-7)
Information
Exchange Matrix
(OV-3)
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
C
Operational Activity
Sequence and Timing
Description (OV-6 a/b/c)
DoDAF Views Coverage
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
System Functionality
Description (SV-4)
Y
X
Systems Functionality
Sequence and Timing
Description (SV-10 a/b/c)
Systems Interface
Description (SV-1)
Physical Schema
SV-11
Activity to System
Function (SV-5)
System - System
Matrix (SV-3)
Delivered now
XY
Z
X
Y
C
Systems Evolution
Description (SV-8)
Technical Architecture
Profile (TV-1)
Standards Technology
Forecast (TV-2)
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
NODE A
System 1
System 2
One-Way
Communications
Link
Two-Way
Communications
Links
System 4
System 3
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
Local Area Net
System 5
EXTERNAL
CONNECTION
(OUTSIDE THE
NODES OF INTEREST)
CONNECTION
TO NODE C
Systems Communications
Description (SV-2)
Operational
Systems Data Exchange
Matrix (SV-6)
Systems Performance
Parameters Matrix (SV-7)
Operational Concept
Description (OV-1)
Systems Technology
Forecast (SV-9)
Operational Activity
Model (OV-5)
• .....
• .....
• .....
Organizational
Relationships
Chart (OV-4)
®
Node Connectivity
Description (OV-2)
•
-
Logical Data
Model (OV-7)
Information
Exchange Matrix
(OV-3)
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
C
Operational Activity
Sequence and Timing
Description (OV-6 a/b/c)
DoDAF Views Coverage
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
System Functionality
Description (SV-4)
Y
X
Systems Functionality
Sequence and Timing
Description (SV-10 a/b/c)
Systems Interface
Description (SV-1)
Physical Schema
SV-11
Activity to System
Function (SV-5)
System - System
Matrix (SV-3)
Next month
XY
Z
X
Y
C
Systems Evolution
Description (SV-8)
Technical Architecture
Profile (TV-1)
Standards Technology
Forecast (TV-2)
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
NODE A
System 1
System 2
One-Way
Communications
Link
Two-Way
Communications
Links
System 4
System 3
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
Local Area Net
System 5
EXTERNAL
CONNECTION
(OUTSIDE THE
NODES OF INTEREST)
CONNECTION
TO NODE C
Systems Communications
Description (SV-2)
Operational
Systems Data Exchange
Matrix (SV-6)
Systems Performance
Parameters Matrix (SV-7)
Operational Concept
Description (OV-1)
Systems Technology
Forecast (SV-9)
Operational Activity
Model (OV-5)
• .....
• .....
• .....
Organizational
Relationships
Chart (OV-4)
®
Node Connectivity
Description (OV-2)
•
-
Logical Data
Model (OV-7)
Information
Exchange Matrix
(OV-3)
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
C
Operational Activity
Sequence and Timing
Description (OV-6 a/b/c)
DoDAF Views Coverage
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
XY
Z
X
Y
C
System Functionality
Description (SV-4)
Systems Functionality
Sequence and Timing
Description (SV-10 a/b/c)
Systems Interface
Description (SV-1)
Physical Schema
SV-11
Activity to System
Function (SV-5)
System - System
Matrix (SV-3)
May - July
Y
X
Systems Evolution
Description (SV-8)
Technical Architecture
Profile (TV-1)
Standards Technology
Forecast (TV-2)
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
NODE A
System 1
System 2
One-Way
Communications
Link
Two-Way
Communications
Links
System 4
System 3
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
Local Area Net
System 5
EXTERNAL
CONNECTION
(OUTSIDE THE
NODES OF INTEREST)
CONNECTION
TO NODE C
Systems Communications
Description (SV-2)
Operational
Systems Data Exchange
Matrix (SV-6)
Systems Performance
Parameters Matrix (SV-7)
Operational Concept
Description (OV-1)
Systems Technology
Forecast (SV-9)
Operational Activity
Model (OV-5)
• .....
• .....
• .....
Organizational
Relationships
Chart (OV-4)
®
Node Connectivity
Description (OV-2)
•
-
Logical Data
Model (OV-7)
Information
Exchange Matrix
(OV-3)
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
C
Operational Activity
Sequence and Timing
Description (OV-6 a/b/c)
Delivered as of March 2006
• Web site documenting AP233 and CADM/AP233 mapping
®
Delivered as of March 2006 (2)
• New additions to AP233 covering
– State machines suite
– Assigning descriptions to anything
– Some gaps filled in Interface schemas
• New API for creating the AP233 XML
– Ruby is a language for proof-of-concept
implementation, not designed for production software
support
®
CADM/AP233 Testing
• Fitting into the “AP233 test harness” is current
focus of my the DODAF CADM/AP233 demo work
– Dwayne made a significant contribution to the
architecture of this 
– Also changing test tools to enabling other AP233 team
members to create test data
• So, earlier “cool CADM/AP233 demos” are broken
into bits at the moment
– Can show a few test harness components today
®
Conclusions
• Confirmed ideas from white paper that AP233 can
support DOD DODAF/CADM data interchange
requirements
– Will complete DODAF CADM/AP233 Gap Analysis before
AP233 ballot ends
– Keeping an eye on the OMG SysML, UPDM, etc. to
identify gaps in AP233
• Positive, direct impact on AP233 completeness by
this OSJTF project
• DOD in a position for future validation to build on
these efforts (e.g. AP233, SysML, UPDM)
®
Many things are coming together
Critical Testing
Happens Here
ISO Ballot
®
Contact Information
• David Price
– [email protected]
– +1 336 283-0606 or +44 20 7221 7307
– exff Systems Engineering
• http://www.exff.org/ap233
• AP233
– NASA AP233 Page at http://www.ap233.org
• DoDAF
– DoD NII Archive at http://www.defenselink.mil/nii/doc
• SysML
– OMG SysEng SIG at http://syseng.omg.org/
• The International Council on Systems Engineering
– INCOSE at http://www.incose.org
®
DoDAF Views Coverage
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
XY
Z
X
Y
C
System Functionality
Description (SV-4)
Next month
Delivered now
Y
X
Systems Functionality
Sequence and Timing
Description (SV-10 a/b/c)
Systems Interface
Description (SV-1)
Physical Schema
SV-11
Activity to System
Function (SV-5)
System - System
Matrix (SV-3)
May - July
Systems Evolution
Description (SV-8)
Technical Architecture
Profile (TV-1)
Standards Technology
Forecast (TV-2)
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
NODE A
System 1
System 2
One-Way
Communications
Link
Two-Way
Communications
Links
System 4
System 3
CONNECTION
TO NODE B
Local Area Net
System 5
EXTERNAL
CONNECTION
(OUTSIDE THE
NODES OF INTEREST)
CONNECTION
TO NODE C
Systems Communications
Description (SV-2)
Operational
Systems Data Exchange
Matrix (SV-6)
Systems Performance
Parameters Matrix (SV-7)
Operational Concept
Description (OV-1)
Systems Technology
Forecast (SV-9)
Operational Activity
Model (OV-5)
• .....
• .....
• .....
Organizational
Relationships
Chart (OV-4)
®
Node Connectivity
Description (OV-2)
•
-
Logical Data
Model (OV-7)
Information
Exchange Matrix
(OV-3)
NODES
TIME A
T1
T2
T3
B
C
Operational Activity
Sequence and Timing
Description (OV-6 a/b/c)
Delivered as of March 2006
• Web site documenting AP233 and CADM/AP233
mapping covering:
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
SV-1 Systems Interface
SV-2 System Communications
SV-3 System Functionality
SV-4 System-System Matrix
SV-10b, SV-10c System Sequence and States
OV-5 Operational Activity Model
OV-6b, OV-6c Operational Activity Sequence and States
TV-1 Technical Standards Profile
• See http://www.exff.org/ap233
®
NIST Project April – July 2006 (1)
• DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 1
– OV-4 Organizational Relationships Chart
– OV-3 Operational Information Exchange Matrix
– OV-2 Operational Node Connectivity Description
• DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 2
– SV-5 Operational Activity to Systems Function
Traceability Matrix
– SV-7 Systems Performance Parameters Matrix
– SV-6 Systems Data Exchange Matrix
®
NIST Project April – July 2006 (2)
• DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 3
–
–
–
–
–
OV-6a Operational Rules Model
SV-10a Systems Rules Model
SV-8 Systems Evolution Description
SV-9 Systems Technology Forecast
TV-2 Technical Standards Forecast
• DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 4
– AV-2 Integrated Dictionary
– AV-1 Overview and Summary Information
– OV-1 High-Level Operational Concept Graphic
• DODAF/AP233 Deliverable Set 5
– OV-7 Logical Data Model
– SV-11 Physical Schema
®