Transcript Resiko/bahaya perbandingan hukum (The perils of

R. Herlambang Perdana Wiratraman, SH., MA.
Fakultas Hukum Universitas Airlangga
E. [email protected]
P. +6281357819129
 Menurut anda, apa yang membahayakan dalam suatu
kajian perbandingan hukum?
Resiko
 Superficial (dangkal)
 Getting the foreign law wrong (keliru mendapat sumber
hukum)
 Scarcely be systematic (jarang/kurang sistematis)
 The system chosen for study may have no proper
relationship, and the conclusion will be lacking in
significance
 Argue too easily from them to a similar situation in another
system which has a relationship with it.
Watson 1993: 10-15
 Menurut anda, apa keuntungan ketika melakukan
suatu kajian perbandingan hukum?
Keuntungan
 Understanding of nature of law and of legal





development
Systematic study of foreign system
Unsystematic knowledge
The subject matter, historical relationship
Borrowing and transmissibility
Rules and their effects
 Ketika melakukan riset thesis misalnya, bagaimana
anda bisa mengelola resiko perbandingan hukum
tersebut?
 Apa prasyarat yang diperlukan untuk mengurangi
resiko?