This is the title

Download Report

Transcript This is the title

REACH and paper chemicals
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo, EPCG (Ciba Specialty Chemicals Oy)
European Paper Week 2005
December 1, 2005
Sheraton Rogier Hotel, Brussels
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH and paper chemicals
Assessment based on 1st reading of European Parliament
• Paper chemicals from regulatory
point of view
• REACH and R&D
• Some examples of products
• Future
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
Paper chemicals
• Most are HPV–substances (> 1000 t per year)
– Even special additives > 1 t per year
• A number of nature based chemicals
– Modified
– Annex II and III – content and interpretations
• Complicated reaction mixtures and poorly soluble substances
– Testing
• Many substances have long history of use, old test data – not under GLP
• NLPs, No Longer Polymers, e.g. emulsifiers
• A number of functional polymers
– Many starting substances will need authorisation
• Time from idea to market will be longer
• Paper machines are sensible for changes in products
• A number of customized products
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
R&D - Pulp and paper chemicals
• Many additives and process chemicals, e.g.
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Solvents
Initiators, catalysts
Chain transfer agents
Emulsifiers, surface active agents
Antioxidants
Plasticizers
Stabilizers
Release agents
pH Regulators
Stripping chemicals
Defoamers
Biocides
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH – Something to gain
+ R&D and PPORD
+ Longer than current PORD  5+10 years
+ Only one application dossier, not separately in every MS:
 Agency
 Same fee and equal opportunity
+ Volume versus application
+ Categories and read across
+ Possibility to play around the molecules and find/use ”new”
molecules without full testing dossier
+ Annex II?
+ Practice?
+ More data publicly available
+ Learning from each other?
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH – Concerns for paper chemicals
• List of available chemicals will be shorter than today
–
–
–
–
EINECS: 100 116 entries
ELINCS: ~5000
+ NLP:s, No Longer Polymers
Future: ~ 30 000 +/- xxxx?
• Practice
– Interpretations
– Annex II and III
– Exposure based waiving…
• OSOR
– Workability
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH – Concerns for paper chemicals
• Chemical Safety Assessment and
Chemical Safety Report (>1 t/y)
– Risk Management Measures included
– Covers also marine environment
– Exposure scenarios
• Paper making and recycling
– Exposure and use categories
– Communication in safety data sheets
• Authorisation may require a lot of resources
– Substitution and research in order to find alternatives
=> ”Defensive R&D”
– Socio Economic Analysis / Methodology
– Time limited (5 years)
– Can be opened by third party intervention
– Many monomers and other starting substances for polymers used
by paper industry will require authorisation
• e.g. acrylamide, acrylonitrile, butadiene, epichlorohydrin…
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
How to find alternative substances?
 Active structural groups = reactive groups
 Other approval processes may take years to complete,
e.g. food contact compliance
 Substances with long history of use are known
– Test results, exposure data exist
– Technical performance known
– Availability
• Production processes and facilities
• Raw materials
– Reasonable price
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
How to find alternative substances?
• Possible change in the composition of paper
chemicals =>
–
–
–
–
–
Literature & desktop research
Laboratory trials
Pilot trials
Production trials
Application trials: by the producer of the chemical
+ customer pilots
– Mill trials
 Easily a couple of years and
yyy yyy € or y yyy yyy €
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH requires resources
•
All functions of a company will be effected
– Purchasing
– R&D, e.g. laboratories
•
•
•
Substance identity, impurities, side reaction products etc.
Physico chemical properties
Registration and authorisation dossier and CSR
> Different uses
• Dosage, content/residues in intermediates and final products,
exposure measurements
> Emission/Effluent measurements
• Air, water, waste water treatment plants (including sludge), soil,
sediment
•
–
–
–
> Recycling and disposal…
R&D in future more defensive than real R&D
Production
Sales
Administration
•
•
”REACH Competence Centers” (including ”office chemists”)
IT…
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH AND PAPER CHEMICALS - Examples
• Styrene acrylate based polymeric size
– Polymers exempted from REACH for the time being but new Safety
Data Sheets, SDSs for the products have to be prepared
– Monomers and other starting substances have to be registered,
HPV chemicals => Chemicals Safety Report, CSR and new SDSs
• Own production and importation but EU-RA, ICCA Initiative and EPA
HPV program data exist for main monomers
• Specific monomers, initiators, emulsifiers, pH regulators, defoamers etc.
> Make sure that they will be available, PBT or vPvB… or prepare for
defensive R&D
> Possible data gaps…
• Food contact approvals exist => this use is exempted from CSR
• Styrene possible endocrine disruptor - authorisation?
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
PAPER CHEMICAL EXAMPLES
• Calcium distearate
– Annex II – pure!
• Annex II: ”Substances commonly found in foodstuffs, such
as citric acid, sugar, oils, fatty acids, etc.”
– Adipic acid (E 355), citric acid (E 330)
– Casein?
– Fatty acids and their derivatives as deinking chemicals?
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH & paper chemicals
• Details and interpretations still open
• Basic volume chemicals - bulk
– No remarkable changes foreseen yet
– Some additives may be ”lost” which may cause additional
workload and cost effects
• Specialty chemicals
– Some pressure on further testing
• Long term effects
• Testing problems
• Substitution is very difficult
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH - Cooperation of mills and chemicals’ suppliers
Management of chemical know how
• ERP systems
• Data per substance versus products
• Communication
– Questionnaires and safety data sheets
Registration, evaluation and authorisation
• Substance information: Suppliers!
• Chemical Safety Reports
– Help from customers will be needed
– Exposure scenarios
– Compare to current EU Risk Assessment
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01
REACH – Future
• Resources?
• Prices
• New type of business with
– REACH compliant chemicals
– IPR
• Data ownership
• Registration and authorisation dossiers and numbers
But paper will be made and paper chemicals will
be manufactured and developed even when
REACH is in force…
Liisa Rapeli-Likitalo and Peter Ungeheuer
2005-12-01