Transcript Statistics Presentation 3
Daria Kluver Independent Study From Statistical Methods in the Atmospheric Sciences By Daniel Wilks
Let’s review a few concepts that were introduced last time on Forecast Verification
Purposes of Forecast Verification Forecast verification- the process of assessing the quality of forecasts.
Any given verification data set consists of a collection of forecast/observation pairs whose joint behavior can be characterized in terms of the relative frequencies of the possible combinations of forecast/observation outcomes.
This is an empirical joint distribution
The Joint Distribution of Forecasts and Observations
Forecast = Observation = The joint distribution of the forecasts and observations is denoted This is a discrete bivariate probability distribution function associating a probability with each of the IxJ possible combinations of forecast and observation.
The joint distribution can be factored in two ways, the one used in a forecasting setting is: The unconditional probability of o j happening.
The refinement of a set of forecasts refers to the dispersion of the distribution p(y occurred on those occasions when the single forecast y i was issued, or how well each forecast is calibrated.
i values y ) i sometimes called the refinement of a forecast.
Scalar Attributes of Forecast Performance
Accuracy Average correspondence between individual forecasts and the events they predict.
Bias Reliability Resolution Discrimination Sharpness The correspondence between the average forecast and the average observed value of the predictand.
Pertains to the relationship of the forecast to the average observation, for specific values of the forecast.
The degree to which the forecasts sort the observed events into groups that are different from each other.
Converse of resolution, pertains to differences between the conditional averages of the forecasts for different values of the observation.
Characterize the unconditional distribution (relative frequencies of use) of the forecasts.
Forecast Skill
Forecast skill- the relative accuracy of a set of forecasts, wrt some set of standard control, or reference, forecast (like climatological average, persistence forecasts, random forecasts based on climatological relative frequencies) Skill score- a percentage improvement over reference forecast.
Accuracy of reference accuracy Accuracy that would be achieved by a perfect forecast.
On to new material…
2x2 Contingency tables Scalar attributes of contingency tables Tornado example NWS vs Weather.com vs climatology Skill Scores Probabilistic Forecasts Multicategory Discrete Predictands Continuous Predictands Plots and score Probability forecasts for multicategory events Non-Probabilistic Field forecasts
Nonprobabilistic Forecasts of Discrete Predictands
Nonprobabilistic – contains unqualified statement that a single outcome will occur. Contains no expression of uncertainty.
The 2x2 Contingency Table
The simplest joint distribution is from I=J=2. (or nonprobabilistic yes/no forecasts) I=2 possible forecasts i=1 or y 1 , event will occur i=2 or y 2 , event will not occur J=2 outcomes j=1 or o 1 , event subsequently occurs j=2 or o 2 , event doesn’t subsequently occur
b
occasions called “false alarms”
a
forecast observation pairs called “hits” C occasions called “misses” D occasions called “correct rejection or correct negative ” their relative frequency, a/n is the sample estimate of the corresponding joint probability p(y 1 ,o 1 ) the relative frequency estimates the joint probability p(y 1 ,o 2 ) the relative frequency estimates the joint probability p(y 2 ,o 2 ) the relative frequency estimates the joint probability p(y 2 ,o 1 )
Scalar Attributes Characterizing 2x2 contingency tables
Accuracy – proportion correct Threat Score (TS) Odds ratio Bias Comparison of the average forecast with the average observation Reliability and Resolution Discrimination Hit rate False Alarm Ratio False Alarm Rate
NWS, weather.com,climatology example
12 random nights from Nov 6 to Dec 1 forecast Will overnight lows be colder than or equal to freezing?
forecaster a b c d PC TS odds ratio bias wx.com
yes no yes 5 2 7 no 0 5 5 5 7 wx.com
NWS 5 6 0 0 2 1 5 5 0.833 0.71429 #DIV/0!
0.917 0.85714 #DIV/0!
0.71429
0.85714
FAR H 0 0.714
0 0.857
clim 1 0 6 5 0.5 0.14286 #DIV/0!
0.14286
0 0.143
forecast NWS yes no yes 6 1 7 no 0 5 5 6 6 forecast clim yes no yes 1 6 7 no 0 5 5 1 11
Skill Scores for 2x2 Contingency Tables
Heidke Skill Score based on the proportion correct referenced with the proportion correct that would be achieved by random forecasts that are statistically independent of the observations.
Peirce Skill Score similar to Heidke Skill score, except the reference hit rate in the denominator is random and unbiased forecasts. Clayton Skill Score Gilbert Skill Score or Equitable Threat Score The Odds Ratio ( ɵ ) can be used as a skill score
Finley Tornado Forecasts example
Threat score gives a better comparison, because large number of no forecasts are ignored.
TS=28/(28+72+23)=.228
Odds ratio is 45.3>1, suggesting better than random performance Bias ratio is B=1.96, indicating that approximately twice as many tornados were forecast as actually occurred Finley chose to evaluate his forecasts using the proportion correct, PC = (28+2680)/2803=0.966.
Gilbert pointed out that never forecasting a tornado produces an even higher proportion correct:, PC = (0+2752)/2803=0.982.
tornados were forecast to occur, whereas a very small fraction of the non tornado cases falsely warned of a tornado.
Skill Scores:
HSS=0.355
PSS=0.523
CSS=0.271
GSS=0.216
Q=0.957
What if your data are Probabilistic?
For a dichotomous predictand, to convert from a probabilistic to a nonprobabilistic format requires selection of a threshold probability, above which the forecast will be “yes”.
Ends up somewhat arbitrary.
Threshold that would maximize the Threat score Climatological probability of precip Produce unbiased forecasts (b=1) Nonprobabilistic forecasts of the more likely of the two events.
Multicategory Discrete Predictands
Make into 2x2 tables R m s rain mix snow R non-rain rain Non-rain
Nonprobabilistic Forecasts of continuous predictands
It is informative to graphically represent aspects of the joint distribution of nonprobabilistic forecasts for continuous variables.
Conditional Quantile Plots
Conditional distributions of the observations MOS observed temps are consistently colder than essentially unbiased.
Subjective forecasts are somewhat sharper, or more refined, more extreme temperatures being forecast more freq.
Contain 2 parts, representing the 2 factors in the calibration – refinement factorization of the joint distribution of forecasts and observations.
a) performance of MOS forecasts b) performance of subjective forecasts These plots are examples of a diagnostic verification technique, allowing diagnosis of a particular strengths and weakness of a set of forecasts through exposition of the full joint distribution.
Scalar Accuracy Measures
Only 2 scalar measures of forecast accuracy for continuous predictands in common use.
Mean Absolute Error, and Mean Squared Error
Mean Absolute Error
The arithmetic average of the absolute values of the differences between the members of each pair.
MAE = 0 if forecasts are perfect. Often used to verify temp forecasts.
Mean Squared Error
The average squared difference between the forecast and observed pairs More sensitive to larger errors than MAE More sensitive to outliers MSE = 0 for perfect RMSE = which has same physical dimensions as the forecasts and observations To calculate the bias of the forecast, compute the Mean Error:
Skill Scores
Can be computed with MAE, MSE, or RMSE as the underlying accuracy statistics Climatological value for day k
Probability Forecasts of Discrete Predictands
The joint Distribution for Dichotomous Events Not just using probabilities of 0 and 1 For each possible forecast probability we see the relative freq that forecast value was used, and the probability that the event o 1 occurred given the forecast y i
The Brier Score
Scalar accuracy measure for verification of probabilistic forecasts of dichotomous events This is the mean squared error of the probability forecasts, where o 1 event occurs and o 2 = 0 if the event doesn’t occur.
Perfect forecast BS = 0 less accurate forecasts receive higher BS.
= 1 if the Briar Skill Score:
The Reliability Diagram
Is a graphical device that shows the full joint distribution of forecasts and observations for probability forecasts of a binary predictand, in terms of its calibration-refinement factorization Allows diagnosis of particular strengths and weaknesses in a verification set.
Underconfident: extreme probabilities forecast too infrequently The conditional event relative frequency is essentially equal to the forecast probability.
Forecasts are consistently too large relative to the conditional event relative frequencies, avg forecast larger than avg obs.
Overconfident: extreme probabilities forecast too often Forecasts are consistently too small relative to the conditional event relative frequencies, avg forecast smaller than avg obs.
Well-calibrated probability forecasts mean what they say, in the sense that subsequent event relative frequencies are equal to the forecast probabilities.
Hedging and Strictly proper scoring rules
If a forecaster is just trying to get the best score, they may improve scores by hedging, or gaming -> forecasting something other than our true belief in order to achieve a better score.
Strictly proper – a forecast evaluation procedure that awards a forecaster’s best expected score only when his or her true beliefs are forecast.
Cannot be hedged Brier score You can derive that it is proper, but I wont here.
Probability Forecasts for Multiple-category events
For multiple-category ordinal probability forecasts: Verification should penalize forecasts increasingly as more probability is assigned to event categories further removed from the actual outcome.
Should be strictly proper.
Commonly used: Ranked probability score (RPS)
Probability forecasts for continuous predictands
For an infinite number of predictand classes the ranked probability score can be extended to the continuous case.
Continuous ranked probability score 1 Strictly proper Smaller values are better It rewards concentration of probability around the step function located at the observed value.
Nonprobabilistic Forecasts of Fields
General considerations for field forecasts Usually nonprobabilistic Verification is done on a grid
Scalar accuracy measures of these fields: S1 score, Mean Squared Error, Anomaly correlation
Thank you for your participation throughout the semester All presentations will be posted on my UD website Additional information can be found in Statistical Methods in the Atmospheric Sciences (second edition) by Daniel Wilks