Transcript Slide 1

Sweden-U.S. Clean Energy Opportunities:
Mapping Expertise, Innovation, and Renewables
Dr. Thomas D. Perry IV
Sweden-U.S.
Entrepreneurial Forum
2010
NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, operated by the Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC.
Sweden-U.S. Clean Energy Opportunities:
Mapping Expertise, Innovation, and Renewables
Dr. Thomas D. Perry IV
Sweden-U.S.
Entrepreneurial Forum
2010
http://www.bobrosato.com/content/photos/IMG0018-01.jpg
NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, operated by the Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC.
Top Cited Patent from Swedish Inventor
United States Patent
4,367,924
Clark , et al.
January 11, 1983
Chiral smectic C or H liquid crystal electro-optical device
Abstract
An electro-optical device including a chiral smectic C or H liquid crystal disposed between flat plates
treated to enforce molecular orientation parallel to the plates. The plates are spaced by a distance
sufficiently small to ensure unwinding of the helix typical in a bulk of the material to form two stable
states of the orientation field. The liquid crystal is switched between two stable states by reversing
the polarity of an externally applied electric field to make a bistable light valve or other electrooptical devices.
Inventors: Clark; Noel A. (Boulder, CO)
Lagerwall; Sven T. (Goteborg, SE)
Appl. No.: 06/110,451
Filed:
January 8, 1980
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Mapping Clean Technology Opportunity
competitiveness
opportunity
innovation
expertise
resource
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
http://www.windpower.org/en/tour/wres/eu
romap.htm
Renewable Resources
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Sweden’s History of Excellence
Resource Expertise =
Opportunity
http://www.chidalgo.com/
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Mapping Clean Technology Opportunity
competitiveness
opportunity
innovation
expertise
resource
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Swedish Inventive Output
Searching 1975-2008 USPTO
Records:
Unique Swedish Inventors
Unique Patents
Total Non-Swedish Collaborators
Unique US Collaborators
Unique Internat’l (non-US)
Collaborators
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
23,435
31,862
4,694
1,681
3,013
36%
64%
Impactful Networks: Large & Small
Ericsson
(+ subsidiaries and affiliates)
3859 patents
9 (0.2%) of which are among Top 25 cited SE
patents Average citations per patent = 9
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Biacore
(formerly Pharmacia Biosensor AB )
45 patents
2 (4%) of which are among Top 25 cited SE patents
Average citations per patent = 29
Opportunities for Energy Collaboration
Expertise + Resource =
Opportunity
Telecom & Software + Grid =
Smart Grid
Biotech & Wood processing + Forestry =
Biofuels
Aeronautics & Automotive + Coastline =
Offshore Wind
+ Heat =
Geothermal
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Mapping Clean Technology Opportunity
competitiveness
opportunity
innovation
expertise
resource
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
REGIONAL
Regional and National Support
Clean Tech Open
CleanTech Open
provides hands-on
education, mentoring,
and networking
CTO companies are
more successful at
being selected to
present at Forum
NATIONAL
NREL Growth Forum
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Forum provides
national investor
exposure
Forum companies are
more successful at
raising and raise more
money
Mapping Clean Technology Opportunity
competitiveness
opportunity
innovation
expertise
resource
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Joint Institute for Strategic Energy Analysis
Credibility ◊ Objectivity ◊ Impact
Move global energy systems toward a sustainable future
through provision of objective and credible data, tools,
and analysis that informs the energy dialogue and guides
energy investment and policy decisions.
• Network leading capabilities to analyze complex energy issues that are beyond the
reach of a single institution.
• Focus: Comprehensively address full spectrum of issues required to change
energy trajectory: physical systems (earth systems and engineered infrastructure),
economic and market systems, and legal and institutional systems.
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
JISEA: International Network
Physical systems
Financial systems
Human systems
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
JISEA: International Collaboration
Comprehensive
JISEA + International Affiliates
JISEA Foundational
Partners
NREL
Partial
Factors Affecting Transformation
Analysis of the global transformation of energy systems (inclusive of physical infrastructure,
policies, markets, institutional and legal structures, and behavior) to simultaneously address
environmental, economic, security, and social issues
Energy Pathways
RE and EE
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
All Pathways
Swedish-U.S. Clean Energy Opportunities:
Mapping Expertise, Innovation, and Renewables
Dr. Thomas D. Perry IV
[email protected]
303-275-3673
NREL is a national laboratory of the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, operated by the Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC.
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Top 25 Cited Patents from Swedish Teams
#
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Cites
Year
Inventor(s)
Assignee
465
1980
"CLARK, NOEL A"
465
1980
"LAGERWALL, SVEN T"
232
1992
"JACOBSON, GUNILLA"
"PHARMACIA BIOSENSOR AB"
232
1992
"SJODIN, HAKAN"
"PHARMACIA BIOSENSOR AB"
232
1992
"EKSTROM, BJORN"
"PHARMACIA BIOSENSOR AB"
232
1992
"OHMAN, OVE"
"PHARMACIA BIOSENSOR AB"
217
1982
"LOFBERG, BO"
205
1984
"LOFBERG, BO"
196
1996
"MUFTIC, SEAD"
"ENTEGRITY SOLUTIONS CORPORATION"
195
1991
"ROY, RICHARD H III"
"ARRAYCOMM INC"
195
1991
"OTTERSTEN, BJORN"
"ARRAYCOMM INC"
172
1995
"LIU, GEORGE"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
159
1994
"PERSSON, BENGT"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
159
1994
"DAHLIN, STEINAR"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
159
1994
"BILLSTROM, LARS"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
159
1994
"WETTERBORG, LARS"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
175
1986
"MIELKE, KLAUS"
"SWEDOT SYSTEM AB"
175
1989
"LUNDBACK, STIG S"
"ASTRA TECH AKTIEBOLAG"
167
1994
"HAARTSEN, JACOBUS C"
"ERICSSON INC"
167
1996
"BESSLER, MARC"
"TRUSTEES OF COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY IN CITY OF NEW YORK"
167
1996
"CHUTER, TIMOTHY A"
"TRUSTEES OF COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY IN CITY OF NEW YORK"
108
1991
"WEJKE, ANNA M"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
108
1991
"ANDERSSON, CLAES"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
161
1994
"STEIN, PER"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
159
1992
"LUNDIN, KENNETH"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
159
1992
"MARKSTROM, ULF"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
155
1982
"LOFBERG, BO"
155
1991
"BERGSTROM, JAN"
"PHARMACIA BIOSENSOR AB"
155
1991
"LOFAS, STEFAN"
"PHARMACIA BIOSENSOR AB"
155
1991
"JOHNSSON, BO"
"PHARMACIA BIOSENSOR AB"
151
1992
"RISCH, TORE J"
"HEWLETT PACKARD COMPANY"
150
1996
"ANDERSSON, STURE"
"AUTOLIV DEVELOPMENT AB"
150
1996
"VALKENBURG, SIMOMN"
"AUTOLIV DEVELOPMENT AB"
150
1996
"H ANG LAND, YNGVE"
"AUTOLIV DEVELOPMENT AB"
150
1996
"FLORBERGER, LARS ERIK"
"AUTOLIV DEVELOPMENT AB"
150
1996
"SVENSSON, I JORGEN"
"AUTOLIV DEVELOPMENT AB"
149
1976
"GRUBB, ANDERS O"
"AB KABI"
149
1976
"GLAD, ULLA C"
"AB KABI"
147
1989
"WALLSTEN, HANS I"
"MEDINVENT SA"
149
1989
"DAHLIN, JAN E A S"
"TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON"
149
1990
"DENT, PAUL"
"ERICSSON GE MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS HOLDING INC"
147
1984
"GUSTAVSSON, BENGT"
146
1994
"DENT, PAUL W"
"ERICCSON GE MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS INC"
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Inventor City
"BOULDER"
"GOTEBORG"
"UPSALA"
"UPSALA"
"UPSALA"
"UPSALA"
"STOCKHOLM"
"STOCKHOLM"
"HASSELBY"
"CUPERTINO"
"STOCKHOLM"
"KISTA"
"DJURSHOLM"
"JARFALLA"
"SONLA"
"JARFALLA"
"MO LNLYCKE"
"VAXHOLM"
"STAFFANSTORP"
"TEANECK"
"MALMO"
"STOCKHOLM"
"STOCKHOLM"
"STOCKHOLM"
"SODERTALJE"
"STOCKHOLM"
"STOCKHOLM"
"BALINGE"
"UPPSALA"
"STORVRETA"
"LINKOPING"
"NACKA"
"MACCLESFIELD"
"FALSTERBO"
"LIDKOPING"
"SALTSJO BOO"
"LUND"
"MALMO"
"VILLA PRE BOISE"
"SOLLENTUNA"
"STEHAG"
"VASTRA FROLUNDA"
"STEHAG"
Location
CO
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
CA
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
NJ
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
GB
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
Energy Collaboration
Solar
Oil
Wind
Nuclear
Biofuels
Coal
Hydro
Natural Gas
Geothermal
All
Percentage
51%
23%
22%
18%
13%
8%
1%
1%
1%
-
Count
73
32
31
26
18
11
2
2
1
142
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Top 20 Cited Energy Patents from Swedish Teams
#
Citations
Year
Inventor(s)
37
2001
"GERTMAR, LARS GUSTAF"
1
37
2001
"LOF, PER ANDERS KRISTIAN"
30
2001
"GERTMAR, LARS GUSTAF"
2
30
2001
"LOF, PER ANDERS KRISTIAN"
30
2001
"ANDREN, LARS ANDERS"
26
1987
"KIGNELL, JEAN ERIK"
3
26
1987
"KIGNELL, JEAN ERIK"
25
1977
"SKOGMAN, HARALD"
25
1977
"HUSS, LENNART"
4
25
1977
"SKOGMAN, HARALD"
25
1977
"HUSS, LENNART"
18
1994
"STIGSSON, LARS"
5
18
1994
"STIGSSON, LARS"
17
1984
"BERGSTROM, TOMMY"
6
17
1984
"BOMAN, GORAN"
17
1984
"ENGLUND, LEIF"
11
1980
"LINDSTROM, OLLE B"
7
11
1980
"LINDSTROM, OLLE B"
10
1979
"THOMSEN, OVE"
10
1979
"RONNOW, PETER"
8
10
1979
"THOMSEN, OVE"
10
1979
"RONNOW, PETER"
8
1981
"ALMSTROM, STEN HAKAN"
9
8
1981
"NELVING, HANS G"
8
2002
"GERTMAR, LARS GUSTAF"
10
8
2002
"LOF, PER ANDERS KRISTIAN"
8
2002
"ANDREN, LARS ANDERS"
8
1981
"ALMSTROM, STEN HAKAN"
11
8
1981
"NELVING, HANS G"
12
7
1989
"SARNER, ERIK"
13
7
1982
"ANDERSSON, BIRGER A"
14
7
1989
"SARNER, ERIK"
15
7
1990
"JORLOV, RICKARD"
7
2000
"ERIKSSON, KJELL"
16
7
2000
"WIK, SUNE"
7
2001
"LINDQUIST, STEN ERIC"
7
2001
"HAGFELDT, ANDERS"
17
7
2001
"LINDSTROM, HENRIK"
7
2001
"SODERGREN, SVEN"
18
7
1990
"JORLOV, RICKARD"
7
2001
"LINDQUIST, STEN ERIC"
7
2001
"HAGFELDT, ANDERS"
19
7
2001
"LINDSTROM, HENRIK"
7
2001
"SODERGREN, SVEN"
20
6
1979
"LJUNGSTROM, OLLE"
NATIONAL RENEWABLE ENERGY LABORATORY
Assignee
"ABB AB"
"ABB AB"
"ABB AB"
"ABB AB"
"ABB AB"
"SVENSKA SOCKERFABRIKS AB"
"SVENSKA SOCKERFABRIKS AB"
"SVENSKA SOCKERFABRIKS AB"
"SVENSKA SOCKERFABRIKS AB"
"KVAERNER PULPING TECHNOLOGIES AB"
"KVAERNER PULPING TECHNOLOGIES AB"
"ASEA AKTIEBOLAG"
"ASEA AKTIEBOLAG"
"ASEA AKTIEBOLAG"
"A BETONG AB"
"A BETONG AB"
"A BETONG AB"
"A BETONG AB"
"UNITED STIRLING AB"
"UNITED STIRLING AB"
"ABB AB"
"ABB AB"
"ABB AB"
"UNITED STIRLING AB"
"UNITED STIRLING AB"
"AC BIOTECHNICS AB"
"SAAB SCANIA AKTIEBOLAG"
"AC BIOTECHNICS AB"
"AIMPOINT AB"
"ABB AB"
"ABB AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
"AIMPOINT AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
"FORSKARPATENTI UPPSALA AB"
City
"VASTERAS"
"VALLINGBY"
"VASTERAS"
"VALLINGBY"
"ORSUNDSBRO"
"UPPLANDS VASBY"
"UPPLANDS VASBY"
"SKANOR"
"MALMO"
"SKANOR"
"MALMO"
"HAMMARO"
"HAMMARO"
"VASTERAS"
"VASTERAS"
"VASTERAS"
"S TABY"
"S TABY"
"VAXJO"
"MOLNLYCKE"
"VAXJO"
"MOLNLYCKE"
"LUND"
"HOLLVIKSNAS"
"VASTERAS"
"VALLINGBY"
"ORSUNDSBRO"
"LUND"
"HOLLVIKSNAS"
"ABBEKAS"
"LINKOPING"
"ABBEKAS"
"LOMMA"
"LUDVIKA"
"LUDVIKA"
"UPPSALA"
"BJORKLINGE"
"UPPSALA"
"UPPSALA"
"LOMMA"
"UPPSALA"
"BJORKLINGE"
"UPPSALA"
"UPPSALA"
"S LIDINGO"
Location
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE
SE