Transcript Demand Response

Demand Response
Commissioner Suedeen Kelly
June 3, 2008
Integration – RTO/ISO
Level
•
•
•
•
•
ISO-NE
NYISO
PJM
MISO
CAISO
6/3/2008
Integration – ISO-NE
• Energy Market:
– Four distinct programs
– Day-Ahead and Real Time opportunities
• Forward Capacity Market (FCM)
– Demand Resources treated as supply resources in FCM
• Ancillary Services:
– Larger Demand Resources can participate fully (5+ MW)
– Pilot program underway to enable smaller Demand
Resources to participate in reserves market
6/3/2008
Integration – NYISO
• Energy Market:
– Participation through Day-Ahead Demand
Response Program and the Emergency Demand
Response Program
• Capacity Market
– Participation through Special Case Resource
Program
• Ancillary Services:
– Operating Reserves and Regulation Service
6/3/2008
Integration – PJM
• Energy Market:
– Economic Load Response enables Demand
Resources to respond LMP
• Capacity Market (RPM)
– Demand Resources may participate as a forward
capacity resource
• Ancillary Services:
– PJM provides opportunity to offer into the
synchronized reserves and regulation markets
6/3/2008
Integration – Midwest ISO
• Energy Market:
– Participation through Emergency Demand
Response Program
• Ancillary Services:
– Operating Reserves and Regulation Service
6/3/2008
Integration – CAISO
• Participating Load Agreements
• MRTU Implementation
• MRTU Release 1A
6/3/2008
Competition NOPR
• Would require RTOs/ISOs to accept bids from
demand response resources in their markets for
certain ancillary services.
• Would eliminate, during a system emergency, a
charge to buyers in the energy market for taking less
electric energy in the real-time market than
purchased in the day-ahead.
• Would permit an aggregator of retail customers to
bid demand response on behalf of retail customers
directly into energy markets.
• Required staff to conduct a technical conference on
demand response.
6/3/2008
DR Technical Conference Issues
• Value of and appropriate compensation for
demand response in organized electric
markets.
• Barriers to comparable treatment of demand
response that have not previously been
identified.
• Potential solutions to eliminate barriers to
demand response.
6/3/2008
Smart Grid
• Energy and Independence and Security Act of
2007
• Interoperability Standards
• FERC-NARUC Collaborative
6/3/2008
Demand Response
• Assessment of Demand Response
• National Action Plan for Demand Response
6/3/2008
Conclusions
• Adding significant new amounts of DR
represents a challenge as well as an
opportunity
• Measurement and Verification protocols and
processes will be increasingly important
• Ultimately, we will see significant
technological infrastructure additions and
improvements
6/3/2008