Transcript MSP
2011 Proposal Writing Workshop
Co-sponsored by the:
National Science Foundation
&
American Association for the Advancement of Science
Workshop Objectives
As the result of this workshop, participants will better
understand:
Key elements of the Robert Noyce Teacher Scholarship
Program
Key features of a successful proposal to the program
Workshop Agenda
Welcome & introductions
Program overview
Q & A
Features of effective proposals
Sample proposal – Scholarship or TF/MTF track
Meet with an NSF program director
“NSF invests in the best ideas generated by scientists, engineers and educators
working at the frontiers of knowledge, and across all fields of research
and education. Our mission, vision and goals are designed to maintain and
strengthen the vitality of the U.S. science and engineering.”
National Science Foundation Investing in America’s Future
Strategic Plan FY 2006-2011
Organization of EHR Directorate
Directorate of Education & Human
Resources (EHR)
Division of Research on Learning in Formal &
Informal Settings (DRL)
Division of Undergraduate Education
(DUE)
Division of Graduate Education
(DGE)
Division of Human Resource Development
(HRD)
Robert Noyce Teacher Scholarship Program
Initiated by Act of Congress in 2002
Reauthorized in 2007 (America COMPETES
Act) and in 2010 under America COMPETES
Reauthorization of Act of 2010
To encourage talented mathematics, science,
and engineering undergraduates to pursue
teaching careers
To encourage STEM professionals to become
teachers
To prepare Master Teachers
2011 Noyce Scholarship Program (NSF 11-517)
Robert Noyce Teacher Scholarship Track
Scholarships for undergraduate STEM majors preparing to become
K12 Teachers
Internships for freshmen and sophomores
Stipends for STEM professionals seeking to become K12 teachers
NSF Teaching Fellowships & Master Teaching
Fellowships
(TF/MTF) Track
Fellowships for STEM professionals receiving teacher certification
through a master’s degree program with teacher certification
Fellowships for science and math teachers preparing to become
Master Teachers
2011 Noyce Scholarship Program
Capacity Building Track (new in 2011)
To establish the infrastructure and partnerships for
implementing a future Noyce Teacher Scholarship or NSF
Teaching Fellowship (TF/MTF) project
Development of new teacher preparation programs for
STEM majors and STEM professionals
Development of new programs for developing Master
STEM Teachers
Noyce Scholarship Program Eligibility
Proposals may only be submitted by:
Universities & 2- or 4-year colleges (including
community colleges)
Nonprofit entities that have established consortia
among such IHEs
Principal Investigators:
The PI, or at least one Co-PI, must be a faculty member
in a STEM department.
Noyce Scholarship Program Scholarship Track
To recruit undergraduate STEM majors and STEM career
changers who might otherwise not have considered a
career in K-12 teaching:
Summer internships for freshmen and sophomores to
interest students in STEM teaching
Undergraduate Scholarships of at least $10,000 per year
for up to three years beginning in junior year
Undergraduate students graduate with a degree in a STEM
discipline and teacher certification and/or licensing.
One-year stipends of at least $10,000 for STEM
professionals (career-changers) and post-baccalaureate
students to obtain teacher certification
Noyce Scholarship Program Scholarship Track
Scholarship and stipend capped by cost of attendance
Recipients commit to teaching in a high need school
district for 2 years for each year of scholarship/stipend
support.
Recipients failing to meet service requirement must
repay scholarship
Noyce Scholarship Program
Projects include:
STEM faculty collaborating with Education faculty
Strong partnership with school district
Recruitment and selection strategies
Exemplary teacher preparation programs leading to certification
and/or professional development programs for Master Teaching
Fellows)
Support for new teachers
Mechanism for monitoring recipients
Institutional support
Evaluation
Noyce Scholarship Track
Phase I: For new awardees or new project with different
focus
Phase II: For previously funded awardees
Scholarships & Stipends: To expand and extend evaluation efforts
begun under previous award and support additional cohorts of
scholarship and stipend recipients
Monitoring and evaluation: To expand and extend evaluation efforts
of previous project without support for additional cohorts.
Noyce Scholarship Track
Phase I
Scholarships, Stipends, Internships
Award size up to $1,200,000
Additional $250,000 for collaboration with two-year colleges
Duration up to 5 years
Administrative/programmatic costs may not exceed 20%
of total direct costs
80% of total direct costs must directly support participants
No cost sharing
Noyce Scholarship Program
Scholarship Track Phase II
Scholarships and Stipends plus longitudinal evaluation
studies of previously supported cohorts of students
Award size up to $750,000; up to 5 yrs.
Up to 20% of
budget for admin./programmatic costs)
80% of budget for direct support to participants
No cost sharing
Monitoring and Evaluation
Award size up to $150,000; up to 3 yrs.
No cost sharing
NSF Teaching Fellowships & Master
Teaching Fellowships Track (TF/MTF)
NSF Teaching Fellows
STEM professionals enroll in a master’s degree program
leading to teacher certification or licensing
Receive one-year stipend of at least $10,000 while enrolled in the
Master’s degree program
Selection of Fellows based on professional achievement,
academic merit, and demonstration of advanced content
knowledge in STEM
Commit to teach for 4 years in a high need school district
Receive annual salary supplement of at least $10,000 while
fulfilling four-year teaching commitment
NSF Teaching Fellowships & Master Teaching
Fellowships Track
NSF Master Teaching Fellows:
Fellowships for math and science teachers preparing to
become Master Teachers
Selection of Fellows based on professional achievement,
academic merit, demonstration of advanced content
knowledge in STEM, demonstrated success in in
improving student achievement
Must have Master’s degree
Commit to teach for 5 years in a high need school district
Receive annual salary supplement of at least $10,000 for 5
years plus professional development while fulfilling the
teaching commitment
NSF Teaching Fellowships & Master Teaching
Fellowships Track
Award size up to $3 million over 5-6 years
Additional $250,000 for collaboration with two-year colleges
Matching funds required:
30% of total budget for request less than $1.5 million, excluding twoyear college incentive
50% of total budget if request is $1.5 million or more, excluding twoyear college incentive
At least 50% of cost share must be cash
At least 80% of total direct costs must be for direct support to
participants (stipends, salary supplements, professional development)
TF/MTF Proposals Must Include:
1. A department within an IHE that provides an
advanced program of study in math and science,
2. A department or entity within an IHE that provides
teacher preparation or a 2-year institution that offers a
teacher preparation program or a dual enrollment or
an articulation agreement with an IHE that
credentials teachers,
3. At least one high need school district and public
school(s) within this district, and
4. At least one nonprofit organization with the capacity
and expertise to support the goals of the project.
Noyce Scholarship Program
Capacity Building Track
Development of new programs, partnerships,
infrastructure for future Noyce project
Award size up to $300,000; up to 2 yrs.
May
include an additional $50,000 over 2 years for collaborations
between two-year and four-year institutions.
No restriction on budget allocation (within standard NSF
policies)
No cost sharing
Project Description: Phase I Scholarship Track
Results from relevant prior NSF support
Descriptions of:
proposed scholarship or stipend program
teacher preparation program
recruitment and marketing activities
selection process
management & administrative structure for
administering scholarship or stipend program
plans to monitor & enforce compliance with the
required teaching commitment
Project Description: Phase I Scholarship Track
Provide evidence of:
infrastructure to support new teachers,
collaboration between STEM & education faculty,
a functioning partnership between the IHE(s) & school
districts,
a commitment to making the program a central
institutional focus
Include an objective evaluation plan
NSF Review Criteria
NSF Merit Review Criteria
Intellectual Merit
Broader Impacts
Additional Considerations
Integration of Research & Education
Integrating Diversity into NSF Programs
Additional Noyce Program specific review criteria,
dependent on proposal type
Review Criteria: Phase I Scholarship Proposals
Capacity and ability of institution to effectively conduct
the program
Number and quality of students that will be served by the
program
Justification for number of students and amount of
stipend & scholarship support
Ability of the program to recruit STEM majors who
would not otherwise pursue a teaching career
Quality and feasibility of recruitment & marketing
strategies
Quality of the preservice educational program
Review Criteria: Phase I Proposals
Extent to which STEM & education faculty are
collaborating in developing & implementing the program
Quality of the preservice student support and new teacher
support infrastructure
Extent to which the proposed strategies reflect effective
practices based on research
Degree to which the proposed programming will enable
scholarship or stipend recipients to become successful
mathematics & science teachers
Feasibility & completeness of an evaluation plan that will
measure the effectiveness of the proposed strategies
Institutional support for the program and the extent to
which the institution is committed to making the program
a central organizational focus
Project Description: TF/MTF Proposals
Results from Prior NSF Support
Description of proposed Fellowship program:
For NSF Teaching Fellows
Description of the Master’s degree program
Evidence of an infrastructure that is supportive of new
teachers
For NSF Master Teaching Fellows
Description of the professional development program
Evidence of an infrastructure that will support and facilitate
the Fellows’ work as Master Teachers
Project Description: TF/MTF Proposals
Describe:
Recruitment activities
Selection
process
Management and
Cost sharing,
administrative structure
including source and amount; enter
amount on Budget form Line M
Project Description: TF/MTF Proposals
Describe:
Plans to monitor and enforce compliance with the required
teaching commitment
Plans for sustaining activities beyond NSF funding period
Evaluation plan
Provide evidence of:
Collaboration between STEM faculty and education faculty
Functioning partnerships between IHEs, school districts, and non-
profit organizations
Commitment to make the program a central institutional focus
Review Criteria: TF/MTF Proposals
Extent to which the proposed strategies reflect effective
practices based on research
Extent to which STEM & education faculty are
collaborating in developing & implementing a program
with curriculum based on the specialized pedagogy needed
to enable teachers to effectively teach math & science & to
assume leadership roles in their schools.
Degree to which the proposed programming will enable
the participants to become successful mathematics and
science teachers or Master Teachers
Review Criteria: TF/MTF Proposals
Capacity & ability of institution to effectively conduct
the program
Number & quality of Fellows that will be served by the
program
Justification for number of Fellows served & amount of
stipend & salary supplements
Quality & feasibility of recruitment & marketing
strategies
Review Criteria: TF/MTF Proposals
Feasibility & completeness of an objective
evaluation plan that will measure the effectiveness
of the proposed strategies
Institutional support for the program & the extent
to which the institution is committed to making
the program a central organizational focus
Evidence of cost sharing commitments
Plans for sustainability beyond the period of NSF
funding
Review Criteria: TF/MTF Proposals
NSF Teaching Fellows only:
Ability of the program to recruit individuals who would not
otherwise pursue a career in teaching & to recruit
underrepresented groups
Quality of the Master’s degree program leading to teacher
certification
Quality of the preservice student support and new teacher
support infrastructure
NSF Master Teaching Fellows only:
Quality of the professional development that will be
provided
Project Description: Capacity Building
Projects
Results from Prior NSF Support: Address prior support
relevant to the proposed project
A description of the activities planned, timeline, and
outcomes expected to result from the proposal.
Plans for evaluating progress and outcomes of the
project.
Review Criteria: Capacity Building
Proposals
Clarity of proposed plans and activities that will lead
to a well-designed program consistent with the
requirements of the Noyce Scholarship Program.
Clear statement of objectives to be completed and
expected outcomes of the project.
Evaluation plans that will measure stated objectives
and outcomes.
The Process
Proposals may be submitted to FastLane or
grants.gov (Use FastLane for TF/MTF proposals)
All proposals are peer-reviewed according to
standard NSF merit review criteria
Notification of results within six months of receipt
Reviewers’ comments may be accessed through
FastLane after final decision is made
All Proposals Must Include:
One page Project Summary (Intellectual Merit and Broader
Impact)
Project description (15 pages)
Budget forms and narrative for each year
Biosketches
Current & Pending Forms
Facilities document
References
Mentoring Plan for Postdoctoral Researchers (if in budget)
Data Management Plan (consult NSF Proposal & Award
Policies & Procedures Guide (PAPPG), NSF 11-1)
Indicate Human Subjects status on cover sheet (pending,
approved, or exempt)
Data Management Plan
The Proposal & Award Policies & Procedures Guide (PAPPG)
contains a clarification of NSF’s long standing data policy.
All proposals must describe plans for data management
and sharing of the products of research, or assert the
absence of the need for such plans.
FastLane will not permit submission of a proposal that is
missing a Data Management Plan.
The Data Management Plan will be reviewed as part of the
intellectual merit or broader impacts of the proposal, or
both, as appropriate.
More information can be found in the Grant Proposal
Guide Chapter II.C.2j (NSF 11-1).
Noyce Budget
Appropriations & Supplemental Funds
FY 2002-2010
FY 2009 Stimulus
60
Funds
FY 2011
Request
Millions of Dollars
50
40
30
Appropriation
Supplemental
20
10
0
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
Fiscal Year
2008
2009
2010
2011
FY 2010 Noyce Proposals and Awards
Category
Number of
Proposals
Number of Funding
Awards
Rate
All Proposals
132
48
36.4%
Phase I
96
26
27.1%
Phase II
7
5
71.4%
TF/MTF
17
9
52.9%
Planning
12
8
66.7%
Noyce Portfolio
Category
FY 2010
Total (all
years)
Phase I
25
220
Phase II
TF
6
25
1
11
4
10
TF/MTF
4
8
Planning
8
23
48
297
MTF
Total
Robert Noyce Teacher Scholarship Program FY 2002-2010
Awards by States
7
2
2
4
1
2
1
3
1
2
6
57
8
3
1
4
6
9
6
3
2
30
5
9
8
7
2
1
8
7
3
14
26
7
2
2
1
5
10
4
3
DC -2
Puerto Rico -1
4
5
Number of
Projects
1-5
6-9
10-20
20-30
30+
FY 2011 Noyce Scholarship Program
Deadlines
Letters of Intent (optional): February 23, 2011
Full Proposal Deadline: March 23, 2011
Questions?
Contact a Noyce Program Officer:
Joan Prival
[email protected]
Richard Alo
[email protected]
Mary Lee Ledbetter
[email protected]
Other Resources:
www.nsf.gov
www.nsfnoyce.org