Studying Medium-Induced Jet Energy Loss with Direct Photon
Download
Report
Transcript Studying Medium-Induced Jet Energy Loss with Direct Photon
g
Justin Frantz
Ohio University
DNP 10/13/09
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
1
Outline
Introduction
Overview of RHIC Photon-Hadron Methods
Direct Photon-Hadron Results
Implications for Energy Loss esp. Geometric Biases
in HI
Fragmentation Photons
Future Directions/Implications for g-jet
talk posted at http://www.phy.ohiou.edu/~frantz/
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
2
Direct Photons @ RHIC
Direct g: excellent probe of strongly interacting medium
g
they escape medium without interacting
At RHIC we’ve established (as predicted!) that:
high pT hadrons are suppressed
Jet Suppression!
Direct g aren’t
Status of latter conclusion: (slight supression @ highest pT?)
Effect not significant within errors & Cu+Cu data does not show
Progress: New Au+Au h measurement: highest pT’s? (T. Sakaguchi DNP09)
Cu+Cu 200 GeV
Great Cross Check
(No “EMCal merging” effects as w/ p0)
X.N. Wang, Z. Huang PRC55 (1997)
3047-3061
Justin
Frantz DNP 2009
7/16/2015
3
Photon to Photon-Jet
Thus Established: Colorless photon
natureexcellent complement to single
jet/ di-jet
Perfect complement to any jet observable
replace jet / hadron w/ g
At Leading Order / Compton Scattering
q
γ
q
γ
Dominance:
g
q
q
Exact Momentum Balance w/ Away-Side Jet g
Compton
Annihilation
ignoring Photons from Jet Fragmentation (TBD)
Direct Photon Processes at LO
Still good approximation including higher
orders
p+p: Measure Gluon Distribution Function
A+A: Calibration of Energy Loss for
awayside jet: D(z) w/o jet reco
D(z)
More sensitive (?) probe than single particle
spectra, Di-Hadron Correlations
Jetg Fragmetation Direct Photon
Also LO Process Complication
4
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
A “golden” HI jet channel: g-jet
Purely hadronic observables clouded by the fact that
hadrons are in the modified jets themselves
Geometric surface bias of the single jet, di-jet ?
Away jet should have longer path length > suppression
Direct g production unmodified by medium: no
surface bias for g vertices
Plus dominant partonic type becomes purely q-jets
compared mainly g-jet/mix in jet-jet
Will discuss
this in more
detail after
we take a
look at the
data
head-on
view
of Au+Au
collision
overlap
region
Compton Diagram
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
5
STAR and PHENIX
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
6
Reminder: 2-p Angular Correlations
Jets by 2-particle correlations in particle pair opening
azimuthal angle
p+p
dijet
Pair Yields (Df)
jet-jet
g-jet
0
0
p
0
Au+Au Flow Subtraction: Underlying Event
p
Au+Au
Au+Au
Find Yield, Y, per-trigger particle
Soft particles: large underlying pedastal
w/ flow (v2) modulation !
Y J(Df)
October 13, 2009
Justin Frantz DNP 09 Hawaii
7
Main Subtraction Formulae
Note: inclusive means
(below) - for PHENIX inclusive single photons
-for STAR , “g-rich” EMC cluster sample, but not 100% devoid of po
decay means meson/meson decay bkg to direct photon signal
Trigger Eff divides
out…crucial point
No absolute g eff
needed!
PHENIX
STAR
For PHENIX “Rg” directly measured in other analyses Rg=Nall/Ndecay direct includes frag
For STAR, Solve for “R” by forcing nearside to be zero (Compton only--implicit isolation)
direct includes NO frag
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
8
Main Subtraction Formulae
g-h: double subtraction of 2-p measurements
Ydirect ∝ Cincl -
Bkgincl (Flow)
- [ Cdecay -
grich
p0
Bkgdecay(Flow)
]
Yxxx ∝
Norm
Bkg(Flow)
For PHENIX full subtraction w/ flow modulation included (low
pTassoc)
New Norm Normalization method employed dramatically reduced
systematics
For STAR working so far with pTassoc > 3 actual v2 modulation
negligible
Underlying event level still relevant ZYAM like subtraction
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
9
PHENIX Systematic Improvement
In going from prelim to final, we found our biggest reduction in systematic from
Underlying event normalization
I’d like to recommend this method to STAR as they push down in pT assoc
Biggest improvement for
publication
New Result
Hard Probes ’08
Result from last
summer
(~Same Scale)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
10
PHENIX MSMP Normalization
MSMP or “Absolute Normalization”
Alternative to ZYAM “b0“
Used previously in PHENIX publications
arXiv:0801.4545v1 Phys. Rev. C 78, 014901 (2008)
Njet pairs “=“ <NtrigNassoc> - ξ <Ntrig><Nassoc>
ξ correction factor for background centrality multiplicity
correlation
b0
ξ
Bkg(Flow)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
11
Direct g Bkg-h Correlations
grich
Both Experiments: Derive from p0-h corr.
p0
STAR: (p02g decay merges to single EMcluster)
Tightly contained shower cut leaves only small
angle symmetric p decay in “grich” sample
Use easily-identifyiable, less symmetric p0 sample to form p bkgh correlation Ybkg-h
Assume (after checking ;>) all other background has same
Nearside/Awayside ratio
p0
0
PHENIX: (2-g inv mass reco of all p )
h+ Bkg-h is simply meson decay g-h Ydecay
Also use p-h to calculate Ydecay, by
mapping Np-h(pT) Ng-h (pT) (& pg)
g
h+-
g
Build Ydecay (Df) up from p0 -h pair by pair with map weights
Low trigger pt bins, systematics from combinatoric under p0
peak
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
12
Other
contributions
to
Bkg-h
Bkg-h not only from p , e.g. for PHENIX:
0
Raw Fraction of decay g from other mesons 20% : > 18% from h
δ = gother/gp = 1.24
h, etc… triggered 2-p correlation not possible in Au+Au (Comb Bkg)
STAR cuts away some fraction of above w/ shower cut
Assumption : as w/ other contrib’s, same NS/AS ratio negligible effect
PHENIX Assumption: same suppression as p for other mesons
(Fragmentation largely outside medium)
Well justified by single h (other high pT meson) measurements
Measure h-h in p+p, scale to Au+Au as correction to p0-h
First h-h measurement at RHIC!!!
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
13
…point is so far is these are very complicated analyses!!!
and now…
What we’ve measured
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
14
STAR and PHENIX g-h Results
Both RHIC experiments busily making measurements in this
channel
STAR
Impressive array of prelimary results including 2007 long Au dataset
Au+Au , d+Au, p+p (baselines) Frag. Function D(z), Ratios (IAA)
Wide z (pTh/pTtrig) coverage and centrality dependence
PHENIX
Recent Publication of 2004 Au+Au dataset measurement
My other simultaneous baby, with SUNY grad student Matt Nguyen, (my
wife and I picked a better name for the the first one)
Preliminary 2007 dataset w/ increased precision
More precise isolation cut measurements in p+p
Exploration of fragmentation photons themselves!
Ava
Both collaborations need more precision to make definitive
statements about Eloss contraints
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
15
Au+Au Awayside Yield Measurement
Both collab’s focus on the 1800 Back to Back Region only
PHENIX
STAR
pTh(GeV/c)
Phys. Rev. C 80, 024908 (2009)
4 x statistics collected
new data fully consistent w/ 2004 data
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
STAR always bins in
zT = pTh/ pTg
16
Look at z > 1 ?
Because of Fragmentation g and NLO (2->3) and the way we define
our z, it can be > 1
in fact some (Wang, Arleo) suggest that is a sensitive region
Highest
precision!
STAR Preliminary
all pT combo’s ~scale
(like frag fn should)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
17
Slope comparison
Fit a ~universal curve
7/16/2015
for all jet energies
p+p slope of 6.89 ±
0.64 more consistent
with quark
fragmentation of b=8
than b=11 for gluons
(LEP)
Slope of Au+Au is 9.49
±1.37
Au+Au slope is ~1.3σ
higher than p+p
Still just hint: need
better stats
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
18
Some Questions:
Actually first we should ask…
For that a short digression…
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
19
Measuring Different Quantities?
STAR method like statistical isolation cut
PHENIX statistical method includes fragmentation
photons
Does the difference in the STAR/PHENIX method affect
the interpretations ? It turns out, not subtantially
Especially, can we interpret PHENIX results ignoring the
fragmentation photons?
In principle PHENIX leaves this to theory
But in practice YES…
Because PHENIX has also measured yields in p+p using
isolation cuts which addresses this question partially
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
20
Real (Ev. by Ev.) Isolation cut: p+p
Idea: most p0/decay g can be removed by looking at other
event properties
Other detector activity around g Jet
ie cuts di-jet events
PHENIX: Isolation cuts
Sum of track pT and Emcal E
must be < 0.1 * Eg
In cone around g of size
DR = sqrt(Df2+Dh2) = 0.5
Also cuts Fragmentation Direct g pure Compton Direct g
Still not 100% pure, still apply subtraction of iso p0
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
21
Comparison of Stat/Iso Methods
Much more precise because subtraction so much smaller
Results consistent with statistical method on the away (jet) side
2 <pT,a< 3 GeV
1 <pT,a< 2 GeV
3 <pT,a< 5 GeV
200 GeV p+p
5 <pT,t< 7 GeV
7 <pT,t< 9 GeV
9 <pT,t< 12 GeV
Preliminary
12 <pT,t < 15 GeV
p
7/16/2015
Awayside
Df [rad]
22
Awayside Only
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
22
Fragmentation g Contribution
Even though for PHENIX Stat. Method:
Direct g = Compton (Iso) + Fragmentation Prompt
… in practice results ≈ Compton Only
Why ? Two Reason
Frag. Prompt should be suppressed w/ associated jet
Au+Au stat method: Compton + ~1/5 Frag ≈ Compton
But then p+p wrong baseline for IAA (use Iso)
Au+Au/(p+p Iso) -- current p+p error bars encompass p+p
Actually this is not established. Zakarov, Gale, Qiu
arguments: at some pt could be enhanced!
Near future publication of PHENIX p+p Isolation method:
make IAA both ways (iso p+p in denominator)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
23
Double Checking the Baseline
Both PHENIX and STAR compare Au+Au data to p+p
baseline data.
In the low multiplicity p+p environment both
statistical methods seem to yield fairly precise data
This can be used to double check the pQCD
calculations the Eloss models use as a basis
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
24
Evaluating pQCD Performance
CTEQ + NLO + KKP
Zhang, Owens, Wang, Wang: arXiv:0902.4000
Df > p/2
Using Isolation Cut p+p Data PHENIX: non-universal slopes
can relate to phenomenological LO kT (non-back to back-ness)
NLO reproduction of this effect? I would say: not clear! (low z)
Although NLO description overall pretty good
Not large enough effect to be concerned? May need to keep in
mind [Same group: Au+Au Eloss info sensitive to slope of D(z)]25
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
STAR Baseline Measurements
STAR comparision to same calculations
very good: imply consistency of STAR/PHENIX results?
(same pT scales, pdfs etc.. inputs?)
STAR one step further: checks baseline cold nuclear
effects in d+Au (~null)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
26
Suppression level IAA
We quantify this with the ratio IAA = DAA/Dpp
In preparation for comparisons of Au+Au data, also
useful to consider di-hadron data
STAR analysis also produces high quality p-h for
comparison
STAR Preliminary
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
27
Constraints for Energy Loss
(…Just taking the same ratio for the Au+Au data shown before)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
28
Au+Au Suppression Level IAA
Strong
STAR Preliminary
Suppression
Signal both
collaborations
At about ~0.3
-h
STAR Preliminary
Dd+Au
Baseline
PHENIX splits into smaller trigger bins
IAA
pTh
zT = trig
pT
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
29
Au+Au h-h vs. g-h
Interesting to
compare to h-h
Very similar
Compares well w/
theory (3 models)
Where is path
length effect?
Dd+Au
Baseline
pTh
zT = trig
pT
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
30
Centrality Dependence
PHENIX: IAA ~= RAA (~= IAA)
First results from STAR showed hint of z- (or pTassoc-)
ordered centrality dependence
Latest data ~z independent with better precision
than before
PHENIX
Phys. Rev. C 80, 024908 (2009)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
31
Regarding model comparisons…
Justin’s opinion about the current state of things….
At least 4 Energy Loss Modeling Methods
Opacity Expansion, Multiple soft thermal pQCD interactions (AMY), etc…
RAA alone can’t discriminate models: other observables must be
included (we’ve learned by now)
But not understood what role parameter adjustments, extensions should
be included to unambiguously kill models
In fact, there is already lots of other Eloss data to confront
Until theorists resolve these issues (TEQHQM) model comparisons to
g-jet can not yet be expected to used to distinguish models
e.g. including g-jet in global fit
Instead
Look for simple statements the experimental data might be telling us
independent of specific models
Test specific behaviors the models may expect under certain assumptions
in order to identify possible areas that may need addressed in order to
make “the global fits” work for each model
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
32
Basic ideas for g-h expectations
Picture jet vtx distribution njet vtx (x,y,z) within medium….
Direct g–jet vtx’s ∝ ncoll(x,y,z)
therefore so is ndirectg (x,y,z) (unmodified)
g-jet IAA (# jet/g) = single jet RAA
high zfrag h g-h ~= single-h RAA qualitatively confirms
geometric picture
not necessarily surface bias!!!!
Big question becomes why is Di-hadron suppression IAA same?
In surface bias should have longer path length
So away jet yield (JAA = Away jet/Ncoll * pp Away) reduced smaller
IAA?
Possible resolution: tangential dominance of hadron (jet) trigger sample
Thus trigger yield reduced also: Per-trigger yield goes back up JAA ~=
RAA2
Reality (X-h NOT X-jet) g-h IAA ≠ g-jet etc..
Need model for translation: one model with this property is ZOWW
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
33
ZOWW Model Realization of This
Zhang, Owens, Wang, Wang: e.g. arXiv:0902.4000
High z g-h: IAA = RAA expectation confirmed
Low z g-h IAA probes interior of medium
Tangent/Corona dominates in h-h IAA, b.c. Eloss
averaged over pathlengths
Single hadron
g-hadron
di-hadron
ZOWW
jet
high z
Origin vertex distributions
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
34
ZOWW Realization of This: Data?
Data: more precision at low z needed to confirm (hint of no
change?)
Problem: centrality dep pTassoc dep now not seen with STAR
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
35
PHENIX Model Comparisons
Run 7: Not enough precision here either to resolve the question
Renk
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
ZOWW
36
What do we conclude?
Renk/ASW : same observables esp. h-h IAA can be
described by allowing for fluctuations in Eloss for a
given path through the medium
No surface bias (disagrees w/ jet reco results?)
But no explanation of why IAAh-h ~= RAAh-h
conspiracy of several effects? It’d be nice to hear why…
some effects (e.g. spectral shape) may be shared by g-h
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
37
The other direct photon
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
38
Fragmentation Photons
Fragmentation diagrams must be
included at NLO to cancel
divergences
|z| < 1 for fragmentation
photons, but how much less?
Dparton/g(z) not well constrained
May oppose either quark or
gluon jets
Larger fraction of direct
@
@ LHC
Suppressed by E-loss?
Enhanced by Medium?
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
γ
q
g
q
g
γ
g
q
Medium Induced
Bremsstrahlung diagrams
I.Vitev, 2007 RHIC-AGS Meeting
--RHIC
– LHC
39
The idea: "Reverse Isolation Cut”
If we require a high pT hadron to be in the event
…and look at hard photons on the same side of the event
We brutally suppress the Compton direct photons
Which leaves only the fragmentation direct g after
statistical subtraction
10/13/2009
Justin Frantz – DNP 09 Hawaii
40
Latest Measurement: Frag g pout
Rates measured, starting to be addressed by theory
Z. Belghobsi et. al. arXiv:0903.4834v1
Latest: Low E frag g have much broader correlation inside
(mini) jet pout = momentum tranverse to jet axis
If persists at higher Q2/Eg, implications for frag g
suppression/ medium induced g arguments?
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
41
A cornerstone of the RHIC program in the next decade
Besides the obvious extensions of the g-h (e.g. exploring reaction
plane/path length dependence of g-h) I wanted to leave you with 2
thoughts about future directions…
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
42
g-jet in the jet reco era
Does jet reconstruction put us out of
business?
No. Even if jet reco is completely
unbiased is the difference, still useful
b.c. of q uark jet dominance of g-jet
but pretty unlikely there won’t be
some difference…
g-jet would probably be needed to
determine that anyway
Jet
Reco
pT
reach
Next step combine jet reco on
awayside with g subtraction/ID
methods already developed
LHC plans to use it to constrain the
reco energy scale
Complication: Likely will always be a
thin region in pT of overlap
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
Direct g
trigger pT
reach
5
15
pT, photon (GeV/c)
43
Other things to do w/ g-hadron
Test for presence of exotic modifications!
Ridge and Shoulder
Do extended rapidity correlations exist between direct photon and
hadrons? Excellent insight for jet origination models
Does shoulder/cone correlation appear in direct photon-hadron
Actually many wonder if it’s there for ANY high pT trigger:
STAR po-h looks like it may have quality to check if push slightly
lower in pTh (maybe slightly lower pT trig)
?
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
7/16/2015
44
Conclusions
STAR and PHENIX have been actively pursuing direct
photon hadron correlations
First measurements already provide some insights, but
much more precision will be needed in the next
decade in order fully constrain energy loss descriptions
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
45
The End!!!
Back up slides follow
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
46
Future directions I:
Develop event by event methods to purify direct
gamma in Au+Au
Limited Isolation Cuts
Anti-tagging p0
High Multiplicity cause
Efficiency (Loss) of Accidental
Tagging of Direct g
low efficiency
Need to find optimal
Rejection/Efficiency
pTg
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
47
Future Directions
Purification: Isolation other E.by E.
Check for Ridge
Reaction Plane
LHC?
Energy Loss Theory
How to combine with Jet Reco studies?
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
48
Future Directions II
Explore rapidity dependence of g-jet
Need large rapidity coverage detector
FOCAL!!!
Test ridge models more directly
FOCAL
by using
gamma-jet w/ more rapidity coverage
Crisp test of Ridge models: Associated w/ gamma too?
Test other deviations of NLO seen at Fermilab
If present @ RHIC, is that physics modified in Au+Au
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
straightforward
application
of current
method?
49
Fragmentation Photon Results
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
50
Fragmentation Photon Results
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
51
Fragmentation Photon Results
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
52
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
53
Summary
PHENIX has lots of g-jet g-h correlation data
Recent publication a RHIC milestone
Proof of principle
Modest precision, but needs much much more
New preliminary datasets offer slightly more
Ideas underway for improvement look for more to
come!!!
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
54
Latest in g+jet
New g+jet cross sections from D0
D0, PLB666, 435 (2008)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
Currently only constraint on gluon
PDF at high x is jet cross-section
We may be absorbing beyond
Standard Model effects into PDF
Need cross check from g+jet
Compare to JETPHOX:
NLO with isolation cuts
By measuring different rapidity
ranges NLO shown not to be fully
compatible with data
Not due to uncertainty in the PDF
Also too large discrepancy for scale
dependence
NLO should really work at such
large energy
55
Sources of Rg
Come from combination of published and not-yet published
measurements
Extrapolated in pT bins, centralities specific to this ana
Like number of other inputs, e.g. v2
philosophy: directly tabulate in the paper (reason for so many tables) to
remove any ambiguity
the “real” publications of these & related quantities will be authoritative
Au+Au Directly measured in other ana’s
Run 4 publication still underway
p+p Used combination of Run3/Run5 p0 and Single direct g
publications
Au+Au
tabulated values in paper
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
p+p
56
p+p h-h Measurement
First h-h correlation
measurement at RHIC!
Even in low
multiplicity p+p
large combinatoric bkg
under h peak
Sideband subtraction
performed this time
h-h gh-h w/ same
weighting fn method
(both sideband &
peak)
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
57
π0 Flow values : Flat @ High pT
Just like RAA suppression
@ high pT…
…latest Run7 high pT p0
v2 looks ~pT
independent
This should be expected
RAA flat for all
centralities
Suppression
thought to be
source of high
pT v2
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
58
π0 Flow values : Fit Assumption
For this reason we used an assumption of constant v2 at high pt
Fitting our own Run4 measurements to determine the level
with Run 7 to set uncertainty constraints
π0 gπ (error level) progagated w/ weighting fns
h, other meson flow: assumed same as π0
Incl g (Direct + Decay) measured, no fit assumption
This Analysis
Run4
Measurement
Run7 Prelim Result
Run4 Measurement
Run4 Flat Fit value
Fit Pi0 v2 / Error
Fit Decay v2 / Error
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
59
Normalization continued…
ξ evaluated from parameterizing
centrality dep. of Ntrig , Nassoc
Measured in different pT ranges
“smaller”, but
of larger
relative
importance
Ntrig ranges higher than previously
used : assumption of constant ξ
ξ = <NtrigNassoc> / <Ntrig><Nassoc>
Results agree w/ ZYAM, smaller uncertainty
Final g-h
double
subtraction
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
60
Decay g-h,
0
p
by
0
p,
First, opening angle of p0 decay
doesn’t matter Ep >> mp
P(E)
(qp-gdecay vs qp-h)
Main problem is mapping
Np(pT) Ng(pT)
Probability of single p0 (vs pTp
decaying into photon
W∝P
Norm cancels
b.c. procedure
performed for trigs
& trig-h pairs,
then divided
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
Pair by Pair
P(Blue) ~ Blue / Tot
∝ 1/Ep
E
5
7
Ep
61
Faux-zero’s
counts
Combinatoric under p0
peak small but non-zero
p0 gp : relevant S/B
higher
Typically from same
high pT p0, combined w/
multiple low E partners
5-7
7-9
9-12
12-15
inv
mass
correlation not very
different
Sideband corr within
limited stats, same, so
apply faux-real diff as
uncertainty
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
counts
S/B
62
ISR Results for Charge Asymmetry
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
63
P(Blue) ~ Blue / Tot
∝ 1/Ep
P(E)
E
5
7/16/2015
Justin Frantz DNP 2009
7
Ep
64