Transcript Work Changes Gender: WP 3

Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
Devon’s response
to domestic violence
& abuse
as the context for the
REPAIR programme
Dartington 2007
Roy Tomlinson and
Rachel Martin
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
CYSP
CDRP
Police
IDVA
CPS
Courts
Civil Solicitor
Substance Misuse Agenices
Women’s Safety Worker
Benefits Agency
Social Services
Women’s Aid
Refuge
Employer
Housing
Health
CDRP
LCJB
Community
Friends
Perpetrator
Individual
Child
CAFCASS
Schools
Voluntary Sector
Educational Welfare
Youth Offending Team
Child Protection Agencies
Educational Psychology
Nursery/Child Care
Social Services
Health
Police
CPSDaphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
PPO
Courts
Probation
Substance Misuse Agencies
Perpetrator Programmes
Family Support
Prison
Employer
Housing
Health
Family
Neighbours
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Immediate
Network
Primary
Agency
Contact
Agency Risk
Assessments
Safety Planning
Process
£60m Cost in
Devon
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
Domestic Violence and Abuse
related costs
• GP visits : £16,591,581
• 1.2% A&E related: £3,744,952
• 35-55% CP cases : £103,140
• 55% of cyp in care : £162,250 a week
• 26% of CIN : £123,864 a week
• 898 Homeless acceptances :
£177,844
• 8,600 incident investigations :
£1,780,000
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Meeting
Need Women
• 7.4% of annual victims
supported by Women’s
Aid
• 13 FTE staff support
2,000 women for
£465,000
• To manage need in
Devon requires 24
Against
Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
outreach
staffDomestic
and 10
www.adva.org.uk
idvas
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
Meeting the
need children
• 30.4% cyp in need
supported by Women’s
Aid
• 1.5 FTE MARAC cyp &
2.5 FTE refuge cyp at
£131,000
• To meet
need 6 idvas &
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
2.5 FTE refuge
www.adva.org.uk
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
Why focus on
men and their
behaviour?
• Historical and institutional context
• Criminal Justice System : 96.4% of
dv incidents did not lead to
conviction
– 869 incidents, 222 arrests, 60 charged,
31 convicted, 4 custodial sentences
• The CJ system treats non-domestic
violence more seriously in terms of
custodial sentences (Hester)
• Men are seeking help from agencies
but are not being referred to
appropriate services
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
REPAIR in
Devon
Community
Perpetrator
Programme
• Programme for men (risk assessment;
one to one; group)
• Support for women (face to face, phone
& pattern changing group work)
• Support for cyp (individual sessions)
• Supervision (fortnightly, 2 hours)
• Agency awareness (to increase
referrals)
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
REPAIR
Programme
•
•
•
5 modules, each module has six
sessions.
The focus of the 5 modules is on the
following forms of abusive behaviour:
• 1) intimidation, coercion and
threats
• 2) emotional abuse
• 3) male privilege
• 4) sexual abuse
• 5) using children and abusive
parenting
Programme flexibility enables depth .
The belief is that to generate genuine
change to our identity is an emotional as
well as a cognitive process.
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
REPAIR key
messages so
far
• Reaching men early in their
cycle of abuse
• Women’s safety increases
as new catchment group
who continue with support
• Risk-assessment critical to
measure motivation and
potential success
• Inter-agency panel improves
joint management of risk in
the community and criminal
justice system
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
Implications
• The unit cost £8,000 per
annum
• Is this a more cost-effective
family intervention model than
supporting one child in need,
per year, costing £6,240?
• Potential for differential
programmes/interventions
based on assessment & risk
• 22% of men referred reach the
full programme. What about
the other 78%?
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Perpetrator
‘types’
• Group 1 – ‘one incident’ group.
One dv incident recorded by
police (31.4%)
• Group 2 – ‘mainly non-dv’
group. One dv incident, arrested
for non-dv offences (17.4%)
• Group 3 – ‘dedicated repeat
dv’ perps. A number of dv
incidents recorded, but no other
offences (17.4%)
• Group 4 – ‘all round repeat
offenders’. Had a number of dv
incidents recorded, and also
been arrested for non-dv
offence (33.8%)
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC
Contact
Details
• www.adva.org.uk
• 01392 382233
Against Domestic Violence and Abuse – ADVA Partnership, Devon
www.adva.org.uk
Daphne Project No:
JLS/DAP/2005-1-249/WYC