Strategy for Agriculture Exports

Download Report

Transcript Strategy for Agriculture Exports

Strategy for Agriculture
Exports
© METRO AG 2006
1
Flow Of Presentation
 Global Trends




Concentration of Modern Retailing
Agriculture Trading shares by Channel
Consumer, Product & Business dynamics
Global Super Market supply chain
 Where do we stand


Strengths
Weaknesses
 Strategic Framework for Agri-Exports
 360 Degree Model
 Policy Issues & Way forward
 Export Opportunities
© METRO AG 2006
2
GLOBAL TRENDS
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
3
Concentration of Modern Retailing & Trends
Top 30
retailers:
$2.1
trillion=31
% of
global
market



$1.3 trillion food
sales
$175 billion F&V
Carrefour , Tesco,
Metro F&V: $29.5b

Over concentration of Modern retailing in developed markets:
Reduced ROI’s for Retailers & Suppliers.

Increasing internationalization: Asia & Eastern Europe

Growth of discounters and specialty formats

Growth of Private label brands: 30 to 50% of top 30 retailer
sales & 20 to 47% of market share by value.

Food= 60-75%, Non-food=25-40%
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
4
Agriculture Trading Shares by Channel
Modern Retailing: HyperMarkets, Super Markets, Discounters
Traditional retailing: Street stalls, Growers, Traditional Markets, Growers, Others
Country
Modern Retailing
Traditional
Retailing
Germany
78%
22%
France
73%
27%
UK
75%
25%
Spain
37%
63%
Holland
69%
31%
Modern Retailing share in E.U= 70-80%, Developed
Asian Economies: 50-80%
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
5
Consumer
Trends:
Greater
demand for convenience= fresh cut,
processed foods.

More diversity of choice, for prolonged seasons

Growth of demand for ethnic and exotic products

Increased demand for organic and fair-trade
products

More ready-cooked, take-out foods

Growth of out-of-home market
Business Dynamics:
•Buying Consolidation and emergence of Modern
Retailing:
•
•
•
•
•
Product :

Food safety
•
Traceability
Quality
Farm
systems: Global Gap, HACCP, IFS, BRC
to fork value chain.
Uniformity

•Supplier’s response:
• Increasing collaboration: Marketing
of sizing and product appearance
Precision agriculture
Consistent
and stable quality.
Straight line sourcing: Elimination
of middlemen
Large scale trading by retail chains:
Uniform, consistent quality over
prolonged seasons
Large centrally controlled
purchasing systems
Control of supply chain from
production areas: Farm to fork
Long term business partnerships
rather than trading mindset
Channelizing of fruit through large
and sophisticated specialized
companies
•
•
•
•
boards, large scale farming,
cooperatives and collaboration
between all stake holders of the
value chain.
Specialization of functions/
activities
Marketing focus on customer
demands and changing trends
Extension of seasons: Production
in multiple regions and countries.
Customized growing for customers
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
6
Super Market Supply Chain
(Farm To Fork)
Farmers & Exporters
Customer demand
assesment
Customized
Product Development
Exporters
Processing &
Packaging
Inland and
sea logistics
Specialized handling Co’s
Importer/ Handling
company of
Super market
Distribution
Centers= repackaging
/ break bulk operations,
JIT deliveries
Super Markets
Consumers
HORECA
Traders
Offices
Hotels
Resturants
Carteres
Cash & Carry
Food Services
Channels
© METRO AG 2006
7
WHERE DO WE STAND
TODAY
© METRO AG 2006
Strengths of Agriculture
8

Low Labour cost

4 seasons and variation of climates

Plenty of land
Extended

seasons: All four provinces
Strategic Location in Asia: Feed Regional markets
Variation
in day and night temperatures
These strategic
strengths can
not be acquired
by other nations
© METRO AG 2006
Weaknesses
of Agriculture & Export Sector
9
Agriculture:





Very small or very large landholding
Lack of Cooperatives, large scale to spread the fixed cost factors.
No concept of precision agriculture
Diseased fruit trees , especially Mangoes & Kinnows.
Lack of business and commercial sense.
Exports:










Major lack of product diversification and new export markets
Lack of infrastructure, processing and cold chain facilities to meet SPS and quarantine
requirements.
Lack of collaboration b/w exporters & farmers for product development.
Volume based, rather than value based exports.
Serious lack of entrepreneurship & reliable business relationship.
Lack of strong government regulations for exports: Quality standards and Supply management.
Minimal Super market penetration
Price killing by over supply
Marketing Failure
The weaknesses
Over dependence on government & subsidies
can be
removed
through
intelligent effort
© METRO AG 2006
Strategic Framework for Agri-Exports
10
NATIONAL AGRICULTURAL STRATEGY
Market Research &
Product identification




Value/ Kg
Seasonality
Freight Solutions
Product economics

National Food
Security
Exports
Production/
R&D/ Transfer of
technology
Production & Process
Management


Supply Chain is built
around a product.
Identification of supply
chain synergies critical,
for cost optimization
and increased capacity
utilization.
Quality Standards
Freight Solutions
Hire experts: Why re-invent the
wheel?: Do we have the luxury of time?
 Product Based: Project teams for
value chain solution
 Precision growing, drip irrigation,
Agricultural engineers.
 R&D focus: Reverse engineering
of value chain hardware.
 Local solutions for cost efficiencies
 10 acre experimental training
farms
 Product clusters from South-North
 Product specific pack houses
 Cold chain near production area
 Model Projects: PPP:
Farmers have eyes, not ears
 ERP solutions for value chain




Global Gap, HACCP, IFS, BRC
Traceability
SPS, QA & MRL standards
Product Handling guides to shelf



Reefer,CA, MAP technologies
Customs regulations
Cross docking platforms
© METRO AG 2006
360 Degree Model, inclusive of all stake holders
11



Investment
Marketing/ lobbying
Adoption of technology/
standards
 MNC’s: Quality inputs &
local manufacturing
 Global Retailers: Access
to markets, Marketing




Direction
Policy making
Strategic intervention
Legislation for Private
sector facilitation
 Diplomacy & FTA’s







Farmer mobilization
Capacity building &
technical training
Product based project teams:
Production & value chain.
Demand driven R&D with
private sector.
Farm management HR
Farm economics models
Transfer of technology & R&D
for local adaptation
Exporters/
Private Sector
Government

NGO’s
360 Degree
Adoption of technology/
standards
 Precision agriculture
 Group cooperation
Farmers



Academia
Funding
Technical experts
International best practices
Donors
© METRO AG 2006
Policy Issues & Way forward
12
Structure

to support strategy:
Centralization & Empowerment of government departments within one organization: Private sector culture
Complete

financial and administrative authority
HR: representatives & experts from within Pakistan as well as expatriates
Solid
Business plan, compensation linked to KPI’s
Reduce
duplication of efforts & better utilization of public money
Excellence
Large
in execution & better utilization of public money
Scale Farming & JV’s with foreign companies:
Sell

Govt structure: function
specific.
 Product based project
management: cross functional
teams.
the benefits:
Large local market, greater consumer propensity to spend
Regional markets of Gulf, Central Asia and Asia: Reduced freight costs: Better margins and lower consumer price: Growth in
market size.
 Tax breaks and other benefits
MNC seed and pesticide companies inclusion
Legislation:
Seed Act & Nursery reforms
International buyers protection against fraud: Criminal cases
Legislation for enforcement of business contracts: e.g. farmers & exporters: criminal
Compulsory Pre-shipment inspections for all export consignments by 3rd parties.
Production Technology
cases.
& R&D:
 Drip Irrigation: 90% government subsidy for export based farming. Essential for supermarket quality.
 Hybrid seeds & customized agronomy: Development of product engineers.
 CA and Reefer experimentation facilities at UAF for global freight solutions
 Government to underwrite losses of private sector for pioneering projects, of new product and new market development.
20 to 40% R&D subsidy for new projects on CNF value for limited time, till technical issues resolved.
New certified mango orchards, with drip irrigation and precision agriculture. Recovery of young mango orchards.
 Sponsor project based transfer of technology and foreign learning.
© METRO AG 2006
Policy Issues & Way forward
13
Proposals by Engro:


Information system for individual farmer profiles:

Details of farming activities, land, usual crops, revenues and loans status.

Form as a basis for unsecured loans by Banks
Develop reliable crop reporting system (GIS) based:

Govt structure: function
specific.

Product
based project
Project to replace primitive crop reporting system
management: cross functional
Form basis for reliable information for planning crop commodity imports, exports, storage, distribution teams.
Develop Standardization laws and verification and certification agency for exports:

With collaboration of USAID & Foreign Agriculture Service (FAS) of USDA

Agency to have accredited & well equipped labs and equipment
Develop
Interest
free lending for corporate farms:

Loan channelizing by USAID through commercial banks.
90%
Corporate
interest free USAID funding & 10% funding with interest.
Meat farm by Engro: Exports to Middle East.
Channelizing
Export
single new non governmental organization with public/ private sector representation
of funds through USAID to Basmati Rice farmers, with Engro guaranteeing Buy-back.
oriented floriculture farms in Sind
© METRO AG 2006
Export Opportunities
14
Immediate:
Kinnows:
China, Latin America
Mangoes:
Sea freight
Floriculture:
Freight solution for exports
Potatoes:
Better varieties,Value addition &
shelf life extension
Value
Halal
added products
 Pulps & Nectars
 Packaged vegetables: Kenya
example
 Convenience packaging: ready
to eat meals
meat exports to Middle East, Europe
& Asia.
Basmati
Rice: Product & Brand
development for direct Super Market exports.

Dairy
Contractual farming & Buy back to ensure
BRC standards.
exports: Specialty Cheeses & Milk
based products
Medium
to long term:
Organics & Fair trade: Labor intensive, inline with developing countries agricultural
practices, hot climates, absorption of air
freight, plenty of virgin land availability

Retailers
Sea
Own Brand Development
Food exports
Tap
growth of Asian Cuisine and target
Food Services channels
Hybrid
Vegetables: Middle East, Central
Asian & South East Asian market.
New
products:

Melons

Water Melons

Grapes

Lychees (Madagascar: 23000 tons

Baby corn

Pumpkins

Peas

Sweetcorn

Guava Juices
We need to upgrade
from Commodity
trading to
Product/ Brand
development:
increase margins
by moving up the
value chain
© METRO AG 2006
15
All stake holders need to act UNITED and play their respective roles in a
FOCUSED AND SYNERGISED effort to:
Make
By
To

up for lost time
making 360 degree efforts on a war footing
develop world class products & services in next 3-5 years
to capitalize on the emerging global trade opportunities
Metro’s support to act as a catalyst will always be there.
THANK YOU
© METRO AG 2006
16
Back up slides
© METRO AG 2006
17
Developing countries F&V exports to E.U
35 % of E.U market
7 billion Euros exports
Top importing countries: U.K, France, Germany, Holland, Begium, Italy.
Fruits
Country
Vegetables
% of total E.U imports
South Africa
14
Costa Rica
12
Ecuador
10
Colombia
Chile
Country
% of total E.U imports
Morocco
32
Kenya
15
8
Turkey
11
8
Egypt
6
Peru
5
Thailand
4
© METRO AG 2006
18
Steps to Mango Exports
Fruit development
•
•
•
Identification of
disease free
orchards
Customized
agronomy for
each farm
Develop strong
fruit
for sea exports
Farmers + Metro
Harvest
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Reception
Selection
HWT
Drying
Waxing
Grading
Packing
Pre-cooling
Cooling
Farmers + Third party
Post shipment
handling
Shipment
& Packing
•
•
•
Loading
Temperature
and CA
settings
Transit
conditions
monitoring
Metro + Maersk
•
•
Developing
special Mango
ripening
chambers
across E.U.
Special
equipment in
Metro stores for
Mangoes
Metro
© METRO AG 2006
19
Short term & Long Term volumes
Containers /
wk
Volume /
season
Required Land
(Acres)
(Tons)
2009
5
1320
440
2010
10
2640
880
2011 onwards
20
5280
2000
© METRO AG 2006
20
Tentative Cost of Project
Cost Head
Building
Processing plant
Cost (million Rs)
Capacity
7-10
4-10 million
5 tons/ hour
Forced air cooling
8 million
44 tons
Cold Store
8 million
88 tons
Working Capital
10 million
Total Minimum
37 million
Total Maximum
46 million
4 containers/ day
© METRO AG 2006
21
Benefits of Metro
• Above
average buying price for Mangoes.
•Guaranteed
•No
middle men = better profits
•Long
•
buy back
term profitable, reliable business partner.
State of the art, transfer of technology.
•Global
supply chain excellence.
•Massive
reach and depth in 31 countries.
** Metro provides a comprehensive farm development, supply chain and
marketing solution.
© METRO AG 2006
22
Mango VISION
Pakistan Mangoes: Oil/ Gold of the future
Build exotic, premium positioning for Pakistan Mangoes = High vaue/kg
Build before India.
© METRO AG 2006
23
FOUR MAIN EXPORT DESTINATIONS VOLUME AND VALUE FOR PAKISTAN MANGOES
No.
1
2
3
4
Country
United Arabic Emirates
Arabia Saudi
Oman
Export (Mt)
33,604
13,224
9,245
Value us$000
9,395
4,810
2,098
Value usd/KG
0.28
0.36
0.23
8,052
2,834
0.35
77468
23426
0.30
UK
TOTAL PAKISTAN EXPORTS
RETURNS PER KG MAJOR EXPORTS NATIONS
PRICES PER KG FOR PAK MANGOES IN
EUROPE
Country
Value usd/KG
Belgium
0.48
Sweden
0.47
Norway
0.45
Germany
0.43
Italy
0.40
Switzerland
0.37
Denmark
0.37
Country
Value usd/KG
Australia
1.79
Philipines
1.59
China
0.91
South Africa
0.79
Peru
0.75
Brazil
0.55
Mexico
0.54
India
0.48
Thailand
0.46
Pakistan
0.30
FRUTOPIA GROUP
© METRO AG 2006
24
FOUR MAIN EXPORT DESTINATIONS VOLUME AND VALUE FOR PAKISTAN MANGOES
No.
1
2
3
4
Country
United Arabic Emirates
Arabia Saudi
Oman
Export (Mt)
33,604
13,224
9,245
Value us$000
9,395
4,810
2,098
Value usd/KG
0.28
0.36
0.23
8,052
2,834
0.35
77468
23426
0.30
UK
TOTAL PAKISTAN EXPORTS
RETURNS PER KG MAJOR EXPORTS NATIONS
PRICES PER KG FOR PAK MANGOES IN
EUROPE
Country
Value usd/KG
Belgium
0.48
Sweden
0.47
Norway
0.45
Germany
0.43
Italy
0.40
Switzerland
0.37
Denmark
0.37
Country
Value usd/KG
Australia
1.79
Philipines
1.59
China
0.91
South Africa
0.79
Peru
0.75
Brazil
0.55
Mexico
0.54
India
0.48
Thailand
0.46
Pakistan
0.30
FRUTOPIA GROUP
© METRO AG 2006