Strategy for Agriculture Exports
Download
Report
Transcript Strategy for Agriculture Exports
Strategy for Agriculture
Exports
© METRO AG 2006
1
Flow Of Presentation
Global Trends
Concentration of Modern Retailing
Agriculture Trading shares by Channel
Consumer, Product & Business dynamics
Global Super Market supply chain
Where do we stand
Strengths
Weaknesses
Strategic Framework for Agri-Exports
360 Degree Model
Policy Issues & Way forward
Export Opportunities
© METRO AG 2006
2
GLOBAL TRENDS
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
3
Concentration of Modern Retailing & Trends
Top 30
retailers:
$2.1
trillion=31
% of
global
market
$1.3 trillion food
sales
$175 billion F&V
Carrefour , Tesco,
Metro F&V: $29.5b
Over concentration of Modern retailing in developed markets:
Reduced ROI’s for Retailers & Suppliers.
Increasing internationalization: Asia & Eastern Europe
Growth of discounters and specialty formats
Growth of Private label brands: 30 to 50% of top 30 retailer
sales & 20 to 47% of market share by value.
Food= 60-75%, Non-food=25-40%
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
4
Agriculture Trading Shares by Channel
Modern Retailing: HyperMarkets, Super Markets, Discounters
Traditional retailing: Street stalls, Growers, Traditional Markets, Growers, Others
Country
Modern Retailing
Traditional
Retailing
Germany
78%
22%
France
73%
27%
UK
75%
25%
Spain
37%
63%
Holland
69%
31%
Modern Retailing share in E.U= 70-80%, Developed
Asian Economies: 50-80%
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
5
Consumer
Trends:
Greater
demand for convenience= fresh cut,
processed foods.
More diversity of choice, for prolonged seasons
Growth of demand for ethnic and exotic products
Increased demand for organic and fair-trade
products
More ready-cooked, take-out foods
Growth of out-of-home market
Business Dynamics:
•Buying Consolidation and emergence of Modern
Retailing:
•
•
•
•
•
Product :
Food safety
•
Traceability
Quality
Farm
systems: Global Gap, HACCP, IFS, BRC
to fork value chain.
Uniformity
•Supplier’s response:
• Increasing collaboration: Marketing
of sizing and product appearance
Precision agriculture
Consistent
and stable quality.
Straight line sourcing: Elimination
of middlemen
Large scale trading by retail chains:
Uniform, consistent quality over
prolonged seasons
Large centrally controlled
purchasing systems
Control of supply chain from
production areas: Farm to fork
Long term business partnerships
rather than trading mindset
Channelizing of fruit through large
and sophisticated specialized
companies
•
•
•
•
boards, large scale farming,
cooperatives and collaboration
between all stake holders of the
value chain.
Specialization of functions/
activities
Marketing focus on customer
demands and changing trends
Extension of seasons: Production
in multiple regions and countries.
Customized growing for customers
© METRO AG 2006
Global Trends
6
Super Market Supply Chain
(Farm To Fork)
Farmers & Exporters
Customer demand
assesment
Customized
Product Development
Exporters
Processing &
Packaging
Inland and
sea logistics
Specialized handling Co’s
Importer/ Handling
company of
Super market
Distribution
Centers= repackaging
/ break bulk operations,
JIT deliveries
Super Markets
Consumers
HORECA
Traders
Offices
Hotels
Resturants
Carteres
Cash & Carry
Food Services
Channels
© METRO AG 2006
7
WHERE DO WE STAND
TODAY
© METRO AG 2006
Strengths of Agriculture
8
Low Labour cost
4 seasons and variation of climates
Plenty of land
Extended
seasons: All four provinces
Strategic Location in Asia: Feed Regional markets
Variation
in day and night temperatures
These strategic
strengths can
not be acquired
by other nations
© METRO AG 2006
Weaknesses
of Agriculture & Export Sector
9
Agriculture:
Very small or very large landholding
Lack of Cooperatives, large scale to spread the fixed cost factors.
No concept of precision agriculture
Diseased fruit trees , especially Mangoes & Kinnows.
Lack of business and commercial sense.
Exports:
Major lack of product diversification and new export markets
Lack of infrastructure, processing and cold chain facilities to meet SPS and quarantine
requirements.
Lack of collaboration b/w exporters & farmers for product development.
Volume based, rather than value based exports.
Serious lack of entrepreneurship & reliable business relationship.
Lack of strong government regulations for exports: Quality standards and Supply management.
Minimal Super market penetration
Price killing by over supply
Marketing Failure
The weaknesses
Over dependence on government & subsidies
can be
removed
through
intelligent effort
© METRO AG 2006
Strategic Framework for Agri-Exports
10
NATIONAL AGRICULTURAL STRATEGY
Market Research &
Product identification
Value/ Kg
Seasonality
Freight Solutions
Product economics
National Food
Security
Exports
Production/
R&D/ Transfer of
technology
Production & Process
Management
Supply Chain is built
around a product.
Identification of supply
chain synergies critical,
for cost optimization
and increased capacity
utilization.
Quality Standards
Freight Solutions
Hire experts: Why re-invent the
wheel?: Do we have the luxury of time?
Product Based: Project teams for
value chain solution
Precision growing, drip irrigation,
Agricultural engineers.
R&D focus: Reverse engineering
of value chain hardware.
Local solutions for cost efficiencies
10 acre experimental training
farms
Product clusters from South-North
Product specific pack houses
Cold chain near production area
Model Projects: PPP:
Farmers have eyes, not ears
ERP solutions for value chain
Global Gap, HACCP, IFS, BRC
Traceability
SPS, QA & MRL standards
Product Handling guides to shelf
Reefer,CA, MAP technologies
Customs regulations
Cross docking platforms
© METRO AG 2006
360 Degree Model, inclusive of all stake holders
11
Investment
Marketing/ lobbying
Adoption of technology/
standards
MNC’s: Quality inputs &
local manufacturing
Global Retailers: Access
to markets, Marketing
Direction
Policy making
Strategic intervention
Legislation for Private
sector facilitation
Diplomacy & FTA’s
Farmer mobilization
Capacity building &
technical training
Product based project teams:
Production & value chain.
Demand driven R&D with
private sector.
Farm management HR
Farm economics models
Transfer of technology & R&D
for local adaptation
Exporters/
Private Sector
Government
NGO’s
360 Degree
Adoption of technology/
standards
Precision agriculture
Group cooperation
Farmers
Academia
Funding
Technical experts
International best practices
Donors
© METRO AG 2006
Policy Issues & Way forward
12
Structure
to support strategy:
Centralization & Empowerment of government departments within one organization: Private sector culture
Complete
financial and administrative authority
HR: representatives & experts from within Pakistan as well as expatriates
Solid
Business plan, compensation linked to KPI’s
Reduce
duplication of efforts & better utilization of public money
Excellence
Large
in execution & better utilization of public money
Scale Farming & JV’s with foreign companies:
Sell
Govt structure: function
specific.
Product based project
management: cross functional
teams.
the benefits:
Large local market, greater consumer propensity to spend
Regional markets of Gulf, Central Asia and Asia: Reduced freight costs: Better margins and lower consumer price: Growth in
market size.
Tax breaks and other benefits
MNC seed and pesticide companies inclusion
Legislation:
Seed Act & Nursery reforms
International buyers protection against fraud: Criminal cases
Legislation for enforcement of business contracts: e.g. farmers & exporters: criminal
Compulsory Pre-shipment inspections for all export consignments by 3rd parties.
Production Technology
cases.
& R&D:
Drip Irrigation: 90% government subsidy for export based farming. Essential for supermarket quality.
Hybrid seeds & customized agronomy: Development of product engineers.
CA and Reefer experimentation facilities at UAF for global freight solutions
Government to underwrite losses of private sector for pioneering projects, of new product and new market development.
20 to 40% R&D subsidy for new projects on CNF value for limited time, till technical issues resolved.
New certified mango orchards, with drip irrigation and precision agriculture. Recovery of young mango orchards.
Sponsor project based transfer of technology and foreign learning.
© METRO AG 2006
Policy Issues & Way forward
13
Proposals by Engro:
Information system for individual farmer profiles:
Details of farming activities, land, usual crops, revenues and loans status.
Form as a basis for unsecured loans by Banks
Develop reliable crop reporting system (GIS) based:
Govt structure: function
specific.
Product
based project
Project to replace primitive crop reporting system
management: cross functional
Form basis for reliable information for planning crop commodity imports, exports, storage, distribution teams.
Develop Standardization laws and verification and certification agency for exports:
With collaboration of USAID & Foreign Agriculture Service (FAS) of USDA
Agency to have accredited & well equipped labs and equipment
Develop
Interest
free lending for corporate farms:
Loan channelizing by USAID through commercial banks.
90%
Corporate
interest free USAID funding & 10% funding with interest.
Meat farm by Engro: Exports to Middle East.
Channelizing
Export
single new non governmental organization with public/ private sector representation
of funds through USAID to Basmati Rice farmers, with Engro guaranteeing Buy-back.
oriented floriculture farms in Sind
© METRO AG 2006
Export Opportunities
14
Immediate:
Kinnows:
China, Latin America
Mangoes:
Sea freight
Floriculture:
Freight solution for exports
Potatoes:
Better varieties,Value addition &
shelf life extension
Value
Halal
added products
Pulps & Nectars
Packaged vegetables: Kenya
example
Convenience packaging: ready
to eat meals
meat exports to Middle East, Europe
& Asia.
Basmati
Rice: Product & Brand
development for direct Super Market exports.
Dairy
Contractual farming & Buy back to ensure
BRC standards.
exports: Specialty Cheeses & Milk
based products
Medium
to long term:
Organics & Fair trade: Labor intensive, inline with developing countries agricultural
practices, hot climates, absorption of air
freight, plenty of virgin land availability
Retailers
Sea
Own Brand Development
Food exports
Tap
growth of Asian Cuisine and target
Food Services channels
Hybrid
Vegetables: Middle East, Central
Asian & South East Asian market.
New
products:
Melons
Water Melons
Grapes
Lychees (Madagascar: 23000 tons
Baby corn
Pumpkins
Peas
Sweetcorn
Guava Juices
We need to upgrade
from Commodity
trading to
Product/ Brand
development:
increase margins
by moving up the
value chain
© METRO AG 2006
15
All stake holders need to act UNITED and play their respective roles in a
FOCUSED AND SYNERGISED effort to:
Make
By
To
up for lost time
making 360 degree efforts on a war footing
develop world class products & services in next 3-5 years
to capitalize on the emerging global trade opportunities
Metro’s support to act as a catalyst will always be there.
THANK YOU
© METRO AG 2006
16
Back up slides
© METRO AG 2006
17
Developing countries F&V exports to E.U
35 % of E.U market
7 billion Euros exports
Top importing countries: U.K, France, Germany, Holland, Begium, Italy.
Fruits
Country
Vegetables
% of total E.U imports
South Africa
14
Costa Rica
12
Ecuador
10
Colombia
Chile
Country
% of total E.U imports
Morocco
32
Kenya
15
8
Turkey
11
8
Egypt
6
Peru
5
Thailand
4
© METRO AG 2006
18
Steps to Mango Exports
Fruit development
•
•
•
Identification of
disease free
orchards
Customized
agronomy for
each farm
Develop strong
fruit
for sea exports
Farmers + Metro
Harvest
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Reception
Selection
HWT
Drying
Waxing
Grading
Packing
Pre-cooling
Cooling
Farmers + Third party
Post shipment
handling
Shipment
& Packing
•
•
•
Loading
Temperature
and CA
settings
Transit
conditions
monitoring
Metro + Maersk
•
•
Developing
special Mango
ripening
chambers
across E.U.
Special
equipment in
Metro stores for
Mangoes
Metro
© METRO AG 2006
19
Short term & Long Term volumes
Containers /
wk
Volume /
season
Required Land
(Acres)
(Tons)
2009
5
1320
440
2010
10
2640
880
2011 onwards
20
5280
2000
© METRO AG 2006
20
Tentative Cost of Project
Cost Head
Building
Processing plant
Cost (million Rs)
Capacity
7-10
4-10 million
5 tons/ hour
Forced air cooling
8 million
44 tons
Cold Store
8 million
88 tons
Working Capital
10 million
Total Minimum
37 million
Total Maximum
46 million
4 containers/ day
© METRO AG 2006
21
Benefits of Metro
• Above
average buying price for Mangoes.
•Guaranteed
•No
middle men = better profits
•Long
•
buy back
term profitable, reliable business partner.
State of the art, transfer of technology.
•Global
supply chain excellence.
•Massive
reach and depth in 31 countries.
** Metro provides a comprehensive farm development, supply chain and
marketing solution.
© METRO AG 2006
22
Mango VISION
Pakistan Mangoes: Oil/ Gold of the future
Build exotic, premium positioning for Pakistan Mangoes = High vaue/kg
Build before India.
© METRO AG 2006
23
FOUR MAIN EXPORT DESTINATIONS VOLUME AND VALUE FOR PAKISTAN MANGOES
No.
1
2
3
4
Country
United Arabic Emirates
Arabia Saudi
Oman
Export (Mt)
33,604
13,224
9,245
Value us$000
9,395
4,810
2,098
Value usd/KG
0.28
0.36
0.23
8,052
2,834
0.35
77468
23426
0.30
UK
TOTAL PAKISTAN EXPORTS
RETURNS PER KG MAJOR EXPORTS NATIONS
PRICES PER KG FOR PAK MANGOES IN
EUROPE
Country
Value usd/KG
Belgium
0.48
Sweden
0.47
Norway
0.45
Germany
0.43
Italy
0.40
Switzerland
0.37
Denmark
0.37
Country
Value usd/KG
Australia
1.79
Philipines
1.59
China
0.91
South Africa
0.79
Peru
0.75
Brazil
0.55
Mexico
0.54
India
0.48
Thailand
0.46
Pakistan
0.30
FRUTOPIA GROUP
© METRO AG 2006
24
FOUR MAIN EXPORT DESTINATIONS VOLUME AND VALUE FOR PAKISTAN MANGOES
No.
1
2
3
4
Country
United Arabic Emirates
Arabia Saudi
Oman
Export (Mt)
33,604
13,224
9,245
Value us$000
9,395
4,810
2,098
Value usd/KG
0.28
0.36
0.23
8,052
2,834
0.35
77468
23426
0.30
UK
TOTAL PAKISTAN EXPORTS
RETURNS PER KG MAJOR EXPORTS NATIONS
PRICES PER KG FOR PAK MANGOES IN
EUROPE
Country
Value usd/KG
Belgium
0.48
Sweden
0.47
Norway
0.45
Germany
0.43
Italy
0.40
Switzerland
0.37
Denmark
0.37
Country
Value usd/KG
Australia
1.79
Philipines
1.59
China
0.91
South Africa
0.79
Peru
0.75
Brazil
0.55
Mexico
0.54
India
0.48
Thailand
0.46
Pakistan
0.30
FRUTOPIA GROUP
© METRO AG 2006