Transcript View slides
CMOs and Implementation Science Researchers: A productive partnership for clinical improvement
Sponsored by CMOG and ROCC Andreas Theodorou, M.D.
Russell Howerton, M.D.
Laura Peterson, M.D.
Hosted by Alexander Ommaya, D.Sc. and David Longnecker, M.D.
Guest Speakers
• Russell Howerton, M.D.,F.A.C.S., CMO of Wake Forest University Medical Center • Andreas Theodorou, M.D., CMO of the University of Arizona Medical Center • Laura A. Petersen, M.D., M.P.H., F.A.C.P., Associate Chief of Staff for Research, Houston VA Medical Center, Director VA HSR&D Center of Excellence, and Professor of Department of Medicine, Baylor College of Medicine
Q& A Communication
During the presentation, your telephone line will be muted To submit questions for the speakers, please use the chat box on the lower right side of your screen
Agenda
12:30 Introduction 1:00 David Longnecker, MD Alexander Ommaya, D.Sc.
12:35 Russell Howerton, MD 12:45 Questions 12:50 Andy Theodorou, MD Questions 1:05 Laura Petersen, MD, MPH 1:15 1:20 1:30 Questions Next Steps Adjourn
AAMC Implementation Science/CMO Webinar
Monday March 25 th , 2013
Observation Unit Stress Imaging to Manage Patients with Intermediate to High Risk Acute Chest Pain
Objective
To reorganize existing resources to deliver care in a way that reduces hospital readmissions among patients with intermediate to high-risk chest pain.
Wake Forest Baptist Health
Vashi et al. JAMA 2013
Study of 5 million hospital admissions Chest pain discharges at 30
days:
12% had treat and release ED visit 10% had hospital readmission Wake Forest Baptist Health PCI-related discharges at 30
days:
7% had treat and release ED visit 13% had hospital readmission
A possible solution: Observation Unit – Stress Imaging Care Pathway
• Highly efficient units driven by care algorithms, staffed by midlevel providers − Efficient and cost effective in low risk patients
ACC/AHA:
Class I recommendation endorses OU care
Institute of Medicine:
“…clinical decision units reduce boarding and diversion, avoid expensive hospitalization, and appear to contribute to improved management ...” ACC / AHA NSTE ACS guidelines: Anderson et al. Circulation 2007; Wake Forest Baptist Health
Higher risk = high complexity
High risk
•
Higher complexity = higher readmission rate
25-40% with pre-existing CAD (1-3) • Perceived complexity inhibits development of care algorithms
Is OU care an alternative to inpatient care?
• Cost?
• Event rates after discharge?
• Readmission rates?
Intermediate risk Lower complexity:
• Care easily integrated into care algorithm
Low risk Very low risk
1.
Tatum et al. Ann Emerg Med, 1997 2.
Stowers et al. Ann Emerg Med 2000 3.
Gomberg-Maitland et al. AHJ 2005 • • •
Proven efficacy of OU care:
Low event rates High patient satisfaction Widely adopted
Methods
• Design for 2 RCTs conducted at Wake Forest
Patients at intermediate to high-probability for ACS ED eval Randomize Inpatient care
Care per individual providers
Observation unit
Serial biomarkers Stress imaging
Follow up through 1 year
Wake Forest Baptist Health
Cost of OU care versus Inpatient care
(Miller et al. Ann Emerg Med 2010) (Miller et al. JACC:Imaging 2011) Analyses based on intent to treat Wake Forest Baptist Health
Trial 2 Primary outcome: Composite Readmit, Revasc, Recurrent testing
Inpatient
38% vs 13%, P=0.004
OU Care Composite Revascularization Hospital readmission Recurrent cardiac testing Wake Forest Baptist Health
OU Care Inpatient
7 (13%) 20 (38%)
P
1 ( 2%) 4 ( 8%) 2 ( 4%) 8 (15%) 12 (23%) 9 (17%) .004
.031
.033
.028
90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
Combined events, Trials 1 and 2
8% 82% 13,5% 28,2% 2,9% 10,9% OU Inpatient Index visit admissions Cardiac hospital readmissions Revascularizations
Observation Unit Inpatient
Adverse Events Death MI (after randomization) Wake Forest Baptist Health 1/104 (1.0%) 6/104 (5.8%) 0/110 (0%) 5/110 (4.6%)
Summary
• OU care with perfusion imaging at Wake Forest: − reduces cost, readmissions, and revascularization procedures • Death and MI − Very low rates with either strategy • Leverages and reorganizes existing resources to achieve these benefits Wake Forest Baptist Health
Future directions and opportunities
• Implementation: − Can benefits observed in single center trials be achieved in a multi-center setting?
• Implementation study with outcome surveillance − Are results dependent on using cardiac MRI as the imaging modality?
• How can we remove barriers so we can organize EMRs to automate data capture and outcome surveillance across medical centers?
Wake Forest Baptist Health
Musculoskeletal Emergency Center
• Development of an integrated practice unit (IPU).
• Replace physician-centric processes with patient-centric ones • Decrease the distance between patient and final decision-maker.
• Prospective database to monitor clinical outcomes.
•
“Maximize Value. Optimize Education.”
Wake Forest Baptist Health
Areas for Multicenter Collaboration
• Develop evidence-based clinical practice guidelines • Develop competencies and standardized education for the new field of
Musculoskeletal Emergency Medicine
• Enhance understanding of operational efficiency and time driven activity based costing • Multicenter prospective database • Create
best practices
in this field Wake Forest Baptist Health
Questions?
3
Healthy Together Care Partnership
Healthcare Dream – Implementation Nightmare
Andreas A. Theodorou, MD, FAAP, FCCM Chief Medical Officer University of Arizona Medical Center Professor and Associate Chair, Pediatrics 20
UAHN – Quick Overview:
Includes two hospital campuses -The University of Arizona Medical Center (University Campus, including Diamond Children’s) & (South Campus) 40 clinics, a health plan division and practice plan for physicians from the University of Arizona College of Medicine Only Level 1 Trauma Center in Southern Arizona – (University Campus) Comprehensive Transplant Program(University Campus) NCI Designation
University & South Campus Patient Statistics 2012-13: Admissions Emergency Visits Total Net Revenue University Campus & South Campus
20,489 74,632 533193
Patient beds 592
21
COMMON CMO PRIORITY ISSUES
• • • Hospital/Healthcare-associated Infections • Core Measures • Procedural Complications • Falls • Patient Satisfaction • • • Access to Care • Patient Through-Put
Safe Medication Use Readmission Rates Hospitalization Avoidance Continuity of Care Dual-Eligible
The Healthy Together Care Model
• Focuses on approximately
345 dual eligible Special Needs Plan
members within our University of Arizona Health Network • Designed to improve quality of care for this high risk/high cost population living in the home and community 23
HEALTHY TOGETHER POPULATION
UAHN Health Plans Dual Eligibles in Pima County (n≈4,000) UAHN Health Plan Duals in Pima County assigned to UAHN primary care provider (n=345) All UAHN Health Plan Duals (n≈9,000) • Early data indicate that sub-population health risk and cost profile is representative of all UAHN Health Plans dual-eligible SNP population and the national dual-eligible population
n=345
COST OF CARE 5% 15% 30% 48% 50% 37% 14% 1% Within our sub-population, the costliest 5% of enrollees account for 48% of total cost of care, while the costliest 20% account for 85% of total cost*
•Based on retrospective chart review and analysis of 307 dual eligibles with UAHN Health Plan coverage and assigned to primary care with a UA Health Network provider (Goel, et al, 2011)
THE CARE MODEL USES MULTIPLE EVIDENCE SUPPORTED STRATEGIES
• Interprofessional team-based care • “Home-based Primary Care” for ~ 45 most complex and homebound (with telehealth) • Case management and telehealth for rest of cohort, in collaboration with primary care providers • Medication Reconciliation • Integrated behavioral health/physical health care management • Patient Engagement and Shared Decision Making 26
HEALTHY TOGETHER CARE PARTNERSHIP
– Delivery System/Health Plan Partnership designed to reduce utilization in a high risk/high utilizing population – Targeted utilization reduction in population • Decreased ED Utilization • Decreased Cost of Admissions • Decreased Readmission Rate • Decreased Med Cost by Pharmacy Review –
Net savings if targets achieved: $1.5 Million
Good News
• Primary goals of the program include
cost savings, improved quality and satisfaction with care, blended physical and behavioral health, development of individualized strategies to manage at-risk patients, and development of best practices
for dual eligible patients in SNP community care settings.
•
Bad News 18 months later the project had still not started!
–
Overcoming Academic Medical Center Inertia: Building an Innovative Dual Eligible Service Line Great News!
• Project now fully launched and
first 4 patients enrolled last week!
28
REASONS FOR DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION
• Organizational Complexity • Clinical Cost Structures • Training Expectations • Credentialing and Privileging of NPs • Employment/supervision of NPs, SWs and RNs • Who Provides Space and Infrastructure • Non-integrated Information System • Coding and Compliance Issues
LONG TERM PLANS
• Eventual development of a stand-alone product that would
provide coverage to the entire population of dual-eligible SNP patients
resulting in reduced costs and better outcomes (e.g., lower hospitalization rates, better medication compliance, improved morbidity and mortality) -Year 1: Dual-eligible patients in UAHN care (n=345), starting with highest-cost stratum, and rolling additional services out to remaining patients in lower-cost stratum.
-Year 2: Expand to include SNP patients in Pima County -Year 3: Expand to include remainder of SNP • Savings realized through better care of high-cost stratum would be the
basis of funding novel programs
for the entire SNP population Current state Healthy Together Pilot Stand-alone product for all UAHN SNP patients 30
HEALTHY TOGETHER DEVELOPMENT TEAM
• Jane Mohler, NP-C, MPH, PhD 1,2 ; • Nancy Wexler, MPH 1 ; • Richard Slaughter 3 ; • James Stover 3 ; • Patricia Harrison-Monroe, PhD 1 ; • Tom Ball, MD 1,2 ; • Mindy Fain, MD 1,2 • UA, College of Medicine 1 ; Arizona Center on Aging 2 ; UA Health Network, Health Plans 3 31
Questions?
CMOs and Implementation Science Researchers: A Productive Partnership for Clinical Improvement
Laura A. Petersen, MD, MPH, FACP Professor of Medicine and Chief, Section of Health Services Research, Baylor College of Medicine Director, Houston VA HSR&D Center of Excellence, Associate Chief of Staff for Research, Michael E. DeBakey VA Medical Center March 25, 2013 Petersen AAMC Webinar
Iraq, March 2003 – Embedded journalist Chip Reid, right, travels through southern Iraq with soldiers from the 3rd Battalion, 5th Marine Regiment.
Petersen AAMC Webinar
• •
Partnerships Between Researchers and the VA Health Care System
Partners include national program offices, regional CMOs and facility leadership, clinical leaders and managers, and individual clinicians Increase impact of research on Veteran health by: – Ensuring appropriate input into research priorities from a variety of VA stakeholders – Encouraging ongoing communication between research and operations – Enabling more timely response from the research community to emerging health system issues – Facilitating effective communication of research results and uptake of research into practice (implementation) Petersen AAMC Webinar
Translation/Implementation Highways
From:
Practice-Based Research —“Blue Highways” on the NIH Roadmap
JAMA. 2007;297(4):403-406. doi:10.1001/jama.297.4.403
Petersen AAMC Webinar
Hold for cartoon
Problems with Linear Translation
• T1 T2 – 17 years from basic discovery to clear evidence from clinical trials Contopoulos-Ioannidis et al. Science 321:1298-99 • T2 T3 – 10 years for widespread guideline implementation • Linear approach to translation creates excessive lag in evidence implementation
Models for Linking Research to Action
P ro d P u c u e rv rs e y o R o e r rs s e o a f rc h U s e R e rs s O e n a e G rc h ro
Model A- Push efforts by producers or purveyors
P ro d u c e rs
(e x:
o o f
H
r R P
o
e u
u
s
st
rv e a
o
e
n
y rc
H
o h rs
S R & D C o E ) (e x:
R
V
e s
IS
e
N
a O rc
1
n
2
e h
)
G U s ro e u rs p o f
Petersen AAMC Webinar Model C- Exchange efforts
u p o f P ro d u P c u e rv rs e y o R o e r rs s e o a f rc h U s e R e rs O s e n a e G rc h ro u p o f
Model B- User pull efforts
P ro d P u u c e rv rs e y o R o e r rs s
(e
e o a
x:
f rc
H H
h
o S u R st & o D n C o E )
P ro je
(e
cts
x:
R
1
Knowledge
V
e
&
s
IS
e
3
N
a rc
1 2
h
)
U s e rs Translation Platforms
(ex: AFHIL & VINCI)
Projects 2 & 4
Model C- Exchange efforts Adapted from Lavis et al, 2006
Technical Problems vs. Adaptive Challenges (from Ronald Heifetz and Marty Linsky, “Leadership on the Line”)
“The single biggest failure of leadership is to treat adaptive challenges like technical problems”
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Technical Problems
Easy to identify Often lend themselves to quick and easy (cut-and-dried) solutions Often can be solved by an authority or expert Require change in just one or a few places; often contained within organizational boundaries People are generally receptive to technical solutions Solutions can often be implemented quickly-even by edict 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Adaptive Challenges
Difficult to identify (easy to deny) Require changes in values, beliefs, roles, relationships, & approaches to work People with the problem do the work of solving it Require change in numerous places; usually cross organizational boundaries People often resist even acknowledging adaptive challenges “Solutions” require experiments and new discoveries; they can take a long time to implement and cannot be implemented by edict Petersen AAMC Webinar
Examples from Health Care
1.
2.
3.
4.
Technical Problems
Implement electronic ordering and dispensing of medications in hospitals to reduce errors and drug interactions Improve availability of hand sanitizer Create workflow and structure to deal with low risk chest pain patients in the ED What are the appropriate peer facilities for quality and efficiency comparisons (Partnership project) 1.
2.
3.
4.
Adaptive Challenges
Encourage nurses and pharmacists to question and even challenge illegible or incorrect prescriptions by physicians Get health care providers to improve hand washing rates Change primary care team roles to adopt a patient centered medical home model (Partnership project) Design and test new model of provider payment to reward quality (Partnership project) Petersen AAMC Webinar
Researchers Can Help with Evidence to Overcome Both Technical and Adaptive Challenges • What are the social, cognitive, workflow barriers to handwashing?
Petersen AAMC Webinar
Examples of Partnership Projects at the Houston Health Services Research and Development Center of Excellence • Longitudinal measures of quality (Petersen and Woodard, PIs) – 10 publications (Circulation, Medical Care, JAGS, HSR, Diabetes Care) • Resource efficiency (Petersen, PI) – 7 publications (HSR, Medical Care) • Hospital and community living center peer facilities (Petersen, PI) – 2 publications (HSR, American Journal of Managed Care) • • Evaluation of primary care re-design (Hysong, PI) RCT of pay for performance (Petersen, PI) – 3 publications Petersen AAMC Webinar
• •
Understanding Differences
Network Needs: – Value fast turnaround, practical projects rather than publications – – – (implementation/external validity) HSR&D cheaper, more knowledgeable than external consultants “It doesn’t really have to be perfect” Rapidly changing needs, priorities Research Needs: – Academic products – – Internal validity focus Slower pace (IRB, funding cycles, data use agreements, HR, – credentialing, contracting) Business model Credentialing Contracting VA Research HR Petersen AAMC Webinar
Challenges to Partnerships
• • Regulations! – Data Use Agreements – Research training for non-researchers Business model Petersen AAMC Webinar
Advantages of Partnership
• • •
For Researchers
Aligning research with specific health system partners to increase the impact on VHA Accelerating the timetable for research in areas critical to the health system Focus upon implementation early in the research process Petersen AAMC Webinar • • •
For Partners
Embedded researchers are cheaper and more knowledgeable about the delivery system May have access to data that other consultants don’t have Diverse skill set to tackle problems
Building and Maintaining Partnership
• • • • • Need champions within partnering organization Some face to face meetings, especially early on Continued mutual recognition of needs of partnering organization Continued attention to sustainability Appreciation of differences Petersen AAMC Webinar
Partnership Research is a Team Sport
• • • Doing partnership work requires an excellent team Ability to respond to questions and requests Relationships, relationships, relationships!
Petersen AAMC Webinar
Petersen AAMC Webinar