Presentation no.6
Download
Report
Transcript Presentation no.6
2010
Benchmarking klastrów
w Polsce - 2010
Clusters in Germany:
Experience, Development,
Financing and Support Policy
Gerd Meier zu Köcker
Benchmarking jako instrument poprawy jakości zarządzania
Warszawa, 14 października 2010
Clusters in Germany:
- Experience, Development, Financing and Support Policy Gerd Meier zu Köcker,
Director General
Agency Competence Networks Germany
Warsaw, October 14th, 2010
Areas of Cluster Policy Intervention
Framework
conditions
Cluster actors
Cluster organisation
page 3
Survey of Cluster Support Initiatives in Germany
Förderung regionaler
Netzwerke
Mecklenburg-Vorpommern
Federal State
Level
Förderprogramm
für Kooperationsnetzwerke
Hessen
1993
Innovationsstrategie
Saarland
1995
1999
BioRegioWettbewerb
2000
2001
Lernende Regionen
Kompetenznetze.de
InnoRegio
Federal Level
Regionaler
Clusterwettbewerb
Baden-Württemberg
Innovationsstrategie
Berlin
Clusterpolitik
Cluster Offensive
SchleswigHessischer
Bayern
ClusterHolstein
Clusterwettbewerb
Orientierung der
Clusterprozess
Hessen
Regionalpolitik in
Mitteldeutschland
RegioCluster.
Brandenburg
NRW
2002
NEMO
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
ZIMSpitzenNEMO
clusterWettbewerb
GA-Förderung
für Cluster Strategische
Partnerschaften
InnoProfile
BioPharmaWettbewerb
BioIndustrie2021
page 4
The Initiative
• is run under the patronage of the Federal
Ministry of Economics and Technology (BMWi)
• gathers and supports the best 102 regional
networks / clusters in Germany
• can be considered as ”Club of the Best
Innovation Networks” in Germany
• provides tailor-made support for its members
• aims to further strengthen its member
clusters
• has ambitious selection criteria in force
page 5
Some Success Factors for Sustainable
Cluster Development
Cluster emergence
Sustainable financing
Cluster management skills
Spectrum and quality of tailor-made services
provided by the cluster management
Added-values provided by the cluster management
Sustainable cluster strategy
page 6
Success Factor I: Cluster Emergence
Bottom-up network
decentralized governance, industrial driven
cluster manager mostly appointed by the cluster
mainly privately financed
political influence: low
Top down network, externally initiated
centralised, externally governed
network coordinator mostly nominated by the initiator
political influence: high, mostly initiated by
governments on regional or national level or business
development agencies
Top down network, internally initiated
centralised, internally governance
lead organisation acts mostly as network coordinator,
also emerged and dominates the network
political influence: varying
page 7
Cluster Performance vs. Type of Cluster Emergence
Data source: Member clusters
of Competence Networks Germany, 2008
page 8
Success Factor II: Sustainable Financing
Source of financing of cluster organisations
35
30
25
20
when emerged
in 2009
15
10
5
0
EC-based
funding [%]
Federalbased
funding [%]
Data source: Member clusters
of Competence Networks Germany, 2009
Regionalbased
funding [%]
Other public
funding
sources [%]
Fee-based
funding [%]
Fee-based Other private
services [%]
funding
sources [%]
page 9
Success Factor II: Sustainable Financing
Development of private and public financing shares over time
1
Share of public funding
Share of private financing
0,9
0,8
Percentage [%]
0,7
0,6
0,5
0,4
0,3
0,2
Data source: Member clusters
of Competence Networks Germany, 2009
0,1
0
when emerged
2007
Time
2009
page 10
Success Factor II: Sustainable Financing
Distribution of shares of private financing of cluster organisations
40
Percentage of cluster [%]
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
< 20 %
21 - 40 %
41 - 60 %
61 - 80 %
> 80 %
Share of private financing of cluster organisations in 2009
Data source: Member clusters
of Competence Networks Germany, 2009
page 11
Success Factor II: Sustainable Financing
Cluster organisations tend to perform better when sustainably financed
Data source: Member clusters
of Competence Networks Germany, 2009
page 12
Success Factor III: Cluster Manager Skills
Sustainable financing vs. cluster management skills
Data source: 75 out of 110 member clusters
of Competence Networks Germany
page 13
Indicators for Sustainable Cluster Development
Size of cluster compared to the regional potential
Dedicated legal constitution
Traceable improvement of competitiveness of the cluster firms
High share of active members
High commitment of key actors
Added values and additionality provided by cluster management
Sustainable financing of cluster organisation
High share of private financing
Professional cluster management
Stability of the cluster development
Visibility and reputation
High commitment of local actors from industry,
science and policy
page 14
Current Hot Topics in Cluster Matters
Sustainable financing
Cluster management excellence
Benchmarking of cluster organisation
Peer assessments
Cluster managements as innovation service
providers for cluster firms
New innovative services
Contribution to sustainable financing
New approaches for internationalization
Branding of cluster regions
page 15
Benchmarking of Cluster Organisations
Benchmarking of Cluster Organisations
Based 60 indicators and 7 sub-dimensions
Focus on cluster organisations, but also cluster
related indicators are regarded
Voluntary moderated self-assessment
No raking or rating
Reasonable efforts
High flexibility in terms of comparative
portfolio and indicators to be applied
Findings can easily demonstrated to
interested parties
http://www.clusterobservatory.eu/library/100183.pdf
page 16
A Look Forward: Clusters in 2013
What are the most significant challenges / objectives related to clusters in 2013 ?
50%
Policy makers
Cluster managers
45%
Cluster actors
40%
Percentage [%]
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Sustainable Financing
Internationalisation
Joint product / technology
development
Training / education
Improve^ment of cooperation among cluster
actors
page 17
A Look Forward: Clusters in 2013
It is expected that the number of clusters in Germany in 2013 will
Policy makers
Cluster managers
90%
Cluster actors
Percentage [%]
75%
60%
45%
30%
15%
0%
strongly increase
slightly increase
remain the same
slightly be reduced
strongly be reduced
page 18
A Look Forward: Clusters in 2013
Do we need cluster organisations / cluster managements in 10 years time ?
100%
Policy makers
Cluster managers
Cluster actors
Percentage [%]
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Yes
No
page 19
Cluster Funding 2015 – Trends in Germany
Focussing on existing clusters rather than to create new ones
From institutional cluster funding towards project-based financing of
cluster management services
Funding of introducing new services for cluster management
Significant reduction of funding rates
Public authorities only pay for services that are provided for public interest
Entrepreneurship, regional marketing, education, etc.
Intended for matured clusters
No funding of cluster management at all
Supporting of introducing new services
Creating better synergies between existing instruments
On regional, national and European Commission level
Using clusters to increase additionality of other innovation support programmes
page 20
The Way Forward Towards Harmonised Cluster
Management Excellence Approaches
The Nordic-German-Polish Cluster Excellence
About 150 cluster organisations will be voluntarily benchmarked
Initiated by
Most participating cluster organisations are
already labelled according to national priorities
Leading National Programme Owners build the consortium
Denmark, Finland, Germany, Iceland, Norway, Poland
and Sweden)
Purpose:
Promote cluster management excellence within Europe
Promote mutual learning by comparing cluster organisations
Testbed for harmonised and internationally recognised
Benchmarking criteria
Application of indicators developed within EC-projekt
European Cluster Excellence Initiative
page 21
Thank you very much for your attention !
Agency Competence Networks Germany
c/o VDI/VDE Innovation + Technik GmbH
Steinplatz 1
D-10623 Berlin
Germany
Tel.: +49 (0) 30 310078-118
Fax: +49 (0) 30 310078-222
E-Mail: [email protected]
www.iit-berlin.de/veroeffentlichungen
page 22
Benchmarking of Clustermanagements - Why?
Benchmarking of cluster managements reveals different advantages
compared to other approaches:
Comparison with others
reveals the current position compared to others / to the best
shows specific strengths and weaknesses
stimulates a process of continues improvement
motivates to learn from the best
provides findings which can be used in the practical work
gives policy makers valid information about the competitive position
of a cluster compared to others
Results of the benchmarking directly support the cluster management in the
effort of improving the value and efficiency of the cluster for its members and
stakeholders
page 23
Pattern of the 7 Sub-dimensions Compared to a „Perfect Cluster“
Cluster structure
100,00%
90,00%
80,00%
Share of maximal score
70,00%
Achievements and performance
60,00%
Financing
50,00%
40,00%
IKT Grenland
30,00%
20,00%
Clusters belonging to
same techn. domain
10,00%
0,00%
Internationalisation
Cluster typology and governance
Output of services
Diversity of services
page 24