Technology and Environment

Download Report

Transcript Technology and Environment

Chemical Technology and Sustainability
environmentally conscious design for chemical engineers
Objective: re-orient chemical engineering education to promote
the new paradigm of sustainability
Basis: a systemic approach (incorporated into existing courses),
with the appropriate scope (abstract ideas into definite problems)
- introduction:
concerns and aware attitudes
- problem analysis (sources, effects)
Fernando Gutiérrez
media, scale and life cycles
EUITI-QUIMICA INDUSTRIAL
TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY
(UPM)
MADRID - España
and
solutions (options, actions)
1- elimination and minimization
2- treatment technologies
- basics & examples
(linking theory w industrial practice)
Summary of new concepts and paradigms in environmental engineering
-
From pollution control and waste handling technologies after generation, to proactive
process integrated prevention (cleaner production, multimedia cross effects and reduction
approach at source, specially diffuse non-point-sources).
-
From consideration of the environmental aspects of the manufacturing process, to
considering also the entire life cycle of a product.
-
From a sole emphasis upon technological measures, to a broader scale perspective
which also encompasses non-tech measures
Environmental technology (BAT)
Cleaner technologies
(CP)
Sustainability
(S)
PC vs PP
x
.
.
x
.
x
SM vs MM
x
.
.
x
.
x
PE vs PU
.
.
x
.
x
x
TE vs
x
x
x
NT
.
.
x
Traditionally BAT are considered only pollution control (PC) technical (TE) measures (end-of-pipe technologies), that have generally
the inconvenients of shifting pollutants from one to another media (SM), and also aditional cost of production.
CP (cleaner production) can be viewed as a conceptual and procedural approach to industrial production (or process oriented, PE) with
the objective of the minimization or prevention (PP) of risks to humans and to the environment: primary emphasis ongoing to
systematic and integrated source reduction approach (MM), but oriented to production organizations.
The sustainability (S) paradigm, doesn´t omit consumption and production structures at the societal level (attitudinal and other non
technical, NT, and product oriented, PU, measures), within a broader policy concept approaching on the entire organization of society
that involves industrialists, government authorities, educators and citizens to ensure sustainable societies. Such an approach in relation
to water, air, or soil pollution should be focused upon both of the reduction of emissions from industrial point sources, and non point
sources, with a multimedia approach (MM).
Integrated pollution prevention and control
ATMOSPHERE
HYDROSPHERE
Pollution prevention in the CPI through clean process
design merged with the interpretation phase of the life
cycle assessment:
LCA tool + system modeling & optimization techniques
BIOSPHERE
elimination
source reduction
recycle
treatment
disposal
LITOSPHERE
Multimedia minimization tetrahedron
Minimization actions (except discharge)
OPTIONS
INTERNAL
EXTERNAL
PREVENTIVE
Source reduction & eco-design
[elimination, clean(er) product-ion/s,
fugitive emissions]
Selection, Recovery, Subproduct
exchange
Linear production model, pollution management, emission and immission limits
CORRECTIVE
Effluent control (end of pipe),
abatement technologies
Waste treatment, clean-up techs
(remediation of existing problems)

Environmental problems are systemic and thus require a `systems approach´,
at different levels, that provides a holistic view of the connections between
industrial practices and human activity, making them easier to identify and solve
(problem analysis: sources, effects; integrated problem solving: options and actions);
it can highlight the need for and advantages of achieving sustainability
 The primary goal is to promote sustainable development at the global,
regional and local levels, and key issues include the use of resources,
ecological and human health, and environmental equity
(both intergenerational and inter-societal)

Sustainable development is only achievable if :



There are radical changes in our attitudes, in our institutions, and the way we work and
interact
Present rates of population growth, which cannot be sustained by available resources, are
brought under control
A safe and sustainable production pathway, which still have not found, is put into effect
PRODUCTION AND CONSUMPTION (1)
Technology domain
WELFARE
STANDARD (wants) vs QUALITY (needs)
Economy domain (+ ?)
SUSTAINABILITY
(equilibrium)
Societal (1) Technical (2)
Physical environment,
antrophosphere and
sustainability
IMPACTS AND POLLUTION (2)
Ecology domain
(+ /-)
Problem analysis: sources and effects

Manufacturing industry is concerned with
processing materials and the laws of science
govern these operations;
two consequences follow from this:
raw materials and energy are needed to
effect transformations and waste is produced

The best that can be achieved is:
to minimize the use of resources and reduce
waste production;
and the first step in this attempting is to describe the
situation that currently exist because this is the basis
Getting
to know any
and understand
problem .
against
which
futurethe
improvement
will be judged





Identifying waste generation sources .
Characterizing and targeting problem waste streams .
Identifying waste reduction alternatives .
Implementing the action plan.

Production loads (discharge on the environment):
material (gases,liquids,solids), energy (heat,radiation,noise)
 Depletion
(resource consumption):
Raw materials (minerals, fossil fuels, renewables)
Perturbations (water, land use)
 Pollution
impacts:
Air, Water and Soil
(levels: urban, regional, global)
Products
Midpoints
Endpoint
inhalation
process
Raw materials Energy
discharges
air
water
soil
dermal
Human
population
ingestion
Environment
Scenery of impacts produced by the chemical industries (generalized)
Global flows of selected materials (million tons/yr)

Minerals





(1,2 t/capita)
Cement
890
Mica
280
Salt
190
Phosphate
120



Metals







(0,3 t/capita)
Steel
780
Aluminum
97
Cooper
8,5
Zinc
7,0
Lead
3,4
Nickel
0,8
Tin
0,2
Fossil fuels (1,6 t/capita)



Coal
Lignite
Oil
Gas
Water

Flow
3200
1200
2800
920
(8200 t/capita)
41.000.000
Water resources in Europe
1800
cubic metres per capita (1995)
1600
1400
1200
long time resources
total extraction
industry
water suply
agriculture
1000
800
600
400
200
0
North
South
Global impacts: the climate change
Products
Chemical
processes
Feedstock
Emissions:
CO2 CH4 N2O CFCs
Increases of
temperatures,
sea level
Human
mortality,
Ecosystem
adjustments
Environment
Energy
Greenhouse emissions (cause and effects chain)

GWPi =  iCidt /  CO2CCO2dt
Greenhouse gases and contributions to global warming
Gas
Source
Emission ant Conc. prind Conc. prst Rsd. time Ef.radiative
Fossil fuels,
CO2
deforestation
50-200 yrs
6000 Mt/yr
280 ppm
360 ppm
1
Anaerobiosis,
CH4
mining, gas
10 yrs
300 Mt/yr
800 ppb
1700 ppb
58
Agriculture,
N2O
Industry
5 Mt/yr
285 ppb
310 ppb 140-190 yrs
206
CFCs refrigerants,
solvent, aerosols
65-110 yrs
1 Mt/yr
0
0,7 ppb
4860
photochemicals
O3
transport & ind.
22 ppb hours-days
2000
Cont.global
50%
12-19%
4-6%
17-21%
8%
depletion of stratospheric ozone
Products
Chemical
processes
Feedstock
Emissions:
Depletion of
ozone layer,
radiation UV
CFCs, HCFCs
Energy
Human
mortality,
Damages to
ecosystems
Environment
Emissions destructive of ozone (cause and effects chain)
Cl + O3  ClO + O2
 ClO + O  Cl + O2
 O3 + O  2 O 2


ODPi = (O3)i / (O3)CFC11
• : f(persistence, Cl atoms, rate constants)
Air quality: trophospheric ozone
Products
Chemical
processes
Feedstock
Emissions:
NOx VOCs
Energy
Photochemical
reactions
Human and
ecological
damages by
ozone or other
oxidants
Environment
Photochemical smog formation (cause and effects chain)
NO2  h  NO + O  O2  O3  NO  NO2 + O2
 VOC + NO  NO2 + oxidation products

POCPi = MIRi/MIRROG
•
MIR: maximum incremental reactivity of organic gases
acid rain
Products
Chemical
processes
Feedstock
Emissions:
reactions of
acidification and
acid depositions
SO2 NOx
Energy
Human and
ecological
damages by H+
and heavy
metals
Environment
Acidification (cause and effects chain)

Xi + ···  i H+ + ···

APi = (i/Mi)/(SO2/MSO2)
Ecological risk assessment: from defining the sources to estimating effects
MEDIUM
Atmosphere
Urban
Regional
Global
photo-chemical and acidification
radiative effects
(CO,VOCs,NOx,SOx,NH3) (CO2,CH4,N2O, CFCs)
Hydrosphere wastewaters and eutrophication
Litosphere
landfills,
incineration
(solid wastes)
water resources, raw
(organics, ions NP) materials and energy
(consumption);
soil & groundwater toxics to air, water, soil
(diffuse pollution) (AH, pesticides, metals)
Impact scales and environmental compartments
ATMOSPHERE
HYDROSPHERE
BIOSPHERE
LITOSPHERE
Multimedia pollution tetrahedron
Environmental assessment of chemicals

Characterization of risks include information on discharges,
environmental fate, the human exposures and its biological
response:
Chemical risk = f ( hazard, exposure )
Products
Chemical
processes
Feedstock
Discharges:
HAPs, WWs, HWs
Energy
transport and
fate of pollutants
(immission)
Human and
ecological
toxicology:
dose and
response
Environment
Toxic releases (air emissions, water effluents, solid wastes) and chain of effects

Risk indexes can be expressed as the product of
inherent potentials (IP) and exposure (EP),
relative to one compound (r):
• Ii = (EP·IP)i /(EP·IP)r
I =  mi·Ii
Springs and inputs to the environment

The 1st step is to identify sources of potential contaminants,
and the 2nd is to inventory flows, concentrations and matrix
characteristics (gas, liquids, solids), by means of balances,
sampling or emission factors
Products
Chemical
processes
Discharges:
HAPs, WWs, HWs
FIRE
Feedstock
TANKS
Energy
Toxic releases (air, water, solids)
Process flow-sheet and design


In this stage we already know the basic equipment and flow streams, so we can
identify the potential sources:
 primary (stack vents, fugitive) or secondary emissions (service use, evaporation)
 aqueous effluents and solid wastes (all the outputs different to useful products)
Then, we evaluate discharges by direct measure, emission factors or modeling,
before characterizing their environmental impacts:
 Measures for existing processes: discharges are calculated by multiplying
concentrations, volumetric flows and densities of the streams
 Emission factors: databases for industrial sectors, combustion processes,
storage tanks and unit operations (www.epa.gov/ttn/chief/)




Emissions for unit operations and non point sources: E(g/h) = XVOC·EFm·M(kg/h)
Combustion: E(kg/year) = DE(energy/year)·EF(kg/volume)·HV-1(energy/volume)·Ef-1
Cleaning losses: can be estimated as a fraction residual of the product based in
recipient characteristics, properties of substances and washing operation.
Models for estimating discharges: many design programs include methods
for calculating output streams (some being pollutants), while there are also
specific procedures for non conventional discharges (tanks, ponds)
Table.- Factors for estimating emissions of process units and fugitives (averaged)
Process units:
Sources of vents
Fugitive emissions:
EFm (g/kg)
Source
Valves
Reactors
1,50
Distillers
0,70
Pumps
Absorbers
2,20
Compressors
Strippers
0,20
Relief valves
Decanters
0,02
Dryers
Refrigeration
towers
0,70
Connections
Open lines
Sampling
Oil separators
(open)
0,10
Factor (g/h·source)
Service
Gas hydrocarbon
Liquid light
Liquid heavy
Hydrogen
Liquid light
Liquid heavy
Gas hydrocarbon
Hydrogen
Gas hydrocarbon
Liquid
All
Organic
industries
5,97
4,03
0,23
19,9
8,62
228
104
7
1,83
1,7
15
Refineries
27
11
0,2
8,3
110
21
630
50
160
7
0,25
2
Gas
plants
20
(all)
63
(liquid)
204
(all)
188
(all)
1,1
22
14600 kg/h for 330000 bbl/day
E.g.- Estimate the fugitive emissions from a organic chemical plant with 1400 valves (168 in gas services),
3048 connectors, 27 pumps (liquid), 20 pressure relief valves, 20 sampling points, y 21 open lines; all fluid
of the process constituted practically by volatile compounds.
Equipment
valves (s. gas)
valves (s. liquid)
connections
pumps
relievers
samplers
open lines
Total
number
168
1232
3048
27
20
20
21
Emission factor (g/h)
5,97
4,03
1,83
19,9
104
15
1,7
Emissions
8,79 (6,9%)
43,5 (34,3%)
48,9 (38,8%)
4,71 (3,9%)
18,2 (14,4%)
2,63 (2,2%)
0.31 (0,3%)
127,0 t/year
case
study
CH
Storage
tank
Reactor
oxidation of cyclohexan to mixture alcohol/ketone
(for synthesis of adipic acid and nylon),
with a production of 100 million of pounds yearly
Boiler
Stripper
Scrubbers
AC
Storage
tank
Refining
D/C
1,64 t CH + 0,13 t NaOH = 1 t A + 0,38 t C
1)
Main sources of contamination and preliminary estimation of emissions:
Sources
Atmospheric contaminants
(g/kg) A/C
CH
SO2
EF
1,5
(50%)
Reactor
(100%)
0,2
Stripper
Decanter 0,02
1,6 g/kgP
0,7
Distiller
Scrubbers (NMHCs,COx,CH4)
Boiler (0,5 tfuel nº6, 0,8 kg/l, 1%S / tP)
0,5
0,25 g/kgP
Fugitive
0,15 g/kgP
Cargo
L(lb/103gal):12·SPM/T
Tank (2-3d 35x20ft, 80% filling)
white, Houston-TX
Total (g/kgP)
2
2)
SO3
NOx
PM
CO
(50%)
(0%)
Liquid
effluents
(organic)
0,8 g/kgP
8,4 g/kgP
19 g/l
0,69 g/l
8 g/l
1,5 g/l
7,6 kg/tP
0,3 kg/tP
3,2 kg/tP
0,6 kg/tP
34 g/kgP
200 g/kgP
0,25 g/kgP
0,5 g/kgP
10
46
Metrics of environmental impacts:
Material intensity: [(1,64+0,13) -1,38]/(1+0,38) = 0,28 kg/kg
Energy intensity: 7 kBTU/ lb of product
Water consumption: 30 gal/ lb of product
Contaminants: 0,3 kg/ kg of product
200

The impact values of the previous example are quite large, if compared
with other representative processes; thus there are high incentives for
improvement
Table.- Environmental indicators of some representative chemical processes
Product
Process
Acetic acid
Methanol
low pressure
Amonoxidation
of propene
Oxidation of
n-butane
Acrilonitrile
Maleic
anhydride
Sulphuric
acid
Pyrometallurgic
Sulphur
Int.material
lb/lb
Energy
kBTU/lb
Water
gal/lb
Toxics
lb/lb
Contaminants
lb/lb
Cont+CO2
lb/lb
0,062
1,82
1,24
0,00011
0
0,133
0,493
5,21
3,37
0,01514
0,00781
0,966
0,565
0,77
1,66
0
0
2,77
0,002
0,001
0,073
-0,87
0,57
0,70
-0,65
0,00195
-0,63
0,00195
-0,04
0,002
Table.- Emission factors for air contaminants in power stations (US-EPA, 1998)
Contaminant
Arsenic
Cadmium
Chromium
Lead
Mercury
Nickel
Coal combustion (g/t)
3
3
Fuel combustion (g/m )
Gas combustion (mg/m )
0,0158
0,0477
0,1013
0,181
0,0135
10,13
0,00369
0,00404
0,00176
0,00434
0,0115
0,0579
0,19
0,023
0,12
0,19
0,038
0,13
Table.- Elimination eficiencies in municipal waste water treatment works (WWT)
Compound
Volatilization
Biodegradation
Sedimentation
Efluent
Triclhoroetane
73%
13%
1%
12%
Toluene
38%
48%
1%
13%
Diclhorobencene
19%
46%
7%
28%
Naphtalene
7%
53%
7%
32%
Anthracene
47%
39%
14%
1%
Pyrene
14%
73%
12%
1%
Dibutyl-phtalate
27%
54%
19%
1%
Phenol
99%
1%
1%
1%
Table.- Percentage estimates of remaining substances in deposits after emptying
Method of
Viscosity and surface tension of the substances
Tipe of vessel
Aqueous
Surfactants Kerosenics
Oily
Viscous
discharge
Pumping
Dumping
Draining
Drum of steel
Plastic
Drum with cover
Open
Bottom in step
Cup of steel
Vitrified
2,29
3,28
0,403
0,034
0,019
0,034
0,033
3,06
NA
0,485
0,089
0,048
0,058
0,040
2,48
2,61
0,404
0,054
0,033
0,038
0,040
2,06
2,30
0,737
0,350
0,111
0,161
0,127
3
4
1
0,5
0,1
0,2
0,2
E.g.- Estimate the wastes of cleaning empty drums (steel, 200 l), in a industry that buys 20000 kg/year of
hydrazine (viscosity similar to water, and emptied with a pump to a process tank):
Losses as drum residues (year) : 20000·0,0229 = 458 kg
Fate and behavior of chemicals in the environment

The 3rd step is to estimate immission levels as pollutants
disperse from the source (distribution and persistence in
the media), and the 4th is the number of people exposed
to these doses (to compare with environmental standards
like: RFC,RFD, LC50,LD50, TLV,PEL,REL, SF,WOE,HV)

Human and ecological toxicity is a function of the dose-response,
the 1st term being dependent of the mode of discharge, transport,
environmental fate and assimilation mechanism (exposure), while
responses of the organisms depend on chemical structures and
action modes (toxicology)
Discharges:
HAPs, WWs, HWs
transport and
fate of pollutants
(immission)
Human and
ecological
toxicology:
dose and
response
Environment
Toxic releases (emissions, effluents, wastes): chain of effects
Exposures

The properties of distribution of substances between phases
(air, water, soil, biotic) and their persistence in environments
(aerial or aquatic reactions, metabolisms) permit to estimate
exposures: represent the amount in contact with humans and
are estimated from emissions with models of transport and fate;
the relation dose/exposure is called bioavailability.
Table.- Criteria for distributions and persistence
-1
Volatility
3
H(atm·m /mol)
Solubility
(S,ppm)
Sorption in soil
(lg Koc)
EPIWIN
Bioacumulation
(BCF)
Biodegradation
(%, time)
-3
very volatil (10 ), volatil (10 ), moderate
-5
-7
-7
(10 ), small (10 ) and non-voilatil (10 )
high (10000), soluble (1000), moderate
(100), low (0,1) and insoluble (0,1)
very strong (4,5), strong (3,5), moderate
(2,5), low (1,5) and negligible (1,5)
high potential (1000, lgKow4,3), moderate
(250, lgKow3,5) and low (250, lgKow3,5)
fast (60, 1 week), moderate (30, 28 day),
slow (30, 28 days), very slow (28 days)

Predicts the concentrations stationary of substances in the
air (1), water (2), soil (3) and sediments (4), from constant
emissions in a defined region:

the balance of contaminants depends on the input levels (Ei),
advections (GAiCBi, DAi), transfer between compartments (Dij),
and chemical transformation (DRi); figure summarizes model,
emissions, transport and reaction parameters; solution of the
equations is complex, but we can use spreadsheets:
www.trentu.ca/cemc/models/VBL3.html
Level III
E.g.- The bencene, ethanol and pentachlorophenol (PCP) are examples of contaminants with very diverse
properties (table), whose environmental fates in stationary state can be estimated with the Mackay model,
for the discharge of 1000 kg/h of each compound, in the three following scenery:
a) air emission, b) aqueous effluents, c) soil dumping
After introducing the environmental properties, the spreadsheet gives as result fugacities, concentrations,
and finally the quantities in each compartment (table). It could be pointed out:
1)
2)
the majority of contaminant would be found in the media where it has been discharged primarily
(with the exception of PCP emission, which has a low vapor pressure)
the quantities increase with the corresponding average lifetimes of each species
Input data:
Properties
Molecular weight
(g/mol)
Melting point
(ºC)
Dissociation constant (pKa)
3
Aqueous solubility
(g/m )
Vapor pressure
(Pa)
Cf. Octanol-water (log Kow)
Life average (h)
Air
Water
Soil
Sediment
Bencene
Ethanol
PCP
78,11
5,5
46,07
-115
266,34
174
4,74
14
-3
4,15·10
5,05
2
5,5·10
2
5,5·10
3
1,7·10
3
5,5·10
2
5
1,78·10
4
1,27·10
2,13
1,7·10
2
1,7·10
2
5,5·10
3
1,7·10
6,78"10
3
7,80·10
-0,31
5,5·10
5,5·10
5,5·10
2
1,7·10
Results:
Scenery
3
Total (10 kg)
Percentages (%)
Air
Water
Soil
Sediment
a
b
c
a
b
c
a
b
c
19,7
99,95
0,03
0,02
0,00
139
4,66
95,00
0,00
0,34
28,7
67,63
0,53
31,84
0,00
45,6
92,89
3,84
3,27
0,00
73,2
0,22
99,70
0,01
0,07
78,3
0,93
5,65
93,42
0,00
2070
0,25
2,55
97,09
0,11
458
0,00
96,19
0,03
3,78
2390
0,00
0,55
99,43
0,02
Inhalation exposures

The simplified dispersion models (gaussian) estimates concentrations,
downwind (u, m/s), from continuous point emission (Q, g/s) at a height
of totally reflecting soil (h, m): C(g/m3)= Q/yzu·exp[-½(h/z)2]
 Standard deviations can be calculated in function of of the distance,
atmospheric stability and local morphology: yz = a·xb
Area
Atmosphere
Neutral
Rural
Stable
Neutral
Urban
Stable

Distance
a
b
x 500 m
x 500 m
x2000 m
x2000 m
x 500 m
x 500 m
x 500 m
x 500 m
0,01082
0,04487
0,0049
0,01901
0,0224
0,394
0,008
0,34
1,78
1,56
1,66
1,46
2
1,54
2
1,37
E.g. : Effects of a ground level emission of hydrogen sulphide (25 g/s), on a
point 300 m downwind from the source, at day (u:4 m/s) and night conditions
(2,5 m/s), with air inhalation rate of 0,9 m3/h and hazard level RfC:42 mg/m3


Cd = 25000/(·0,01082·3001,78·4) = 7,17 mg/m3
Cn = 25000/(·0,0049·3001,66·2,5) = 50,2 mg/m3
Cd/RfC1 (exposure: 6,45 mg/h)
Cn/RfC1 (exposure: 45,2 mg/h)
Effects on the aquatic biota and dermal exposure

Toxic concentration from continuous effluents (g/s), sent to a sewerage
system (wwt) before being diluted in a free water stream (m3/s), can be
estimated by: SWC (ppm) = Effluent(g/s)·(1-wwt)/Flow(m3/s)

E.g.: Estimate the potential impact on fish (LC50:20 mg/l), resulting from an
effluent of 34 kg/day of toluene to a sewer (primary-secondary treatments),
that discharges into a river with a minimal historic volume of 2,38 m3/s
• SWC = (0,37 g/s)(0,13)/(2,38 m3/s) = 0,020 ppm (three order less than LC)

The doses adsorbed by human skin depend on the surface area (cm2),
permeability (cm/h), duration of event (h) and toxic concentration (mg/l).
The exposure is the result of the dose and frequency of events/year.

E.g.: Swimmer of medium size (1,94 m2), in river contaminated with 3 g/l
of trichloroethylene, during 15 days summer (0,5 h).
• DA = S·Kp·Ed·Wf = 0,5 g/event
Exposure: 7,5 g/year
lg Kp (cm/h) = -2,72 + 0,71·lgKow -0,0061·Mw = -1,8
lg Kow = 0,229 + ni·fi = 2,47
CCl2 = CHCl (Mw= 131,5)
=CH- , =C
-Cl (olefin)
n1 = 2 f1 = 0,3836
n2 = 3 f2 = 0,4923
Aquifers contamination

Underground transport depends on the environmental characteristics
and the chemical properties; the equation describes the distribution of
concentration with time, by the plume of contaminants originated from
instantaneous discharge (m) of non-reactive solutes in homogeneous
media: C(x,y,z,t)= m/[8(t)3/2(DxDyDz)½]·exp{-[(x-ut)2/4Dxt]-[y2/4Dyt]-[z2/4Dzt]}


The maximum concentration is in the plume centre (x=u·t, y=0, z=0),
where the exponential term is the unity; the zone containing 99,7% of
contaminant is an elipsoid of dimensions: di=(2Dit)1/2 (from the centre).
Hydrodynamic dispersivity combines convection and diffusion: D=u+D*
(=0,1m for porous soils, u: interstitial velocity, D*: molecular difusivity)
E.g.: The rupture of a deposit discharges 100 kg of aqueous arsenic over
saturated soil were the flow of water is 50 cm/day; the diffusion coefficient
of arsenic: 2·108 m2/s, and is not eliminated by precipitation or adsorption.
Estimate the location, size and concentration of the plume 90 days later of accident:
Location of the plume centre: (0,5 m/d)·(90 d) = 45 m from the deposit (in the flow direction)
-8
2
2
Dx = (0,1 m)·(0,5 m/d) + (2·10 m /s)(86400 s/d) = 0,0517 m /d
-8
2
2
Dy = Dz =
(2·10 m /s)(86400 s/d) = 0,00173 m /d
dx =
[2·0,0517·90]½ = 3,05 m (ahead and behind the centre)
dy = dz = [2·0,00173·90]½ = 0,56 m (above, below and each sides)
3/2
½
Maximun concentration: C= m/[8(t) (DxDyDz) ] = 6,68 kg/m
3
Potential hazards

We can distinguish the exposure routes (inhalation, ingestion)
and the health effects (genotoxic and non-carcinogen)

The curves dose-response (bioassays) show different threshold
and sensibilities of the exposed populations: percent of incidence
per mgcontaminant/kgbody·day
100Table.- Criteria for persistence, bioacumulation and distributions of ecotoxicity
high (10000), soluble (1000), moderate
(S,ppm) (100), low (0,1) and insoluble (0,1)
Sorption in soil
Very strong (4,5), strong (3,5), moderate
50
(lg Koc) (2,5), low (1,5) and negligible (1,5)
Biodegradation
fast (60, 1 sem), moderate (30, 28 d),
(%, tiempo) slow (30, 28 days), very slow (28 days)
-1
-3
very volatil (10 ), volatil (10 ), moderate
Volatility
3
-5
-7
-7
H(atm·m10/mol) (10 ), small (10 ) and non-voilatil (10 )
Bioacumulation
high potential (1000, lgKow4,3), moderate
(BCF)
(250,
lgKow3,5)
and low(%)
(250,
lgK(doses)
ow3,5)
Fig.Curves
of toxic
responses
vs log
Solubility
Nº of compounds
800
Organics neutral ----------Esters - - - - - - - - - - - - - Acids - . - . - . - . - . - . - . Amines --------------------Phenols - - - - - - - - - - - Aldehydes - . - . - . - . - . -.
600
400
Lg(1/LC50)=a·lgKOW-b
200
0
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
lg LC50 (fish, 96h)
5
6
7
8
for two agents with different relative values (TD10,TD50)


genotoxics don´t have safe thresholds; slope factors (SF) relates the
excess of deaths with the exposure: %= SF·(mg·kg-1day-1)
for non-carcinogens, chronic exposures are compared with the `safe´
dose or concentration (RfX): hazard quotients
Considerations during the initial stages for selecting a process

Including both economical (added values) and environmental criteria: ideally the indexes
are compounded values of the emissions and measures of persistence, bioaccumulation
and toxicity, by using ratios of importance (low, moderate, high)
E.g.- Consider the two alternative routes for synthesis of methyl metacrilate:
acetone-cianhydrin
(CH3)2CO + HCN + H2SO4 + CH3OH  CH3-(C=CH2)-COOCH3
isobutene-metacrolein-oxigen):
CH3-(C=CH2)-CH3 + O2 + CH3OH  CH3-(C=CH2)-COOCH3
Stoichiometry, approximate costs and environmental data of materials in the synthesis of metacrilate
i (kgrm/kgp) Pi (E/kg)
Route acetocianhydrin i·Pmp: 1,32
Compound
Acetone
Ac. cianhydric
Methanol
Acid sulphuric
Metacrilate
-0.68
-0,32
-0,37
-1,63
1,00
Route isobutilene
Isobutene
Methanol
Pentane
Acid sulphuric
Metacrilate
-1,12
-0,38
-0,03
-0,01
1,00
0,95
1,48
0,14
0,09
1,72
i·Pmp: 0,82
0,68
0,14
0,25
0,09
1,72
Persistence (average life)
Bio-accumulation
aerial and aquatic
(BCF)
Factor toxic global
TLV(ppm) Inhalation and ingestion
0,86
52 days
1 year
17 days
Weeks
Weeks
D-Weeks
3,2
3,2
3,2
7 hours
Weeks
2,3
750
10
200
2 (est)
100 (PEL)
16600
NA
1000
10
10000
10
0,01
2,5 hours
17 days
2,6 days
7 hours
Weeks
D-Weeks
D-Weeks
12,6
3,2
81
Weeks
2,3
200 (est)
200
600
2 (est)
100 (PEL)
NA
100
10
1
10
100
NA
10
NA
10000
10
NA
10
NA
1
10
Life averages and bioaccumulation values were calculated with software EPISuite based in SAR models
(www.epa.gov/oppt/exposure/docs/episuite.htm); compared with the classification criteria of table 1 (scale 0-3),
practically all compounds have index 1 (moderate-low).
For toxicity we use subrogates as TLV or combined responses to dose and ingestion (global indexes could
be the highest of both); in this example, the greatest hazards are due to sulphuric and cianhydric acids and
we can see a preference for the route of isobutene (also with less costs of the raw materials).
Environmental index:
 i/TLVi
or
 i·(factor inhalation/oral)max
Valuation of toxic risks

Valuation of risks include information on potential hazards,
the routes and magnitude of exposures, and the population
affected:
Chemical risk = f ( hazard, exposure )
Risk indexes are based in the concentration of contaminants
in air or water (Ci,c) after discharge of 1000 kg/h of substance
in the compartment (Mackay model)
 these are converted in doses by multiplying concentration and
assimilation rates (standard factors: u= 20 m3/d and 2 l/day, for
inhalation or ingestion), by body weight (p: 70 kg):

Di = (Ci,m·u/p)

finally, doses are transformed in risk with the previous hazard
parameters, and the indexes (INHXP, INGXP) result from the
comparison with two reference compounds (toluene, benzene)
in each case; all the input flows (mi) are aggregated to obtain
a global process index:
TPi = (Ci,c/Rfxi)/(CT,c/RfxT)
CPi = (Ci,c·SFi)/(CB,c·SFB)
IT =  mi·TPi
IC =  mi·CPi
Waste VOC (toluene, ethyl acetate) is recovered by absorption with tetradecane and distillation; emissions
sources (absorber, condenser vents, deposits, fugitive and fuel) are estimated by a simulator (HYSYS) and
correlations (EFRAT), showing the effect of absorbent: VOCs capture but also service related emissions.
Indicators for 3 impact categories (equivalent factors) show a compromise between selective absorption and
fluegases, with significant reductions of IGW (42%) and ISF (82%), and modest increase of IA, at flow 50 kmol/h.
Absorbent flow
(kmol/h)
0
10
20
50
100
200
400
Toluene
193,5
119,9
53,1
0,97
0,02
0,02
0,03
AcEt
193,5
185,9
178,4
160,4
128,1
59,9
1,70
CO2
0
37
74
183
360
714
1420
Emissions (kg/h)
CO
TOC
0
0
0,013
0,001
0,027
0,001
0,066
0,003
0,129
0,007
0,257
0,013
0,512
0,026
NOx
0
0,05
0,11
0,26
0,52
1,03
2,05
SOx
0
0,41
0,81
1,99
3,39
7,82
15,56
n-C14
0
4,28
4.83
4.67
4,23
4,13
4,05
Indexes for:
20
2
c
a
s
e
s
t
u
d
y
Global warming (IGW /10 )
1
Smog formation (ISF/10 )
0
Acidification
(IA/10 )
IA
15
IGW
10
5
ISF
0
100
200
300
400
absorbent flow in the column (kmol/h)
To evaluate toxicity in this example, we consider 3 relevant compounds: Toluene, AcEt, and Hexane as
a subrogate for products of incomplete combustion (TOC), none of them considered carcinogen.
Environmental concentrations are calculated from the standard emission of Mackay model (1000 kg/h),
as their potentials relative to reference compound (toluene) don´t depend on emission levels (see table).
Figure shows variations of toxicity indexes for process (virtually identical), using the previously estimated
emissions; risks depend on absorption efficiency of toluene and acetate, while much less on TOC levels,
and these indexes could be minimized 39% operating at a flow of 50 kmolabs/h.
Compound
Physical properties
Molecular weight
Melting point, ºC
Ratio of fugacity
P. vapor (25ºC), Pa
Solubility, mg/l
Log Kow
Life average, h
Air
Water
Soil
Sediment
Concentration, mg/l
Air
Water
Inhalation:
3
RfC, mg/m
LC50, ppm
INHTP
Ingestion
RfD, mg/kg·d
LD50, mg/kg
INGTP
Toluene
92,13
-95,0
1,0
3800
550
2,70
Ethyl ac. Hexane
88,11
-82,0
1,0
12000
80800
0,70
86,17
-95,3
1,0
20000
10
4,00
Toxicity indexes by inhalation and ingestion
IT
800
600
400
17
550
1700
5500
55
55
170
550
-7
1,97·10
-7
4,00·10
17
550
1700
5500
-7
4,36·10
-6
5,00·10
0,4
4000
3200
1,0
2,8
0,2
5000
0,9
1,0
2,8
IINH , IING
200
-7
1,97·10
-9
1,50·10
0,2
2,0
28700
6,5·10-4
0
100
200
300
400
Absorbent flow (kmol/h)
The uncertainties in these analysis (estimation of emissions,
fate, exposures, effects), and particularly the use of different
toxicity parameters (Rfx, Lx), must be taken into account as
they introduce variations in the evaluations.
On the other hand, the use of multicriteria indexes requires
also weighting factors to valuate their relative importance.
Substance (i)
Emission to air (standard environment)
Concentration stationary
Air (Ci,A)
Standard risk (Si,A)
RfC (mg/m3)
LC 50 (ppm)
Inhalation,
INHTPi= (Ci,A/Si,A)/ (CR,A/SR,A)
Concentration stationary
Water (Ci,W)
Standard risk (Si,W)
RfD (mg/kg·d)
LD 50 (mg/kg)
Ingestion,
INGTPi= (Ci,W/Si,W)/ (CR,W/SR,W)
Process emissions
(50 kg/h of absorbent)
mi
Global toxic index
I INH =  mi INHTPi
I ING =  mi INGTPi
Toluene (R)
Ethyl acetate
Hexane
1000 kg/h
1000 kg/h
1000 kg/h
197 ng/m3
0,4
4000
436 ng/m3
197 ng/m3
0,2
3200
1,00
0,400 ng/l
0,2
5000
2,77
1,51·10-3 ng/l
5,02 ng/l
0,9
28700
1,00
0,97 kg/h
2,00
6,58·10-4
2,79
160,4 kg/h
0,003 kg/h
445,3
448,5
EPA hap-index
MSDS