Transcript Document

Physics at hadron collider
with Atlas
3rd lecture
Simonetta Gentile
Università di Roma La Sapienza, INFN
on behalf of Atlas Collaboration
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Outline
 Introduction to Hadron Collider Physics
 LHC and ATLAS detector
1st  Test of Standard Model at LHC
• Parton distribution function
• QCD + jet physics
• Electroweak physics (Z/W –bosons)
2nd • Top physics
3rd  Search for Higgs boson
4th  Supersymmetry
 Conclusions
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Cross Section of Various SM
Processes
The LHC uniquely combines the
two most important virtues of
HEP experiments:
1.
2.
High energy 14 TeV
and high luminosity
1033 – 1034/cm2/s
 Low luminosity phase
1033/cm2/s = 1/nb/s
approximately
 200 W-bosons
 50 Z-bosons
 1 tt-pair
will be produced per second!
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Status of SM model
High precision measurements→ Test of Standard Model
1000 data points combined in 17 observables calculated in SM
TOP MASS
 a em(precision 3 10-9) (critical part Da had)
- GF (precision 9 10-6) (→MW)
- Mz(precision 2 10-5)from line-shape
 as(Mz) precision 2 10-2 hadronic observable
Mtop and MHiggs
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Top Mass from Semi-Leptonic Events
Reconstruct mt from hadronic W decay
Constrain two light quark jets to mW
j1
W
j2
t
70% top purity - efficiency 1.2 %
b-jet
• 3.5 million semileptonic events in 10 fb-1
(first year of LHC operation)
 Error on mt   1 – 2 GeV
Dominated by
• Jet energy scale (b-jets)
• Final state radiation
Linear with input Mtop
Simonetta Gentile
Largely independent
Top 2005
PT
Gomel Schoolon
of Physics
Top Mass from Other Channels
Di-lepton events:
• BR  5%
• low background
• but two neutrinos in final state
 Dmt   1.7 GeV
Fully hadronic events:
• BR  45%
• difficult jet enviroment
 Dmt   3 GeV
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Top Mass from J/ channel
1000 events/y @ 1034
• Method:
Partial reconstruction of
top J/ + lepton
•The lepton from W decay is rather
sensitive to mt
BR(ttWb+qqJ/)  5 10-5
•efficiency (e ~ 30%)
L =100fb-1
• Estimated ultimate precision:
•Low background
• indipendent of jet energy scale
• limited by b fragmentation & needs
Simonetta Gentile
high luminosity
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Dmt  1 GeV
Top mass from J/
M J/
M(J/+ )
M(J/)
Different
systematics
(almost no
sensitivity to
FSR)
Pttop
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Uncertainty on
the b-quark
fragmentation
function
becomes the
dominant error
W Polarization
Massive gauge bosons have three polarization states
At LEP in e+e  W+W :
determine W helicity from lepton (quark) decay angle in W rest frame 
 (1  cos )2 transverse
 sin2
longitudinal
• Fraction of longitudinal W
in e+e  W+W
0.218  0.031
SM: 0.24

• Tevatron:
Longitudinal W in top decays
0.91  0.52 CDF
0.56  0.31 D0
SM: 0.7
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
W Polarization in Top Decays
Use tt events to study the Lorentz structure of tt decays.
P ossible W configuration in top decays.
Standard Model
Within SM (V-A coupling) only 2 configuration are allowed
Lepton kinematical distribution are rather sensitive to W boson
helicity
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
W Polarization in Top Decays
cos *
 A sensitive W spin analyser in top decays is the angle *
between the charged lepton in W rest frame and W in top rest frame
cos *
1 dN
3   sin  
 1  cos 
 1  cos  
  F0  
  FL  
  FR  


N d cos 2   2 
2 
2 



2
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005

2

2
W Polarization in Top Decays
F0=0.699 ± 0.005
ATLAS 10 fb-1
SM
ATLAS
(±stat ±syst)
F0
0.703
 0.004  0.015
F-
0.297
 0.003  0.024
F+
0.000
 0.003  0.012
FL=0.299 ± 0.003
FR=0.002 ± 0.003
 Systematic dominated by b-jet scale.
Precision on fraction of long.polarization W~ 0.03 after 10fb-1
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
tt Spin Correlation
• Very short lifetime, no top bound states
• Spin info not diluted by hadron formation
•Measure the correlation through the angular distribution of
daughter of articles in top rest frame
Distinguishes between
• quark annihilation
A = -0.469
• and gluon fusion
A = +0.431
Use double leptonic decays
tt  bb l l
Predicted value A=0.31
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
tt-correlation dileptonic events
Double leptonic decays
tt  bb l l
e+/+
 *
top
θ*  angle of charged lepton in top (or antitop) rest frame
<Cos θ *+  · Cos θ * - >
Without
helicity
correlation
<Cos θ *+  · Cos θ *-  >
With
helicity
correlation
 Dilepton and -Semileptonic events analysis with same power to
Gentile
probe SM at 5s in 10fb-1 GomelSimonetta
School of Physics 2005
Single Top Production
Production mechanisms and cross sections:
 60 pb
 245 pb
1
 direct measurement of Vtb
 10 pb
2
3
tt final states (LHC,10 fb-1)
( observable by Tevatron in Run II )
W→e,
• process 1 (0.5M) : 
+  + 4jets
• process 2 (0.12M) :  +  + 3ets
• process 3 (0.02M) : 2 +  + 2jets
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Single Top Production
Production mechanisms and cross sections:
• Selection:
t  bW  b e ()
b-jet + high pT lepton
reconstruction of top mass
• Background from tt
signal to bkgd. 3.5 : 1
 10 pb
 60 pb
 245 pb
Process
Vtb
(stat)
Vtb
(theory)
1
0.4%
6%
2
1.4%
6%
3
2.7%
5%
experimental determination of Vtb
-1)
to
percent
level
(with
30
fb
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Determination of Top Charge
Top charge:
• Qt = +2/3 not yet established
• Qt = -4/3 not yet excluded
t  W+b
t  W–b
Methods:
 jet charge determination. Measure the lepton charge from W
decays and distinguish b-quark from anti-b with jet charge
determination
 ttg events . Final state photon
radiation would be more likely
if |Q| is larger.
Radiative top production
cross section proportional to Q2top.
Radiative top decay
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Determination of Top Charge
Determine charge from rate of radiative ttg events
pT spectrum of photons for 10 fb-1:
Qt = +2/3
Qt = -4/3
Q=2/3
Q=-4/3
ppttg
101 ± 10
295 ± 17
pptt ; tWbg
6.2 ± 2.5
2.4 ± 1.5
Total background
events
pT(g)
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
38 ± 6
Top Charge Determination
ATL-PHYS-2003-035
• Determine charge of b-jet
and combine with lepton
q bjet
  κ
q j  pi

i i

  κ
i j  pi
– Use di-lepton sample
Investigate ‘wrong’
combination b-jet charge
and lepton charge
– Effective separation b and
b-bar possible in first year
LHC
– Study systematics in
progress
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Measurement of tt cross section
σxBR [fb]
Total cross section:
 At 14 TeV interesting in itself
 Sensitive to top mass stt  1/mt2
Differential cross sections:
 ds/dpT checks pdf
 ds/d checks pdf
 ds/dmtt sensitive to production of heavy object
decaying to top-pairs Xtt
1.6 TeV
resonance
830fb
sxBR required for a discovery
30 fb-1
300 fb-1
Mtt
1TeV
Simonetta Gentile
A resonanceGomel
could
be ofdiscovered
School
Physics 2005 if sxBr >830 fb
mtt [GeV/c2]
Summary & Conclusions
SM physics at the LHC with ATLAS
• Very important in initial phase
to check detector
 to check generators (pdf)
 to prepare discoveries
• Large potential for precision measurements
large cross sections
 precision limited by systematics
 use as many different strategies as possible
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Standard
Model
Higgs Search
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Combination of Measurements
Only best analysis from each
decay mode, each experiment.
Year
Mtop
[GEV]
EPS95 KojiSato
MHiggs
[GEV]
2003
174.3±5.1 < 219
2004
178.0±4.3 < 251
2005
(june)
174.3±3.4 < 208
2005
(july)
172.7±2.9
?
Expected precision in 2007 at Tevatron:
Simonetta Gentile
±
~1GeV
Gomel School of Physics 2005
SM Higgs search at Tevatron
S.Lammel, Fermilab,LP05
LP05
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Higgs Production Mechanism@ LHC
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
4 production mechanisms
key to measure H-boson parameters
Standard Model Higgs production
Direct production
gg fusion
Associated production
tt H, WH, ZH :
gg fusion dominant
1-10% of gg fusion
WW/ZZ fusion
•isolated lepton from W
decay
VectorBosonFusion 20%
of gg at 120 GeV
•2 jets @ large 
• reconstruct topquarks
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Properties of Higgs boson
The Higgs boson couples to particles proportionally their mass
→ preferred decays in heaviest particle allowed.
W+, Z, t,b,c, t+ …. g
H
W-, Z, t,b,c, t- …. g
•Lepton & photons are essential final state against QCD background
bb decay mode only possible in associated production tt…
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Higgs Discovery Channels at LHC
Dominant BR for mH<2mZ:
s (H  bb)  20 pb;
s (bb)
 500 b
for m(H) = 120 GeV
 no hope to trigger
or extract fully
hadronic final states
 look for final
states with , g
( = e, )
Low mass region: m(H) < 2 mZ :
H  gg : small BR, but best resolution
H  bb : good BR, extract backg ttH, WH
H  ZZ*  4
H  WW*   or jj : via VBFand direct
production
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
H  tt : via VBF
m(H) > 2 mZ :
H  ZZ  4
qqH  ZZ    *
qqH  ZZ   jj *
qqH  WW jj *
* for mH > 300 GeV forward
jet tag
Discovery in a channel
 Particle decaying in X → 
Signal significance
Ns
S
Nb
peak
Ns= number of signal events
Nb= number of background events
m
Nb
In the
signal
region
Error on number of background events
(for large statistics, for low Poisson statistics)
 S > 5 : signal larger 5 times error on background.
Gaussian probability that background fluctuates up more
than 5 s is 10-7→ DISCOVERY
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Considerations
Detector resolution
If the detector resolution became worst s . To keep the same
number of signal events, Ns ,the region has to be 2 times larger
to keep the same number of events.
If background flat →→ Nb ,increases ~ 2
Ns
S
Nb  2  s 
decrease
Nb
An high resolution detector has better chance for a discovery
• If GH << s m (if the width particle X is broad of detector resolution this
comment is not important)
Remind : mH = 100 GeV → GH ~ 0.001 GeV
mH = 200 GeV → GH ~ 1 GeV
mH = 600 GeV → GSimonetta
GeV GH ~ m3
H ~ 100 Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Considerations
Luminosity
Ns ~ L
Nb ~ L
S ~√ L
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
The Challenge
Theoretical limits:
M(Higgs) < 1 TeV
LEP
Experimental limits:
M(Higgs) > 114.4 GeV
Indirect constraints:
M(Higgs) < 208 GeV
Safe channels:
H→ gg
H→ZZ→    
here discovery “easy”
with H  4
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Prospects for Standard Model Higgs searches
EW fit MH<211 GeV @95% CL
LEP direct MH>114.4 GeV @95% CL
•Discovery: several
complementary channels.
• some channels with very exclusive
topologies (large bgd. suppression).
• Coupling measurements @ 30fb-1.
• Mass, width (direct and indirect).
•Detector performance is
crucial: b-tag, /g , E-resolution,
g/j separation, ETmiss resolution,
forward jet tags, central jet-veto,
treconstruction.
Expected results discussed at Integrated Luminosity of
10fb-1 30fb-1 100fb-1. Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
SM-like Higgs searches early reach
Low mass
LEP : mH > 114.1 GeV
mH ~ 115 GeV
•observation of all channels
important to extract
convincing signal 4-5 s
significance in first year
( Several channels give ~ 2 s
significance 10 fb-1 )
H  gg relies only on
electromagnetic calorimeter,
(constant term < 0.7 %)
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
H  gg
MH= 115 GeV
H  gg
S
B
S/B
150
3900
0.04
ttH  ttbb
( + -had)
15
45
0.33
~ 10
~ 10
Signif.
2.4
2.1
CLb
9 10-3
2 10-2
K  factor 
qqH  qqtt
3.5
ttH  tt bb  b bjj bb
4 10-3
b
σ NLO
 2 not included
σ LO
b
Total S/ B for 10
and complete detector:
~ 4.2 s
fb-1
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
qqH  qqtt
t
H
t
SM-like Higgs searches early reach
Inter mass
mH ~ 130 GeV
•observation of all channels
important to extract convincing
signal 6 s significance in first
year ( Several channels give
<3 s significance 10 fb-1 )
•4 complementary channels 
robustness
 H  4 : low rate but very
clean (large S/B, narrow mass peak)
< 3s significance per channel
(except qqWW counting channel)
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
MH= 130 GeV
10 fb-1
H  gg
S
B
S/B
120
2500
0.05
Signif.
2.4
CLb
9 10-3
Intemediate mass
complete detector
qqH  qqtt H  4 qqH  qqWW
( + -had)
~8
~5
18
~6
<1
15
~5
~1
~ 2.7
4 10-3
3.2
3.9
6 10-4
4 10-5
Total S/B for 10 fb-1 and complete detector:
~ 6.5 s
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Light Higgs Search:
H -> ZZ* ->4 leptons
s Br = 5.7 fb (mH =100 GeV)
Example of analysis:
•PT of 2 most energetic  > 20 GeV
•PT of 2 less energetic  > 7 GeV
•|η|<2.5 (barrel)
•M(  ) ~ Mz
•M(  ) < Mz
L =100
fb-1
background
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Invariant mass constraints
Light Higgs Search:
H -> ZZ* ->4 leptons
background
•Top production
tt →W b W b → c  c
s Br ≈ 1300 fb
W b W b
•Associated production of Zbb s Br(Z→) ≈ 22.8pb
Zbb → c  c
To reject the background:
1.leptons from b-quarks decays are not isolated
2. don’t originated from primary vertex (tb ~1.5 ps)
s Br(Z→bb)
• ZZ background
after isolation cut continuum
Br(Z→) ≈ 0.15pb
Discovery potential in mass range
from ~ 130 GeV to 600 GeV
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
100fb–1
Light Higgs
Search:
H -> ZZ* -> 4
required lumi for discovery
100fb–1
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
H→gg
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Light Higgs Search: gg, ttH channels
100fb–1
Significance:
2.8 toSimonetta
4.3s for
Signal significance (5s) :
Gentile
-1
100
Gomelfb
School of Physics 2005 m < 120 GeV needs 100 fb–1
H
VBF Higgs boson production at low mass
Distinctive Signature of:
- two high PT forward jets
- little jet activity in the central region
 Jet Veto
Rapidity distribution of tag jets
VBF Higgs events vs. ttbackground
Channels studied:
qqH  qqWW*  qq    
qqH  qq t t  qq      
 qq    had 
Hard leptons with distinctive kinematics;
Full H->tt reconstruction
possible
Simonetta
Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Higgs
tt
 jet
Forward jet tagging
Rapidity distribution of tag jets
VBF Higgs events vs. tt-background
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Rapidity separation
Background
el.weak background:
WW jj production
Z + 2 jets
QCD backgrounds:
tt production
Z + 2 jets
Background rejection:
qqH  qqWW*  qq l  l 
• Lepton PT cuts and tag jet requirements
(D, PT)
• Require large mass of tag jet system
• Jet veto
• Lepton angular and mass cuts
Higgs boson (mH = 160 GeV)
tt background
g / Z + jets
el.weak WW jj
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
qq→qq W W*→qq    
Transverse distribution excess
On the background tt -production
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
qq→qq W W*→qq    
K.Jacobs
Azimuthal difference
Between the two
leptons
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
H  WW*  
mT = 2pT ETmiss(1-cosf)
Observe excess in transverse
mass distribution
S ~ 10-40 events for 10fb-1
B ~ 10-15 events


p
H
W
p
W


• Two isolated leptons
• Two forward tag jets
• Central jet veto: pT<20 GeV
• Gentile
lepton angular correlation
Simonetta
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Vector Boson Fusion
Signal significance
These studies demonstrate that vector
boson fusion channels may be
accessible in the low mass region
already in the first year.
ATLAS
qqH  qqtt
qqH  qqWW
All channels
fb-1 in ATLAS:
5 s significance for
120  mH  190 GeV 10
For 10
5
Results are conservative:
- K-factor not included
- very simple analyses used
1
100
120
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
140
160 180 200
200
mHiggs (GeV)
Low mass remarks
The 3 channels are complementary  robustness:
• different production and decay modes
• different backgrounds
• different detector/performance
requirements:
-- ECAL crucial for H  gg
(in particular response uniformity) :
Note :
s/m ~ 1% needed
-- b-tagging crucial for ttH :
all require “low” trigger thresholds.
4 b-tagged jets needed to reduce
e.g. ttH analysis cuts :
pT () > 20 GeV,
combinatorics
pT (jets) > 15-30 GeV
-- efficient jet reconstruction over || < 5
crucial for qqH  qqtt :
forward jet tag and central jet veto
needed against background
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
200 GeV<MH<600 GeV
200 GeV < m(Higgs) < 600 GeV:
Large mass
-1
complete detector 10 fb
- discovery in H  ZZ  +-+-
H  ZZ  +-+-
background smaller than signal,
Higgs natural width larger than
experimental resolution (mHiggs > 300 GeV)
- confirmation in H  ZZ  +- jj
channel
m(Higgs) > 600 GeV:
4 lepton channel statistically limited
H  ZZ  +- 
H  ZZ  +- jj , H  WW  + jj (150 times larger BR than 4l channel)
Event signature: high pT lepton, two high pT jets
Combination of analyses allows
Higgs discovery in full mass range
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Higgs signal in ATLAS
LHC can probe entire set of ”allowed”
Higgs mass values (100 GeV – 1 TeV)
at least 2 channels for most of range
Full mass range can be covered
After few years at low luminosity
30 fb-1
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Discovery potential
All channels together
 For most of the mass range at least two channels available
 Good sensitivity over the full mass range from
~ 100 GeV to ~ 1TeV

mH<180 GeV: several complementary
channels (gg, ttbb, 2ETmiss , 3ETmiss, 4 , tt)
 mH>180 GeV: easy with gold-plated H  ZZ*  4
Challenging channels (multijets…, WH) not included
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Standard Model Higgs
Once Higgs boson has been discovered
measure its properties:
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Measurement of the Higgs boson mass
•No theoretical error
•Dominant systematic
uncertainty: g /, E scale.
Assumed 1‰
Goal
0.2‰
Scale from Z   (close to light
Higgs)
Assumed 1% jets
Resolution for
g g &   1.5 GeV/c2
bb 15 GeV/c2
Dominated from
At large masses decreasing
ZZ→4  and H → g g
precision due to large GH
Higgs boson mass can be measured with a precision of
Simonetta Gentile
2)
0.1% over a large mass
range
(130
~450
GeV
/
c
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Measurement of Branching Ratios
Measurement of relative branching ratios
Fitting Br(H->XX) (assume Higgs production works as in SM)
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Measurement of Higgs Boson Couplings
•Global likelihood-fit (at each possible Higgs boson mass)
Input: measured rates, separated for the various production modes
• Output: Higgs boson couplings, normalized to the WW-coupling
Relative couplings can be measured
with a precision of 10-20%
(for 300 fb-1)
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005
Conclusions on the SM Higgs
Inclusion of Vector
Boson Fusion
channels improves
SM Higgs discovery
potential:
~10 fb-1 needed for
5s discovery over
the full (interesting)
mass range
mH > 114.4 GeV here discovery “easy”
with H  4
30 fb-1 more robust
result
Simonetta Gentile
Gomel School of Physics 2005