Transcript Slide 0

AHAM--Household Appliance Sustainability
Standards
2012
Energy Use per Unit Volume (GJ/m3)
Why is AHAM developing sustainability metrics?
As home appliances become more energy efficient, relatively speaking, the
proportion of environmental impacts from other attributes are increasing. We
need to broaden the conversation beyond just energy.
Source: Boustani et al. (2010). Appliance Remanufacturing and Energy Savings
1
Refrigerator/Freezer Annual Energy Consumption
1400
1200
kWh/yr.
1000
800
600
400
200
0
1980 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
This is but one example of the tremendous gains in energy efficiency by
appliances over the last 30 years.
Isn’t just one measurement or attribute enough?
Energy Star is largely a single attribute
certification program for energy efficiency
Multi-attribute standards are now the
expectation
Government procurement
• Buildings – LEED
• Computers – EPEAT
• Office furniture – BIFMA
Retailers
• Walmart Supplier
Sustainability Assessment
• Kohl’s Department Store Reports
3
The Intersection of Many Ideas
Standards Organizations
• UL Environment, CSA, Good
Housekeeping, and Green Seal
developing sustainability
standards in other sectors
• Interested in appliances
Retailers
Government
•“Manufacturers
should take steps
to measure and
address
sustainability”
•EPA Energy Star
writing sustainability
measures in electronics
sector
•Green Guides
•Gov’t Procurement
Create business value
•AHAM has the technical leadership and understanding of its products to develop
sustainability measurements.
4
AHAM has partnered with the experts
Recognized expertise in developing
sustainability standards
Contributing in-house LCA and
toxicology expertise
Credible, recognized expertise in the
environmental sector
Contributing stakeholder review and
document management functions
Internationally recognized
sustainability consulting firm
Contributing project management
and liaison with key stakeholders
5
Target Audiences
We recognize any standards
must be available and will be
relevant to many target
audiences.
CONSUMERS
MANUFACTURERS
ENVIRONMENTAL
NGO’s
Several target audiences
for the Sustainability Standards
GOVT: DOE/EPA
RETAIL TRADE/
BUILDERS
6
Standards Development –
Streamlined Process (Collaborative)
7
Phase
1
Life Cycle
Screening
Define Scope and
Elements
Selected
Stakeholder Input
Phase
2
Develop Draft
Standard
Stakeholder
Review
Draft Standard
Available for
Internal Use
Phase
3
Pilot Test the
Standard
Phase
4
Incorporate
Lessons from Pilot
Testing
Publish Standard
Phase
5
Form Consensus
Stds Committee
(ANSI, SCC)
Publish Final
Consensus
Standard
Standards Development – Progress to Date
Refrigeration
Release Standard
8
Portable & Floor Care
Released
2012
Release Standard
Final Stakeholder
Review
Final Stakeholder
Review
Pilot Testing
Pilot Testing
Drafting Standard
Drafting Standard
Stakeholder Review
of Scoping
Document
Stakeholder Review
of Scoping
Document
Development of
Standards
Methodology
Development of
Standards
Methodology
Research
Research
Organization
Organization
Standards Development – Progress To Date
Conventional
Cooking
Clothes Washer
Release Standard
Release Standard
Final Stakeholder
Review
Final Stakeholder
Review
Pilot Testing
Pilot Testing
Drafting Standard
Drafting Standard
Stakeholder Review
of Scoping
Document
Development of
Standards
Methodology
Research
Organization
9
Stakeholder Review
of Scoping
Document
Development of
Standards
Methodology
Research
Organization
Commenced
Nov. 2012
Selected Stakeholder Input
Priority stakeholders we have engaged include
representative from the following organizations:
The Sustainability Consortium
EPA Sustainability Office
EPA ENERGY STAR
Environment Canada
Individual Retailers
Lowes, Sears-Kenmore, Best Buy, Kohl’s
Consumers Union
Environmental Defense Fund
Carbon Disclosure Project
10
Scope of Standards
The AHAM sustainability standards will cover household
appliances.
In major appliances, we will utilize the definitions and scopes
of the coverage of products under 10 CFR 430, the U.S.
Department of Energy, energy efficiency standards for
appliances.
The Portable and Floor Care Appliance Sustainability
Standard will encompass over 70 different types of electrical
small appliances in the following areas:
Kitchen Countertop motorized and heating appliances
Beverage appliances
Garment care appliances
Home environment portable appliances
Personal care portable appliances
Floor care appliances
11
Multiple Steps in Standards Processes
Life Cycle-Based Research
Develop value-chain initial heat-map
Existing LCA
Reviewed PCR’s, government studies,
company studies, academic studies
Coordinated with environmental impact reports
Conduct generic LCA based on ISO 14064
Interview stakeholders
Refine Hot Spot Analysis
Multi-Attribute Approach
The methodology for developing the Home Appliance
Environmental Performance Standard is multi-attribute
because it addresses an array of environmental and human
health considerations.
The multi-attribute approach was developed using a
combination of life cycle assessment (LCA) information,
literature sources, and input from a broad spectrum of key
stakeholders.
By starting with refrigeration products, we established a
procedure, utilized multi-attribute methodology, identified
unique North American parameters, and set the stage for
other appliances.
13
Life Cycle Hot Spot Methodology
14
Life Cycle Hot Spot Methodology
15
An example of a
Life Cycle Screening (“Hot Spots”)
Life Cycle Stages
Sustainability
Impact Category
Air
Climate
Change
Living
Resources
(Flora & Fauna)
Non-Living
Resources
Water (Quality
& Quantity)
Human Health
Socioeconomic
Raw Mat’ls
Mfg
Refrigerant
ODP
Releases
during mfg
Refrigerant
Blowing
Agent
Packaging/
Distribution
Hazardous
waste
Recycled
content
Solid waste
Releases in
supply chain
Releases
during mfg
End-of-Life
Noise
Transport to
recycling?
Refrigerant
Releases
during mfg
Hazardous
waste
Use
Energy
Foam
High
Priority
Recyclability/
content of pkg
Med.
Priority
Low
Priority
Materials of concern
Continued
use of
fridge
Review of Hotspots drives attributes and criteria selection and weighting.
16
Framework for Development of Standard
Informed by
Requirements of Standard
Criteria
Metric
A characteristic of
a product or
process that has a
direct influence on
environmental
performance
The requirements
for a product to
meet the standard
Quantification of
the criteria that
can be measured
e.g.
e.g.
e.g.
Avoid materials of
concern
Conformance with a
central list of
restricted materials
Analytical test data
demonstrating
compliance
Promote use of
recycled materials
5-10% recycled
content
Documentation of
calculation
17
Demonstration
that specified
requirements are
fulfilled
Materials
Manufacturing &
Operations
End-of-Life
Management
Principles
Conformity
Assessment
Attribute
Energy during Use
Life Cycle
Screening
Assured by
Innovation
Prerequisites
Each of the six Attributes may have one or more prerequisites
that are required as the minimum performance level.
Products shall meet all prerequisites in a particular attribute
section in order to be eligible for evaluation using the points
system in that attribute section. If a product does not meet one
or more of the prerequisites in a particular attribute section, it
cannot be evaluated against that attribute.
The product may still be assessed and receive points against
the other attributes provided their associated prerequisites are
met.
18
Major Attributes
Each of our sustainability standards may
draw from attributes such as:
Materials
Energy & Water during the use phase
Manufacturing and Operations
Product Performance
End of Life
Consumables
Innovation
19
Innovation
The intent is to award activities that exhibit exceptional
performance above and beyond the requirements of this
standard as well as activities that are not covered by the
criteria within these requirements.
The product is evaluated based on the following criteria:
Innovation in product features and manufacturer programs and
policies that demonstrate environmental performance
improvement that is exceptional, measurable and beyond the
requirements and criteria covered within this standard.
20
Standards breakdown
Each of the product sustainability standards
attributes are then broken down into criteria
For example, the materials attribute may be broken
into such areas as:
Substances used in the product’s design
Special substances, such as refrigerants and foam
blowing agents in cold products
Product recycled content
Packaging recycled content
Optimized use of raw materials
The refrigeration standard has 19 criteria
21
Benefits of the standards
Through a life-cycle approach, we can show the
relative balance of environmental impacts of
appliances across the attributes and criteria.
Manufacturers can use these standards to
measure existing and design future products
Retailers, customers, procurement officials, and
consumers know that the standards are based on
a systematic approach using recognized
methodologies and principles.
22
Next steps in Standards
Complete collaborative standards development
Allow companies to use the standards
Form consensus standards committees
Ballot and complete ANSI and SCC processes
Refrigeration products
Portable & Floor Care appliances
Clothes Washers
Others
Stay tuned
There is more coming…
24
Questions?
For more information, please contact:
Sriram Gopal
Policy Analyst
Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers
1111 19th St. NW, Suite 402, Washington, DC 20036
Tel: 202.872.5955, ext. 306
Email: [email protected]
Thank you for your time.
25