Transcript Document

Feedback Presentation
on the Revision of Laws Consultation
St Pierre Park Hotel
10 June 2015
1
Welcome
Philip Nicol-Gent
General Counsel
Guernsey Financial Services Commission
2
Objectives
•
•
•
•
•
Addressing the new MiFID regime
Changes to meet international standards
Enhancing consistency and creating efficiencies
“Future proofing”
What NOT to do
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
3
The process so far
•
•
•
•
•
Informal soundings
Discussion paper
Drop-in sessions 13th and 14th November 2014 – 25 attendees
Legal dinner with UK lawyers 24th November 2014
Feedback:
•
•
•
•
Financial Sector Forum
Guernsey International Business Association
Fiscal and Economic Policy Group
Commerce and Employment
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
4
Consultation paper
•
•
•
•
Launched 10 February 2015
Legal dinner with UK lawyers 2nd March 2015
Drop-in sessions 10th and 13th March 2015 – 12 attendees
Consultation period closed 24 April 2015
– 38 responses
• 50% licencees
• 25% industry bodies
• 25% others
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
5
Today
•
•
•
•
Matters discussed are those changes needed to primary legislation
Further amendments needed to rules and regulations
Proposals being made to government
No questions at the end of this presentation – please join us for coffee and a
croissant in the adjoining room
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
6
The new MiFID regime
Dr Andy Sloan
International Policy Advisor
Guernsey Financial Services Commission
7
Markets in Financial Instruments Directive
MIFID II / MIFIR
‘Europe’s approach to increased market transparency and
investor protection post financial crisis’
• Determines market access for ‘investment services’ for third
country firms
• MIFID II – retail
– Branches (and conditions) or national regimes
• MIFIR – institutional
– Passport across EU with ‘jurisdictional equivalence’
Dr Andy Sloan, International Policy Advisor
8
MIFID II / MIFIR scope
MIFID II
• Authorisation and operating conditions for investment firms, authorisation and operation of
regulated markets and data reporting service providers
• Supervision, cooperation and enforcement by competent authorities
• Provision of investment services through a branch for third country firms
[retail market access for investment services]
MIFIR
• Disclosure of trade data, reporting of transactions, trading of derivatives (on organised
venues), (non-discriminatory) access to clearing and trading in benchmarks
• Product intervention powers of competent authorities and powers of ESMA on position limits
and management
• Provision of investment services for third country firms through ‘jurisdictional equivalence’
(my words, my italics)
• [institutional market access for investment services]
Dr Andy Sloan, International Policy Advisor
9
Revision of laws feedback
4.3.8. Do you agree with the suggestion that market access to retail clients in the
EU (including the UK) is not necessary for Bailiwick firms?
Answer – NO!
4.3.20. Do you support the introduction of a targeted enabling power into each of
the Supervisory Laws to ensure that these laws can be efficiently amended once
the detailed requirements of the new MiFID regime are clear?
Answer – YES.
Dr Andy Sloan, International Policy Advisor
10
Equivalence
•
•
MIFID II: No equivalence, market access through branch or national regime
MIFIR: “that firms providing investment services and activities (my italics) in
that third country are:
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
subject to authorisation and to effective supervision and enforcement on an ongoing
basis (MIFID II Art 5 – 8, Art 67-78);
subject to sufficient capital requirements and appropriate requirements applicable to
shareholders and members of their management body (MIFID Art 9, 10 – 15 (plus
Prudential Requirements Directive));
subject to adequate organisational requirement in the area of internal control
functions (MIFID II, Art 16);
subject to appropriate conduct of business rules (MIFID II, Art 21-30); and
it (the jurisdiction) ensures market transparency and integrity by preventing market
abuse in the form of insider dealing and market manipulation” (MIFID Art 31 – 32
MIFIR Art 28 – 30).
Dr Andy Sloan, International Policy Advisor
11
Implications for revision of laws
•
•
•
Criteria a) and e) relate to the overall regulatory approach.
Criteria b), c) and d) relate to the specific approach to firms providing investment service
providers.
The simplest approach to equivalence would be to:
–
–
•
•
•
ensure that our sector wide requirements are consistent with the overall regulatory approach (ongoing
authorisation, effective supervision and enforcement; prevention of insider dealing and market manipulation)
(which may require law change)
supported by development of a separate and specific ‘rulebook’ for investment services.
Potentially few necessary law changes: market abuse, clarity over powers of product
intervention, enforcement powers and (potentially) the powers to create an investor
compensation scheme.
Detail of depth of assessment not yet known
Acceptability of this approach not for us to determine
Dr Andy Sloan, International Policy Advisor
12
International standards, clarity,
consistency, efficiencies and
“future-proofing”
Tania Shires
Legal Project Officer
Guernsey Financial Services Commission
13
• Changes necessary to meet international standards (CP section 3)
• Seeking clarity, consistency and efficiency (CP section 5)
• Supporting industry and “future-proofing” (CP section 6)
• Protecting the consumer (CP section 7)
• Gathering information and keeping things confidential
(CP section 10)
• Miscellaneous and administrative changes (CP section 12)
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
14
Changes necessary to meet international
standards
Current international standards
• The Basel Committee Core Principles for Effective Banking Supervision
(revised 2012)
• The Insurance Core Principles issued by the International Association of
Insurance Supervisors (revised 2013)
• The International Organization of Securities Commissions Objectives and
Principles of Securities Regulation (revised 2010)
• The Standard on the Regulation of Trust and Corporate Services Providers
- the Group of International Finance Centre Supervisors (September 2014)
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
15
Meeting international standards …
• Banking: disclosure of information to resolution authorities; objection to
appointment of a significant shareholder; definition of related parties;
bilateral meetings with auditors
• Fiduciaries: corporate directors (secondary licensees); notification and
approvals of directors and senior management; change of controllers;
reporting by auditors; financial statements of parent entities
• Investment: enabling provisions for credit rating agencies
• Insurance: remaining changes limited to rules and regulations
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
16
Seeking clarity, consistency and efficiency
• Notifications and authorisations: strong support for standardisation across sectors
• Minimum criteria for licensing: unanimous support for standardisation where
possible
• Fiduciary exemptions
– Strong support for proposed changes
– Propose merging ss 3(1)(o) and 3(1)(p) and extending to accountants
– Proposal for statutory exemption in respect of PTCs dropped
– NEW: proposed amendment of s 3(1)(w) in relation to the fiduciary/investment
overlap
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
17
Seeking clarity, consistency and efficiency …
The fiduciary / investment overlap
• New proposal
• Amendment of s 3(1)(w) in Fid Law Fiduciary exemptions: to include any
activity carried on in respect of entities that have been notified to the Commission,
and agreed by it as being ancillary entities
• Not limited to private equity structures
• Closely associated vehicles
• Notification at any time / consideration by the Commission / exemption
continues so long as requirements are met / periodic self-certification
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
18
Seeking clarity, consistency and efficiency …
Some definitions
• Definitions committee: representatives from GIBA, GAT, GIFA, Commercial Bar
Association and Commerce and Employment
• “manager” – support for clarification
• “by way of business” – decision not to extend to other sectors
• “sophisticated investor”
• “documents” – additional proposal to assist future-proofing
• “promotion” – by whatever means or media
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
19
Seeking clarity, consistency and efficiency …
• Other matters with unanimous or near unanimous support:
– Deemed withdrawal of a licence application after 3 months inactivity
– Change from “designated manager” to “designated administrator”
– Amendment to definition of “significant shareholder” in Banking Supervision Law
– Change to definition of “director” in the Insurance Laws
– Standardisation of the circumstances in which the Commission must give notice of
a decision, and the information that must be included in those notices (including the
circumstances in which the Commission must give reasons for decisions)
– Standardisation of powers and liabilities of receivers
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
20
Support industry and future-proofing
• Insurance linked securities: link to GIIA guidance on GFSC website
• Private trust companies: discretionary exemption and guidance
• Personal fiduciary licence regime: ability to suspend
• Unanimous support for a declarations scheme under the POI Law:
particulars of the scheme in rules or regulations
• Facilitating prime brokerage and AIFMD
• Consumer credit (outside the scope of the Revision of Laws project)
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
21
Support industry and future-proofing
• Enabling provisions:
– Credit rating agencies
– MiFID amendments
– New types of investment funds
– Ability to designate products, services and jurisdictions
– Power to amend definitions
– Power to specify and amend restricted descriptions and names
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
22
Protecting the consumer
• Some proposals attracting unanimous or near unanimous support
– Empowering the Commission to refuse consent to surrender of a licence
– Standardisation of the Commission’s investigatory powers in respect of market
abuse whether initial suspicion is formed by the Commission or a foreign regulatory
authority
– Empowering the Commission to apply for a court direction that an unlicensed entity
change its name (subject to the restricted words and names regime being fit for use)
– Making it an offence for a person to adopt a name that falsely implies that a person
is licensed without the Commission’s consent (subject to the restricted words and
names regime being fit for use)
– Extending powers of intervention and administration
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
23
Protecting the consumer …
• Investigation of market abuse:
– Standardisation of investigatory powers
– Extension to other sectors
– Safeguards when information is sought from persons outside the regulatory net
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
24
Protecting the consumer …
• Restrictions on descriptions and use of names:
– Strong support for providing universal list in regulations
– Enabling provisions to provide for by regulation
– Concern about “commonplace” words
– Clarification that use of words or descriptions will only be restricted where the use
falsely suggests or implies that the person is licensed
– The list of words and descriptions to be implemented by regulation, after
consultation
– Starting point FCA’s list of restricted words (subject to proviso above)
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
25
Protecting the consumer …
• Protecting policyholders in an insolvency
– Proposed amendment of Insurance Business Law to require licensee to hold at least
90% of assets representing policyholder liabilities in trust (currently standard
licence condition)
– Mixed responses to proposal
– Decision to maintain status quo and not pursue amendment
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
26
Protecting the consumer …
• Extending powers over investment funds
– Notification and authorisation – enabling provisions only (States by Ordinance)
– Minimum criteria for registration or authorisation of investment funds
– Enabling prohibition orders to be made in relation to investment funds
– Obtaining information from investment funds
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
27
Gathering information and keeping things
confidential
• Standardisation of information-gathering powers across all sectors
• Commission may obtain information and documents that it may reasonably
require for the performance of its functions.
• “relevant person” and “associated party” are being considered by the
definitions committee
• Information from unsupervised entities (with safeguards)
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
28
Gathering information and confidentiality …
• Information from all exempted entities – policing the perimeter
– Unanimous support for proposals, including re exempt directors
– Obligation on all exempted entities to immediately notify the Commission if any of
the circumstances justifying an exemption change
– Exempted entities to certify to the Commission every 3 years that the circumstances
justifying an exemption remain unchanged
– Commission to have the power to obtain information from exempted entities and
persons associated with those entities to ensure exemption remains appropriate
– Failure to provide information or certification may justify disapplication of
exemption
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
29
Gathering information and confidentiality …
• Sharing of information
– “relevant supervisory authority”
– Confidentiality of information received: standardisation of provisions already
contained in Insurance Laws across all sectors
– Sharing information with Company Registrars and Legal Aid Authorities
– Providing declarations to support the subsequent use of documents in foreign
proceedings
• Retention of documents
–
Practical issues associated with this issue under consideration.
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
30
Gathering information and confidentiality …
• Accountants and auditors
– Definition of auditors
– Notification by auditors: when they resign, are removed, not reappointed or
sign a qualified audit report
– Bi-lateral meetings
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
31
Miscellaneous and administrative changes
• Proposals attracting unanimous or near unanimous support:
– Extending the ability to introduce codes of conduct under the POI Law
– Express inclusion of acting as an enforcer of a purpose trust as a regulated activity
in the Fiduciaries Law
– Amendment of s36C Banking Supervision Law re annual reviews by licensed banks
– General rule-making power around all types of licence, authorisation and
registration applications
– Amendments to expressly allow for the electronic service of information and
documents
– Amendments to the public disclosure requirements re financial statements of banks
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
32
Miscellaneous and administrative changes …
• Proposals attracting unanimous or near unanimous support (cont):
– Extending provisions relating to the winding up of companies to encompass the
dissolution or winding down of entities other than companies
– Clarifying the Commission’s power to publish lists of licensees, as well as the fact
that someone is not licensed under each law
– The Commission should be able to recover monies due to it as a civil debt
– Suggested amendments to reflect updates to other legislation
– Suggested amendments to correct typographical errors
• Information relating to money laundering and financing of terrorism
Tania Shires, Legal Project Officer
33
Supervision & Enforcement
Philip Nicol-Gent
General Counsel
Guernsey Financial Services Commission
34
Supervision vs Enforcement
• Understanding the balance
• Getting the balance correct
– Voluntary vs compulsory interviews
– Conditions vs enforcement requirements
– Skilled persons vs inspectors
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
35
Proposals
• Enforcement Law
– Accumulate existing powers in one place
– Ensure consistency
– Clarity of process
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
36
Investigation and Proceedings
• Increase ability to police the perimeter
• Ability in appropriate circumstances to announce investigations
• Whistleblowing protection when evidence provided to the Regulator or
Law Enforcement subject to safeguards
• Rationalisation of enforcement proceedings
• Rationalisation of appeal provisions
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
37
Sanctions
• Existing powers
• New proposals
– Enforceable undertakings
– Private reprimands
– Enforcement requirements
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
38
What Happens Next?
Roadmap
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
September 2015 – Proposals published in Billet
October/November 2015 – States Debate
Quarter 4 2015 – Drafting begins
Quarter 1 2016 - Consultation on amendments to regulations and rules
July 2016 – draft legislation to Legislation Select Committee
September/October 2016 – Legislation enacted
November 2016 – Royal Assent
39
Citizen Space
•
•
•
•
A first for the GFSC
Feedback - positive experience
Worked well, some lessons learned
Efficient process for GFSC
Philip Nicol-Gent, General Counsel
40
[email protected]
THANK YOU
& PLEASE JOIN US FOR
COFFEE
41