Responses to Emerging Corruption Trends In Nigeria By

Download Report

Transcript Responses to Emerging Corruption Trends In Nigeria By

Nigeria
POPULATION: 167 million (47% of the West African Sub-Region)
GDP: 7.68% (real growth rate); $2,600 (per capita)
2
Introduction
 Nigeria’s corruption rating by Transparency International
in the last six(6) years witnessed an improvement in 2008
and thereafter suffered, a steady decline
 Coincidentally, the last six years also witnessed the
reinvigoration of enforcement actions by the various anticorruption agencies
 The seeming contradiction can be explained within the
context of the legacy corruption cases that are yet to be
resolved and also fresh investigations that have been
launched into new cases
 Overall, corruption remains a major governance challenge
in an emerging economy such as Nigeria. Consequently, it
is only with sustained enforcement actions and extensive
governance reforms over time that will improve the
situation
3
6 years Scorecard on the Transparency International CPI
YEAR
SCORE
RANK
2006
2.2
142 of
163
2007
2.2
147 of
179
2008
2.7
121 of 180
2009
2.5
130 of
180
2010
2.4
134 of
170
2011
2.4
143 of
183
4
Corruption Trends
 Revenue from Hydro carbons/oil & gas continue to




provide a major opportunity for corrupt practices
particularly in the public sector with a strong private
sector conspiracy and facilitation
Procurement contract abuses either through bribes,
inflation or bid rigging using
Outright embezzlement by senior public officials
managing agencies or departments with huge revenues
or budgets
Abuses relating to the management of security votes
Utilization of complex web of Special Purpose Vehicles
(SPVs)
5
Corruption Trends Contd.
 The corrupt seem to be shifting destination from the safe
heavens in Europe to Asia and the middle east in hiding
their proceeds of corruption
 Others choose to invest part of the proceeds of crime in
expensive real estates domestically
6
Legal Framework
 Nigerian is a signatory to the UNCAC
 UNCAC has been domesticated through the creation of the
Independent Corrupt Practices & Other Related Offences
Commission (ICPC)Act, 2000 and the Economic &
Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) Act, 2004
 There is also the Code of Conduct Bureau (CCB) created
under the Constitution of Nigeria, 1999 to manage
declaration of assets by public officers
 Other complimentary anti-corruption bodies include the
Nigerian Financial Intelligence Unit (NFIU) and the
Bureau of Public Procurement (BPP), 2007
7
Legal Framework Contd.
 The Nigerian Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative
(NEITI) Act, 2007
 Nigeria is also signatory to the African Union (AU)
Convention against corruption and the Economic
Community of West African States (ECOWAS) Protocol on
Good Governance
 The
above anti-corruption laws/instruments are
collaboratively enforced by the national anti-corruption
authorities
8
Responses to Corruption Trends in Nigeria
 Further






to the provisions of UNCAC and other
international instruments, Nigeria has responded by:
Criminalizing corruption/Money laundering
Embarking on sustained investigation and prosecution of
offenders particularly PEPs
Tracing and recovering tainted assets and
Institution of prevention measures through wide
institutional reforms
Approaching the anti corruption fight as part of its
national economic and political reforms strategy-the
transformational agenda
Ongoing effort to strengthen existing legislation
9
Responses Contd.
Investigation/Prosecution/Asset Recovery
 DSP Alameyesiegha Case - Involved in looting of the Bayelsa
State treasury and money laundering in the UK. Successfully
investigated by the EFCC in collaboration with the MET Police,
tried, convicted and sentenced. Assets of over USD$40 Million
recovered domestically and internationally
 Tafa Balogun’s Case- Looting of public treasury and money
laundering. Investigated/Prosecuted and sentenced in Nigeria.
Assets of over USD$5 Million recovered domestically.
 Prosecution of illegal oil bunkerers in the Niger Delta region and
the confiscation and recovery of several vessels worth millions of
Dollars
10
Responses Contd.
The Value of International cooperation in fighting
corruption
 The Raj Bhojwani Case (Part of Abacha loot)-Nigeria and Jersey
collaborated effectively to investigate, prosecute and sentence Mr.
Bhojwani for money laundering offences arising from corruption
using SPVs. Approximately USD$40 Million recovered and
returned to Nigeria through a sharing arrangement
 The Alamieyeseigha case. The EFCC and the MET Police
collaborated in the investigation leading to his sentence in
Nigeria and the recovery of over $40 million from assets in UK,
South Africa and Nigeria etc
 The Ibori Case. Sentenced in April 2012 to 7 years imprisonment
by a London court for money laundering. Confiscation of assets
worth over $35 million in progress
11
Responses Contd.
Settlements/Deferred/Non Prosecution Agreements
Nigeria has also adopted the settlement strategy to bring to
closure some of the major corruption cases involving
foreign multinational companies.
 The TSKJ USD$180 Million bribery scandal involving the
USD$6 billion Nigerian Liquefied Natural Gas (NLNG)
Project in Bonny
A total of USD$157,000,000 was recovered from the
consortium and a local conspirator through settlement
 Siemens telecoms fraud- Euros 34,000,000 recovered
through settlement
 Bribery of foreign public officials by multinationals relating
to Temporary Import Permits (TIPs) -Shell, Transocean,
and Noble Drilling. Over USD$20,400,000 recovered
through settlement/DPA/NPA
12
Responses Contd.
 The driving philosophy for all these settlements has been
in keeping with public policy and public interest
considerations to save time and cost of litigation and
effectively combating and deterring crime and making
substantial recoveries of the proceeds of crime in the
quickest and most efficient manner
 It must be noted that while Nigeria was the country
harmed by these bribery scandals, it was not involved in
the settlement processes that occurred in other
jurisdictions that were enforcing anti-bribery laws in those
other countries
13
Preventive Measures
 Enhanced enforcement actions against PEPs in particular is




serving as a preventive tool, reminding senior public officials
that nobody is above the law
Enforcement actions has also ramped up public awareness which
has triggered a flurry of whistle-blowing on corrupt practices
particularly by civil societies
The institution of due process by the Bureau of Public
Procurement has also helped reduce contract frauds and bid
rigging
The enactment of the freedom of Information Act, 2011
empowering civil society as an effective anticorruption watchdog
The establishment of a Transaction Clearing Platform (TCP)by
the EFCC has equally helped prospective foreign investors from
falling into fraudulent business proposals and demand for
facilitation payments which are unknown to Nigerian law
14
Challenges
 The bulk of evidence in foreign bribery cases is not
locally available. Most of the negotiation and payments
were made abroad and many jurisdictions are not disposed
to sharing such evidence even on intelligence basis. Those
that are disposed, insist that the normal MLAT process
must be followed
 The slow justice system is a major challenge making
prosecution of corruption cases windy and frustrating
 The legal framework today recognizes only conviction
based system making asset recovery a difficult task.
15
Challenges Contd.
 Safe financial heavens abroad have also made the problem
of fighting corruption challenging for law enforcement
Agencies in victim States. Proceeds of crime stashed in
foreign Banks are never spontaneously reported until a
criminal investigation is launched at which time a lot of the
proceeds have been dissipated or layered and moved to yet
other jurisdictions making tracing even more difficult
 The 2010 Global Witness Report chronicled how British
Banks – HSBC, RBS, NATWEST and USB facilitate
corruption and money laundering
in Nigeria and
Equatorial Guinea.
 Victim States including Nigeria are not involved in the
settlement of foreign bribery cases and there is emerging
discourse that seem to confuse who the real victim is in a
bribery case and the principle of ‘direct proximate harm’
16
Challenges Contd.
 The drive for revenue by countries enforcing anti bribery
laws on the supply side seem to be gradually whittling
down the real value of international cooperation with
countries on the demand side where transactions for these
bribes took place
 There is equally emerging the argument on double
jeopardy canvassed by multinational companies who
consider the payment of fines/compensation in several
jurisdictions as double punishment.
17
Moving Forward
 Sustaining the investigation and prosecution of corrupt




officials and their collaborators in the private sector
Combine the settlement and the criminal conviction
option to recover assets
Push for the passage of a non-conviction based legislation
to compliment the conviction based system
Collaborate with countries whose multinationals are
involved in bribery of Nigerian public officials to bring
them to justice in accordance with the spirit of UNCAC.
Ensure the enforcement of transparency codes by
Multinationals
18
Conclusion
 The supply and demand sides are still largely working
in silos and even in cases where they collaborate, there
is mutual suspicion which prevent the exchange of
vital information. This is a negation of the spirit of
UNCAC. The gap must be closed if the global fight
against corruption must succeed.

THANK YOU
19
Conclusion
20
Contact
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL CRIMES COMMISSION
No. 5 Fomela Street,
off Ademola Adetokunbo Crescent
Wuse II, Abuja
Tel/Fax: +234- 9- 4604603
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.efccnigeria.org
21