Presentation Title - Information Technology Services

Download Report

Transcript Presentation Title - Information Technology Services

Introduction to
Computational Chemistry
Shubin Liu, Ph.D.
Research Computing Center
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Outline
 Introduction
 Methods in Computational Chemistry
• Ab Initio
• Semi-Empirical
• Density Functional Theory
• New Developments (QM/MM)
 Hands-on Exercises
The PPT format of this presentation is available here:
http://its2.unc.edu/divisions/rc/training/scientific/
/afs/isis/depts/its/public_html/divisions/rc/training/scientific/short_courses/
its.unc.edu
2
About Us
 ITS – Information Technology Services
• http://its.unc.edu
• http://help.unc.edu
• Physical locations:
 401 West Franklin St.
 211 Manning Drive
• 10 Divisions/Departments
 Information Security
 Research Computing Center
 User Support and Engagement
 Communication Technologies
 Enterprise Applications
its.unc.edu
IT Infrastructure and Operations
Teaching and Learning
Office of the CIO
Communications
Finance and Administration
3
Research Computing
 Where and who are we and what do we do?
•
•
ITS Manning: 211 Manning Drive
Website
http://its.unc.edu/research-computing.html
•
Groups
 Infrastructure -- Hardware
 User Support -- Software
 Engagement -- Collaboration
its.unc.edu
4
About Myself
 Ph.D. from Chemistry, UNC-CH
 Currently Senior Computational Scientist @ Research Computing Center, UNC-CH
 Responsibilities:
• Support Computational Chemistry/Physics/Material Science software
• Support Programming (FORTRAN/C/C++) tools, code porting, parallel computing, etc.
• Offer short courses on scientific computing and computational chemistry
• Conduct research and engagement projects in Computational Chemistry
 Development of DFT theory and concept tools
 Applications in biological and material science systems
its.unc.edu
5
About You
 Name, department, research interest?
 Any experience before with high
performance computing?
 Any experience before with
computational chemistry research?
 Do you have any real problem to solve
with computational chemistry
approaches?
its.unc.edu
6
Think BIG!!!
 What is not chemistry?
•
•
•
From microscopic world, to nanotechnology, to daily life, to
environmental problems
From life science, to human disease, to drug design
Only our mind limits its boundary
 What cannot computational chemistry deal with?
•
•
•
•
•
its.unc.edu
From small molecules, to DNA/proteins, 3D crystals and
surfaces
From species in vacuum, to those in solvent at room
temperature, and to those under extreme conditions (high
T/p)
From structure, to properties, to spectra (UV, IR/Raman,
NMR, VCD), to dynamics, to reactivity
All experiments done in labs can be done in silico
Limited only by (super)computers not big/fast enough!
7
Central Theme of
Computational Chemistry
STRUCTURE
DYNAMICS
REACTIVITY
its.unc.edu
CENTRAL DOGMA OF MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
SEQUENCE

STRUCTURE

DYNAMICS

FUNCTION

EVALUTION
8
Multiscale Hierarchy of
Modeling
its.unc.edu
9
What is Computational
Chemistry?
Application of computational methods and
algorithms in chemistry
• Quantum Mechanical
i.e., via Schrödinger Equation
also called Quantum Chemistry

 i   Hˆ 
t
• Molecular Mechanical
i.e., via Newton’s law F=ma
also Molecular Dynamics
Focus Today
• Empirical/Statistical
e.g., QSAR, etc., widely used in clinical and medicinal
chemistry
its.unc.edu
10
How Big Systems Can We
Deal with?
Assuming typical computing setup (number of CPUs,
memory, disk space, etc.)




its.unc.edu
Ab initio method: ~100 atoms
DFT method: ~1000 atoms
Semi-empirical method: ~10,000 atoms
MM/MD: ~100,000 atoms
11
Starting Point: Time-Independent
Schrodinger Equation

 i   Hˆ 
t
H  E
N
 h2
Z 
2
H   i - 

2m
i 1 
 1 ri 
n
n
n
n

ji
i 1
1
rij
n
1
H   h i   
i 1
ji i 1 rij
its.unc.edu
12
Equation to Solve in
ab initio Theory
H  E
Known exactly:
3N spatial variables
(N # of electrons)
its.unc.edu
To be approximated:
1. variationally
2. perturbationally
13
Hamiltonian for a Molecule
ˆ 
H
electrons


 2 2
i 
2me
i
electrons 2

i j
e

rij
nuclei

 2 2
A 
2m A
A
nuclei 2

A B
electronsnuclei
 
i
A
 e2Z A
riA
e Z AZ B
R AB
 kinetic energy of the electrons
 kinetic energy of the nuclei
 electrostatic interaction between the electrons and
the nuclei
 electrostatic interaction between the electrons
 electrostatic interaction between the nuclei
its.unc.edu
14
Ab Initio Methods
 Accurate treatment of the electronic distribution using the





its.unc.edu
full Schrödinger equation
Can be systematically improved to obtain chemical accuracy
Does not need to be parameterized or calibrated with
respect to experiment
Can describe structure, properties, energetics and reactivity
What does “ab intio” mean?
• Start from beginning, with first principle
Who invented the word of the “ab initio” method?
• Bob Parr of UNC-CH in 1950s; See Int. J. Quantum Chem.
37(4), 327(1990) for details.
15
Three Approximations
 Born-Oppenheimer approximation
• Electrons act separately of nuclei, electron and
nuclear coordinates are independent of each other,
and thus simplifying the Schrödinger equation
 Independent particle approximation
• Electrons experience the ‘field’ of all other
electrons as a group, not individually
• Give birth to the concept of “orbital”, e.g., AO,
MO, etc.
 LCAO-MO approximation
• Molecular orbitals (MO) can be constructed as linear
combinations of atom orbitals, to form Slater
determinants
its.unc.edu
16
Born-Oppenheimer
Approximation
 the nuclei are much heavier than the electrons and move more
slowly than the electrons
 freeze the nuclear positions (nuclear kinetic energy is zero in the
electronic Hamiltonian)
ˆ 
H
el
electrons

i
  2 2 electrons
i  
2me
i
nuclei

A
 e2 Z A electrons e2 nuclei e2 Z A Z B
 

riA
rij A B rAB
i j
 calculate the electronic wave function and energy
ˆ   E , E 
H
el el
el
* ˆ

 el Hel el d
*

 el el d
 E depends on the nuclear positions through the nuclear-electron
attraction and nuclear-nuclear repulsion terms
 E = 0 corresponds to all particles at infinite separation
its.unc.edu
17
Approximate Wavefunctions
 Construction of one-electron functions (molecular orbitals,
MO’s) as linear combinations of one-electron atomic basis
functions (AOs)  MO-LCAO approach.
 N

l qi     ukl  k ri  i  ;
 k 1

  (spin - up)
 i   
 (spin - down)
 Construction of N-electron wavefunction as linear
combination of anti-symmetrized products of MOs (these
anti-symmetrized products are denoted as Slaterdeterminants).
its.unc.edu
18
The Slater Determinant
ˆ  a 1 b 2  c 3 z n 
Α

1
n!
 a 1 b 2 c 3 z n    a 2 b 1 c 3 z n     
 a 1  a 2   a 3   a n 
 b 1  b 2  b 3   b n 
 1n!  c 1  c 2  c 3   c n 



 z 1  z 2  z 3


  z n 
  a 1 b 2  c 3 z n    a b c  z
its.unc.edu
19
The Two Extreme Cases
 One determinant: The Hartree–Fock method.
  HF  1 12 23 3N N 
There are N MOs and each MO is a linear combination of N AOs.
Thus, there are nN coefficients ukl, which are determined by
making stationary the functional:
ˆ 
E HF    HF H
HF
 N *

   ij   uki S kl ulj   ij 
i , j 1
 k ,l 1

N
The ij are Lagrangian multipliers.
 All possible determinants: The full CI method.
its.unc.edu
20
The Full CI Method
 The full configuration interaction (full CI) method
expands the wavefunction in terms of all possible Slater
determinants:
CI 
 2N

 n



c   ;


1
 There are
ˆ CI
E CI   CI H







*
c S c  1

 , 1


 2N

 n



 2N 

 n 



possible ways to choose n molecular
orbitals from a set of 2N AO basis functions.
 The number of determinants gets easily much too large.
For example:
 40
   109
 10 
its.unc.edu
Davidson’s method can be used to find one
or a few eigenvalues of a matrix of rank 109.
21
The Hartree–Fock Method
  HF  1 12 23 3N N 
E HF    HF Hˆ  HF
 HF Hˆ  HF
N
N


 Enuc   Pmn hmn  12  Pkl mk nl  ; Pkl   uki* uli
m , n 1
k ,l 1
i 1


N

E HF   0
uki
its.unc.edu
 N *

   ij   uki S klulj   ij 
i , j 1
 k ,l 1

N
Hartree–Fock equations
22
The Hartree–Fock Method
c  F


i
  i  ci S
Overlap integral

S   |  
1


F  H    P  |     |  
2



occ
Density Matrix
its.unc.edu
P  2 ci ci
i
23
Self-Consistent-Field (SCF)
c  F


i
  i  ci S

1. Choose start coefficients for MO’s
2. Construct Fock Matrix with coefficients
3. Solve Hartree-Fock-Roothaan equations
4. Repeat 2 and 3 until ingoing and outgoing
coefficients are the same
its.unc.edu
24
Ab Initio Methods
Semi-empirical methods
(MNDO, AM1, PM3, etc.)
excitation hierarchy
(CIS,CISD,CISDT,...)
(CCS, CCSD, CCSDT,...)
Hartree-Fock
(HF-SCF)
perturbational hierarchy
(MP2, MP3, MP4, …)
excitation hierarchy
(MR-CISD)
perturbational hierarchy
(CASPT2, CASPT3)
Multiconfigurational HF
(MCSCF, CASSCF)
Full CI
its.unc.edu
25
Who’s Who
its.unc.edu
26
Size vs Accuracy
Full CI
Accuracy (kcal/mol)
0.1
Coupled-cluster,
Multireference
Nonlocal density functional,
Perturbation theory
1
Local density functional,
Hartree-Fock
Semiempirical Methods
10
1
its.unc.edu
10
100
Number of atoms
1000
27
AN EXAMPLE
Equilibrium structure of (H2O)2
W.K., J.G.C.M. van Duijneveldt-van de Rijdt, and
F.B. van Duijneveldt, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2, 2227 (2000).
95.7 pm
symmetry:
RCOO,e
= 291.2
s
96.4 pm
95.8 pm
pm
Experimental [J.A. Odutola and T.R. Dyke, J. Chem. Phys 72, 5062 (1980)]:
 ROO2 ½ = 297.6 ± 0.4 pm
SAPT-5s potential [E.M. Mas et al., J. Chem. Phys. 113, 6687 (2000)]:
 ROO2 ½ – ROO,e= 6.3 pm  ROO,e(exptl.) = 291.3 pm
its.unc.edu
28
Experimental and Computed
Enthalpy Changes He in kJ/mol
Exptl. CCSD(T)
SCF
G2
DFT
CH4  CH2 + H2
544(2)
542
492
534
543
C2H4  C2H2 + H2
203(2)
204
214
202
208
H2CO  CO + H2
21(1)
22
3
17
34
2 NH3  N2 + 3 H2
164(1)
162
149
147
166
2 H2O  H2O2 + H2
365(2)
365
391
360
346
2 HF  F2 + H2
563(1)
562
619
564
540
Gaussian-2 (G2) method of Pople and co-workers is a combination of MP2 and QCISD(T)
its.unc.edu
29
LCAO  Basis Functions
   c  


’s, which are atomic orbitals, are called basis
functions


usually centered on atoms

larger number of well chosen basis functions yields
more accurate approximations to the molecular
orbitals
its.unc.edu
can be more general and more flexible than atomic
orbital functions
30
Basis Functions
 Slaters (STO)
 Gaussians (GTO)
 Angular part * exp( r)
 Better behaved than Gaussians
 2-electron integrals hard

x l ym z n * exp  r 2

 2-electron integrals simpler
 Wrong behavior at nucleus
 Decrease too fast with r
its.unc.edu
31
Contracted Gaussian Basis Set
 Minimal
•
STO-nG
•
 Split Valence: 321G,4-31G, 631G
its.unc.edu
Each atom optimized STO is fit with n
GTO’s
Minimum number of AO’s needed
• Contracted GTO’s optimized per atom
• Doubling of the number of valence AO’s
32
Polarization /
Diffuse Functions
 Polarization: Add AO with higher angular
momentum (L) to give more flexibility
Example: 3-21G*, 6-31G*, 6-31G**, etc.
 Diffusion: Add AO with very small exponents for
systems with very diffuse electron densities
such as anions or excited states
Example: 6-31+G*, 6-311++G**
its.unc.edu
33
Correlation-Consistent
Basis Functions
its.unc.edu




a family of basis sets of increasing size


cc-pVQZ, cc-pV5Z, cc-pV6Z
can be used to extrapolate to the basis set limit
cc-pVDZ – DZ with d’s on heavy atoms, p’s on H
cc-pVTZ – triple split valence, with 2 sets of d’s
and one set of f’s on heavy atoms, 2 sets of p’s
and 1 set of d’s on hydrogen
can also be augmented with diffuse functions
(aug-cc-pVXZ)
34
Pseudopotentials,
Effective Core Potentials
its.unc.edu

core orbitals do not change much during chemical
interactions

valence orbitals feel the electrostatic potential of the
nuclei and of the core electrons

can construct a pseudopotential to replace the
electrostatic potential of the nuclei and of the core
electrons

reduces the size of the basis set needed to represent the
atom (but introduces additional approximations)

for heavy elements, pseudopotentials can also include of
relativistic effects that otherwise would be costly to treat
35
Correlation Energy
 HF does not include correlations anti-parallel electrons
 Eexact – EHF = Ecorrelation
 Post HF Methods:
• Configuration Interaction (CI, MCSCF, CCSD)
• Møller-Plesset Perturbation series (MP2, MP4)
 Density Functional Theory (DFT)
its.unc.edu
36
Configuration-Interaction (CI)
 In Hartree-Fock theory, the n-electron wavefunction is approximated by one
single Slater-determinant, denoted as: HF
 This determinant is built from n orthonormal spin-orbitals. The spin-orbitals that
form HF are said to be occupied. The other orthonormal spin-orbitals that
follow from the Hartree-Fock calculation in a given one-electron basis set of
atomic orbitals (AOs) are known as virtual orbitals. For simplicity, we assume that
all spin-orbitals are real.
 In electron-correlation or post-Hartree-Fock methods, the wavefunction is
expanded in a many-electron basis set that consists of many determinants.
Sometimes, we only use a few determinants, and sometimes, we use millions of
them:
In this notation,  is a Slater-
CI  HF   c 

determinant that is obtained by
replacing a certain number of
occupied orbitals by virtual ones.
 Three questions: 1. Which determinants should we include?
2. How do we determine the expansion coefficients?
3. How do we evaluate the energy (or other properties)?
its.unc.edu
37
Truncated configuration interaction:
CIS, CISD, CISDT, etc.
 We start with a reference wavefunction, for example the HartreeFock determinant.
 HF    i 1 j 2 k 3 N N 
 We then select determinants for the wavefunction expansion by
substituting orbitals of the reference determinant by orbitals that
are not occupied in the reference state (virtual orbitals).
 Singles (S) indicate that 1 orbital is replaced, doubles (D) indicate
2 replacements, triples (T) indicate 3 replacements, etc., leading
to CIS, CISD, CISDT, etc.
 ia   a 1 j 2  k 3 N N  ,
its.unc.edu
 ijab   a 1b 2 k 3 N  N  ,
etc.
38
Truncated
Configuration Interaction
Number of linear variational parameters
in truncated CI for n = 10 and 2N = 40.
its.unc.edu
Level of
excitation
Number of
parameters
Example
CIS
n  (2N – n)
300
CISD
… + [n  (2N – n)] 2
78,600
CISDT
…+ [n  (2N – n)] 3
18106
…
…
…
Full CI
 2N 


 n 
 109
39
Multi-Configuration
Self-Consistent Field (MCSCF)
 The MCSCF wavefunctions consists of a few selected determinants or CSFs. In the
MCSCF method, not only the linear weights of the determinants are variationally
optimized, but also the orbital coefficients.
 One important selection is governed by the full CI space spanned by a number of
prescribed active orbitals (complete active space, CAS). This is the CASSCF method.
The CASSCF wavefunction contains all determinants that can be constructed from a
given set of orbitals with the constraint that some specified pairs of - and -spinorbitals must occur in all determinants (these are the inactive doubly occupied
spatial orbitals).
 Multireference CI wavefunctions are obtained by applying the excitation operators to
the individual CSFs or determinants of the MCSCF (or CASSCF) reference wave
function.
Internally-contracted MRCI:
MR - CISD   (ck  Cˆ1k  Cˆ 2k ) k
k
its.unc.edu
IC - MRCI   (ck  Cˆ1k ) k  Cˆ 2  dk k
k
k
40
Coupled-Cluster Theory
 System of equations is solved iteratively (the convergence is
accelerated by utilizing Pulay’s method, “direct inversion in
the iterative subspace”, DIIS).
 CCSDT model is very expensive in terms of computer
resources. Approximations are introduced for the triples:
CCSD(T), CCSD[T], CCSD-T.
 Brueckner coupled-cluster (e.g., BCCD) methods use
Brueckner orbitals that are optimized such that singles don’t
contribute.
 By omitting some of the CCSD terms, the quadratic CI method
(e.g., QCISD) is obtained.
its.unc.edu
41
Møller-Plesset
Perturbation Theory
 The Hartree-Fock function is an eigenfunction of the
n-electron operator
Fˆ .
 We apply perturbation theory as usual after decomposing the
Hamiltonian into two parts:
H  Hˆ 0   Hˆ 1
Hˆ 0   Fˆ
Hˆ 1  Hˆ  Fˆ
MP2, MP3, MP4, …etc.
number denotes order to which
energy is computed (2n+1 rule)
 More complicated with more than one reference determinant
(e.g., MR-PT, CASPT2, CASPT3, …)
its.unc.edu
42
Semi-Empirical Methods
 These methods are derived from the Hartee–Fock model, that is,





its.unc.edu
they are MO-LCAO methods.
They only consider the valence electrons.
A minimal basis set is used for the valence shell.
Integrals are restricted to one- and two-center integrals and
subsequently parametrized by adjusting the computed results to
experimental data.
Very efficient computational tools, which can yield fast
quantitative estimates for a number of properties. Can be used
for establishing trends in classes of related molecules, and for
scanning a computational poblem before proceeding with highlevel treatments.
A not of elements, especially transition metals, have not be
parametrized
43
Semi-Empirical Methods
Number 2-electron integrals (|) is n4/8, n = number of basis
functions
Treat only valence electrons explicit
Neglect large number of 2-electron integrals
Replace others by empirical parameters
Models:
•
•
•
its.unc.edu
Complete Neglect of Differential Overlap (CNDO)
Intermediate Neglect of Differential Overlap (INDO/MINDO)
Neglect of Diatomic Differential Overlap (NDDO/MNDO, AM1, PM3)
44
Approximations of 1-e
integrals
H   U    VAB
U from atomic spectra
VAB value per atom pair
B A
H  0
, on the same atom
H   ABS
 AB  1 2  A   B 
One  parameter per element
its.unc.edu
45
Popular DFT
 Noble prize in Chemistry, 1998
 In 1999, 3 of top 5 most cited
journal articles in chemistry (1st,
2nd, & 4th)
 In 2000-2003, top 3 most cited
journal articles in chemistry
 In 2004-2005, 4 of top 5 most
cited journal articles in chemistry:
its.unc.edu
•
1st, Becke’s hybrid exchange
functional (1993)
•
2nd, LYP correlation functional
(1988)
•
3rd, Becke’s exchange
functional (1988)
•
4th, PBE correlation functional
(1996)
Citations of DFT on JCP, JACS and PRL
http://www.cas.org/spotlight/bchem.html
46
Brief History of DFT
 First speculated 1920’
• Thomas-Fermi (kinetic energy) and Dirac
(exchange energy) formulas
 Officially born in 1964 with HohenbergKohn’s original proof
 GEA/GGA formulas available later 1980’
 Becoming popular later 1990’
 Pinnacled in 1998 with a chemistry Nobel
prize
its.unc.edu
47
What could expect from DFT?




LDA, ~20 kcal/mol error in energy
GGA, ~3-5 kcal/mol error in energy
G2/G3 level, some systems, ~1kcal/mol
Good at structure, spectra, & other
properties predictions
 Poor in H-containing systems, TS, spin,
excited states, etc.
its.unc.edu
48
Density Functional Theory
 Two Hohenberg-Kohn theorems:
• “Given the external potential, we know the
ground-state energy of the molecule when
we know the electron density ”.
Energy
 Hˆ 

 E  
• The energy density functional is variational.
its.unc.edu
49
But what is E[]?
E[] = TS[] + Vne[] + J[] + Vnn[] + Exc[]
 How do we compute the energy if the density is
known?
 The Coulombic interactions are easy to compute:
Enn [  ] 
nuclei

A B
Z AZB
 r  r 
, Ene [  ]    r Vext r  dr, J [  ]  12 
drdr ,
rAB
r  r
 But what about the kinetic energy TS[] and exchangecorrelation energy Exc[]?
its.unc.edu
50
Kohn-Sham Scheme
• Suppose, we know the exact
density.
• Then, we can formulate a
Slater
determinant
that
generates this exact density
(= Slater determinant of
system of N non-interacting
electrons with same density
).
• We know how to compute
the kinetic energy Ts exactly
from a Slater determinant.
• Then, the only thing
unknown is to calculate
Exc[].
its.unc.edu
Hˆ nk   nk nk ,
where
Hˆ  K  Vne ( r )  Vee ( r )  Vxc ( r )
and
K 
1 2
 ,
2
The Only
, Unknown
Za
a | r  Ra |
 ( r ) 3
Vee ( r )   
d r,

|rr |
E xc
Vxc ( r ) 
,
Vne ( r )   

 (r )   f nk | nk ( r ) |2 ,
nk
51
All about Exchange-Correlation
Energy Density Functional


QXC     f r,  r ,  2  r ,  dr
 LDA – f(r) is a function of
(r) only
 GGA – f(r) is a function of
(r) and |∇(r)|
 Mega-GGA – f(r) is also a
function of ts(r), kinetic
energy density
 Hybrid – f(r) is GGA
functional with extra
contribution from HartreeFock exchange energy
its.unc.edu
Jacob's ladder for the five generation of DFT functionals,
according to the vision of John Perdew with indication of
some of the most common DFT functionals within each rung.
52
LDA Functionals
 Thomas-Fermi formula (Kinetic) – 1
parameter
TTF    CF  
5/3
 
3
r dr, CF  3 2
10
2/3
 Slater form (exchange) – 1 parameter
E    C X  
S
X
4/3
3 1/ 3 2 / 3 1/ 3
r dr, C X  3 4 
8
 Wigner correlation – 2 parameters
 r 
ECW    a 
dr
1 / 3
1  b r 
its.unc.edu
53
Popular Functional: BLYP/B3LYP
Two most well-known functionals are the Becke exchange functional
Ex[] with 2 extra parameters  & 
E XB    E XLDA

2
4/3

,


1   2
 4/3
2
The Lee-Yang-Parr correlation functional Ec[] with 4 parameters a-d
EcLYP    a 

1
1 2  c 1 / 3 
1
2 / 3 
5/ 3


b

C


2
t

t

   e


dr
W
W
 F
1  d 1/ 3 
9
18




Together, they constitute the BLYP functional:
E xcBLYP  E xB  EcLYP    r exB  ,  dr    r ecLYP  ,  dr
The B3LYP functional is augmented with 20% of Hartree-Fock
exchange:
E
its.unc.edu
B3LYP
xc
aE E
B
x
LYP
c
N
 b  Pmn
m , n 1
N
P
k ,l 1
kl
km nl
54
Density Functionals
BLYP
HCTH
BP86
TPSS
M06-L
B3LYP
B97/2
MPW1K
MPWB1K
M06
its.unc.edu
Increasing quality and computational cost
VWN5
LDA
local density
GGA
gradient corrected
Meta-GGA
kinetic energy density
included
Hybrid
“exact” HF exchange
component
Hybrid-meta-GGA
Better scaling with system
size
Allow density fitting for even
better scaling
Meta-GGA is “bleeding
edge” and therefore largely
untested (but better in
theory…)
Hybrid makes bigger
difference in cost and
accuracy
Look at literature if
somebody
has compared functionals
for
systems similar to yours!
55
Density Functionals
Percentage of occurrences of the names of the several functionals indicated in Table 2, in
journal titles and abstracts, analyzed from the ISI Web of Science (2007).
its.unc.edu
S.F. Sousa, P.A. Fernandes and M.J. Ramos, J. Phys. Chem. A 10.1021/jp0734474 S1089-5639(07)03447-056
Problems with DFT
 ground-state theory only
 universal functional still unknown
 even hydrogen atom a problem: self-interaction
correction
 no systematic way to improve approximations
like LDA, GGA, etc.
 extension to excited states, spin multiplets,
etc., though proven exact in theory, is not
trivial in implementation and still far from
being generally accessible thus far
its.unc.edu
57
DFT Developments
 Theoretical
• Extensions to excited states, etc.
• Better functionals (mega-GGA), etc
• Understanding functional properties, etc.
 Conceptual
• More concepts proposed, like electrophilicity, philicity, spin•
philicity, surfaced-integrated Fukui fnc
Dynamic behaviors, profiles, etc.
 Computational
• Linear scaling methods
• QM/MM related issues
• Applications
its.unc.edu
58
Examples DFT vs. HF
its.unc.edu
Hydrogen molecules - using the LSDA (LDA)
59
Chemical Reactivity Theory
Chemical reactivity theory quantifies the reactive propensity of
isolated species through the introduction of a set of reactivity indices
or descriptors. Its roots go deep into the history of chemistry, as far
back as the introduction of such fundamental concepts as acid, base,
Lewis acid, Lewis base, etc. It pervades almost all of chemistry.
-- Morrel H. Cohen, and Adam Wasserman, J. Phys. Chem. A 2007, 111,2229
 Molecular Orbital Theory
•
•
•
•
Fukui’s Frontier Orbital (HOMO/LUMO) model
Woodward-Hoffman rules
Well developed: Nobel prize in Chemistry, 1981
Problem: conceptual simplicity disappears as computational
accuracy increases because it’s based on the molecular orbital
description
 Density Functional Theory (DFT)
• Conceptual DFT, also called Chemical DFT, DF Reactivity Theory
• Proposed by Robert G. Parr of UNC-CH, 1980s
• Still in development
its.unc.edu
60
DFT Reactivity Theory
 General Consideration
• E  E [N, (r)]  E []
• Taylor Expansion: Perturbation resulted from an
external attacking agent leading to changes in N and
(r), N and (r),
E  E N  N , r    r   E N , r 
 E 

 N 
 N 

 E 

  r dr 
  r   N
1   2 E 
2

N
2

2 
2!  N 



   E  


  N r dr 
 N   r   
N 



  2E 

  r  r 'drdr '
  2 r  


N
Assumptions: existence and well-behavior of all above partial/functional derivatives
its.unc.edu
61
Conceptual DFT
 Basic assumptions
• E  E [N, (r)]  E []
• Chemical processes, responses, and changes
expressible via Taylor expansion
• Existence, continuous, and well-behavedness
of the partial derivatives
its.unc.edu
62
DFT Reactivity Indices
 Electronegativity (chemical potential)
 HOMO   LUMO
 E 
 
 
2
 N 
 Hardness / Softness
1   2 E   LUMO   HOMO
   2  
, S  1/
2  N 
2
 Maximum Hardness Principle (MHP)
its.unc.edu
63
DFT Reactivity Indices
 Fukui
function f r     r  
 N 
– Nucleophilic attack
f  r    N 1 r    N r 
– Electrophilic attack
f  r    N r    N 1 r 
– Free radical activity
f  r   f  r 
f r  
2
its.unc.edu
64
Electrophilicity Index
2

2
Physical meaning: suppose an
electrophile is immersed in an electron
sea
1
E   N   N 2
2
The maximal electron flow and
accompanying energy decrease are
N max
Emin
its.unc.edu
2

2
2


2
Parr, Szentpaly, Liu, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121, 1922(1999).
65
Experiment vs. Theory
log (k) = s(E+N)
2

2
Pérez, P. J. Org. Chem. 2003, 68, 5886. Pérez, P.; Aizman, A.; Contreras, R. J. Phys. Chem. A 2002, 106, 3964.
its.unc.edu
66
Minimum Electrophilicity Principle
 Analogous to the maximum hardness principle (MHP)
 Separately proposed by Noorizadeh and Chattaraj
 Concluded that “the natural direction of a chemical reaction is
toward a state of minimum electrophilicity.”
Noorizadeh, S. Chin. J. Chem. 2007, 25, 1439.
Noorizadeh, S. J. Phys. Org. Chem. 2007, 20, 514.
Chattaraj, P.K. Ind. J. Phys. Proc. Ind. Natl. Sci. Acad. Part A 2007, 81, 871.
non-
1
2
3
-0.093
-0.093
4
5
6
7
LA
Aa
-0.091
0.085
Bb
-0.089
-
-0.172
-
-0.088
-0.089
-0.171
0.246
-0.083
-0.090
-
-0.087
-0.0842
-
0.087
-0.230
-0.220
0.247
Bb
-0.087
0.088
0.084
Aa
-
-
0.0892
-0.226
-0.2518
0.218
-0.247
-0.233
0.221
0.2161
-0.226
-0.2506
0.2157
its.unc.edu
67
Yue
Xia, Dulin Yin, Chunying Rong, Qiong Xu, Donghong Yin, and Shubin Liu, J. Phys. Chem. A, 2008, 112, 9970.
Nucleophilicity
 Much harder to quantify, because it related to local
hardness, which is ambiguous in definition.
 A nucleophile can be a good donor for one electrophile
but bad for another, leading to the difficulty to define a
universal scale of nucleophilicity for an nucleophile.
2
1    B 
  A
    A
2   A B 
 = -N - ½ S()2
Minimizing  in Eq. (14) with respect to ,
one has
=-N and  = - ½ N2.
Making use of the following relation
N
 A  B
 A B
Jaramillo, P.; Perez, P.; Contreras, R.; Tiznado, W.; Fuentealba, P. J. Phys. Chem. A 2006, 110, 8181.
its.unc.edu
68
Philicity and Fugality
 Philicity: defined as ·f(r)
• Chattaraj, Maiti, & Sarkar, J. Phys. Chem. A 107, 4973(2003)
• Still a very controversial concept, see JPCA 108, 4934(2004); Chattaraj,
et al. JPCA, in press.
 Spin-Philicity: defined same as  but in spin resolution
• Perez, Andres, Safont, Tapia, & Contreras. J. Phys. Chem. A 106,
5353(2002)
 Nuclofugality & Electrofugality
(   )2
En   A   
2
(   )2
Ee  I   
2
Ayers, P.W.; Anderson, J.S.M.; Rodriguez, J.I.; Jawed, Z. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2005, 7, 1918.
Ayers, P.W.; Anderson, J S.M.; Bartolotti, L.J. Int. J. Quantum Chem. 2005, 101, 520.
its.unc.edu
69
Dual Descriptors
3rd-order cross-term derivatives
2


f 2 r    2
 N


f 2 r dr  0
 E 


  r  N
   2E 

 


2


  r   N 


 
f 2r  f

r  f  r 

   f r     

N    r  N

N
f 2r   LUMO r   HOMO r 
Recovering Woodward-Hoffman rules!
its.unc.edu
Ayers, P.W.; Morell, C., De Proft, D.; Geerlings, P. Chem. Eur. J., 2007, 13, 8240
70
Geerling, P. De Proft F. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2008, 10, 3028
Steric Effect
 one of the most widely used
concepts in chemistry
 originates from the space occupied
by atom in a molecule
 previous work attributed to the
electron exchange correlation
 Weisskopf thought of as “kinetic
energy pressure”
Weisskopf, V.F., Science 187, 605-612(1975).
its.unc.edu
71
Steric effect: a DFT description
Assume
since
E[] ≡ Es[] + Ee[] + Eq[]
E[] = Ts[] + Vne[] + J[] + Vnn[] + Exc[]
Ee[] = Vne[] + J[] + Vnn[]
Eq[] = Exc[] + EPauli[] = Exc[] + Ts[] - Tw[]
Es[] ≡ E[] - Ee[] - Eq[] = Tw[]
we have
1
TW   
8

 r 
 r 
2
dr
S.B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys. 2007, 126, 244103.
S.B. Liu and N. Govind, J. Phys. Chem. A 2008, 112, 6690.
S.B. Liu, N. Govind, and L.G. Pedersen, J. Chem. Phys. 2008, 129, 094104.
M. Torrent-Sucarrat, S.B. Liu and F. De Proft, J. Phys. Chem. A 2009, 113, 3698.
its.unc.edu
72
Experiment vs. Theory
 In 1956, Taft constructed a scale for the steric effect of different substituents,
based on rate constants for the acid-catalyzed hydrolysis of esters in aqueous
acetone. It was shown that log(k / k0) was insensitive to polar effects and thus,
in the absence of resonance interactions, this value can be considered as being
proportional to steric effects. Hydrogen is taken to have a reference value of
EsTaft= 0
its.unc.edu
73
QM/MM Example:
Triosephosphate Isomerase (TIM)
DHAP
H2
O
GAP
494 Residues, 4033 Atoms, PDB ID: 7TIM
Function: DHAP (dihydroxyacetone phosphate) GAP (glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate)
its.unc.edu
74
TIM 2-step 2-residue Mechanism
DHAP
GAP
Glu 165 (the catalytic base), His 95 (the proton shuttle)
its.unc.edu
75
QM/MM: 1st Step of TIM
Mechanism
QM/MM size: 6051 atoms
QM Size: 37 atoms
QM: Gaussian’98
Method: HF/3-21G
MM: Tinker
Force field: AMBER all-atom
Number of Water: 591 Model for Water: TIP3P
MD details: 20x20x20 Å3 box, optimize until the RMS energy
gradient less than 1.0 kcal/mol/Å. 20 psec MD. Time step 2fs.
SHAKE, 300 K, short range cutoff 8 Å, long range cutoff 15 Å.
its.unc.edu
76
QM/MM: Transition State
=====================
Energy Barrier (kcal/mol)
------------------------------------QM/MM
21.9
Experiment
14.0
=====================
its.unc.edu
77
What’s New: Linear Scaling
O(N) Method
 Numerical Bottlenecks:
•
•
•
diagonalization ~N3
100
orthonormalization ~N3
90
matrix element evaluation ~N2-N4
80
 Computational Complexity: N log N
 Theoretical Basis: near-sightedness of density
matrix or orbitals
 Strategy:
•
•
CPU se conds pe r CG ste p
70
60
Diagonalization
50
40
sparsity of localized orbital or density
matrix
30
direct minimization with conjugate
gradient
OLMO
NOLMO
20
10
 Models: divide-and-conquer and variational
0
0
methods
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
Atoms
 Applicability: ~10,000 atoms, dynamics
its.unc.edu
78
What Else … ?
 Solvent effect
• Implicit model vs. explicit model






its.unc.edu
Relativity effect
Transition state
Excited states
Temperature and pressure
Solid states (periodic boundary condition)
Dynamics (time-dependent)
79
Limitations and Strengths
of ab initio quantum
chemistry
its.unc.edu
80
Popular QM codes
its.unc.edu
Gaussian
(Ab Initio, Semi-empirical, DFT)
Gamess-US/UK
(Ab Initio, DFT)
Spartan
(Ab Initio, Semi-empirical, DFT)
NWChem
(Ab Initio, DFT, MD, QM/MM)
MOPAC/2000
(Semi-Empirical)
DMol3/CASTEP
(DFT)
Molpro
(Ab initio)
ADF
(DFT)
ORCA
(DFT)
81
Reference Books
 Computational Chemistry (Oxford Chemistry Primer) G. H.
Grant and W. G. Richards (Oxford University Press)
 Molecular Modeling – Principles and Applications, A. R. Leach
(Addison Wesley Longman)
 Introduction to Computational Chemistry, F. Jensen (Wiley)
 Essentials of Computational Chemistry – Theories and Models,
C. J. Cramer (Wiley)
 Exploring Chemistry with Electronic Structure Methods, J. B.
Foresman and A. Frisch (Gaussian Inc.)
its.unc.edu
82
Questions & Comments
Please direct comments/questions about research computing to
E-mail: [email protected]
Please direct comments/questions pertaining to this presentation to
E-Mail: [email protected]
The PPT format of this presentation is available here:
http://its2.unc.edu/divisions/rc/training/scientific/
/afs/isis/depts/its/public_html/divisions/rc/training/scientific/short_courses/
its.unc.edu
83
Hands-on: Part I
Purpose: to get to know the available ab
initio and semi-empirical methods in the
Gaussian 03 / GaussView package
• ab initio methods
 Hartree-Fock
 MP2
 CCSD
• Semiempirical methods
 AM1
The WORD .doc format of this hands-on exercises is available here:
http://its2.unc.edu/divisions/rc/training/scientific/
/afs/isis/depts/its/public_html/divisions/rc/training/scientific/short_courses/labDirections_compchem_2009.doc
its.unc.edu
84
Hands-on: Part II
Purpose: To use LDA and GGA DFT
methods to calculate IR/Raman spectra
in vacuum and in solvent. To build
QM/MM models and then use DFT
methods to calculate IR/Raman spectra
• DFT
 LDA (SVWN)
 GGA (B3LYP)
• QM/MM
its.unc.edu
85