Transcript Slide 1

State Health Plan 2011-2016
Access To Care Workgroup
Troy Alexander
Texas Department of State Health Services
Director, Centers for Program Coordination,
Policy, and Innovation
February 19, 2010
Presentation Purpose
• To share preliminary thoughts on workforce
implications with respect to access to care
• Not a comprehensive review
• Seeking input on missing gaps
2
Presentation Outline
Uninsured
Access
To
Care
Health Disparities
Primary Care & Beyond
Various Populations
3
Uninsured Population
• Health insurance
– Contributes significantly to an individual’s ability
to access healthcare services
• Inability to access primary care
– Leads to costly hospital treatment for preventable
health problems
4
Uninsured Population
• Increasing numbers of uninsured
– Places extraordinary economic burden upon
health care community
• Texas leads the nation in the percentage of
uninsured adults and children
5
Uninsured Population, Total
5.4% - 11.1%
11.3 - 13.2%
13.6% - 16.2%
16.6% - 25.2%
Uninsured: Total
Population (2008)
TX
U.S.
25.2%
15.4%
Source: Kaiser Family
6
Uninsured Adults, 19–64 Years
7.3% - 14.4%
14.4 - 17.8%
17.9% - 21.6%
21.8% - 31.5%
Uninsured Adults
19-64 Years (2008)
TX
31.5%
U.S.
21.4%
Source: Kaiser Family
7
Uninsured Children, 0-18 Years
3.2% - 6.5%
6.7 - 9.1%
9.3% - 11.4%
12.0% - 20.1%
Uninsured Children
0-18 Years (2008)
TX
20.1%
U.S.
10.3%
Source: Kaiser Family
8
Where are the uninsured Texans?
• 80% uninsured population reside in 35 of the
state’s 254 counties
• Common misconception
– Uninsured are concentrated along the TexasMexico border
9
Where are the uninsured Texans?
• Five counties account for
close to half of the
uninsured statewide
–
–
–
–
–
Dallam
Sherman Hansford Ochiltree Lipscomb
Hartley
Moore Hutchinson
Roberts Hemphill
Oldham
Potter
Deaf Smith
Randall
Parmer
Carson
Gray
Armstrong Donley
Castro
Swisher
Briscoe
Lamb
Hale
Floyd
Hall
Wheeler
Collingsworth
Childress
Hardeman
Harris
Dallas
Bexar
Tarrant
El Paso
Bailey
Motley
Cottle
Foard
Wilbarger
Wichita
Clay
CochranHockley Lubbock Crosby
Hudspeth
• Access to care is not just
an issue for border and
rural areas
Terry
Lynn
Garza
Kent
King
Knox
Baylor
Cooke
Montague
Archer
Stonewall HaskellThrockmorton
Young
Jack
Wise
Grayson
Fannin
Red
Lamar
River
Delta Franklin
Bowie
TitusMorrisCass
Camp
Rockwall
Rains
Marion
Palo
Gaines
Dawson Borden Scurry
Fisher
Shackelford
Parker
Wood Upshur
Tarrant Dallas
Jones
Stephens Pinto
Kaufman
Harrison
V an
Gregg
Zandt
Hood Johnson
Smith
Andrews
Henderson
Martin Howard Mitchell Nolan
Callahan Eastland
Ellis
Erath
Somervell
Taylor
Rusk Panola
Hill
Ector
Navarro
Midland
Comanche
Runnels
Anderson
Bosque
Loving Winkler
Sterling Coke
Shelby
Coleman
Cherokee
Glasscock
Freestone
Brown
Hamilton
NacogdochesSan
McLennan Limestone
Culberson
Ward
Crane
Mills
Augustine
Reagan
Houston
Coryell
Tom
Sabine
Reeves
Upton
Concho
Angelina
Leon
Irion
Green
McCulloch
Falls
Lampasas
Newton
San
Trinity
Robertson
Bell
Saba
Madison
Jasper
Schleicher Menard
Polk
Pecos
Jeff Davis
Tyler
Burnet
Milam
Crockett
Mason
Walker San
Llano
Williamson
Brazos
Jacinto
Grimes
Sutton
Kimble
Burleson
Gillespie
Hardin
Lee
Montgomery
Blanco
Travis
Liberty
Orange
Terrell
Washington
Presidio
Bastrop
Kerr
Hays
Waller
Brewster
Edwards
Kendall
Austin
Val Verde
Harris
Jefferson
Caldwell
Fayette
Chambers
Real
Comal
Bandera
Fort
Colorado
Guadalupe
Bend
Galveston
Gonzales
Medina
Bexar
Lavaca
Uvalde
Kinney
Wharton
Brazoria
Wilson
DeWitt
Jackson
Maverick
Atascosa
Frio
Matagorda
Karnes
Zavala
Victoria
Goliad
Calhoun
Bee
Dimmit
Live
La
McMullen Oak
Refugio
Aransas
Salle
Yoakum
El Paso
Dickens
W ebb
Duval
Jim
Wells
Denton
Collin
Hunt
Hopkins
San
Patricio
Nueces
Kleberg
Zapata
Jim
Hogg
Brooks
Kenedy
Starr
Hidalgo
Willacy
Cameron
10
Who are the uninsured Texans?
• Moderate to Low-Income Texans
• Texans Who Do Not Receive Insurance Through
Their Jobs
• Texans Who Work in Small Businesses
• Texans Who Can Afford It, But Don’t Want It
• Texans Eligible for, but not Enrolled in Government
Programs
– 3 out of 4 uninsured Texas children are eligible for
Medicaid or CHIP but are not enrolled
• Texans with Catastrophic Medical Bills
• Immigrants
11
Emergency Medical Treatment
• Federal Emergency Medical Treatment and
Active Labor Act (EMTALA)
– Assures access to emergency medical care
services
– Payments are below costs or unfunded
– Utilization of emergency medical care services
are not financially sustainable
• Hospital Diversions
– Impacts access to timely and more geographical
or culturally appropriate care
12
Consequences of Uninsured
• Increasing numbers of uninsured Texans may
result in…
– Increased medical insurance costs
– Higher expenditures in health services,
emergency care and physician services
• Uninsured individuals postpone preventive
measures and early disease treatments with
resulting…
– Poorer health that impacts attendance and
performance in schools and the overall workforce
– Shorter lives
13
Workforce Implication
• Increased demand for health care
• Limited availability of healthcare
professionals
• Texas currently has insufficient workforce
capacity to accommodate the uninsured,
much less the newly insured and individuals
with existing insurance coverage
14
Health Disparities
Uninsured
Access
To
Care
Health Disparities
Primary Care & Beyond
Various Populations
15
Health Disparities
• Linked with social or economic disadvantage
• Adversely affected groups of people who have
systematically experienced greater social and/or
economic obstacles to health, including:
–
–
–
–
–
–
Racial or ethnic groups
Religious determination or groups
Socioeconomic status
Gender
Geographic location
Persons with mental illness or substance abuse,
cognitive, sensory or physical disability
– Other characteristics historically linked to discrimination or
exclusion such as homeless or incarcerated persons
16
Health Disparities
• Challenges associated with providing health
care to individuals affected by health
disparities
– Communication
– Cultural relevance
– Diversity of physicians and health care
professionals
– Generalization and stereotyping
17
Health Disparities
• Healthcare access includes a consumer’s (or
potential consumer’s) ability to locate
providers
– Deliver individualized services that address their
unique needs
– Have offices located within a close geographical
proximity to where the consumer lives
– Can develop a relationship based on mutual
respect, open communication, and trust
18
Health Disparities in Texas
Population Breakdown
White
Black
4.4%
45.9%
38.1%
Hispanic
11.6%
Asian, Native
American, and
other
race/ethnicities
• Diverse population
• Population increasing faster than the national rate
19
Health Disparities in Texas
2009 PC Physicians
Other
42%
White
White
58%
Other
• In 2009, the majority of the state’s PC physicians
were White
• Blacks and Hispanics have historically been underrepresented
20
Health Disparities in Texas
• Disproportionately impacted by already
existent workforce shortages
• Exacerbated by shortages of culturally
competent workers for disadvantage
populations
21
2009 Texas Supply Ratios
Licensed Healthcare Professionals
• Supply ratio is the number of health care professionals per
100,000 population
• Lower supply ratios for most licensed healthcare
professionals than the overall U.S.
• LVNs are a notable exception
• Ratios are higher in metropolitan counties than
nonmetropolitan counties
• Non-border area has higher ratios than border areas
• Panhandle, West Texas, and South Texas counties often
have lower supply ratios than the rest of the state; with most
of those counties having no providers
• For most professions, the largest growth in supply has
occurred in Central, East, and North-east Texas
22
Disparities:
Culturally Competent Care
• Meaningful Material in Curricula
– Need for curricula to include unique cultural
factors
• Healthcare Quality Improvements
– Disparities in quality of care have stayed the
same or worsened for ethnic groups
• International Medical Graduates
– Helps to address PC shortage outside MSAs
– Double culture increases complexity of
communication
23
Disparities:
Need for Health Literacy
• Populations most likely to experience low health literacy
– Older adults, racial and ethnic minorities, individuals with less than a
high school degree or GED certificate,
– People with low income levels,
– Non-native speakers of English, and
– People with compromised health status
• Persons with limited health literacy skills
– More likely to skip or not understand the importance of taking
preventive measures
– Have a higher rate of hospitalization and use of emergency services
• Much of health information is written at college level
• Health literacy automatically limits many minorities from
participating in chemical dependency research studies
24
Primary Care & Beyond
Uninsured
Access
To
Care
Health Disparities
Primary Care & Beyond
Various Populations
25
Primary Care & Beyond
• Primary care includes
– Health promotion, disease prevention, health maintenance,
counseling, patient education, diagnosis and treatment of acute and
chronic illnesses in a variety of health care settings
• Access is affected by several factors
–
–
–
–
Economic
Health insurance
Geographic, and
Availability of PC and specialty care providers
• Supply and distribution of numerous types of health
professionals may affect
– Timeliness of access, and
– Therapeutic milieu available to treat certain types of conditions
• Need to access different types of health care providers
– Not just primary care
26
Findings:
Primary Care Physicians
• The Texas PC-to-population ratio = 67.7
– Lags behind the national ratio = ~80
• Whole County PC HPSAs
– 118 of 254 Texas counties designated
• Partial PC HPSAs
– 16 additional counties designated
27
Findings:
Physician Assistants (PA)
• Texas (18.3) has fewer PAs per number of
persons than the national ratio (~24)
• Lower ratio in nonmetropolitan areas than
metropolitan areas
• Augmenting roles for PAs in areas including
• Primary care services
• Hospital inpatient services
• Teaching centers
28
Findings:
Nursing Professions
• Advanced Practice Nurses (APNs)
– Authorization by the Board of Nursing
– To practice as…
•
•
•
•
Nurse Practitioner (NP)
Certified Nurse Midwife (CNM)
Clinical Nurse Specialist (CNS), or
Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA)
29
Nurse Practitioners (NP)
• Texas (17.1) has fewer NPs per number of
persons than the national ratio (~39)
• Highest NP ratios are in the northern parts of
the state
• Higher ratios in metropolitan counties than
nonmetropolitan counties
• 59 counties have no NPs
30
Certified Nurse Midwives (CNM)
• Texas lags the U.S. in the supply of CNMs
relative to the female population of
childbearing age, 15 to 44 years
• Compared to other health professions, Texas
has very few CNMs
• 211 Texas counties without a CNM (2009)
31
Registered Nurses (RN)
• More RNs in Texas than any other health
profession
– Texas (681.2) lags behind the U.S. in the number
of RNs-to-population (~835)
• In 2009, only four counties did not have an
RN
32
Findings: Optometrists
(Doctors of Optometry)
• Texas lags behind the U.S. in supply ratios of
optometrists
– In 2009, there were 108 counties without an
optometrist
– For lower Panhandle area and portions of West
Texas - one would have to travel through several
counties to reach an optometrist
– Border counties also have very low supply ratios
– 19 of 32 border counties have no optometrists
33
Findings: Dentists
• Dental Health Professional Shortage Area (HPSA) –
Oct 2009
– 111 Texas counties had some type of designation, and
– 44 counties with no dentists; most of these were in the
Panhandle, West Texas, and South Texas
• Slight net increase in supply of dentists (37.8) in
Texas
– Still significantly below the national average (~65)
• Border counties have fewer dentists than
nonmetropolitan non-border areas
– Widening gap in supply between metropolitan and
nonmetropolitan counties
34
Findings: Community
Health Workers (CHW)
• Low numbers of certified CHWs or promotores(as)
– 605 certified CHWs located in 47 Texas counties (Sept
2009)
– Harris County with the highest number
• 191 CHWs
– Several counties having just one or two
– State also has uncertified CHWs
• Certified training programs
– Only ten counties in the state
– Limits access to, and the ability of potential community
health workers to complete required training for
certification
35
Findings: Community Health
Workers (CHW)
• Represents an emerging resource
• Helps overcome barriers to healthcare and
increases access to services, especially for
disproportionately affected populations
• Can contribute to community development
• Can improve coverage and access in environments
where formal health care services are limited or
hard to access
• The role of PHWs and CHWS within the Texas
health care delivery system may need to be
clarified.
36
Findings Related to Pharmacists
• State experienced a steady increase in the number
of pharmacists
• Texas pharmacist-to-population ratios (78.7)
exceed U.S. ratios
– (Based on 1982 through 2003 data. Recent U.S. data are
unavailable)
• Even though the ratios have increased for Texas as
a whole since 2000, 137 counties have experienced
a decline in the ratios
• In 2009, 29 counties were without a pharmacist
37
Findings:
Behavioral Health Professionals
• Insufficient mental health workforce supply to
meet future demand
– Workforce supply trends
– Distribution problems
– High turnover rates
– Anticipated retirement of current workers, and
– Projected state mental health job growth rate of
20% or more
• 172 of 254 state counties are designated as
an MH shortage area
38
Findings:
Behavioral Health Professionals
• Behavioral healthcare is provided by a wide range
of licensed professionals
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Psychiatrists
Psychologists
Primary care physicians
Social workers, and licensed marriage and family
therapists
Psychiatric nurses, and
Licensed professional counselors
Licensed chemical dependency counselors
Paraprofessionals (ex. Qualified mental health
professionals, psychiatric technicians, etc.)
39
Findings:
Behavioral Health Professionals
• In 2009 , the Texas supply ratio for specialists
in psychiatry/psychoanalysis field was 6.6
• Ratio of specialists decreased from 6.8 in
1990
• Most located in major urban areas
– Some in less populated counties containing state
psychiatric hospitals
40
Findings:
Behavioral Health Professionals
• Few child psychiatrists in Texas (based on 2005 data)
– 190 child psychiatrists
– Supply ratio of 2.9, children ages 0-18
• No significant increase for psychologists
– Counties in South Texas, West Texas, and the Panhandle had lower
ratios; most of these counties did not have any psychologist
– Compared to five states with the largest populations, Texas has the
lowest supply of psychologists
•
•
•
•
•
Texas = 24.2,
New York = 49.9
Illinois = 43.3
California = 40.4
Florida at 27.1
41
Findings:
Behavioral Health Professionals
• Social workers
– Among the five states with the largest populations, Texas
has the lowest supply ratio
•
•
•
•
•
Texas = 68.2
New York = 188.1
Illinois = 164.4
California = 124.7
Florida = 109.4
• Supply ratios of other professions that support
mental healthcare have declined
• The supply gap likely to become even wider due to
many factors
– Aging workforce retiring
– Fewer people entering the profession
42
Findings:
Behavioral Health Professionals
• Texas imports more psychiatrists from out of state
than it graduates from its medical schools
• Texas state agencies that serve persons with
mental health disorders consistently report
difficulties recruiting
– Mental health professionals (especially in rural areas)
– Employees who serve persons with mental disorders
such as teachers, probation officers
• High turnover rates also pose a problem
43
Presentation Discussion
Uninsured
Access
To
Care
•
•
•
•
Persons with Disabilities
Rural Population
Children and Adolescents
Elderly
Health Disparities
Primary Care & Beyond
Various Populations
44
Findings: Persons with Disabilities
• Many definitions of disability
– Texas has its own definition of developmental disabilities
– Based on eligibility requirements to some services
• The need for skilled medical interventions
• Limitations in functional abilities
• Access to health care for persons with disabilities
differ than those without disabilities
• Constrained access includes more than physical
access to buildings, but also access to services,
information, care and support
– To respond adequately to health care needs of this
population, providers need to view this population in
terms of their specific health needs and not strictly in
terms of their disability
45
Findings:
Persons with Disabilities
• 20% of the population live with some kind of disability
• Nationally, adults with disabilities have significantly…
–
–
–
–
Lower self-reported health status,
Increased disease rates,
Higher incidence of suicide, and
Higher incidence of unhealthy behaviors
• Shortage of physician specialists and a severe shortage of
subspecialists
• Limited number of training programs
– devoted to producing physicians with expertise in treating individuals
with developmental disablities
• Preventable secondary conditions
– Lack of awareness and responsiveness by clinical and public health
professionals about this population
46
Findings:
Persons with Disabilities
• Need for Transition medicine
• Disparities between Children’s Medicaid and
Adult Medicaid programs
• More study needed in this subject area
47
Findings: Rural Areas
• Lack of access to care cor populations living
in rural areas is well documented
• Workforce shortage will most likely continue
• Vulnerability to workforce shortages
– small population size and scale
– loss of just one physician can have profound
effects
• Attracting and retaining practicing physicians
in rural areas is a concern
48
Findings:
Children and Adolescents
• Child and adolescent psychiatrists are in great demand
• The number of child and adolescent psychiatrists practicing
in the U.S. has not changed much in the last two decades
– rural and poor populations clearly have the greatest shortage
• Surgeon General estimates only 20% of children with mental
illness obtain any care at all
• Families turn to primary care for at least initial care for
common mental health problems
• An opportunity to expand the role of primary care for early
identification and interventions of adolescents in need of
mental health services
49
Findings:
Elderly
• Growing elderly population in Texas may delay or
forgo care because of these factors
• Services and resources are required at a
disproportionately higher rate
• Health care costs is a significant factors associated
with lack of access
• Trends
– Substantial aging of the population
– High co-morbidity rates for seniors (or elderly)
– Likely that the percentage of the population as a whole
who have a disability will increase
50
Questions??
51