Transcript Module 5 - TV Worldwide
FRAUD PREVENTATION PROGRAMS(ANTI-FRAUD) The Institute of Internal Auditors June 8, 2004
Ed Dudley, CIA, CPA Retired Vice-President & General Auditor-ABB Americas 1
2
Agenda
• • • • • • •
Introduction & Overview
Ed Dudley
Strategy to Address Fraud Issues
George Farragher
Fraud Risk Assessment
Jonny Frank
Prevention and Detection of Fraud
Claudius Modesti
Fraud Prevention in the Corporate Environment
Joe Hendrix Break Q & A
Key Prevention Issues
• • • • • •
Fraud Policy Guidelines and Limitations Fraud Risk Profile Objectives of Approach to Fraud Key Performance Indicators Fraud Risk Assessment & Link to COSO Anti-Fraud Program Implementation Plan 3
Key Prevention Issues
(cont’d)
• • • • •
PCAOB-Auditing Standard #2
–
Fraud Considerations
–
Oversight of Audit Committee Organizational Culture Verification of compliance Testing for High Fraud Risk Role of PCAOB Div. of Enforcement 4
Key Prevention Issues
(cont’d)
• • • • •
Fraud Prevention - Corporate Environment
– –
Policies Scope Role of Corporate Compliance Office Business Conduct Code Provisions Fraud Reporting Role of Fraud Council 5
6
Developing a Strategy to Address Fraud Issues
George Farragher, CPA, CFE Global Investigations & Dispute Advisory Ernst & Young LLP
Fraud Policy Guidelines & Limitations
Guidelines:
–
Define tolerance for fraud – All allegations investigated
–
Agree what action will be taken
• • •
Restitution Termination And/or prosecution
–
Policy is global 7 Limitations:
– – – –
Investigations divert resources Cost benefit Reactive vs. proactive approach Management risk
•
Regulatory, reputation and business risk
8
Fraud Risk Profile
• • • • •
Environment Industry factors Domestic and global locations Corporate focus Fast growing and continuous changing business Liability exposure and legal requirements
Objectives of Proposed Approach
9 Short Term
– –
Provide immediate relief to current backlog Develop foundation for sustainable fraud prevention and investigation process
–
Ability to respond immediately to concerns in a coordinated manner
–
Address issues early in the process, before material damages incurred
–
Quality - ensure investigations are managed in manner that will not create liability
10
Objectives of Proposed Approach
Long Term
–
Develop a sustainable model for effectively and efficiently investigating fraud
– – –
Cost efficiency Improve overall risk profile Develop process remediation loop within the organization
•
Source of feedback for ongoing process improvement
–
Conduct proactive audits and investigations based on trends/data collected from historical frauds
11
Key Performance Indicators
Balanced Scorecard - Identification of success factors
–
Reporting and measuring value – fraud stopped/avoided
– – – – –
Timely resolution of incidence Timely reporting of resolution and remediation Cost recovery/ restitution Referrals to authorities Feedback to the organization
•
Internal Audit
Thank You !
12
• George P. Farragher CPA, CFE – – –
Global Investigations & Dispute Advisory 925 Euclid Avenue, Suite 1300 Cleveland, Ohio 44115-1476
– – –
216-583-1356 tel 216-583-2595 fax
Fraud Risk Assessments: Cornerstone of Effective Antifraud Programs & Controls
Jonny Frank, JD, LLM Fraud Risks & Controls PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP 13
SEC Rules and PCAOB
Auditing Standards Require Antifraud Programs & Controls Which Meet All Five Components of COSO
• •
Control Environment
– – – – – –
Code of conduct/ethics Ethics hotline Hiring and promotion Audit committee oversight Investigative process Remediation Fraud Risk Assessment
– – –
Systematic process Level within organization Likelihood and significance
• • •
Control Activities
–
Linking controls to identified fraud risks Information/Communication
– – –
Information systems & technology Knowledge management Training Monitoring
– –
Ongoing monitoring by management Separate “after the fact” evaluations by internal audit 14
Fraud Risk Assessment Is The Foundation Of An Effective Antifraud Program
• • •
Active audit committee oversight Systematic, Not Haphazard Scheme & Scenario Based
– – –
Fraudulent financial reporting Misappropriation of assets Unauthorized or improper use and disposition of assets
–
Unauthorized acquisition of assets
–
Fraud of any magnitude by senior management
•
Vulnerability to circumvention and management override 15
Fraud Risk Assessment Is The Foundation Of An Effective Antifraud Program (cont’d)
• • •
Considers:
– – –
Incentives and pressures Likelihood Significance and magnitude Occurs:
– –
On a recurring basis When special circumstances arise, e.g. changed operating environments, new products and markets, corporate restructurings Conducted at the company-wide, business unit and significant account levels 16
Antifraud Program Implementation Plan
Key Elements of Antifraud Whitepaper
Step 1:
Create a Baseline: • Assess Existing Antifraud Programs & Controls • Develop & Remediate Plan IA Whitepaper Appendix A
Step 2:
Organize a Fraud and Reputation-Risk Assessment
Step 3:
Evaluate & Test Design & Operating Effectiveness IA Whitepaper pp. 30-32 IA Whitepaper pp. 17-25
Step 2.1:
Organize Assessment by Business Cycle or Separate Fraud Cycle
Step 2.2:
Determine Units & Locations to Assess
Step 2.3:
Identify Potential Fraud Misconduct Schemes & Scenarios
Step 2.4:
Assess Likelihood of Fraud and Significance of Risk
Step 2.5:
Link Antifraud Control Activities
17 Step 4:
Address Residual Risks IA Whitepaper pp. 29
Step 5:
Standardize Process for Incident Investigation and Remediation • Disciplinary & legal action • Recovery/restoration of losses & other damages • Consideration of how and why fraud occurred • Determination of whether controls were non existent, circumvented, and/or overridden • Explanation to senior management and audit committee regarding likelihood of recurrence
Additional Information and Guidance
• • • •
PwC, Key Elements of Antifraud Programs and Controls (December 2003) available at www.internalaudit.com
PwC, Emerging Role of Internal Audit in Addressing Fraud and Reputation Risk (April 2004) available at www.internalaudit.com
J. Frank, Fraud Risk Assessments (Internal Auditor April 2004) J. Frank, A New Audience for COSO (BNA Compliance Reporter, April 19, 2004) 18
Additional Information and Guidance
Contact Information: Jonny Frank Tel. 646-471-8590 Email: [email protected]
19
20
Prevention and Detection of Fraud
Claudius Modesti, Esquire Director Division of Enforcement and Investigations PCAOB
Disclaimer
• •
The views I express today are my own and do
not
necessarily represent the views of the Board Members or staff of the PCAOB In addition my participation in this webcast should not be considered any endorsement to any entity or sponsor supporting this webcast 21
22
• • •
Detection and Prevention of Fraud
General Comments
–
New Paradigm
–
Organization Culture
–
Robust Internal Controls PCAOB – Auditing Standard # 2
–
Fraud Considerations
–
Significant Deficiency – Material Weakness Division of Enforcement and Investigations within PCAOB
New Paradigm - Role of Audit Committee and Internal Auditors PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 2 paragraph 140 23 Following should be regarded as at least a significant deficiency and a strong indicator that a material weakness exists: “…Oversight of the company’s external financial reporting and internal control over financial reporting by the company’s audit committee is ineffective.
The internal audit function or risk assessment function is ineffective at a company for which such function needs to be effective… Identification of fraud of any magnitude on the part of senior management”
24
How to Prevent Fraud
• •
Organization Culture - Ethics Internal Control
25
How to Prevent Fraud Organization Culture - Ethics
• • •
Tone at the Top
– – –
Corporate culture Message communicated – what is important?
Unethical behavior not tolerated Clear Expectations of all Employees
– –
Codes of Conduct (ethics, conflict, fraud, etc.) Certifications as to compliance Compensation – Incentives
26
How to Prevent Fraud Internal Control
• •
Robust Policies and Procedures Verification of Compliance therewith
–
Internal Audit
–
External Audit
•
Continued Education - Training
27 PCAOB - Auditing Standard No. 2 Controls Addressing Risk of Fraud
• • • • •
Auditor should evaluate all controls specifically intended to address the risk of fraud that may have a material effect on financial statements, including but not limited to: Controls restraining misappropriation of assets Company’s risk assessment processes Code of ethics/conduct – monitoring/enforcing by Board and Audit Committee Adequacy of internal audit activity and extent of Audit Committee’s involvement Adequacy of handling complaints (See p. 24 of Auditing Standard No. 2)
28
PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 2
•
External Auditor must perform himself or herself:
–
Enough testing to provide principal evidence for opinion
–
Areas of High Fraud Risk (See par. 108+ Auditing Standard No. 2)
PCAOB Audit Standard No. 2
Significant Deficiencies – Material Weakness
• • • • • • • •
Circumstances regarded as Significant Deficiencies and strong indicator of Material Weakness (par. 140) Restatement of FS to correct misstatement Identification by auditor of a material misstatement in current FS not identified by the company Oversight of external FR and internal controls over FR by Audit Committee is ineffective Internal audit function is ineffective For regulated industries, ineffective reg. compliance Identification of fraud on the part of senior management Significant deficiencies identified continue uncorrected Ineffective control environment 29
PCAOB
Division of Enforcement and Investigations Role of the Office:
•
To promote high quality audits of public companies by thoroughly investigating possible violations, engaging in fair administrative proceedings, and recommending to the Board the imposition of sanctions, as warranted.
30
PCAOB
Division of Enforcement and Investigations
•
How may our cases originate?
–
Tips received
•
– – –
Referrals - SEC and other regulatory bodies PCAOB - On-site inspections Publications - Data mining
• •
Filings with SEC Business journals 31
PCAOB
Division of Enforcement and Investigations
• • •
(DEI)
•
Investigations Informal inquiries opened and closed by Director of DEI
–
Authorized to request information and cooperation Board must issue an Order to open a Formal Investigation
–
Empowers the DEI to issue “Accounting Board Demands” to registered firms and associated persons Board may request that SEC issue a subpoena on any person for testimony or required documents All information obtained is strictly confidential (not subject to civil discovery) until public proceeding filed or otherwise released under Section 105(c).
32
PCAOB
Division of Enforcement and Investigations
• • • • • •
Enforcement Witnesses have right to counsel Administrative Hearings Board Determination May appeal to Board May appeal to the SEC May petition for Court Review with respect to the SEC determination 33
34
PCAOB - RECRUITING
•
WWW.PCAOBUS.ORG
–
CAREERS
–
WASHINGTON, D.C.
• •
FORENSIC ACCOUNTANT ATTORNEY – INVESTIGATIONS & ENFORCEMENT
35
Fraud Prevention within the Corporate Environment
Joseph Hendrix, CPP, CFE Director of Global Investigations Electronic Data Systems
Fraud Policy
• •
Defines Fraud Policy states, “includes not only those acts considered fraud in the legal sense, but also includes a variety of violations of the code of conduct involving dishonesty, deceit or other similar conduct.” 36
37
Fraud Policy
(cont’d)
•
Scope
–
Applies to any fraud or suspected fraud globally
–
Involving any employee, contractor, vendor, supplier, agents/representatives, visitors, etc.
•
No employee has authority to commit, condone or ratify fraud or any illegal activity on behalf of EDS
38
Fraud Policy
(cont’d)
• • •
Leaders are responsible to prevent, identify and report fraud Defines reporting mechanisms Defines investigative responsibilities, “Corporate Investigations and Legal Affairs have primary responsibility”
39
Fraud Policy
(cont’d)
• •
Requires all employees to cooperate Grants full unrestricted access to employees and records without prior knowledge or consent from any individual
•
Violation may include disciplinary action
40
Ethics and/or Compliance Office
•
Reports through Office of General Counsel
•
Provides regular training in ethics and management responsibility
•
Manages Ethics Hotline and reports as appropriate
•
Owns Code of Business Conduct
41
Code of Business Conduct
• •
Issues
–
One global code or a specific code for each Country
–
Certification (electronic done annually) Typical code provisions
–
Drugs and Alcohol, (Substance Abuse Policy)
–
Conflicts of Interest
–
Outside Employment
42
Code of Business Conduct
(cont’d)
•
Typical code provisions (cont’d)
–
Outside Directorships
–
Personal Investments
–
Business Opportunities
–
Family and Personal Relationships
–
Exchanging Gifts and Other Business Courtesies
–
Protecting Assets
43
Code of Business Conduct
(cont’d)
•
Typical code provisions (cont’d)
–
Limited Personal Use of Corp Resources
–
Electronic Communications (no expectation of privacy)
–
Insider Trading
–
Transnational conduct
–
Bribery and Improper Payments (FCPA, Internal Policies)
–
Compliance and Discipline
Code of Business Conduct
(cont’d) “Disciplinary actions will be considered if any employee is found to be uncooperative or untruthful during an internal investigation into any violation or potential violation of the EDS code of Conduct or any EDS policy.” 44
45
Reporting
• • • •
Maintain statistical information on Fraud Ensure availability of reporting mechanism to all employees in all languages Insurance claims and stolen asset write offs require investigations report Reports to appropriate levels
–
CEO, CFO, Audit Committee, Internal Audit, Risk Management, Public Relations
Global Investigations Organization
• • • •
Report through CFO Investigative methodology
–
Evidence gathering = Electronic, paper, legal process Evidence Analysis = Physical vs. electronic Interview Techniques
– – –
Informational Confrontational Sworn and transcribed 46
Global Investigations Organization
• •
Prosecution of offenders where appropriate Remedies
–
Direct recoveries from target (cash, assets, promissory notes)
–
Criminal court orders
–
Civil court judgments
–
Insurance claims 47
Fraud Prevention Program
• • •
Fraud Council:
Members include: Audit, Investigations, Legal, Risk Management, Finance, Public Relations Meet monthly or as needed Discussion topics include: monthly case update, root cause analysis, control impact, change actions needed 48
49
Q & A
50
To Get Your CPE Certificate go to www.auditlearning.org
51
Summary of Main Points
• Develop an Anti-Fraud Strategy • Prepare a Fraud Risk Profile • Collect Key Performance
Indicators
• Prepare a Formal Fraud Risk
Assessment
• Develop a Formal Anti-Fraud
Program Implementation Plan
Summary of Main Points (cont’d)
• Prepare Robust Anti-Fraud Policies
and Procedures
• Understand Role of PCAOB Division
of Enforcement & Investigations
• Use Strong Code of Business Conduct • Maintain Good Statistical
Information for Reporting on Fraud
• Utilize a “Fraud Council” to Review
and Advise on Anti-Fraud Efforts 52
53 August 8, 2004
“COSO ERM”
54