Section 1 - Repo-NT

Download Report

Transcript Section 1 - Repo-NT

wcsr.com
Intellectual Property and the
Patent System
University of Virginia
MAE 400: Financial Aspects of Engineering
April 10, 2003
Jack Hicks, Esq.
B.S.M.E. ‘79, M.E.M.E. ‘80 (UVA SEAS)
J.D. ‘87 (Univ. of Texas School of Law)
Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice, PLLC
1900 First Union Tower
300 N. Greene St.
Greensboro, NC 27401
Telephone: (336) 574-8050; [email protected]
© Womble Carlyle 2002
wcsr.com
Topics
• Overview of Intellectual Property Law
– Copyrights, Trademarks, Trade Secrets, and Patents
• Patents
– Different Types of Patents
– Patentable Subject Matter
– Patenting Process/Record Keeping
• Engineer/Attorney Opportunities and
Requirements
• Hot Topics
• Questions
wcsr.com
Basic Concept One:
Ideas Are Free
What You Do
With Idea
Expression
Legal Protection
Reduce to Practice
Useful Way
Designate Origin or
Endorsement for Sale
of Goods or Services
Patents, Trade secrets
Copyright
Trademarks, Trade
Dress, Rights of
Publicity/Privacy
wcsr.com
Basic Concept Two:
IP Protection Only Needed
for Good Ideas
• Patent Cannot Turn Make a Bad
Design a Good Design
• Registered Trademark Cannot Make
Bad Mark a Good Mark
wcsr.com
Ideas Are Free, But…
What You Do
With Idea
Expression
Legal
Protection
Copyright
Reduce to Practice
Useful Way
Designate Origin or
Endorsement for Sale
of Goods or Services
Patents, Trade secrets
Trademarks, Trade
Dress, Rights of
Publicity/Privacy
What is a copyright?
wcsr.com
The owner of a copyright has the
following five exclusive rights:
a.
To make copies
b.
To make derivative works
c.
To sell or distribute copies
d.
To publicly perform the work
e.
To display the work
wcsr.com
Copyrightable Subject Matter:
Literary Works
wcsr.com
Copyrightable Subject Matter:
Photographic Works
wcsr.com
Copyrightable Subject Matter:
Works of Visual Art
wcsr.com
Copyrightable Subject Matter:
3-D Works of Art
wcsr.com
Copyrightable Subject Matter:
Audio-visual Works
Director: Tom Shadyac, Virginia ’80 (X)
wcsr.com
Copyrightable Subject Matter:
Computer Programs
wcsr.com
Ideas Are Free
What You Do
With Idea
Expression
Legal
Protection
Copyright
Designate Origin or
Endorsement for Sale
of Goods or Services
Reduce to Practice
Useful Way
Trademarks, Trade
Dress, Rights of
Publicity/Privacy
Patents, Trade secrets
wcsr.com
What is a trademark?
• A source identifier
• Trademarks can be
–
–
–
–
–
words
pictures
symbols
smells
sounds
wcsr.com
wcsr.com
wcsr.com
How are trademark rights
established?
• Priority of use
• Distinctiveness
wcsr.com
The Continuum of
Trademark Distinctiveness
Most distinctive
Least distinctive
wcsr.com
Examples of
Arbitrary Trademarks
wcsr.com
Examples of
Suggestive Trademarks
wcsr.com
Examples of
Descriptive Trademarks
GOLF
MAGAZINE:
A
magazine about golf
TAYLOR MADE:
Stuff made by guy named Taylor
wcsr.com
Examples of
Generic Non-Trademarks
Escalator
Aspirin
Examples of
Fighting-to-Avoid Generic
Trademarks
Kleenex®
Xerox®
wcsr.com
Trademark Examples
®
UVA
Reg. No. 586,514 (1954)
wcsr.com
Trademarks
UVA®
Reg. No. 586,514 (1954)
Electro-hydraulically operated grinding
machines and wheel-heads therefore for
grinding metallic work pieces, especially
work pieces of ferrous metal and steel. First
use: 19381004
Ulvsunda Verkstader Aktiebolag Corporation Sweden
Johannesfredsvagen 15-17 Stockholm Sweden
wcsr.com
Trademarks
®
UVA UVA
Reg. No. 2,117,085
wcsr.com
Trademarks
UVA UVA®
Reg. No. 2,117,085
The English translation of "UVA UVA" means "grape, grape".
Beverages consisting of - soft drinks,
carbonated waters and fruit juices.
M. A. CIMINO & DAUGHTERS CORPORATION CALIFORNIA
wcsr.com
Trademarks
UVAFLEX®
wcsr.com
Trademarks
UVAFLEX®
Reg. No. 1921372(1995)
UV curing flexographic and gravure printing
inks for the graphics industry
Zeller & Gmelin GmbH CORPORATION FED REP
GERMANY Schlosstrasse 20 D-73054 Eislingen
FED REP GERMANY
wcsr.com
Trademarks
UVA®
Reg. No. 1,668,865
Educational and entertainment services;
namely, providing courses of instruction at
the college level, offering sports exhibitions,
and producing radio and television
programs.
Rector and Visitors of the University of
Virginia
wcsr.com
Trademarks Logos
wcsr.com
U.S. Trademark Registration No. 0977190 for
ATHLETIC SHOES
(Registered 1974)
wcsr.com
wcsr.com
Trademark Slogans
Nobody Doesn’t Like Sara Lee®
for food products
Just Do It®
for sports apparel and shoes
wcsr.com
New Trademark Slogans?
Let Us Remove Your Shorts™
On Electrician’s Truck
If You Don’t See What You’re Looking For,
You’ve Come to the Right Place™
Optometrist
We repair
fixed.™
Plumbing services #1
what
your
husband
wcsr.com
TRADEMARK SLOGANS
Don't sleep with a drip. Call me.™
Plumbing services #2
No appointment necessary. We'll hear
you coming.™
Muffler sales
Best place to take a leak.™
Radiator Repair Shop
wcsr.com
TRADEMARK SLOGANS
PICK YOUR NOSE HERE™
Plastic Surgeon
wcsr.com
How long does a trademark
last?
Indefinitely, if use is:
• continuous; and
• exclusive
wcsr.com
Is a registration necessary?
• No, but it is strongly recommended
• Benefits of a federal registration
include:
– constructive notice to infringers
– right to expand
wcsr.com
Beware
Translations
PSCHITTT GEL
for Hair styling preparations
By Laboratoire Garnier &
Cie ADDRESS- 281 Rue SaintHonore Paris FRANCE
wcsr.com
Ideas Are Free
What You Do
With Idea
Expression
Legal
Protection
Copyright
Designate Origin or
Endorsement for Sale
of Goods or Services
Reduce to Practice
Useful Way
Trademarks, Trade
Dress, Rights of
Publicity/Privacy
Patents, Trade Secrets
wcsr.com
What is a Trade Secret?
• Valuable business information
• Reasonable efforts to preserve secrecy
(no reverse engineering)
wcsr.com
What is a Trade Secret?
(continued)
Examples of Trade Secrets
•
•
•
•
Manufacturing Techniques
Coca-Cola Formula
Profit Margins, Business Plans
Customer Lists (maybe)
wcsr.com
Original Recipe® is Still a
Secret
“Today, the recipe is
locked away in a
safe in Louisville, Ky.
Only a handful of
people know that
multi-million dollar
recipe (and they've
signed strict
confidentiality
contracts).”
http://www.kfc.com/about/secret.ht
m
wcsr.com
Semiconductor Circuit,
Materials, Process
Reverse Engineering
Electron Microscope
(SEM, TEM) , or
Secondary Ion Mass
Spectrometry (SIMS)
Reports ($20K - $200K)
http://www.chipworks.com/
wcsr.com
What is a Patent?
• Grant by government of right to
exclude others from making, using and
selling
• Government grants patents in
exchange for a full disclosure of how
to make and use the invention
wcsr.com
Top 10 Companies Receiving
U.S. Patents in 2002
IBM Corp.
Canon
Micron Tech.
NEC Corp.
Hitachi
3288
1893
1833
1643
1602
Matsushita
Sony Corp.
GE
H-P
Mitsubishi
1544
1434
1416
1385
1373
wcsr.com
Patent Damages and Settlements
wcsr.com
Types of Patents
Utility Patent
Design Patent
Plant Patent
wcsr.com
Utility Patent
A new, non-obvious and
useful process, product or
composition of matter, or
any new and useful
improvement thereof.
35 U.S.C. §§ 101, 103.
wcsr.com
Banner Pharmacaps is a leader in the
development and manufacture of
prescription, over-the-counter
pharmaceuticals, and nutritional
supplements sold in softgels and
Soflet™ gelcaps. Our customers range
from major pharmaceutical and
nutritional companies with global sales,
to small start-up firms.
wcsr.com
Utility Patent (Process)
Process of making a product
Softgel Manufacturing Process
US Pat. 5,200,1911.
A method of film enrobing article preforms such as
medicine tablets comprising the steps of
(A) providing a pair of films of selected thickness and
composition …
(B) moving the films along selected paths including
through a pair of coacting dies …
(C) substantially at the place of die coaction
individually dispensing an article preform …
(D) at the place of die coaction, stretching the films
into contact with each other …, and
(E) separating the enrobed preforms from the films
essentially at said peripheral lines … .
wcsr.com
Utility Patent (Product)
Multiple Layer Softgel
(U.S. Pat. 6,183,845)
1. A softgel capsule having
opposing ends comprising a first
sheet that covers a first end, the
first sheet comprising at least a
first gelatin layer and a second
gelatin layer, … . wherein the
first and second sheets meet at a
seam.
wcsr.com
Utility Patent (Product
Apparatus)
US 5,459,983: Tablet
Enrobing Apparatus
1. An apparatus
comprising two coacting dies, two feed
rollers, a plurality of
nip rollers …
wcsr.com
Utility Patent (Composition)
US 6,214,376: Non-gelatin substitutes for oral
delivery capsules, their composition
A composition comprising:
a) 8 to 50% by weight of a plasticizer;
b) 0.5 to 12% by weight of .kappa.carrageenan; and
c) 1 to 95% by weight water,
wcsr.com
Design Patent
A new, non-obvious,
original and
ornamental design
for an article of
manufacture or
improvement thereof.
35 U.S.C. §§ 103,
171.
wcsr.com
Design Patent
wcsr.com
Design Patent
A new, non-obvious,
original and
ornamental design
for an article of
manufacture or
improvement thereof.
35 U.S.C. §§ 103,
171.
wcsr.com
Patent Duration
• Utility and Plant Patents: 20 years
from filing date
• Design Patent: 14 years from issuance
wcsr.com
What can be patented?
• “Anything under the sun made by man”- capable
of being a machine, process, article of
manufacture, composition or an improvement
thereof, such as:
• End Product
• Machine Design
• Control Systems
• Method of making, using
• Business Methods
• New applications of existing technology
wcsr.com
Turned On
Winston-Salem Doctor
Stumbles Upon Orgasm
Machine
Feb. 8, 2001 — A woman
who was being treated
for chronic back pain
experienced a sexy sideeffect when an electrode
was placed in her back to
relieve the aches and
pains
wcsr.com
US Patent No.
6,169,924: Spinal
cord stimulation
wcsr.com
US Patent No.
6,169,924: Spinal cord
stimulation
We claim:
1. A method for
treating orgasmic
dysfunction comprising:
supplying electrical
stimulation to a selected
area of the spinal cord
of a patient in an
effective amount to
achieve genital
stimulation and orgasm.
wcsr.com
Legal Bars to Patentability
US allows one year grace period to
file an application after invention is:
• on sale,
• offered for sale, or
• made public-very easy to make public
wcsr.com
Invention Development
• Document each stage of development
• Record in bound notebook, with each
stage witnessed (“read and
understood”) and dated by co-worker
not directly involved
• Consider patent search and application
prior to public disclosure, commercial
use or offer for sale
wcsr.com
Legal Bars to Patentability
Foreign protection is lost if an
invention is made public prior to
filing an application in one of the
following:
– in the US,
– in a foreign country, or
– under an international system- PCT, EP.
There is no one year grace period for
publication when foreign protection is
desired.
wcsr.com
Patenting Steps
• Submit Inventor’s Disclosure Report to New
Idea Coordinator
• Review of Idea by New Idea Committee, “Will
the patent protection provide economic
advantage?”
• Search:
– Inventor’s “Prior Art”
– On-line databases (fee)
– Internet (free)
• www.uspto.gov
• www.delphion.com
– Patent & Trademark Office, Crystal City, VA
wcsr.com
wcsr.com
wcsr.com
Patenting Steps (cont’d)
•
•
•
•
•
Patentability opinion based on search
Prepare application
Prosecution of application at PTO
Issuance of application into a patent
Enforcement of issued patent
wcsr.com
Parts of a Utility Patent
• Front Page having bibliographic
information, abstract, and cited prior art
• Background of the invention
• Summary of the invention
• Detailed description of the invention
• Drawings
• Claims
wcsr.com
Documents Necessary for
Filing Application
Declaration
Assignment
Power of Attorney
wcsr.com
Patent Granted!
• Notify company of any potential
infringers
• Identify potential licensees
• Submit any improvements of original
patented idea through process
wcsr.com
ENGINEER/ATTORNEY
OPPORTUNITIES AND
REQUIREMENT
wcsr.com
Engineer  Attorney
• Law (thought process; problem
solving; people and writing skills)
• Patent Law (IP Law)
• Products Liability
• Environmental
• Venture Capital/Technology
wcsr.com
Patent Law
• Work with numerous types of
technology and people
• Learning cutting edge of each industry
• Help shape companies’ future by
leveraging technology
• Interplay of law and science
wcsr.com
Patent Attorney Opportunities
• Greatest demand for patent attorneys
than any other attorney specialty
• Corporate (In-house)
• Private law firms
• Government (few)
wcsr.com
Requirements to Sit For
Patent Bar
• Patent Agent
• Law Degree/Patent Attorney
• Engineering or scientific degree or
relevant work experience and college
degree
wcsr.com
More Information
• Placement Office
• Law Schools (LSAT)
• www.abanet.org (American Bar
Association)
• www.aipla.org (American Intellectual
Property Law Association)
wcsr.com
Hot Topics
wcsr.com
Hot Topics
Amazon, Barnes & Noble settle
patent dispute (March 7, 2002)
• 9/97 Amazon.com introduced one-click feature
• 9/99 Patent issued
• 12/99 Preliminary Injunction Issued Against
Barnesandnoble.com
• 2/01 Injunction overturned due to question of validity of
patent (not novel)
• 3/02 Confidential Settlement
wcsr.com
U.S. Patent 5,960,411
Method and system for placing a
purchase order via a communications
network
We claim:
1. A method of placing an order for an item
comprising:
 under control of a client system,
 displaying information identifying the
item; and
 in response to only a single action
being performed, sending a request to
order the item along with an identifier
of a purchaser of the item to a server
system;
wcsr.com
Hot Topics
Court Denies Lemelson Petition for
Rehearing En Banc -- The petition was
for a rehearing in light of the court's opinion
of Jan. 24 holding that Lemelson's patents
could be unenforceable for unreasonable
delay in the USPTO. (APRIL 4, 2002)
Jerome Lemelson – 1 patent/month 40 years (1923-1997)
wcsr.com
Hot Topics
April 9 - Biotech Patent Invalid
Because of Inadequate
Written Description of the
Invention
Trademark Cases
wcsr.com
“Let’s roll” to Court - Passenger’s last
words spark trademark dispute (Feb. 2,
2002)
– Philadelphia (AP) – The foundation set up
in the name of Sept. 11 hero Todd Beamer
is racing to trademark his last known words
– “Let’s roll.”
– Sixteen trademark applications have been
filed for the mark. All are pending.
wcsr.com
Harley-Davidson drops fight to
trademark sound of its engines
- June 21, 2000
• MILWAUKEE -- Harley-Davidson Inc., the
largest U.S. motorcycle manufacturer,
dropped its six-year effort to trademark the
sound of its V-Twin engines, saying it was
tired of spending money on a case with no
end in sight
wcsr.com
TYPOSQUATTING
In National Association of Professional
Baseball Leagues, Inc. v. John Zuccarini
(Case No. D2002-1011), a three-member
WIPO panel found bad faith under UDRP
because "typosquatting is inherently
parasitic and of itself bad faith" and that
the intent is to "siphon off traffic from its
intended destination, by preying on
Internauts [the panel's term, not mine] who
make common typing errors.“ 02-11-2003
www.minorleaugebaseball.com
wcsr.com
MP3.COM ORDERED TO PAY UP TO
$250 MILLION IN MUSIC
COPYRIGHT CASE.
NEW YORK -- A federal judge on
Wednesday found that MP3.com
willfully violated the copyrights of
Universal Music Group, and ordered
the Internet music sharing company to
pay Universal $25,000 per compact
disc, or as much as $250 million.
- CNN.COM, September 6, 2000
wcsr.com
9th Circuit Affirms Preliminary
Injunction against NAPSTER
(Feb. 12, 2001)
– Finds contributory/vicarious copyright
infringement, no fair use defenses
– Scope of injunction modified to only enjoin
assistance with known copyright works
– $5M Bond Affirmed (Napster sought $1.5 $2B)
wcsr.com
Questions