Transcript Slide 1

Taskforce on the Health
Aspects of Violence
against Women and
Children
Christine Christie
Violence and Social Exclusion Team
9th February 2010
Violence against women and
children: context
“It’s not so much what was done to me but what it did to me
that matters to me now”
Around 10,000 women are sexually assaulted, and 2,000 women
are raped, every week
Across the UK there are upwards of five million adult women who
experienced some form of sexual abuse during childhood
2 million children in the UK experience sexual violence and
abuse, many never tell anyone
More than one third (36%) of all rapes recorded by the police are
committed against children under 16 years of age
24,000 girls are estimated to be at risk of FGM in the UK
Prevention & improved response
to violence against women and
children
o The cross-government strategy Together We Can End Violence Against
Women and Girls was launched in November 2009. It was informed by a 3
month public consultation, March to May 2009
o The Strategy sets out a co-ordinated approach to ending violence against
women and girls for the police, local authorities, the NHS and government
departments across three areas: prevention, provision and protection.
o The Department of Health’s Taskforce on Violence Against Women and
Children takes this Strategy further by explicitly setting out the health service
contribution both to prevention, intervention and support to the women and
children who are victims of violence.
o ‘Children’ not just ‘girls’
Health Taskforce on Violence
Against Women and Children
o Taskforce Steering Group chaired by Sir George Alberti and four expert
sub-groups (membership drawn from DH, NHS, statutory & third sector
agencies:
1)
2)
3)
4)
Sexual Violence and Abuse against Children
Sexual Violence against Women
Domestic Violence
Harmful Traditional Practices & Trafficking
o The Steering & sub-groups met between July 2009 and January 2010, and
the Taskforce Report and Government Response are scheduled for publication
mid-March 2010
o Informed by consultations with children (65 children) and women (14 focus
groups) undertaken over the same period by children’s clinicians and the
Women’s National Commission
Health Taskforce on Violence
Against Women and Children
o Recommendations are being made in 6 categories:
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
6)
Prevention and identification
Key services and successful pathways
Improving quality of and access to services
Information sharing
Workforce
Systems and incentives
o The taskforce Report’s headline recommendations will be underpinned by
each sub-group report published separately and intended as a handbook
for practitioners, commissioners and inspectors (Care Quality
Commission) on what services should be offered in each PCT area
o Together with Care Pathways; and
o NHS Commissioning Guidance
Taskforce Consultations: Women
o The Women’s National Commission consulted 211 women who have
experienced domestic violence; rape, sexual abuse and incest; women who
have used statutory mental health services; women from Black Asian and
Minority Ethnic (BAME) communities who have experienced domestic and
sexual violence, including forced marriage and so-called ‘honour’-based
violence; women refugees and asylum seekers; older women, and disabled
women
o A small number of women also worked in local specialist violence against
women services, so spoke from both an individual and organisational
perspective
o The WNC Report will be published alongside the Taskforce & sub-group
reports
Taskforce Consultations: Children
o The Taskforce sought views from children and young people about their
experience of seeking and/or receiving help from the NHS after experiencing
sexual violence or abuse
o Feedback was gathered within existing therapeutic relationships from:
1) A range of non-health specific agencies offering recovery services in
the community to children who are victims of sexual abuse, sexual violence
and exploitation
2) Mental health residential units, community CAHMS and third sector
agencies offering interventions to those children who have been diagnosed
with mental health issues warranting interventions ranging from tier 1 to tier 4
services
o The Children’s Consultation Report will be published alongside the
Taskforce & sub-group reports
Taskforce Consultations: NHS
Staff, the Public & a Professionals
call for evidence
o The Taskforce team worked in partnership with South Birmingham PCT to
undertake focus group work with NHS professionals
o The DH hosted a survey for members of the public accessing the NHS
Choices website pages relating to violence against women and children
o The Taskforce called for evidence from all relevant professional bodies,
from the Royal Colleges, Unions, third sector organisations and statutory
sector agencies e.g. Local Government Association
Health Taskforce Findings
NHS Staff feedback:
o Staff listed 4 key requirements:
1) Staff should have the skills and support to identify the signs and
symptoms of violence or abuse & be open to hearing disclosures and
responding to them appropriately
2) Staff should be confident and supported to share information;
information collection should not be duplicated and staff should receive
feedback about how the information has been used
3) Staff should have ready access to an up to date and comprehensive
directory of local and regional services for women and children who have
been abused
4) There should be process and outcome measures for services
responding to women and children who have experienced violence and
abuse, and their families, across pathways and organisations
Health Taskforce Findings
NHS Choices – public feedback:
o Local police (31%) or a GP (20%) were most frequently mentioned to be
the first port of call if they or someone close to them were a victim of abuse
or sexual violence
o Those with personal experience of domestic and/or sexual violence or
abuse would be more likely than those without that experience to turn to a
GP or A&E
o The two characteristics that were the most likely to encourage all
respondents to use the health service were ‘approachable and respectful’
staff & 24 hour access
Health Taskforce Findings
Women’s feedback:
o Choice of seeing women health professionals across health services,
particularly if they had experienced sexual violence
o SARCs should be located in appropriate settings, and care pathways
should include agencies within the specialist voluntary sector
o Health professionals needed to ask questions in a sensitive manner &
in private, treat women with dignity and respect, help women to feel that
they were in a supportive environment
o There should be compulsory training on all forms of violence for all
those working in health care settings
o There should be better identification and response to women who
have experienced childhood sexual abuse or incest
o Dentists should have specific training in the impact of sexual violence
and/or sexual abuse
Health Taskforce Findings
Women’s feedback:
o Health services should be more effective in providing evidence to support
civil and criminal court cases, and receive training and guidance on
recording notes for evidential purposes
o BME women want health services that are culturally sensitive and in their
own language or through trained professional interpreters
o NHS should better resource specialist independent violence against
women advocates (IDVAs)
o There should be clear protocols for safe information sharing within the
NHS as well as external to the NHS – with the woman’s consent
o Older women’s experiences of rape and sexual violence should be taken
seriously
o Health services need to recognise the crucial role of specialist women’s
services in providing longer-term individual & group support for women
Health Taskforce Findings
Children’s feedback:
o Some professionals did not believe the children when they disclosed
their abuse
o Some health professionals don’t ask why a child may be behaving in a
certain way or if they have been harmed
o Some of the children said their attempts to tell were sometimes seen
as symptomatic of a diagnosed mental health condition
o Some health professionals’ demeanour prevents or delays a potential
disclosure from a child of their experience of violence or abuse
o There is little recognition by professionals, including those in health
systems, of the need for choice regarding male/female staff when in a
crisis and attending Accident & Emergency, GUM or GP services
Health Taskforce Findings
Children’s feedback (continued):
o Children highlighted the benefit of counselling - as and when they want it
and not necessarily through a specialist CAMHS provider
o When a child had an independent advocate it was reported that this
proved to be pivotal in their recovery
o Some young children found themselves passed from one service to
another without any explanation about why this was happening
o There is insufficient education and awareness raising regarding child
sexual abuse within schools, health clinics, youth clubs and other settings
that children encounter during their childhood. This results in reduced
opportunities for helping children get the support they need and knowing
what resources are available to them.
Children’s Consultation Quotes
“I think people don’t tell because they are frightened of being called a
liar…After the worker didn’t believe me I didn’t tell anybody for a year
after and it really screwed my head”
“I nearly blurted it out but the doctor was dead stoney faced and I
was scared so I didn’t say anything to him”
“You ask me why I didn’t say anything sooner, I’ll tell you why. Because
no-one asked”
“I think the health service needs to think about what they can do for
children who have been abused and not just send them to their mental
service”
“And I suppose it all started to get better when the CAMHS worker
believed me”
“There needs to be more and better after care for children and
parents e.g. counselling groups”
Women’s Consultation Quotes
“I didn’t know where to get help after I’d been raped. My GP is a man
so I couldn’t talk to him… so I just tried to get through as best I
could”
“When I was being treated for my bulimia mental health professionals
never acknowledged that the abuse was the cause of my bulimia – you
can’t look at the bulimia without looking at the whole package, the
cause of it.”
“Even when I was sat in the doctor’s surgery, with my partner, and I
was bruised and shaking and he was doing all the talking for me, the
doctor didn’t pick up on it.”
“Health services are too quick to hand out prescriptions, to hand over
the Prozac. I don’t want to be medicated for having experienced
abuse; it’s not the answer to my problems.”
“I have been waiting nearly a year for counselling… I don’t know what
the point of it is now.”
Women’s Consultation Quotes
“When your husband or your in laws have hit you they take to you to
the doctors, and they tell you not to say anything about the violence.
The doctors should have more awareness.”
“Health services need to do more publicity, to tell everyone that
violence against women, forced marriage, FGM, these are all wrong,
none of them are our fault and we should not be blamed or left to
suffer with health problems for years later.”
“Confidential health services where women can go to tell of their
concerns, without family members getting to know what she’s said, is
very important. We know many women who have had their
confidentiality breached through GPs who have good links with local
communities.
A woman we supported who was threatened with ‘honour’ killing spoke
to her GP about her concerns through an interpreter, who was a friend
of the family. They passed this information she gave him, back to the
family, and she got killed as a result.”
Health Taskforce Recommendations
o Recommendations are being made in 6 categories:
1) Prevention and identification
2) Key services and successful pathways
3) Improving quality of and access to services
4) Information sharing
5) Workforce
6) Systems and incentives
o Publication will be in March 2010
o The Taskforce Report will be accompanied by a Government Response
o DH is putting a National Implementation Team in place
Christine Christie
Taskforce on Violence Against Women and Girls
Violence and Social Exclusion Team
Department of Health, Skipton House
80 London Road, London SE1 6LH
07841 054 204
[email protected]
and
[email protected]