SecurityandPolicing2015(2.05)
Download
Report
Transcript SecurityandPolicing2015(2.05)
Homeland Security and Policing:
Opportunities and Challenges of Accelerating Change
FBI Futures Working Group 2005
John Smart, President, ASF
(accelerating.org/slides.html)
Presentation Outline
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
VI.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Futures Quiz
Present Paradigm
World Security and the Non-Integrating Gap
Big Picture Future
Homeland Security and Policing
Conclusions
© 2005 Accelerating.org
I. Futures Quiz
Futures Quiz
Q: Of the 100 top economies in the world, how
many are multinational corporations and how
many are nation states?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Futures Quiz
Q: Of the 100 top economies in the world, how
many are multinational corporations and how
many are nation states?
51 MNC’s and 49 Nations.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Futures Quiz
Q: Disney and Sony (respectively) produce and
launch one new product every _________?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Futures Quiz
Q: Disney and Sony (respectively) produce and
launch one new product every _________?
Once every three minutes for Disney.
Once every twenty minutes for Sony.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Futures Quiz
Q: How much of Hewlett Packard’s revenue
comes from products launched in the last
year?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Futures Quiz
Q: How much of Hewlett Packard’s revenue
comes from products launched in the last
year?
70%
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Elizabeth Debold, What is Enlightenment?, March-May 2005
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Acceleration Awareness
What do you see accelerating
around you?
What do you see remaining
constant?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Many Accelerations are Underwhelming
Some Modest Exponentials:
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Productivity per U.S. worker hr has improved 500%
over 75 years (1929-2004, 2% per yr)
Business investment as % of U.S. GDP is flat at 11%
over 25 years.
Nondefense R&D spending as % of First World GDP
is up 30% (1.6 to 2.1%) over 21 years (1981-2002).
Technology spending as % of U.S. GDP is up 100%
(4% to 8%) over 35 years (1967-2002)
BusinessWeek, 75th Ann. Issue, “The Innovation Economy”, 10.11.2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
II. Present Paradigm
Moore’s Law
Moore’s Law derives from two predictions in 1965 and 1975 by Gordon
Moore, co-founder of Intel, that computer chips (processors, memory,
etc.) double their complexity every 12-24 months at near constant unit
cost.
This is one of several abstractions of Moore’s Law, due to
miniaturization of transistor density in two dimensions. Others relate to
speed (the signals have less distance to travel) and computational
power (speed × density).
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
The Extraordinary Present
“There has never been a time more
pregnant with possibilities.”
- Gail Carr Feldman
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
The Future is Already Here
We need a pragmatic optimism, a can-do, change-aware attitude. A
balance between innovation and preservation. Honest dialogs on
persistent problems, tolerance of imperfect solutions. The ability to
avoid both doomsaying and a paralyzing adherence to the status quo.
- David Brin (paraphrased)
We have two options:
Future Shock or Future Shaping
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Big Picture
Outer Space
2025: Sustainability, Transitioning to Nuclear, Hydrogen and Solar
Human Space
2025: Advanced Globalization, Transparency, Early Symbiotic Age,
Linguistic User Interface, Early Valuecosm
Inner Space
2025: Synthetic and Computational Biology, Early Technocellular
Substrate (Silicon Photonics, Spintronics, Nuclear Energy, etc.)
Cyber Space
2025: GPS/LPS, Local Search, Persistent and Mirror Worlds, Early
Artificial Life and Hyperreality
Hyper Space
2025: Bio-Inspired Computing, Early Personality Capture/DT
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
America’s Greatest Strategic Interest Today:
Managing Globalization
“America has had 200 years to invent, regenerate, and calibrate
the balance that keeps markets free without becoming monsters.
We have the tools to make a difference. We have the
responsibility to make a difference. And we have a huge interest
in making a difference. Managing globalization is a role from
which America dare not shrink. It is our overarching national
interest today and the political party that understands that first,
the one that comes up with the most coherent, credible, and
imaginative platform for pursuing it is the party that will own the
real bridge to the future.”
- Thomas Friedman, The Lexus and the Olive Tree:
Understanding Globalization (2000).
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Globalization Eras
Globalization I: 1800’s – WWI
Mechanism:
Industrial Revolution, cheap transportation
Backlash Ideologies:
Communism, Socialism, Fascism
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Globalization Eras
Globalization II: 1980’s – Present
Mechanism:
Information Revolution, cheap communications
Backlash Ideologies:
Fundamentalism, nationalism, civil disobedience,
eco-extremism, white collar crime
Examples: Sem Teto, Hugo Chavez
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Globalization Eras
These forces have to be kept in check by
•
•
•
•
•
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
global economic growth
accountability
transparency
fair policies
minimal government.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Revisit 1929
Business Week’s First Edition:
IBM has an ad for “electric sorting machines.”
PG&E has an ad announcing natural gas powered
factories in San Francisco.
Could we have predicted that one of these technologies
would sustain a relentless, profound, accelerating
transformation while another would (on the surface)
stay unchanged?
Can we predict this now?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Areas of Accelerating Innovation, 1929-2004
“The Microcosm” (the “ICT” domain)
Materials Science (“Substrates”)
Synthetic Materials
Transistor (Bell Labs, 1948)
Microprocessor
Fiber Optics
Lasers and Optoelectronics
Wired and Wireless Networks
Quantum Wells, Wires, and Dots
Exotic Condensed Matter
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
BusinessWeek, 75th Ann. Issue, “The Innovation Economy”, 10.11.2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Areas of Accelerating Innovation, 1929-2004
“The Microcosm” (the “ICT” domain)
Systems and Software
Television (1940’s)
Mainframes (1950’s)
Minicomputers (1970’s)
Personal Computers (1980’s)
Cellphones/Laptops/PDAs (1990’s)
Embedded/Distributed Systems (2000’s)
Pervasive/Ubiquitous Systems (2010’s)
Cable TV, Satellites, Consumer, Enterprise, Technical
Software, Middleware, Web Services, Email, CMS,
Early Semantic Web, Search, KM, AI, NLP…
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
BusinessWeek, 75th Ann. Issue, “The Innovation Economy”, 10.11.2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Areas of Accelerating Innovation, 1929-2004
“The Macrocosm” (the “human-ICT” domain)
Defense and Space (“Security-oriented human-ICT”)
Aircraft carriers, nuclear weapons, ICBMs, cruise
missiles, lunar landers, nuclear powered
submarines... (theme:major open problems (security))
Manufacturing (“Engineering-oriented human-ICT”)
Lean manufacturing, supply-chain management,
process automation, big-box retailing, robotics…
(major open problems (theme: rich-poor divide))
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
BusinessWeek, 75th Ann. Issue, “The Innovation Economy”, 10.11.2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Areas of Accelerating Innovation, 1929-2004
“The Macrocosm” (the “human-ICT” domain)
Social and Legal (“Fairness-oriented human-ICT”)
Civil rights, social security, fair labor standards, ADA,
EOE, tort reform, class actions, Miranda rights,
zoning, DMV code, alimony, palimony, criminal law
reform, penal reform, education reform, privacy law,
feminism, minority power, spousal rights, gay civil
unions... (“accelerating refinements” (vs. disruptive
changes), consider E.U. vs. U.S. vs China.)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
BusinessWeek, 75th Ann. Issue, “The Innovation Economy”, 10.11.2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Areas of Accelerating Innovation, 1929-2004
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
“The Macrocosm” (the “human-ICT” domain)
Agrotech/Biotech/Health Care (“Bio-oriented human-ICT”)
Green revolution, antibiotics, pharmaceuticals,
transplants, medical imaging, prosthetics, microsurgery,
genomics, proteomics, combinatorial chem,
bioinformatics… (“accelerating regulation”)
Finance (“Capital-oriented human-ICT”)
Venture capital (American R&D, 1946), credit cards (Bank
of America, 1958), mortgage derivs (1970’s), mutual and
hedge funds, prog. trading, microcredit…
Transportation and Energy (“Infrastructure human-ICT”)
Jet aircraft, helicopters, radar, containerized shipping
Nuclear power, solar energy, gas-powered turbines,
hydrogen (“accelerating efficiencies (vs. change)”)
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Human ICT vs. Microcosmic ICT
1. Entertain this radical proposition: “Human ICT” domains
are saturating. “Microcosmic ICT” are not.
2. Defense, security, space, finance, social, legal, agrotech,
biotech, health care, finance, transportation, energy and
envirotech all will look surprisingly similar in 2030, but with
major ICT extensions.
3. Condensed matter physics, the nanoworld and cosmology
continue to surprise us.
4. ICT (sensors, storage, communication, connectivity,
simulation, interface) now look and feel very different.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Physical Space:
Technological “Cephalization” of Earth
"No one can deny that a world
network of economic and
psychic affiliations is being
woven at ever increasing
speed which envelops and
constantly penetrates more
deeply within each of us. With
every day that passes it
becomes a little more impossible
for us to act or think otherwise
than collectively."
- Teilhard de Chardin, 1954
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
“Finite Sphericity + Acceleration =
Phase Transition”
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Our Generation’s Theme
First World Saturating,
Third World Uplifting.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Taiwan’s Example
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Taiwan requires all university undergraduates to take
courses in Futures Studies.
Taiwan owns 46,000 contract factories in China
(mutually assured economic destruction).
Taiwan has become the IT hardware manufacturing
capital of the world.
Taiwan is the new leader in innovation outsourcing
(Quanta, Compal, HTC, Premier = 10,000 R&D Staff)
Taiwan has the highest degree of economic creative
destruction in the world.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Creative Destruction: Creating a Legal
and Social Culture of Innovation
Of the top 25 companies in each country 25
years ago, how many are still the same?
France, Germany, Japan: Almost all
Europe: Most
United States: Roughly half
Taiwan, Hong Kong: Very few
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Thomas Friedman, The Lexus and the Olive Tree, 2000
© 2005 Accelerating.org
III. World Security and the
Non-Integrating Gap
The Pentagon’s New Map
A New Global Defense Paradigm
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Shrinking the Disconnected Gap
The Computational “Ozone Hole”
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
The Disconnected Gap:
Our Planetary Ozone Hole
Global Polarization (Core vs. Gap)
“Disconnectedness (tech, economic, cultural) defines
danger.” (Thomas Barnett, Pentagon’s New Map)
Strategy: Encircle the Gap, Support the Seam States
-- Plant resources in “supportive soil.”
-- Greatest comparative advantage for shrinking the
hole (eg. Koreas).
Strategy: Don’t Stir Up the Ant’s Nest
-- This is difficult, as due to differential immunity, our
cultural memes (materialism, democracy, etc.) are as
powerful as the germs that wiped out up to 90% of the
less immunologically complex cultures (Rome: 1200AD, Europe: 1300, America: 1492-1600)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Why the Gap Shrinks
“He who can handle the quickest rate of change survives.”
- Col. John Boyd, Military Strategist (OODA loop)
Time compression is one form of MEST compression.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Why Eurasia won the sociopolitical, technological,
military, and germ development race (Largest EastWest Axis, earliest domestication of animals, Jared
Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel).
Why Europeans decimated the Americas and Pacific
Islanders with a host of crowd infectious diseases,
and not the other way around.
Why the Gap will shrink to next-to-nothing as we
create a transparent global society this century.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Connectivity is a
Developmental Attractor
Francis Fukuyama (The End of History), Thomas
Friedmann (The Lexus and the Olive Branch), Robert
Kagan (Of Power and Paradise) Thomas Barnett (The
Pentagon’s New Map) and Samuel Huntington (The
Clash of Civilizations) are all mostly right.
The developmental destination for nation states is
becoming clear. But the evolutionary path is bottom
up, and so must be culturally unique.
Our job is to facilitate this one-way transition as
uniquely and as measurably as possible.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
These two goals sometimes conflict.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Unconscious Gap Strategy:
Measurable Exponential Value (MEV)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Culture-appropriate determination of needs
Invited solutions, two way communication,
feedback, local customization
Subsidize the solutions
Measure the growth rate (exponentiation)
Bottom up marketing
A mix of self sufficiency and philanthropy
(development)
If you don’t see exponential adoption,
intervention will not be perceived as a
comparative advantage. Adapt and iterate.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
The Psychology of Exponential Growth
Exponential growth keeps people satisfied.
Benefits are self-reinforcing.
People maintain behavior on non-zero sum interactions,
where the size of the pie and your absolute return
grows even as your percentage decreases annually
(Robert Wright, Non-Zero, 2000)
Citizens turn toward personal and local development,
much less toward nationalism and ideology
(Ron Inglehart, The Silent Revolution, 1976;
Modernization and Postmodernization, 2002)
We can measure this (census and other surveys).
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
“Broken Windows” Policies:
A Precondition to MEV
Broken Windows theory of political scientist James
Wilson and criminologist George Kelling (The
Atlantic Monthly, March 1982)
Rapid response to and repair of the visibly "broken"
aspects of a local community increases sense of
control, ownership, initiative and vigilance against
crime.
Billboards with easy reporting phone numbers and list of
the top acts people should report. Giving statistics and
trends. Enlisting the collective in simple vigilance.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Examples: Iraq
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Communications (cellphones)
Lighting (digital solid state)
Energy (centralized economies of scale, subsidized
deflationary prices; decentralized storage and
generation)
Example: Donkey cart generators
Security (networked cameras; camera traps)
Culturally-dependent: Britain vs. S. Africa vs. U.S.
Portable CD Players/local music ($10 at Wal-Mart)
Public access radio and TV stations
Food storage, culinary, and women’s needs
Sports / Youth Fads
© 2005 Accelerating.org
IDAP Technology Processes
Innovation
Diffusion
Assessment
Policy
“The future is here, it’s just not evenly distributed yet.”
– William Gibson
First to third world diffusion is arguably the greatest
gap. But culture-appropriate assessment processes,
sensitive policymaking, and fostering cultures of
innovation are also important.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
The Key Strategic Question
with any Gap Intervention
Not whether we could have been liked better,
won more “hearts and minds” (in Iraq or
among our allies).
The key question is the degree to which new
exponential ecologies (technological,
economic, social) are adopted and persist in
the community.
-- Tools, Markets, Rules
We can measure this (operations research).
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
The Say-Do Development Gap
2,600 Iraqi Development Projects Promised
160 under way presently. (Time, July 2004)
Of all of these, communications projects have been
our biggest shortcoming.
We wired ourselves superbly (CPOF) but we never
wired in to the populace, or even helped them to wire
themselves, in exponential fashion.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Example: DARPA/USC ICT Tactical Language project.
Top-down thinking. “A.I.” vs. Persistent Worlds.
We could have had scores of Iraqi/Arabic youth teaching
our incoming soldiers tactical culture in massively
multiplayer online worlds, and using those worlds for
their own benefit as well. A tipping point among the
youth (like Satellite Television in India, etc.). © 2005 Accelerating.org
Immune Recognition vs. Rejection
The phenomenon of immune recognition (and
immune tolerance) vs. rejection.
The honeymoon period.
Rejection, if no measurable exponential value
within the host network.
We did not pass this test (in fairness, we may
never have passed).
Nevertheless, there were many missed
opportunities for deploying MEV strategy.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Tech Immune Systems Example:
Cellphones
Cellphones are an intrinsically defensive asset.
-- Monitorable (location and content)
-- Strengthen personal networks
-- The mean can self-police the extremes (report
scofflaws)
-- Granular privileges (given and revoked)
-- Can be built robustly (dynamo, shoe batts)
-- Chip provides superior ID (address books)
-- Hot button to security radio band
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Tech Immune Systems Example:
Firearms for Police
Networked weapons are an intrinsically
defensive asset.
-- Single shot magazines (deterrence)
-- Cameras and microphones (“Black Box”)
-- Cellphone to CENTCOM when safety off
-- The best training possible (on the job)
-- The inevitable future (worldwide buyback of all
non-networked lethals except antiques (eg.
Australia) the emergence of networked nonlethals.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
What is our ‘control’ study?
How do we know providing Measurable
Exponential Value would have worked in Iraq?
What’s our ‘control’ for the connectivity doctrine?
The Gap’s own history:
Maoist China, Kampuchea, Afghanistan.
Every example of swings away from connectivity
has been unsustainable in space and time.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Army: Development Challenges
and Opportunities
Security Leader
Development Follower
This makes institutional sense. A natural constraint.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Many development capability options:
Specialization (Corps of Engineers, etc.).
Unique Capacities (Fire and weather mgmt, FLEs)
Competition (Cross services bidding)
Incentives if under budget and before deadline with
quality (ex: Kowloon Tunnel (Hong Kong), Human
Genome Project, etc.))
Networks (America’s Army: worldwide devel. recruits)
Partnerships. Most obvious: USAID (long term
optimists). Many others as well (bottom up). © 2005 Accelerating.org
IV. Big Picture Future
Systems Theory
Systems Theorists Make Things Simple
(sometimes too simple!)
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler."
— Albert Einstein
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Smart’s Laws of Technology
1. Tech learns ten million times faster than you do.
(Electronic vs. biological rates of evolutionary development).
2. Humans are selective catalysts, not controllers, of
technological evolutionary development.
(Regulatory choices. Ex: WMD production or transparency,
P2P as a proprietary or open source development)
3. The first generation of any technology is often
dehumanizing, the second is indifferent to humanity,
and with luck the third becomes net humanizing.
(Cities, cars, cellphones, computers).
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Something Curious Is Going On
Unexplained.
(Don’t look for this in your physics or information theory texts…)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
The Technological Singularity:
2nd Order “Envelope of S-Curves”?
Each unique physicalcomputational substrate
appears to have its own Sshaped “capability curve.”
The information inherent in
these substrates is apparently
not made obsolete, but is
instead incorporated into the
developmental architecture of
the next emergent system.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Three Hierarchical Systems
of Social Change
Technological (dominant since 1950!)
“It’s all about the technology” (what it enables, how
inexpensively it can be developed)
Economic (dominant 1800-1950’s, secondary now)
“It’s all about the money” (who has it, control they gain with it)
Political/Cultural (dominant pre-1800’s, tertiary now)
“It’s all about the power” (who has it, control they gain with it)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Developmental Trends:
1. The levels have reorganized, to “fastest first.”
2. More pluralism (a network property) on each level.
Pluralism examples: 40,000 NGO’s, rise of the power
of media, tort law, Insurance, lobbies, etc.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Four Pre-Singularity Subcycles?
A 30-year cycle, from 1990-2020
–
A 20-year cycle, from 2020-2040
–
LUI personality capture (weak uploading), Mature
Self-Reconfig./Evolutionary Computing.
2050: Era of Strong Autonomy
–
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
LUI network, Biotech, not bio-augmentation,
Adaptive Robots, Peace/Justice Crusades.
A 10-year cycle, from 2040-2050
–
1st gen "stupid net "/early IA, weak nano, 2nd
gen Robots, early Ev Comp. World security begins.
Progressively shorter 5-, 2-, 1-year tech cycles,
each more autocatalytic, seamless, human-centric.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Henry Adams, 1909:
The First Singularity Theorist
The final Ethereal
Phase would last
only about four
years, and
thereafter "bring
Thought to the
limit of its
possibilities."
Wild speculation
or computational
reality?
Still too early to
tell, at present.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Eric Chaisson’s “Phi” (Φ):
A Universal Moore’s Law Curve
Free Energy Rate Density
Substrate
Ф
(ergs/second/gram)
time
Galaxies
Stars
Planets (Early)
Plants
Animals/Genetics
Brains (Human)
Culture (Human)
Int. Comb. Engines
Jets
Pentium Chips
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
0.5
2 (“counterintuitive”)
75
900
20,000(10^4)
150,000(10^5)
500,000(10^5)
(10^6)
(10^8)
(10^11)
Source: Eric Chaisson, Cosmic Evolution, 2001
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Understanding MEST Compression
We
End Up
Here
The Finite
Universe Box
Six Billion
Years Ago
MEST compression/Time
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
MEST Compression: Managing
Technological Development
Since the birth of civilization, humanity has been
learning to build special types of technological systems
that are progressively able to do more for us, in a more
networked and resilient fashion, using less resources
(matter, energy, space, time, human and economic
capital) to deliver any fixed amount of complexity,
productivity, or capability.
We are faced daily with many possible evolutionary
choices in which to invest our precious time, energy, and
resources, but only a few optimal developmental
pathways will clearly "do more, and better, with less."
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Replication & Variation
“Natural Selection”
Adaptive Radiation
Chaos, Contingency
Pseudo-Random Search
Strange Attractors
Evolution
Complex Environmental Interaction
The Left and Right Hands of
“Evolutionary Development”
Left Hand
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
New Computat’l Phase Space Opening
Selection & Convergence
“Convergent Selection”
Emergence,Global Optima
MEST-Compression
Standard Attractors
Development
Right Hand
Well-Explored Phase Space Optimization
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Adaptive Radiation/Chaos/
Pseudo-Random Search
Evolution
Multicellularity
Discovered
Complex Environmental Interaction
Cambrian Explosion
Bacteria
Insects
Invertebrates
Selection/Emergence/
Phase Space Collapse/
MEST Collapse
Development
Vertebrates
570 mya. 35 body plans emerged immediately after. No new body plans since!
Only new brain plans, built on top of the body plans (homeobox gene duplication).
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Body/brain plans: “eukaryotic multicell. evolutionary developmental substrates.”
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Marbles, Landscapes, and Basins
(Complex Systems, Evolution, & Development)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
The marbles (systems) roll around on the landscape, each
taking unpredictable (evolutionary) paths. But the paths
predictably converge (development) on low points (MEST
compression), the “attractors” at the bottom of each basin.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
How Many Eyes Are
Developmentally Optimal?
Evolution tried this experiment.
Development calculated an operational optimum.
Some reptiles (e.g. Xantusia vigilis, and certain skinks)
still have a parietal (“pineal”) vestigial third eye.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
How Many Wheels are Developmentally
Optimal on an Automobile?
Examples: Wheel on Earth. Social computation device.
Diffusion proportional to population density and diversity.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Physical Space:
A Transparent Society (“Panopticon”)
David Brin,
The Transparent Society, 1998
Hitachi’s mu-chip:
RFID for paper currency
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Stratellites:
A Developmental Attractor?
Inventor: Hokan Colting
21stCenturyAirships.com
180 feet diameter. Autonomous.
60,000 feet (vs. 22,000 miles)
Permanent geosynch. location.
Onboard solar and navigation.
A “quarter sized” receiver dish.
Why are satellites presently losing
against the wired world?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Border monitoring
(low altitude drug flights)
City monitoring
Early warning radar
Urban broadband
Latency, bandwidth, and launch costs.
MEST compression always wins.
Don’t bet against it!
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Physical Space:
Is Biotech a Saturated Substrate?
21st century neuropharm and neurotech won’t
accelerate biological complexity!
– Neural homeostasis fights “top-down” interventions
– “Most complex structure in the known universe”
Strong resistance to disruptive biointerventions
– Ingroup ethics, body image, personal identity
We’ll learn a lot, not biologically “redesign humans”
– No human-scale time, ability or reason to do so.
– Expect “regression to mean” (elim. disease) instead.
Neuroscience will accelerate technological complexity
– Biologically inspired computing. “Structural mimicry.”
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Virtual Space:
Is Inner Space the Final Frontier?
Mirror Worlds, David Gelernter, 1998.
Real structures in spacetime (very large and very small) are:
• Computationally very simple and tractable (transparent)
• A vastly slower substrate for evolutionary development
• Rapidly encapsulated by our simulation science
• A “rear view mirror” on the developmental trajectory of
emergence of universal intelligence?
versus
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Non-Autonomous ISS
Autonomous Human Brain
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Interface:
Oil Refinery (Multi-Acre Automatic Factory)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Tyler, Texas, 1964. 360 acres. Run by three operators,
each needing only a high school education.
The 1972 version eliminated the three operators.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Interface:
Understanding Process Automation
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Perhaps 80% of today's First World
paycheck is paid for by automation
(“tech we tend”).
Robert Solow, 1987 Nobel in Economics
(Solow Productivity Paradox,
Theory of Economic Growth)
“7/8 comes from technical progress.”
Human contribution (20%?) to a First
World job is Social Value of Employment
+ Creativity + Education
Developing countries are next in line
(sooner or later).
Continual education and grants
(“taxing the machines”) are the final job
descriptions for all human beings.
Termite Mound
© 2005 Accelerating.org
An ICT Attractor:
The Linguistic User Interface
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Google’s cache (2002)
Watch Windows 2004 become
Conversations 2020…
Convergence of Infotech and Sociotech
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Personality Capture
In the long run, we become seamless with our machines.
No other credible long term futures have been proposed.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
“Technology is becoming organic. Nature is becoming
technologic.” (Brian Arthur, SFI)
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Your “Digital You” (Digital Twin)
“I would never upload my consciousness
into a machine.”
“I enjoy leaving behind stories about my life
for my children.”
Prediction: When your mother dies in 2050,
your digital mom will be “50% her.”
When your best friend dies in 2080, your
digital best friend will be “80% him.”
Successive approximation, seamless
integration, subtle transition.
When you can shift your own conscious
perspective between your electronic and
biological components, the encapsulation
and transcendence of the biological will feel
like only growth, not death.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
We wouldn’t have it any other way.
Greg Panos (and Mother)
PersonaFoundation.org
© 2005 Accelerating.org
V. Homeland Security and Policing
FBI Mission
1. To protect and defend the United States against
terrorist and foreign intelligence threats,
2. To uphold and enforce the criminal laws of the
United States
3. To provide leadership and criminal justice
services to federal, state, municipal, and
international agencies and partners.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
FBI Priorities
1. Protect the United States from terrorist attack.
2. Protect the United States against foreign intelligence operations
and espionage.
3. Protect the United States against cyber-based attacks and hightechnology crimes.
4. Combat public corruption at all levels.
5. Protect civil rights.
6. Combat transnational and national criminal organizations and
enterprises.
7. Combat major white-collar crime.
8. Combat significant violent crime.
9. Support federal, state, county, municipal, and international
partners.
10. Upgrade technology to successfully perform the FBI’s mission.
Major priority transitions are rare. The FBI is in one now. This is a
unique time of opportunity and responsibility.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
FBI FWG Mission
“The Futures Working Group will identify and
promote innovation for the future of policing.”
Implicit message:
Leadership in innovation promotion.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Branches of Government
Executive Branch (enforces the law)
Legislative Branch (makes the law)
Judicial Branch (interprets the law)
The executive branch (DoJ, etc.) also forms new
policy and leads the country.
How do we cultivate a greater leadership, policyforming, and executive culture (e.g. a culture of
innovation and calculated risk-taking) in the FBI?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Tools for Shaping the Future
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Education
Environmental Literacy / Scanning
– Technological
– Business
– Social/Political
Culture of Foresight
Culture of Innovation
Culture of Competition
Local Commitment
Global Perspective
© 2005 Accelerating.org
National Innovation Initiative
Recommendations (sample)
Talent
Investment
Politics
Expedited, expanded
sci-tech immigration
3% of federal R&D for
“innov. accel.” grants
Cabinet-level or NEC
interagency group
National sci-tech
scholarship fund, tax
credits to contributors
3% of DoD budget
must go back to scitech, 20% of this at U’s
New innovation
metrics, national
innovation agenda
Portable graduate tech
fellowships similar to
NSF fellowships
Develop “services
science” as a new
academic discipline
National innovation
scorecard, prizes.
Better patent office.
Matching funds for
postsecondary MS
programs in tech and
innovation
Reward ten regional
“innovation hotspots”
with 5 yrs of funding
Improved IP, tort law,
intangible disclosure
law.
Our Biggest Opportunity: Innovation partnerships with the 3 billion
new workers who weren’t in the global economy ten years ago.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Innovate America, NII, Council on Competitiveness, 2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Innovation/Competitiveness/Acceleration
has flagged in recent years
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
China surpassed the U.S. this year as the largest recipient of
foreign direct investment.
In 2002, US Corporate R&D declined by $8 billion, largest
percentage drop since 1950.
Five countries (Japan, South Korea, Sweden, Finland, Israel)
spend more GDP on R&D than the U.S.
Foreign owned companies and foreign born inventors now count
for nearly half of all U.S. patents, with Japan, Korea, and Taiwan
accounting for more than one fourth.
Federal R&D funding is now 1/2 of its 1960's peak of 2% of GDP.
Total scientific papers by American authors peaked in 1992 and
have been flat ever since.
Services are the fastest growing sector of many technology
companies, yet much of our service sector, now more than half the
U.S. economy, traditionally does little R&D on business process
design, organization, and management.
Innovate America, NII, Council on Competitiveness, 2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Innovation/Competitiveness/Acceleration vs.
Efficiency/Cooperation/Sustainability
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
The first of these macro processes of change is
in our control (evo), second is less so (devo).
Ideally each must be equally prioritized, in
general (yet not in specific contexts).
Asia presently overweighted to the former,
Europe is overweighted to the latter.
The U.S. has fallen behind in the former in
recent years.
Innovate America, National Innovation Initiative, Council on Competitiveness, 2004
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Education and Civics
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
How do we educate our youth (and criminal justice
undergrads) to have a futures perspective?
How do we help youth understand how to create a
better individual future through collective action?
Show them scenarios of various community futures,
utopian and dystopian.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Networks and Feedback
How do we maximize the value of citizen security
suggestions on 311 and other forums? Cell phones
increase citizen empowerment and reporting of
scofflaws. How can these be used in homeland
security?
When IPTV comes, every city will have its own
channel. How can citizens use phone cams to
decrease violence and vandalism?
Example: Trap TV, reporting of citizen-submitted
candid camera footage of vandalizers and lawbreakers asking for citizen help to identify the perps.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Neighborhood Involvement
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Neighborhood watch and citizen networks, crime tip
billboards, posted rewards, and local police that are
trusted confidants.
Community-oriented and problem solving policing.
Personalized and localized security solutions by law
enforcement personnel who know the residents of
their community.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Auto Safety, Automated and
Intelligent Vehicle Highway Systems
- How much would it cost to add remote kill switches to new
model cars? Perhaps in combination with LoJacks (vehicle
locators). This would eventually end high-speed chases, a
significant source of officer fatalities.
- Is law enforcement ready to advocate for increasingly
automated vehicle navigation?
Thirty years from now, Automated Highway Systems (AHS) may
save half of the 42,000 auto fatalities a year in the US, perhaps
one third of the 1.3 million auto annually fatalities worldwide.
Consider the law enforcement resources that will be freed up
from auto-related activities in this transition.
In the interim, Intelligent Vehicle Highway Systems (IVHS) can
have increasing impact, and should be advocated for.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Simulation Games
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
America’s Army has been a great armed forces
simulation and recruiting tool. When can we expect
America’s Justice? America’s FBI?
Will Wright, creator of The Sims, would probably jump
at the chance to produce an appropriately funded and
sanctioned law enforcement simulation.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Virtual Crime Maps
When can we bring America’s Most Wanted into the
virtual space?
-
-
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
A universally accessible virtual police blotter for crime
in a major metro area would:
make people more aware of community crime
allow them to see law enforcement in action
make crime solving and cold cases more transparent
make high income cities more willing to fund crime
prevention programs in adjacent low-income, highcrime cities.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Financial Innovation
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
How do we securitize the safety of a
community?
Key Idea: Why don’t cities issue bonds with
interest rates keyed to public safety and
security indicators?
If traded publicly, there would be an incentive
to raise their value by lowering crime
indicators further.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Law Enforcement Partnership
with Private Legal Groups
Southern Poverty Law Center
Hate speech, racial intolerance, patriot groups.
How can law enforcement help their cause?
Who is the counterpart to the Electronic
Frontier Foundation?
Cyber freedoms come with cyber responsibilities.
Can law enforcement ask NGOs to engage in security activism?
Who is suing the authors of Hacking: The Art
of Exploitation, 2004 for incitement?
How do we minimize incitement? Laws? Conduct codes? Civics?
One Model: “hate speech” codes of conduct at U.S. universities.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Problems: Cyber Crime
US street crime is trending down since 1994
(Internet?). Cyber crime is increasing. Identity
theft is the number one cyber crime. Old
crime, powerful new venue.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Law Enforcement
Advocating for a Transparent Internet
Someone needs to advocate for an internet immune
system, a secure digital identity. This legal and
technological innovation will solve a host of security
problems.
Question: Law enforcement has a unique ability to paint
the true cost of identity theft and other cyber crime. Is
there an activist role for short term administrative
leaders or retiring officers here? Unseen strategic
partnerships?
When will cyberspace move out of the wild west?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Problems: Labor Unions and
Innovation
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Technologies that improve productivity necessarily
displace labor (robots, voicemail, etc.).
From 1983 to 2002, workers in protective service
occupations including police officers had the highest
union membership rate (37% in 2002) of any broad
occupation group in every year. (BLS)
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solutions: Labor Stratification (Temps
vs. Permanent)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Does your union acknowledge the necessity
for temp and contract workers and job
retraining in an age of constant productivity
innovation?
Do you have a set of permanent staff who get
extra pay and privileges for being beta testers
of a wide array of products and services (from
small and large businesses?)
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Problem: Metropolitan Staff
Redundancy
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Massive departmental duplication of law
enforcement staff function in adjacent cities.
How much money could be saved on a
gradual phase out of this system in every city
over 1 million population?
© 2005 Accelerating.org
Solution: Integrated Metro Model
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
Kaiser Permanente (HMO) has an integration
model that is working in medicine. One great
advantage, besides cost savings: more superand sub-specialist functions can now be
afforded. What super- and sub-specialists
would we want to see in law enforcement?
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Crime-ridden inner cities
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Crime-ridden inner cities
Solution: Subsidized front-lawn cameras
(camera traps) photographing all
neighborhood activity, car drive-bys, people,
etc.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Inadequate gun control
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Inadequate gun control
Solution: Networked legal and non-legal
weapons. Lojacked weapons (stings).
Approved database of networked weapon
manufacturers.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Widening income gaps, loss of middle
class weakens democracy
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Widening income gaps, loss of middle
class weakens democracy
Solution: This dynamic is pendular. There was
no middle class 100 years ago, maximum
middle class 50 years ago. How do we
reverse the current trend?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Underfunded, archaic, and overregulated public schools
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Underfunded, archaic, and overregulated public schools
Solution: Digital kids. More online education.
Home schooling resources. Young teacher
recruitment. Technology internships.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Culture of litigation
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Culture of litigation
Solution: Another pendular dynamic. Do we
have the right balance?
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Overly consumerist culture
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Overly consumerist culture
Solution: Media reform, access to alternative
views. Public education on individual and
social costs of consumption. IPTV and
intelligent internet are coming.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Lax campaign finance laws,
plutocratic politics.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
U.S. Problems & Solutions
Problem: Lax campaign finance laws,
plutocratic politics.
Solution: Plutocracy is pendular. What kind of
corporate and special interest excess will it
take to bring back a democratizing
President? (e.g. Teddy or Franklin Delano
Roosevelt?)
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org
VI. Conclusions
Conclusions
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
We live in a world in a world of accelerating
technological capacities.
There is an increasing opportunity gap between
potential and applied solutions.
Futures studies, innovation studies, and leadership
can help us prioritize and bridge this gap.
The FBI, as a member of the executive branch of the
world’s leading democracy, has a unique leadership
responsibilty.
Applying futures and innovation to the department
first, and the community second, will allow effective
leadership by example.
© 2005 Accelerating.org
In Appreciation
Thank you for inviting me.
The ASF would be honored to serve the FBI Futures
Working Group in achieving its 21st century goals.
Los Angeles
Palo Alto
© 2005 Accelerating.org