Transcript Slide 1

From Human to Transhuman:
Technology and the
Reconstruction of the World
Templeton Research Lecture
Arizona State University
October 22, 2007
Brad Allenby
Templeton Research Fellow
Lincoln Professor of Ethics and Engineering
Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering
Professor of Law
So long as we do not, through thinking,
experience what is, we can never belong to
what will be.
The flight into tradition, out of a combination
of humility and presumption, can bring about
nothing in itself other than self deception and
blindness in relation to the historical moment.
Source: M. Heidegger, The Question Concerning Technology and Other Essays, translation by W. Lovitt (New
York, Harper Torchbooks, 1977), “The Turning,” p. 49; “The Age of the World Picture,” p. 136.
“We are as gods, and we might as well
get good at it.”
Stewart Brand, 1968, Whole Earth Catalogue
“The future is already here; it’s just
unevenly distributed.”
William Gibson
“Now I am become Death, destroyer
of worlds.”
Vishnu, Bhagavad Gita, Robert Oppenheimer at
Trinity Test, 1945, White Sands, New Mexico
What Is Transhumanism?
• From the World Transhumanism Website:
• 1) The intellectual and cultural movement that affirms the
possibility and desirability of fundamentally improving the
human condition through applied reason, especially by
developing and making widely available technologies to
eliminate aging and to greatly enhance human
intellectual, physical, and psychological capacities.
• (2) The study of the ramifications, promises, and
potential dangers of technologies that will enable us to
overcome fundamental human limitations, and the
related study of the ethical matters involved in
developing and using such technologies.
We Are Already Transhuman
• The evolution of human varietals better suited to niche
conditions (e.g., “digital natives” with brains hardwired for
complex information environments)
• The distributed self (e.g., high percentage of males
experimenting with female avatars in virtual realities)
• Integration of individual cognition with distributed
information/technology structures (e.g., google as
substitute for factual memory)
• Augcog: information dense environments, such as
combat, require AI consciousness protection active filters
(AI as subconscious)
• Life extension through redesign of the human platform
Where Are We Now?
• The world is entering the “Age of Humans,” the
Anthropocene:
– Global climate change
– Biodiversity shift from “evolved biodiversity” to “engineered
biodiversity”
• Technology, especially the converging foundational
streams of nanotechnology, biotechnology, cognitive
science, robotics, and information and communication
technology, is critical locus of accelerating evolutionary
pressures.
• There is an extraordinary flight from ethical responsibility.
It is based on a profound misunderstanding of the world
as we have created it.
Key Concepts
• “Earth systems” include economic, technological, and
cultural systems, not just physical systems. Moreover,
the human/natural/built integrated systems of the
Anthropocene cannot be understood through just one
worldview, be it scientific, theological, or postmodern.
• Complexity and focus on systems
• Mutually exclusive but equally valid ontologies
• The world as design space (e.g., shift from “withdraw
from using fossil fuels” to “designer atmosphere”)
• The human as design space
• Result: radical contingency
Technology Clusters as Integrated
Systems: The Railroad Example
•
•
•
•
Railroads required a uniform, precise system of time,
and thus created “industrial time” and its associated
culture
Railroads created the need for, and co-evolved with,
national scale communications systems (telegraph) (all
technology systems have coupled infrastructures);
Railroad firms created modern managerial capitalism
(modern accounting, planning, and administration
systems);
Railroad firms created the modern capital and financial
markets (railroad construction was the single most
important stimulus to industrial growth in Western
Europe by 1840s);
Technology Clusters as Integrated
Systems: The Railroad Example
•
•
•
•
Railroads in the United States became a potent symbol of national
power, and, more subtly, instantiated and validated the US
integration of religion, morality and technology;
Railroads transformed landscapes at all scales: Chicago existed,
and structured the Midwest economically and environmentally,
because of railroads;
Like most major technological systems, railroads fundamentally
changed US economic and power structures, validating the US
nation-state and Manifest Destiny and restructuring the economy
from local/regional business concentrations to trusts (scale
economies of national markets); and,
Railroads dramatically changed the underlying teleology of
American culture, changing it from Jeffersonian agrarianism, an
Edenic teleology, to a technology-driven New Jerusalem, a
cultural schism that replays itself today in the continuing
environmentalist challenge to technology.
Case Study: The Autonomic City
• Trend 1: increasing integration of ICT at all scales in urban systems:
smart materials, smart buildings, smart infrastructure, regional
sensor systems of all kinds – and all interconnected.
– And increasingly virtual: highly complex Net-based systems (e.g.,
Google Earth) are being mashed against these evolving “smart urban
components” to create far more complex information topographies.
• Trend 2: ICT itself evolving to be qualitatively more complex:
– autonomic ICT at all scales, from chip, to PC/assembly, to global
communications networks
– Piggybacked on Net, an auto-catalytic, self-designing system
• Result: The Autonomic City, already here, profoundly different from
anything we know, but essentially invisible to us
The Autonomic City: Portents
• Remember October 19, 1987 – “Black Monday” – Dow
Jones dropped 22% in one day. Main reason: internal
systems dynamics (multiplying independent
computerized trading programs with “sell” floors working
in an integrated system), not major changes in market
fundamentals.
• This was simple system: What happens at much more
complex urban systems level? Who’s even looking?
• Note that the trick is in the interplay of technology with
cultural and economic systems at many different scales.
Case Study 2: The Human as
Design Space
• Leon Kass, Chair of President’s Council on Bioethics:
“Victory over mortality is the unstated but implicit goal of
modern medical science.” (Nature editorial, 2004,
432:657).
• Some consider significant lifetime extension probable
within decades, with “synthetic biology” approach that
applies engineering models and systems to biology. ICT
view: “Engineering and Aging” – using “engineered
negligible senescence” to control ageing will allow
average ages of well over 100 within a few decades
(IEEE Spectrum, 2004, 41(9):10, 31-35).
• Two separate discourses – bioengineering and ICT claim “functional immortality” within 50 years (beyond
horizon where most observers feel able to predict at all)
Changing The Human:
Evolution of Cognitive Networks
– Cognition (including memory) dispersed over Net, enhancing
individual cognitive power and changing nature of wetwarebased cognition (“intelligence” changes from fact-based to
“navigate different realities gracefully” based). How do we
educate for this change?
– Drugs: “At least 40 potential cognitive enhancers are currently in
clinical development” (The Economist, Technology Quarterly,
September 18th, 2004).
– MRIs (brain hardwiring) of young developed country “digital
natives” different than that of their parents, or non-Net youth.
The real digital divide is already biologically based.
– Nicolelis at Duke: monkey with brain implants moves mechanical
arm in next room; Schwarz at U. Pitt: monkeys with implants use
mechanical arm to feed themselves.
Changing The Human:
Evolution of Cognitive Networks
– Kennedy at Neural Signals: cone implant entirely
sealed within brain enabled completely paralyzed
patient to move cursor; Donoghue at Cyberkinetics:
implant multiple needle electrode in patient, who
within two months could open email, change
television channels, switch lights on and off, and
operate robotic arm (Braingate to be on market 2007).
– Wolpaw/McFarland – external cap allows paraplegic
control of cursor
– DARPA and DoD?
THE HUMAN AS DESIGN SPACE:
IMPLICATIONS
• Given economic, national security, cultural
competitiveness, psychological and other
drivers, it is highly unlikely redesign of human
and nature will be stopped
• “Meaning” will become clearly contingent,
deliberately constructed phenomenon (by elite?
By democratic choice?). Think Fox News.
• “Truth” will be replaced by contingency and
constructed behaviors and networks at
perceivable timescales: “All that is solid melts
into air” (Marx).
THE HUMAN AS DESIGN SPACE:
IMPLICATIONS
• Baseline terms and assumptions – including ethical and religious
concepts and values - are becoming contingent within the cycle
times of decisionmaking, political action, and cultural perceptual
horizons.
• What will it mean to have to be facile in a number of different
“realities” – many “Digital Natives” already are.
• What happens when humans become integrated combinations of
technology and biology, with designs dictated by whimsy, fashion,
money or industrial demand (note much initial genetic work is being
done for professional athletics; plastic surgery as fashion).
• Major social conflict when religions realize that all components of
the human are contingent, and it becomes clear that meaning is
manufactured and historically/culturally contingent, and wholly
anthropogenic.
FIDES ET RATIO: JOHN PAUL II
• Faith and reason are like two wings on which the
human spirit rises to the contemplation of truth
[introduction].
• This truth, which God reveals to us in Jesus
Christ, is not opposed to the truths which
philosophy perceives. On the contrary, the two
modes of knowledge lead to truth in all its
fullness. The unity of truth is a fundamental
premise of human reasoning, as the principle of
non-contradiction makes clear. [para 34]
Encyclical Letter, FIDES ET RATIO, of the Supreme Pontiff JOHN PAUL II to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on the
Relationship Between Faith and Reason, 1998.
FIDES ET RATIO: JOHN PAUL II
• Both the light of reason and the light of faith come from God, he [St.
Thomas Aquinas] argued; hence there can be no contradiction
between them. . . . More radically, Thomas recognized that nature,
philosophy's proper concern, could contribute to the understanding
of divine Revelation. Faith therefore has no fear of reason, but seeks
it out and has trust in it. Just as grace builds on nature and brings it
to fulfilment, so faith builds upon and perfects reason. [para 43,
references omitted]
• It is an illusion to think that faith, tied to weak reasoning, might be
more penetrating; on the contrary, faith then runs the grave risk of
withering into myth or superstition. By the same token, reason which
is unrelated to an adult faith is not prompted to turn its gaze to the
newness and radicality of being. . . . This is why I make this strong
and insistent appeal—not, I trust, untimely—that faith and
philosophy recover the profound unity which allows them to stand in
harmony with their nature without compromising their mutual
autonomy. [para. 48, references omitted]
Encyclical Letter, FIDES ET RATIO, of the Supreme Pontiff JOHN PAUL II to the Bishops of the Catholic Church on the
Relationship Between Faith and Reason, 1998.
Science and Religion, II
This is our way of seeing how God created the
universe, and [the Vatican] wants to make a
strong statement that truth doesn’t contradict
truth; that if you have faith, you’re never going
to be afraid of what science comes up with.
Because it’s true.
“Guy Consolmagno, curator of the Vatican meteorite collection describes
how Catholicism has nothing to fear from the discoveries of science.”
quoted in NewScientist 196(2624):12 (6 October 2007).
Undermining the Enlightenment
•
Radically increasing complexity:
–
–
–
–
a) static complexity
b) dynamic complexity
c) “wicked” complexity
d) scale
–
Implications can be profound: Marxism in the Soviet
Union and China collapsed not from external
conquest or even from Reagan’s vaunted spend
race, but rather because the centralized economic
model adopted by large Marxist societies simply
became incapable of managing the complexity
inherent in a modern industrial economy.
Undermining the Enlightenment
•
Accelerating evolution of technology systems,
especially ICT, combined with the postmodern
fragmenting of time, space and culture,
dramatically decreases the stability of all
cultural constructs:
–
–
–
Externally, the social and cultural landscapes that
we look out on;
Internally, that which looks out – the self and our
individuality
Fundamentalism is the reaction to radical
contingency introduced by accelerating change
Undermining the Enlightenment
•
Transhumanism is often viewed, particularly by opponents, as a
conflict between the human; rather, what is already happening is
that the two are merging.
Failure of current modes of simplification:
•
–
Many groups, from deep greens to Marxists to religious conservatives
opposing modernity, cling to ideologies and older worldviews
But ideological approaches of all kinds are particularly problematic
given rapid change:
–
•
•
•
•
Oversimplification;
Based on past verities, and thus embed assumptions and implications
that are necessarily increasingly anachronistic in a period of rapid and
discontinuous change
They create a utopian vision validating an “ends justify the means”
morality;
They cut off information transfer and dialog, and are profoundly antidemocratic, anti-intellectual, and anti-rational.
Undermining the Enlightenment
.
•
•
•
Transhumanism and technological change may well mark the end of the
great Enlightenment project of radical democratic power. A world marked by
inter-national patterns of inequality is increasingly becoming a world where
an elite skilled in navigating complex and information dense environments
dominates, and more and more others sink into a global proletariat.
This proletariat opposes technological evolution in increasingly effective
ways in democratic states, but can be finessed in authoritarian states. This
rapidly growing base is incapable of keeping pace with continuing change,
unable to integrate into the information webs that increasingly define human
cognition, and aghast at the changes in lifestyle, income distribution, relative
power relationships, and changes in sexual and family roles and structures
that have resulted.
Because accelerating technological change can only increase opposition to
itself, and yet it is an important component of cultural dominance,
technology generally and transhumanism specifically enhances cultural
competitiveness only where democratic mechanisms do not enable activist
opposition that increasingly hobbles technological evolution
A New Authenticity
•
•
•
•
•
We must recognize and accept the world as it is, not as various ideologies would
wish it to be.
We must accept that the new human condition requires each person to accept the
personal validity of their cognitive networks, while simultaneously recognizing
them as contingent and stochastic in a world characterized by mutually exclusive
but equally valid ontologies.
We must accept the epistemological and existential implications of complex
adaptive systems, in that any perceptual or cognitive network, or understanding of
a complex system, is created by the query posed to the system, and thus
embodies unavoidable reflexivity between the system and the cognitive network,
and implies the contingency and incompleteness of any particular perspective on a
complex adaptive system.
Given proposition 3, we must have the integrity to create appropriate queries,
since they will structure the cognitive networks within which we operate.
Substituting wistful fantasies for honest query or gameplaying the query process to
create ideologically predetermined local realities must be rejected as profoundly
inauthentic.
We must accept the condition that meaning, truth, and values are functions of
network state, and thus are contingent and continually regenerated in a reflexive
dialog between cognitive systems posing queries to, and thus generating
configurations of, external complex adaptive systems.
A New Authenticity
•
•
•
•
•
That which you most believe, you must distrust the most. Meaning, and truth,
arise from the dialectical process of their continued rejection.
We must accept rationality as partial and constructed, an interplay between
different and contingent ontologies and partial structures of underlying complex
adaptive systems, congealed intentionality and cognition, and institutional and
network dynamics – without, however, slipping into a solipsistic relativism, which is
its own form of inauthenticity.
Even though the macroethics of complex adaptive systems are beyond the level of
the individual, authenticity requires that each individual, operating in good faith,
participate in establishing institutional capabilities to dialog with such systems, be
they technological, environmental, biological, cultural, or social.
We must thoughtfully reject the ideologies and frameworks characteristic of the
first Enlightenment, and actively participate in the reinvention of the Enlightenment
for a profoundly multicultural, and much more complex, world.
Authenticity requires understanding that the individual is a contingent framework
that has worked well in the past, but is increasingly dysfunctional in a complex
world characterized by cognitive networks extending across technological,
biological, and human systems, and the evolution of transhuman variants, already
well underway. Thus, authenticity demands acceptance of cognition as
increasingly involving production of emergent systems characteristics at levels
higher than the individual.
“He, only, merits freedom and existence
Who wins them every day anew.”
(Goethe, 1833, Faust, lines 11,575-76)