Malta Piracy Rate: 45% Losses: 7 million Dollars

Download Report

Transcript Malta Piracy Rate: 45% Losses: 7 million Dollars

Dr. Simon Schembri
Trusts
 Creation
 Oral
of Trusts
Trusts
 Validity
of Trusts
1.1 Oral Trusts
Article 7 of the Trusts and Trustees Act (Chapter 331):
7(1)
Within the meaning of Article 3, a Trust may come into existence in
any manner.
(2)
Without prejudice to the generality of sub-article (1), a Trust may
come into existence unilaterally or otherwise by means of an oral
declaration, or by an instrument in writing including by a will, by
operation of Law or by a judicial decision.
Provided that where assets are held, acquired or received by
a person for another on the basis of oral arrangements of a fiduciary
nature, express or implied, there shall be presumed to be a
mandate regulated by Title XVIII of Book Second of the Civil Code or
a deposit regulated by Title XIX of Book Second of the Civil Code, as
the case may be, unless there is evidence of an intention to create
an oral trust.
A vs. B


“ evidence of intention to create an oral trust”
“Il- Qorti kellha l- opportunita` li tisma’ lil rapprezentant
tal- Bank, u hi moralment konvinta li fil- laqgha li saret 30
ta’ Mejju 2008 mal- konjugi..., bdiet tezisti trust permezz
ta’ dikjarazzjoni verbali. Ix- xhieda… ma thalli l- ebda
dubju li dik kienet il- volonta’ tal- konjugi…L- intenzjoni
taghhom kienet li jkunu certi li wara li jmutu ma jkun [lit –
tifla] jonqosha xejn. Fil- fatt kienu diga` ghamlu l- ewwel
pass f’ April 2007 meta fethu [Bank]Trust Account u
saret referenza ghal The ABC Trust, li sa dakinhar kienet
ghandha ma tezistix..... In- notamenti li ha l- uffical talBank fil- laqgha li saret fit- 30 ta’ Mejju 2008, huma prova
ohra li dakinhar bdiet tezisti The ABC Trust. Notamenti li
gew traskritti u ffirmati minnu u maghluqin fil- vault talbank li ghandu x’ jaqsam mat- trusts.”
A vs. B (cont)
Article 7(3) of the TTA:
A unilateral declaration of trust is a declaration in writing
made by a trustee stating that it is the trustee of a trust,
containing all the terms of the trust as well as the names or
the information enabling the identification of all the
beneficiaries.
Corn Marine Case
(Warrant of Prohibitory Injunction –
22nd September 2010)

Warrant of prohibitory Injunction – prima facie
evidence

Shares held on trust? Was there ‘evidence of
intention to create an oral trust’?

Official Documentation (M&A, Share Register)

Qualified Person (Article 43(9) of the TTA)
Corn Marine Case (cont)
Adherence to formalities requisite for the
creation of a trust?
 Personal v. Immovable property
 The position with regards to shares

“For shares to be transferred validly under statute
such that a trustee is vested with the legal title in
those shares, it is necessary that the shares be
registered in the name of the trustee (Hudson)”

Is there a requirement to register the
trust/fiduciary relationship even though this
was created prior to the coming into force of
the TTA?
Corn Marine Case (cont)

“Il- Qorti wara li fliet id- dokumenti a dispozizzjoni ...... hi
konvinta li prima facie ir- rikorrenti Charles Gamon u
konsegwentement Lintec Trading limited ippruvaw li
prima facie jivvantaw dritt fuq tmenin sehem mill- ishma
li ghandha registrata f’isimha Caden Limited fis- socjeta`
Corn Marine Limited liema ishma qed jigu mizmuma
mill- istess Caden Limited bhala prestanome ghal
Charles Gamon u konsegwentement Lintec Trading
Limited.”
1.2
Validity of Trusts

“There are three forms of certainty which the courts require:
certainty of intention to create a trust; certainty of identity of
the subject matter comprising the trust fund; and certainty of
the beneficiaries (or ‘objects’) of the trust” (Knight vs. Knight)

Settlor’s intention must clearly be to create a trust - the
courts will be prepared to infer that there was an intention to
create a trust from the circumstances and the parties conduct,
even though there is no written evidence as in the case with oral
trusts (A vs. B) or when the wording used is not clear

However if the surrounding circumstances and other facts point
to a different intention then that which have been prescribed in
writing then the courts after giving due consideration from such
facts of the true intention of the settlor would declare such trust
to be merely a sham
Validity of Trusts (Cont)



The true intention of the parties must be to create a trust.
Article 3 of the TTA:
“A trust exist where a person (called a trustee) holds, as
owner or has vested in him property under an obligation to
deal with that property for the benefit of persons (called the
beneficiaries), whether or not yet ascertained or in
existence, which is not for the benefit only of the trustee, or
for a charitable purpose, or for both such benefit and
purpose aforesaid.”
Rahman v. Chase Bank Trust Company - trust
arrangement was seen as a sham and the trustee as a
mere agent
The Vossberg Case
(27 February 2009 –subject to appeal)



Actio Pauliana – ‘Eventus Danni’ and ‘Consilium Fraudis’
Settlement of property on trust amounted to a gratuitous or
an onerous transfer? If onerous animus nocendi of trustee
must be proved as well.
Art. 962 of the Civil Code:
“(1) When each of the parties undertakes an obligation, the
contract is termed onerous.
(2) When one of the parties gratuitously procures an advantage to
the other, the contract is termed gratuitous.”

Art. 3(1) of the TTA:
“a trusts exists where a person (called a trustee) holds, as owner or
has vested in him property under an obligation to deal with that
property for the benefit of persons (called the beneficiaries)…”
The Vossberg case (cont)



“Poiche` il trust e` un negozio programmatico, in quanto la funzione
del trustee e` gestire i beni a lui affidati osservando le regole
stabilite e le previsioni della legge regolatrice scelta, il legislatore
deduce la causa contrattuale dal comportamento imposto al
trustee. La conseguenza di una simile scelta e` la mancata richiesta
di una somma quale corrispettivo del transferimento dei beni ai
trustee senza pero` considerare il vincolo in trust un atto di
donazione.” [Berti-Riboli/Ganado]
Trustee also paid for his services [Article 28 TTA]
The court decided that since the settlement of the property on trust
is deemed to be an onerous one, the plaintiff had to prove that the
trustee also had the animus nocendi.
“F’ dina l- kawza l- attrici ittentat tannulla dana t- trust permezz ta’ lazzjoni pauliana izda fil- fehma tal- Qorti ma gewx pruvati lelementi kollha rikjesti mill- Ligi biex tigi ezercitata dina l- azzjoni
kontra l- konvenuti. Taht dina l- azzjoni billi l- att kien wiehed oneruz
l- attrici kellha tipprova li l-konvenuti Equinox kienu jafu li l- att li sar
kien ta’ hsara ghall- kreditur.”
The Vossberg Case (cont)

It appears that the court would have been ready to
declare the trust in question as a sham, had the plaintiff
chosen a different action than the action pauliana:
“L-attrici setghet tattakka dan it- trust bhala illegali jew
sham billi tipprova li kollox kien montautura u li l- partijiet
ma kellhom ebda intenzjoni li tigi krejata trust u li ttrustee kien biss “a mere puppet dancing to the bidding of
the settlor”
2. Fiduciary Obligations

Introducing the concept of Fiduciary
Obligations

Application of Fiduciary Obligations in our
legal system

Fiduciary Obligations in employment matters

Fiduciary Obligations relating to
lawyers/accountants
2.1 The Concept of Fiduciary Obligations
The main trait common to civil law institutes such as mandate, deposit
 Trust one of the sources that give rise to fiduciary obligations.


Article 1124 A of the Civil Code - entered into force 1st January 2005:
1124A. (1) Fiduciary obligations arise in virtue of law, contract, obligations,
quasi-contract, trusts, assumption of office or behaviour whenever a person
(the ''fiduciary'') (a) owes a duty to protect the interests of another person;
or
(b) holds, exercises control or powers of disposition over
property for the benefit of other persons, including
when he is vested with ownership of such property for
such purpose; or
(c) receives information from another person subject to a
duty of confidentiality and such person is aware or
ought, in the circumstances, reasonably to have been
aware, that the use of such information is intended to
be restricted.

Fiduciary obligations not solely tied with trusts
2.2 Application of Fiduciary Obligations

Where fiduciary obligations applicable/in existence prior to
the introduction of Article 1124 of the Civil Code?

Yolanda Carabott v. Pauline Calamatta ( 10th June 2008)
“Illi li kieku il- kaz sehh wara l- 2004 kienu japplikaw ukoll
id- disposizzjonijiet tal- Kodici Civili dwar l- obbligazzjonijiet
fiducjarji u fost dawn l- obbligazzjonijiet il- ligi trid illi lfiducjarju irid jezercita diligenza ta’ bonus pater familias flezekuzzjoni ta’ l- obbligi tieghu u jevita kull konflitt ta’
interess fost obbligazzjonijiet ohra.”

Mandatary was still bound in terms of Art. 1132 of the Civil
Code
2.2 Application of Fiduciary Obligations (Cont)

Joann Cordina v. Charles Cordina ( 26th September 2007)
“Bl- Att XIII ta’ l- 2004 gew introdotti emendi komprensivi filKodici Civili dwar id- dmirijiet ta` fiducjarju(Artikolu 1124A talKodici Civili) u dwar il- mandate prestanome (principju li kien
ilu jigi applikat fis- sistema guridika taghna). Il- Qorti tqies li
bid-dhul fis- sehh ta’ dan l- Att, is- sitwazzjoni giet hafna
iktar iccarata...”
2.3 Fiduciary Obligations in Employment
Matters
Anthony Caruana & Sons v Christopher Caruana (24th
September 2010 – subject to Appeal)
 First Court confirmed the inapplicability of fiduciary obligations to
dealings prior to 1st January 2005
 General Manager – does this role give rise to fiduciary
obligations? How is the institute of manager regulated under our
law?
 First Court held that fiduciary obligations arise from one’s office if
he would be holding a policy making position
 What about the situation where employees due to their position
are entrusted with information of a confidential nature?
2.4 Fiduciary Obligations relating to
lawyers/accountants


Lawyers/Accountants owe a duty of loyalty towards their
clients
Desmond Mizzi et v. Dr. Tonio Fenech (19th May 2010
– subject to Appeal)
 Valuation Committee (composed of lawyer/accountant)
accused of acting impartially and breaching its fiduciary
obligations
 Bristol and West Building Society v Mothew - where a
lawyer or accountant act for two principals, even if they
have conflicting interests, they must act in good faith in the
interests of each and must not act with the intention of
furthering the interests of one principal to the prejudice of
those of the other
Thank You
Mamo TCV Advocates
Palazzo Pietro Stiges
90, Strait Street
Valletta VLT1436
Malta
Telephone:
Fax:
(+356) 21232271
(+356) 21231345
(+356) 21244291
(+356) 21231298
www.mamotcv.com
E-Mail: [email protected]