Transcript Document

Presentation to Industry
Action Plan for Summer 2004
April 1, 2004
[email protected]
225/219-3434
Overview
•
•
•
•
•
•
Current Status of Baton Rouge Area
Re-classification to Severe
Chapter 22 NOx Rule
HRVOC Workgroup
HRVOC Survey
Action Plan for Summer 2004
2
Current Status of BR Area
• 1-Hr Standard




No more than 3 exceedances in 3 years at
any monitor (10 monitors in BRNA)
Exceedance =/>125ppb (truncated)
Capitol and LSU were out for 01-03 and
already have 4 hits for current 02-04 period
See Table
3
1-Hr Ozone Status
Monitor
2002
Baker
2003
2004
02-04
03-05
1
1
2
2
Capitol
2
2
4
2
LSU
1
3
4
3
Port Allen
1
2
3
2
B Plaquemine
1
1
2
1
2
2
2
17
12
Pride
Carville
Grosse Tete
Dutchtown
F Settlement
Total
5
11
1
4
Current Status of BR Area
• 8-Hr Standard




4th highest value each year is averaged over
a 3 year period
Exceedance =/> 85ppb (truncated)
LSU monitor was out for 2001-03
See Table
5
8-Hr Ozone Status
2002
(4th Hi)
2003
(4th Hi)
01-03
2004
(4th Hi
2004
(trigger)
Baker
83
88
84
60
84
Capitol
79
82
80
54
94
LSU
78
100
86
59
77
Pride
75
80
77
60
100
Port Allen
80
89
84
61
86
B Plaquemine
73
81
77
59
101
Carville
75
89
84
58
91
Grosse Tete
74
81
78
61
100
Dutchtown
75
77
75
58
103
F Settlement
75
82
77
59
98
1
to 3/21
Monitor (ppb)
Monitors Out
6
1-Hr Summary
• LSU monitor already has 3 hits for 2005
• Capitol, Port Allen, and Carville have 2
Exceedances in 2004 and 2005 (especially at
LSU) are crucial or the area will be out of
attainment in 2005 – the Clean Air Act
attainment year.
7
Re-Classification to Severe
• BR was originally classified serious with an
attainment date of 1999.
• Modeling showed that the area was being
affected by ozone transport from Houston.
• Under EPA guidance, an extension to 2005
was granted based on transport.
• Under pressure EPA pulled the approval and
the area was bumped-up to severe with a
2005 attainment date. (June 23, 2003)
8
Consequences of Bump-Up
• Definition of major source reduced from 50
tpy to 25 tpy for both NOx and VOC (revise
Chapters 21 and 22)
• Offset requirements increase to 1.3 with
LAER and 1.5 to avoid LAER (Lowest
Achievable Emission rate)
• Reformulated Gasoline (RFG)
• Section 185 fees for failure-to-attain by2005
9
Section 185 Fees
(rule in comment period until 4/2)
• Fees start in 2007 (for 2006) and continue
until the area is in attainment
• Exemptions: (EPA opposed, no exemptions)


if equipped with minimum 95% control; or
if equipped with BACT
• Baseline is the average of annual emissions
of VOC and NOx from non-exempt sources
for the most representative 3 years between
1998 and 2002. (EPA opposed, must be 2005)
10
Section 185 Fees (continued)
Fee = [A-(80% x B)] x C
A = Total actual VOC and NOX emissions
in previous year from non-exempt sources
B = Baseline amount (tons)
C = $5,000 per ton adjusted by CPI to
subject year (approximately $8,000)
11
Chapter 22 NOx Rule
• Promulgated March 2002
• Applicable in 9 parishes during ozone season
• Establishes emission factors for boilers, heaters,
furnaces, turbines and engines
• Sources must be in compliance by 5/1/05
• Average point NOx reduction is 30%
• Model shows attainment in 2005
Revision for severe classification by June 23
12
HRVOC Workgroup
• 1-hour ozone design value has dropped
from around 170 ppb in the early 90s to the
low 130s ppb today
• VOC and NOx have been dropping steadily
since the early 90s
• See VOC and NOx graphs
13
Point Source VOC Emissions Trend
Baton Rouge Nonattainment Area (1990-2002)
45000
40000
TONS PER YEAR
35000
30000
25000
20000
15000
10000
5000
90
93
94
95
96
97
YEAR
98
99
00
01
02
Data Source: DEQ
14
Point Source NOx Emissions Trend
Baton Rouge Nonattainment Area (1990-2002)
80000
TONS PER YEAR
70000
60000
50000
40000
30000
20000
10000
0
90
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
00
01
02
YEAR
Data Source: DEQ
15
HRVOC Workgroup (continued)
• Continuing to have exceedances (11 in 03)
• Plot shows rapid ozone formation events
(greater than 40ppb/hr rise) - see graph
• Similar spikes in Houston, Texas 2000 Air
Study implicated HRVOC – 1,3-butadiene,
acetaldehyde, butenes, ethylene, propylene,
toluene and xylenes
16
Sept 11, 2002 Ozone
180
Capitol
160
LSU
B Plaquemine
120
100
P Allen
80
60
40
20
22
20
18
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
0
O3 ppbv
140
Hour
Capitol
Baker
LSU
Port Allen
Carville
Bayou Plaquemine
Pride
17
HRVOC Workgroup (continued)
• Workgroup (DEQ, Industry, Environmentalists)
formed to evaluate role of HRVOC.
• Recommendations:





Add NOx at Dutchtown, Met at LSU and Carville
Add continuous VOC at LSU, Capitol, Carville
Add VOC canister every 6th day at others
Record 5 minute data in addition to 1 hour average
Develop database for past and future data, perform
statistical analyses
18
VOC
Site
NOx
O3
Met
3-hr
(daily)
3-hr
(3-days)
Capitol



*

Trigger
(1 ppm of
TNMHC)(3
)
LSU


*
*
*
*
Bayou Plaquemine



Port Allen



Pride



Dutchtown
*


*
Baker




Carville


*
Grosse Tette



French Settlement




24-hr
(6-days)

*



*
*
Southern


South Scotlandville

*
19
HRVOC Survey
• Purpose was to identify sources of HRVOC
(TEDI-toxics, EIS-total VOC, TRI-facility)
• Sent to 148 facilities in BR area
• 62 met criteria of >1,000 lbs/yr HRVOC
emissions and submitted information
• Results:
 See graphs
20
HRVOC Emissions by Chemical
xylene
6.4%
butenes
6.4%
acetaldehyde
2.8%
1,3-butadiene
2.2%
ethylene
44.8%
propylene
12.5%
toluene
24.9%
Total = 3,500,000 lbs
21
HRVOC Emissions by Emission Type
non-routine
1.26%
start-up/shutdown
3.25%
accidental
9.33%
loading/unloading
0.97%
other
0.10%
routine
52.45%
fugitives
32.63%
22
Breakdown of Routine Category
analyzer
6%
wastewater
2%
Cooling Tower
2%
miscellaneous
6%
process vents
47%
Flare
8%
Tank/Silo
29%
23
HRVOC Emissions by Estimation Method
educated guess other
2.9%
1.4%
calculated
6.2%
measured
8.7%
modeled
0.6%
factors
35.5%
engineering
estimate
9.5%
estimated
13.9%
material balance
21.2%
24
Action Plan for Summer 2004
• Review Environmental Management System




Are all emissions being accounted for?
Can emissions be lowered by reducing at
source, recycling, recovery or treatment?
Are measured values being used, where
available, to estimate the quantity of emissions?
Are the latest and best factors and estimation
methodologies being used?
25
Action Plan for Summer 2004
(continued)
• Fugitives – before Summer - consider remote
imaging to survey regulated and non-regulated
components where HRVOC could leak, make
extraordinary attempts to fix tagged leakers
• Flares – always operate within design, delay
discretionary flaring to evening
• Cooling Towers – check inlets weekly for
HRVOC, fix leaks as soon as possible
• Wastewater – reduce HRVOC wherever
possible
26
Action Plan for Summer 2004
(continued)
• Analyzer Vents – route to flare or minimize
• Shutdowns – do early or postpone until after
ozone season
• Maintenance/Equipment Opening – delay
until evening, refueling in late evening
• Seasonal Activities – delay painting until later
in year, do grass cutting in evenings, etc.
27
Summary
• Ozone exceedances in downtown BR in
2004/05 will put the area out of attainment.
• If this happens, emission fees will kick-in.
• Facilities are asked to develop action plans
to reduce emissions, especially HRVOC,
but also, other VOC and NOx.
28
Fugitive Monitoring
• EPA is preparing an alternate to Method 21
that will allow Remote Imaging by end 04.
 laserimagingsystems.com
 leaksurveysinc.com
 patinc.com/Sherlock.htm
29