SURVEYING WOMEN’S DRINKING: 20 YEARS OF LEARNING HOW

Download Report

Transcript SURVEYING WOMEN’S DRINKING: 20 YEARS OF LEARNING HOW

Some core findings in research on self-change and some implications for practice

(with an emphasis on Swedish research and addiction care in Sweden) Dansk Selskab for Misbrugspsykologi Seminar om ’self-change’

København, 10 December 2007

© Jan Blomqvist

Topical issues in handling addiction problems in Sweden:

The alcohol field: Accession to the EU

disarmament of tra ditional alcohol policy

increasing con sumtion; perceived need for alternatives The drugs field: Increasing abuse; increasing mortality

ambition to strengthen traditional restrictive policy New interest in addiction care:

—

New resources for care of ”heavy” abusers (coerced care /”care chains”)

—

National guidelines for treatment of substance abuse and dependence

The state of art of addiction care in Sweden

© Jan Blomqvist

The official picture of addiction care

National Board of Health and Welfare on addiction care (2005): … There are good examples, but … Interventions are often ad hoc and ill planned, and treatment is often interrupted … Intense (but often unsuccesful) treatment attemps alternate with long periods without support … Relapse seems to be the standard outcome of fragmented interventions

Some research-based conclusions:

        

Low professional consensus (ideology; theory; terminology) Differing views on alcohol and drug problems (the drug addict more alien and worse out) Large between-unit differences (what you get depends on where you live) Large within-unit differences (what you get depends on who you meet) Lacking legal security (coercive care) Few ask for the client’s own opinion Everyone is not judged alike – but economy, local traditions, and ideology as important as – or more important than – clients’ needs and whishes Large resources are spent on a small group with severe social and psychological problems, who turn up repeatedly Persons with less severe problems / earlier stages / with better social resources are not reached by / reluctant to contact the treatment system (low availability / fear of stigmatisation /low confidence in existing treatment)

(E.g., Blomqvist & Wallander, 2004; Wallander & Blomqvist, 2005; Blomqvist et al., 2007))

Evidence-based practice guidelines – some pros and cons

© Jan Blomqvist

Arguments in favour of EBP:

Humanism:

- focus on outcome, not on legislation/procedural rules or on ”filling beds” (clients’ welfare, not staff’s comfort or safety)

Certainty:

- focus on facts, not personal convictions or beliefs (what actually works, rather than guesswork or ”sunshine stories”)

Utility, economic rationality:

- tax payers can’t afford that money are spent on activities that do not effectively solve the problems in question

© Jan Blomqvist

How ”evidence based” is Swedish addiction care?

(National inventory, 2005; ”bearing ingredients”)

Social skills training (32 %)

Ego-strengthening therapy / suport (31 %)

12-step treatment / Minnesota model (25 %)

Cognitive behavior therapy (19 %)

Solution-focused treatment (16 %)

Social-pedagogical model (responsibility training) (11 %)

Motivational interviewing (10 %)

System-theoretical model (10 %)

Behavior therapy (10 %)

Acupuncture ( 9 %)

…………………

Community Reinforcement Approach – CRA ( 1 %)

………………..

About 1/3 of all units offer medicine-assisted treatment

Actual vs. recommended methods in Swedish addiction care ( ” matches” & ”mismatches” with National guidelines, 2007)

Social skills training (32 %)

Ego-strengthening therapy / suport (31 %)

12-step treatment / Minnesota model (25 %)

Cognitive behavior therapy (19 %)

Solution-focused treatment (16 %)

Social-pedagogical model (responsibility training) (11 %)

Motivational interviewing (10 %)

System-theoretical model (10 %)

Behavior therapy (10 %)

Acupuncture ( 9 %)

…………………

Community Reinforcement Approach – CRA ( 1 %)

………………..

About 1/3 of all units offer medicine-assisted treatment

      

RCTs useful /needed for:

Valid causal inferences Discarding of ineffective and harmful methods Basis for resource allocation - aggregate level

However:

The most practiced metods have not been studied in RCTs (what is ”unspecific support”?) Ever-changing knowledge base (guidelines may be obsolete before publishing)

 

Moderate effects; control groups change as well Results at group level not necessarily valid at individual level (but we know little about what is best for whom)

”Method” explains only part of the outcome variance

Dividing the outcome variance pie

Method/ technique: 15% Extra-therapeutic factors 40% Clients' expectations: 15% (Lambert, 1992) The therapeutic alliance: 30%

© Jan Blomqvist

      

RCTs useful /needed for:

Valid causal inferences Discarding of ineffective and harmful methods Basis for resource allocation - aggregate level

However:

The most practiced metods have not been studied in RCTs (what is ”unspecific support”?) Ever-changing knowledge base (guidelines may be obsolete before publishing)

 

Moderate effects; control groups change as well Results at group level not necessarily valid at individual level (but we know little about what is best for whom)

 

”Method” explains only part of the outcome variance Limited external validity (only treated persons; selection and standardization of therapies, therapists, clients)

Heterogenous problems:

who have been studied and who are treated?

RCT-studies Addiction care

      

RCTs useful /needed for:

Valid causal inferences Discarding of ineffective and harmful methods Basis for resource allocation - aggregate level

However:

The most practiced metods have not been studied in RCTs (what is ”unspecific support”?) Ever-changing knowledge base (guidelines may be obsolete before publishing)

 

Moderate effects; control groups change as well Results at group level not necessarily valid at individual level (but we know little about what is best for whom)

  

”Method” explains only part of the outcome variance Limited external validity (only treated persons; selection and standardization of therapies, therapists, clients) Short-term consequences of time-limited interventions (but what happens before, outside of, and after the treatment is also important)

Research on ”natural recovery” or ”self-change”

© Jan Blomqvist

Historical ”natural recovery” issues:

Does ”natural recovery” exist?

How common is ” natural recovery”?

Who are the ” natural recoverers”?

Which are the underlying processes?

© Jan Blomqvist

”Self-change” – from ”mis-diagnosis” to ”the natural thing”

Some ”classic” studies: Les Drew (Australia, 1968): alcoholism as a self-limiting disease Charles Winnick (USA; early 1960s): ”maturing out” of drug addiction Lee Robins (USA; 1970s): Vietnam veterans stopped addiction at return Past decade: Abundance of ”self-change” studies: Canada, Switzerland, Sweden, Finland, Germany, GB, USA, Australia, Spain and other countries; The occurence of ”self-change” widely recognised (less so for drugs) ”Whether formal treatment is involved or not, ’assisted self-recovery’ is the norm (Blomqvist & Cameron, 2002) Studies of the interplay between environmental influences, formal help experiences and internal processes in long-term recovery

Change of perspectives on alcohol problems: The Alcoholism Paradigm New Public Health Approach Problematic drinking is: Underlying mechanisms: Character of process: Policy implications: Individual development: ”Natural recovery” Out of subject's control Bio-chemical; neuro physiological Intractability Treatment offers (not moralising or punishment) Irreversible progression, chronicity (if not halted by treatment) Volitional Pleasure-seeking; influenced by availability, norms, social pressure etc.

Changeability Reducing aggregate-level consumption Unpredictable (transition, flux) Non-existing or represents mis diagnosis

© Jan Blomqvist

Normal, expected

How common is ”self-change”?

Smart (1975): annual rates of ”spontanoeus recovery” from alcoholism: 1 % - 33 % (nine studies)

Waldorf & Biernacki (1979): nine studies on ”spontanoeus recovery” from drug addiction: equally varying annual rates

Sobell et al. (1996) ”natural recovery” the predominant path from alcohol problems

Cunningham et al. (1999) vast majority of ex-drug users never went to treatment

However:

The prevalence of ”self-change” will depend on how one defines ”addiction”, ”solution” and ”treatment” (Roizen et al., 1978; Blomqvist, 2001)

© Jan Blomqvist

Three patterns of improved drinking habits –

Subjects in a representative population sample who improved risky drinking habits (N= 339/2,862) Figure 1. Three clusters of former "risk consumers" 1,4 1,2 1 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0 D rin ki ng fr eq ue nc y Q ua nt ity /o cc as D io eg n re e of d ep en N de eg nc ar e tiv e co ns eq ue nc es "S oc ia l c ap tia So ci l" o ec on om ic s ta tu s A ge a t c C ha on ng sc e io us c ha ng e ef Pr fo of rt es s si on al /in fo rm al h el p Cluster 1 Cluster 2 Cluster 3 (Blomqvist et al., 2007)

How important is treatment?

Proportion who improved their drinking habits without treatment; representative population sample; N= 339/ 2862 Previous drinking: Present drinking:

”Risk consumer” ”Problem consumer” Dependent (ICD-10) ”Normal”

94 % 90 % 83 %

”Moderate”

85 % 72 % 44 %

Abstainer

55 % 48 % 28 % (Blomqvist et al., 2007)

© Jan Blomqvist

Who are the ”natural recoverers”?

(Logistic regressions) Predictors for untreated vs. treated recovery (former dependent drinkers n= 104): - lower degree of dependence (ICD-10) - shorter period with ”risk drinking” - larger social resourses (index) Predictors for – formal and informal – help (all former risk drinkers; n= 339): - higher degree of dependence (ICD-10) - longer period with ”risk drinking” - parental responsibilities (Consumtion in itself – frequency, quantity, frequency 5+ – not significant) (Blomqvist et al., 2007)

© Jan Blomqvist

One year follow-up of previously untreated problem drinkers Improved* Treated (n= 136) 58 (44 %) Not improved 78 (56 %) * abstinent or problem-free drinking last 30 days Untreated (n= 84) 19 (22 %) 65 (78 %) Predictors for improvement (logistic regressions): Men: - employed at baseline - treatment - low social pressure to drink past year (”dry” social network) Women: - univesity education - low social pressure to drink past year (”dry” social network) (The AHF-project: Blomqvist & Christophs, 2005; preliminary analyses of 1-year data)

Processes of – untreated and treated - recovery ( Blomqvist, 1999; 2002) COMMON FEATURES: Recovery evolved over several years, (as a result of) interplay between external influences and internal processes Motivation built on combination of negative consequences and positive incentives Strategies to cope with immediate hardships after treatment supported lasting change Maintaning the resolution required social support, ”gains” from living sober, and new alternatives /comittments Alcohol / drug problems were on a par with clinical populations DIFFERENCES BETWEEN UNASSISTED AND ASSISTED RECOVERIES: ”SELF-REMITTERS”: Some remaining social capital (“more to loose”) TREATED REMITTERS Exhausted personal and social resources Positive incentives before misusers tapered drinking the resolution; many alcohol Returned to a ”conventional” life-style Many former alcohol misusers resumed moderate drinking ”Rational” adaptation to external influences and new conditions Increasing substance use and life strains until treatment entry; treatment created hope / pointed to alternatives Substituted social networks; found new comittments Most stayed abstinent ”Transformation” of life-style

The path into and out of addiction - course and driving forces

INDIVIDUAL FACTORS LIFE EVENTS personal and social resourses) ”turning points”; positive incentives)

”Functional” drinking/ drug use New social and/or personal identity Drinking/drug use as ”central activity” Increasing problems (ill ness, social, psychological) Connecting problems to use /crisis / insight / wishes to change life style problems (”resisting”) Hopes; alternatives/ desicion;change attempts

STRUCTURAL FACTORS RELATIONS (Distributions of material goods; alcohol- and policies; ”governing images”; social policy

”Governing images” of addiction and recovery

© Jan Blomqvist

% 75

Popular images of nine types of addiction

Who is responsible for solving the problem?

(repr. population survey; N > 1.000):

50 25 0 Snuff Smoking Gambling

Only subject her/himself

Alcohol Cannabis

Mostly subject

Amphetamine Cocaine

Mostly society

Heroin Presc.drugs

Only society

© Jan Blomqvist

Perceived chances for ”self change”

%

60 40 20 0

Snuff Smoking

None/almost none

Gambling Alcohol

Rather low

Cannabis Prescr.drugs Amphetamine

"Fifty-fifty" Rather high

Cocaine Heroin

Very high

© Jan Blomqvist

Others’ reactions toward addicted people

(repr. population sample; N > 1.000): Addiction: Tobacco: Alcohol: Cannabis: Other narc. drug: Proportion with someone close addicted Proportion (of those) who tried helping 54,3 % 48,5 % 13,3 % 12,2 % Prescribed drugs: 11,5 % Gambling: 11,2 % 43,4 % 50,1 % 57,9 % 60,9 % 58,8 % 60,7 %

© Jan Blomqvist

Implications for practice: EBP in a wider perspective

© Jan Blomqvist

The challenge:

The official/manifest goal:

to make people stop using narcotic drugs and (ab)using alcohol (Government action plans on alcohol and drugs)

The actual / latent goals:

Diminishing suffering & mortalilty /creating more tolerable life conditions/ relieve some pressure from relatives and friends (Lindström, 1994)

”Controling the uncontrolable” (Bergmark & Oscarsson, 1988)

Assisting society in ”living with its addicts” (Kühlhorn, 1983)

Given that both aims are legitimate, what could and should be done to

  

adapt what is done to variegated and heterogenous needs in a variegated and heterogenous group of people with a variety of addiction problems?

1. Facilitating self change / helping people help themselves

Counteract moralism and simplistic categorisations. See addiction as a life style problem / ”environmentally responsive behavioral health problem”

Teaching that self-change is possible and how the environemt may help

Options to evaluate own consumption habits / easily available advise / reliable self-help materials (web sites, telephone ”help lines” a s o)

Encouraging different kinds of ”mutual help”- and support groups

Easily accessible / brief / attractive forms of support (no clear border between ”self change” and ”treatment”)

Social policy interventions to create sound alternatives (Blomqvist, 2006; Blomqvist et al., 2007)

© Jan Blomqvist

2. Making services attractive and relevant to the large majority of problem users

High availabilty / support on demand (”motivation is perishable goods”)

”Start where the individual is”

Assessment/planning/choice of intervention in dialouge with the client

”To each according to his needs” – not ready-made ”care chains” (specific or global interventions; assessment/brief advise/treatment/long-term support)

Continuous follow-up/revision of plans - in dialouge with the client

Broad menue of approved methods and supportive interventions

Cross-disciplinary team (”bio-psycho-social”; joint organisation?)

Co-operation with the environment (other help systems; ”natural healing forces”)

(Blomqvist, 1999; 2003; Humphreys & Tucker, 2002)

   

3. Improving the situation of the ”heavy” addicts or ”chronic cases” – do we need new resources or new ways of thinking?

Some points of departure: Continuity is crucial: long-term problems require long-term support No evidence for the benefits of long-term coercive care No intervention is as influential as ”the natural environment”

Own choice → stronger committement / positive expectations → better outcome

 

Good relation / working alliance is crucial Less intense consumption / improved life quality is acceptable goal

  

”From intensity to extensity”: Rather than irregular, intense, and often interrupted interventions (coercive institutions, treatment homes a s o): continuous, less intense contact (”generic counselor”; personal ”ombud”), varying forms of support when needed, mobilisation/strengthening of ”healing forces” in each person’s life context; swift and adequate interventions in ”acute” situations (Humphreys & Tucker, 2002; Blomqvist et.al. 2007)

How to keep the learning process going? Three interpretations of EBP:

The informed practitioner – consulting research data bases for each individual case

The guidelines-directed and manual-abiding practitioner

The pragmatic practitioner – trying to balance scientific evidence, well-documented clinical experience, and clients’ needs and whishes (cf. Sacket et al., 1997)

© Jan Blomqvist

Pragmatic practice: how to strike the balance?

Research needs:

   

More controlled outcome studies (efficacy studies of common techniques) More efficiency studies of ”promising” methods More studies of the treatment process and ”common factors” More long-term, naturalistic studies; user’s perspective; organizational aspects, a s o Developing a basis of well-documented clinical experience and professional consensus :

Systematic documentation – follow-up – collegial dialouge at the practice level Putting the single client i focus:

Keeping track of the development of the single case (corrections / adaptions to new circumstances / increased motivation / better outcome)

How to keep the knowledge process going:

Bridging the gap between research and practice

Research:

Practice: contribute ’abstract’ knowledge

(causes; methods; principles)

(translate and adapt abstract knowledge to shifting concrete circumstances) (advise practice on documentation

Scrutinise, articulate and systematise

and self-scrutiny)

… in dialouge with users/clients…

and…

on-going ethical discussions

© Jan Blomqvist

Some titles referred to:

Blomqvist (1999) Will soon be able to download from: www.stockholm.se/fou Blomqvist (2002) Blomqvist & Wallander (2004) Blomqvist et al. (2007)