Transcript Slide 1

Preparing for the Carbon Market:
Forestry Offsets
Where are the State and Federal
Policies on Forestry Offsets Headed?
What is Coming Over the Horizon?
Linc Cannon
Oregon Forest Industries Council
April 21, 2009
IPCC 4th Assessment Report (2007)
“In the long term, a sustainable forest
management strategy aimed at
maintaining or increasing forest carbon
stocks, while producing an annual
sustained yield of timber, fibre or energy
from the forest, will generate the largest
sustained mitigation benefit.”
From: Forestry. In Climate Change 2007: Mitigation. Contribution of Working Group III to
the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [B.
Metz, O.R. Davidson, P.R. Bosch, R. Dave, L.A. Meyer (eds)], Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA.
Put another way…
Sustainable Forest Management can best contribute to
reduction of atmospheric carbon by:
• Maintaining Forest Stocks
– Keep Forestland in Forest Use
– Reforestation
• Increasing Forest Stocks
– Afforestation
– Active Management to Increase Growth Rates
– Rotation Age
• Sustainable Production of:
– Forest Products
– Bioenergy, biofuels, biochemicals
How it all fits together:
Managed Forest Carbon Effects
How it all fits together:
Forest Carbon Effects
Wood Product Life Cycle (from CCAR)
http://www.climateregistry.org/resources/docs/protocols/agendas/CCAR_Workshop_February3.ppt
Imported
wood product
Recycling
Harvested
wood product
Mill
- -term
Short
wood products
Long-term wood
products
Landfill
Landfill
Substitution
Biomass
Forest
Energy
Green Bldg
Private Forest Carbon Reduction (Offset)
Opportunities
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Keep Forests in Forest Use (avoided conversion)
Afforestation Conservation Forests (longer rotation)
Forest Management (reforestation, increased yields)
Forest products and landfill
Bioenergy & biofuels (renewable energy credits/green tags)
Energy substitution (green building)
Cobenfits?
• Federal Forests
– Avoided wildfire emissions
– Feedstock for bioenergy & biofuels
– Increased sequestration from active management
The Multi-Billion Dollar Question!
Will Private Forests Managed for
Sustainable Wood Production Get
Credit (Offset Payments) for Their
Contributions to Reducing
Atmospheric Carbon??
Cap & Trade - Forestry Offsets
•
Regions
•Regional Green House Gas Initiative
(RGGI)
•Midwest GHG Reduction Accord
•Western Climate Initiative (WCI)
• States
•California
•Washington
•Oregon
•Utah
• Federal
U.S. Regional GHG
Reduction Initiatives
Regional
Greenhouse Gas
Initiative
RGGI
RGGI
• First mandatory, market-based effort in the
United States to reduce GHG emissions.
• Cap and then reduce CO2 emissions from
the power sector 10% by 2018.
• Compliance obligations begin in 2009
• Sell emission allowances through auctions
• 2nd Auction – 12/17/08, 31.5 million
allowances @ $3.38 = $106.5 million
RGGI Forestry Offsets
•
Draft Recommendations (May ‘08)
– Conservation & Managed Forests
•
FIA Average Regional Inventory Baseline
– Forest Products
•
Above Business As Usual “BAU”
– Biomass Plantations
•
Displace Fossil Fuel Use
– No Avoided Deforestation
– NOT included in Dec ‘08 Model Rule
•
Afforestation only, permanent easement
Western Climate
Initiative
WCI
WCI Recommendations (Sept 2008)
General
Regional cap and trade program framework
WCI ONLY recommends,
it’s up to states/provinces to adopt!
• Phase 1 takes effect in 2012
• Phase 2 takes effect in 2015
WCI Recommendations (Sept 2008)
Offsets
Offsets = Emission reductions outside the cap
• Limited to no more than 49% of total emissions
reductions from 2012 to 2020
• Priority offset types for investigation
– Agricultural
– Forestry
– Waste management
WCI Recommendations (Sept 2008)
Key for Forest and Forest Products
• Forestlands are not included under the cap
• Carbon neutral biomass emissions
– determined by each state
• Cogeneration unresolved
• Biofuel exempt, with possibility that
upstream emissions could still be counted
• Priority consideration for Forestry offsets
• WCI Offsets Working Group
WCI Work Plan (Feb 2009)
Offset Protocols (Ag, Forestry, Urban Waste)
• Forestry Offset Types to be Evaluated
–
–
–
–
–
–
Afforestation
Reforestation
Forest Management
Forest Preservation/Conservation
Forest Products
Urban Forestry
“The Committee will aim to identify those stakeholders with
knowledge, experience and resources to be directly
involved in the appropriate protocol task teams”
California
California
• AB 32 (2006) Mandates
– 1990 GHG emissions levels by 2020
– 80% reduction from 1990 levels by 2050
• California Air Resources Board (CARB) adopts
AB 32 Scoping Plan on December 11, 2008
– identifies cap and trade program as one of the main
strategies to reduce GHG emissions
– Must adopt cap and trade regulation by Jan 1, 2011
– Program begins in 2012
– Rule development coordinated with WCI timeline
California Climate Action Registry
Climate Action Reserve
What is the Climate Action Reserve?
•CCAR program to register and track carbon offset
projects throughout the U.S.
•Established as its own name, but co-branded with
CCAR
•Intended to be the premier place to register carbon
offset projects for North America (VCS approved)
•Until now, U.S.-based projects only
•Expanding to Mexico and Canada
California Climate Action Registry
Climate Action Reserve
Draft Forest Project Protocols (Dec 2008 & Jan 2009)
Eligible Forest Project Types
• Afforestation
• Improved Forest Management
– Natural Forest Management Practices
• Mixed native species, multiple ages, multiple scales
– Baseline
• BAU regulatory baseline modeled on forest practices regulations
• Reference is FIA average mean stocking
–
–
–
–
Additionality is above and beyond Business as Usual (BAU)
Allows limited credit for harvested wood products
Minimum 100 year duration
No credit for wood in landfills
• Avoided Conversion
– Immediate site specific threat
– Conversion uncertainty discount
California Climate Action Registry (CCAR)
Forest Protocols Process/Timeline
 Original protocols recognized afforestation and
conservation forestry project types
 Draft Revised Forest Project Protocols (December 2008)
 Public workshop on wood products quantification and
other miscellaneous items on February 3, 2009.
 Additional two week public comment period to address
wood products or other protocol issues. Concluded on
February 20, 2009
 Final draft delivered to CCAR on March 8, 2009
• Final Forest Project protocol to CCAR Board in April
2009
Washington
Washington
House Bill 2815 (2008)
• GHG Emission Reduction Targets
– 1990 GHG emissions levels by 2020
– 80% reduction from 1990 levels by 2050
• Directs the Department of Ecology to develop and
implement a program to limit statewide greenhouse gas
emissions.
• Authorizes a reporting system to monitor greenhouse
gas emissions.
• Directs the Department of Ecology to develop a design
for a regional multisector market-based system to limit
and reduce greenhouse gas emissions, in coordination
with WCI.
• Climate Advisory Team to provide a report to the
Legislature by December, 2008
Washington
Forest Sector Workgroup On Climate Change
Mitigation - HB 2815 (2008)
Diverse Stakeholder Group, Consensus
Process, DNR/DOR Report (December
• Priorities
–
–
–
–
–
–
Conversion
Active Forest Management/Harvested Wood Products
Afforestation/Reforestation
Substitution
Avoided Emissions
Biomass Energy
Washington
Report – Forest Sector Workgroup On
Climate Change Mitigation (Dec 2008)
• Avoided Conversion
– Cluster development (w/ permanent easement)
– Transferable Development Rights (TDRs)
• Urban Forests
• Forest Management
– Offsets Beyond BAU
• Include Harvested Wood Products
• Exclude wood in Landfills
– Non-offset Carbon Storage Incentives
• Funded by carbon auction revenues
• Revisit if not created or appropriately funded
• Can recognize co-benefits
Washington
• Washington state Governor Chris Gregoire told reporters
in Washington D.C. on February 23 she hopes her state
will pass a bill setting a mandatory cap on greenhouse
gas emissions and enabling it to participate in emissions
trading in the Western Climate Initiative (WCI).
• Gregoire has warned that it would not bode well for other
WCI states if the Democratic-controlled Washington
legislature fails to pass the bill.
• “If I can’t get the job done I fear we will have others that
can’t. That’s why failure is not an option for us.”
Washington
HB 1819 (2009)
• Authorizes the Department of Ecology to create an
allowance trading program.
• Creates a cap-and-trade work group.
• Creates criteria for the cap, allowances, and offsets.
• Specifies the emissions covered in the allowance
trading program.
• Requires the Department of Ecology to develop a
design for the auctioning of the state's allowances.
• Sets compliance obligations and penalties.
• Creates the Climate Protection Account.
• Sets reporting requirements for fuels.
• Is Dead…
SB 5735 (2009)
• Functionally caps emission from the only
coal plant (Transalta) in Washington
• Allows use of offsets (up to 49%) to meet
emissions reductions requirements
• 14 page bill, 1/3 dealing with forest offset
language.
• Study and make recommendations
Oregon
Oregon HB 3543 (2007)
Global Warming Strategy
• Carbon emissions reduction goals:
– 10 percent below 1990 levels by 2020
– 75 percent below 1990 levels by 2050
• Examine cap and trade systems
• Develop strategy for educating the citizens
• Track economic, environmental, health, and
social impacts
Oregon
• Global Warming Commission
– Natural Resources Committee
• Forestry Subcommittee
• Forest Carbon Stakeholders Group
(facilitated)
• Woodlands Carbon Company
• SB 80 (2009) – DEQ Cap and Trade
• HB 2186 (2009) – DEQ Alternative
Measures
• Oregonians for A Balanced Climate Policy
– Balanced Carbon Reduction Act
Forest Carbon Stakeholder Group
Comments to WCI – July 2008
“Our deliberations have led us to believe
that a properly structured forest carbon
offset program can provide significant
ecological, social, and economic benefits
in addition to offsetting GHG emissions…”
American Forest Resource Council – Associated Oregon Loggers –
Boise Cascade - California Forestry Association - Defenders of Wildlife Ecotrust - Forest Capital Partners - Lone Rock Timber Company –
Oregon Forest Industries Council – Oregon Small Woodlands Association Oregon Woodland Cooperative - Roseburg Forest Products –
Mark Copeland - The Collins Company - The Conservation Fund –
The Nature Conservancy in Oregon – Washington Forest Protection
Association – Weyerhaeuser Company
From Governor Kulongoski’s testimony
at the February 5th hearing on SB 80
Over the last year I have – like you – been listening to
those still in denial who argue that SB 80 is not the right
approach to address the issues around CO2 emissions.
Their answer to the climate change debate has been to
promote fear and confusion … They argue against a
cap and trade and other parts of this proposed package
by claiming now is not the time to make significant
changes with a fragile economy, or let the federal
government deal with this issue….
You may recall that the same coalition of Salem
Beltway naysayers made similar arguments about
the Renewable Portfolio Standard bill in the 2007
session…
Oregonians for Balanced Climate Policy
American Chemistry Council -- American Forest and Paper
Assn -- Associated Oregon Industries -- Associated
Oregon Loggers -- Building Owners and Managers
Association -- IBEW Local 48 -- Industrial Customers of NW
Utilities -- Oregon NFIB -- Northwest Food Processors Assn
-- Northwest Industrial Gas Users -- Northwest Propane
Gas Assn -- Northwest Pulp and Paper Assn -- Oregon
Association of Realtors -- Oregon Cattlemen’s Association
-- Oregon Dairy Farmers Association -- Oregon Farm
Bureau -- Oregon Forest Industries Council -- Oregon
Home Builders Association -- Oregon Metals Industry
Council -- Oregon Refuse and Recycling Assn -- Oregon
Rural Electric Coop. Assn -- Oregon Seed Council -- Oregon
State Building Trades Council -- Oregon Trucking
Associations -- Oregon Wheat Growers League -Oregonians for Food and Shelter -- Umatilla Electric
Cooperative
SB 80/HB 2186 Metamorphosis
• Cap and Trade
• Hard Cap (no trade)
• Hard Cap (with offsets)
• Hard Cap (with off ramps)
• Soft Cap??
Oregonians for Balanced Climate Policy
SB 80 Messages- April 21, 2009
•
Legislature needs to slow down harmful and costly climate change
legislation. Oregon cannot solve global climate change on its own.
•
The U.S. EPA recently classified carbon as a harmful pollutant. The federal
government is taking steps now to press for carbon reductions.
•
Utilities estimate that to meet the pie-in-the-sky carbon reduction goals in
SB 80, it would cost nearly $17 billion in higher electricity costs--$12.5
billion for PGE and $4.5 billion for PacifiCorp. Oregonians cannot afford
increased costs, which result in lost jobs and higher unemployment.
•
Legislators should not leave major climate change policies in the hands of
state agencies. They need to have all the proposals on the table, and know
all the costs and benefits before making a decision. Elected officials
should set economic policy, not unaccountable bureaucrats.
•
We should not fund large, new state programs at the expense of existing
programs that protect our air and water.
•
The federal government is moving ahead quickly on climate change.
Oregon should find out how it can benefit from a program like this before
jumping head first into a duplicative and costly program.
Oregonians for a Balanced Climate Policy
Alternative Legislative Proposal
“Balanced Carbon Reduction Plan of 2009”
Electric Sector Alternative (PUC)
Forest and Agricultural Offsets
Emissions Performance Standards
Transportation Sector Alternative
Alternative Measures
Woodland Carbon Company
• An aggregation organization providing access
to the Chicago Climate Exchange for certified
members of the American Tree Farm System in
Oregon.
• One of three National Tree Farm pilot programs
that will be established in 2008 as models for
other Tree Farm organizations that wish to
enter the forest carbon market.
• WCC will operate as a sub-aggregator to the
National Carbon Offset Coalition (NCOC) that
will bring aggregated pools of eligible forest
projects to the Chicago Climate Exchange
(CCX).
Utah
Utah “Beltway Naysayers”
• HR3, a non-binding resolution urging Gov. Jon
Huntsman Jr. to withdraw Utah from the
multistate Western Climate Initiative cleared
Utah’s House on Tuesday, February 24, 51-19.
• Sponsor Rep. Mike Noel, R-Kanab said the
measure would send a message to Utah’s chief
executive that he overstepped his bounds by
participating in energy policy that could affect the
economic health of many of the state’s
businesses.
National
Chicago Climate Exchange - CCX
• North America’s only greenhouse gas (GHG)
trading system.
• Launched in 2001. Modern web-based trading
platform.
• Only Members can buy and sell on CCX.
• Trading launched in 2003; Currently trading
emissions dated 2003 through 2010.
• Trading rules managed by expert committees
drawn from CCX members.
• Info at www.chicagoclimatex.com
CCX Forest Offset Project Types
• Afforestation – Planting trees on land that has not been in
forest for the previous 10 years or more. A land use
change that creates new forest lands.
• Reforestation – Planting trees on forest land where the
forest was destroyed and is not naturally regenerating.
• Sustainable Forest Management – Changing forest
management so as to increase forest biomass and retain it
for long periods.
• Harvested Wood Products – Credit for the amount of wood
that will remain in use or in landfills 100 years after it is
harvested.
National
• President Obama’s 10-year budget plan
includes $645 billion from 100% auction of
GHG allowances (2012-2020) in a national
cap and trade program.
• Cap and Trade Legislation this year?
– Waxman/Markey is currently in markup
– House Energy Chair Waxman wants a bill out
of Committee by End of May
– Senate Environment Chair Boxer is drafting
bill, probably for consideration later this
summer
Society of American Foresters
Preferred Forest Offsets Policy Options
for a national carbon trading program
•
Afforestation. Planting trees on suitable land that has been in another land
use for 10 or more years (including riparian forests, windbreaks, mined land
reclamation, etc.).
•
Reforestation. Planting trees on former forestland where forests damaged
through natural events have not begun to regenerate after two years.
•
Forest management. Managing forests sustainably under either a
sustainable forest management standard or other suitable criteria
•
Forest products. Providing credit for the carbon that remains out of the
atmosphere in harvested forest products at the end of 100 years. Carbon
credit values and their assignment can be determined between a landowner
and a timber buyer via contractual arrangements.
•
Forest conservation. Protecting forests from land-use change with
conservation easements, contracts, or other legal instruments
American Forest Foundation (AFF)
Forest-Climate Working Group (FCWG)
Begun in December 2007 to build consensus on how
forests can play a meaningful role in addressing climate
change.
Co-chaired by Drue DeBerry (AFF) and Jad Daley (the
Trust for Public Land) it has broad representation from
virtually all sectors of the forest community—the forest
products industry, conservation and wildlife groups,
foresters, private forest owners, academics, and carbon
finance groups.
In order to build and achieve consensus, the organizations
engaged in a series of Dialogues on forest-climate issues
in 2008.
More info available at http://www.affoundation.org/ccs_carbon.html
Binational Forest Carbon
Standards Committee (FCSC)
The Forest Carbon Standards Committee
(FCSC) was formed by a binational group
of stakeholders familiar with the suite of
forest carbon offset protocols and
standards that have been developed to
date and the difficult issues that forest
managers face in complying with the
demands of emerging greenhouse gas
emission programs.
Binational Forest Carbon
Standards Committee (FCSC)
Their purpose is to develop and maintain
consensus standards for the
measurement, reporting, and verification
of forest carbon emission reduction
projects (e.g., offsets) under current and
emerging greenhouse gas emission
reduction programs in Canada and the
United States.
Binational Forest Carbon
Standards Committee (FCSC)
• Standards will be developed under American National
Standards Institute (ANSI) accredited standards, efforts
to be consistent with procedures of the Canadian
Standards Association (CSA), an accredited standards
development organization of the Standards Council of
Canada (SCC)
• ANSI and SCC are the national standards accreditation
bodies for the United States and Canada respectively
• AF&PA is the Secretariat for the process. Other
sponsoring organizations include the Society of
American Foresters, the Forest Products Association of
Canada, and the Canadian Institute of Forestry
Binational Forest Carbon
Standards Committee (FCSC)
Members are drawn from three Interest categories:
• Producers – individuals or organizations that will use
the proposed standard to guide the production,
measurement, monitoring, and sale of forest carbon
offsets
• Users – individuals or organizations that will use the
proposed standard to verify, approve, register, broker,
or purchase forest carbon offsets, or to establish public
policy or rules that may refer to the standard
• General interest – individuals or organizations that have
a direct interest in the environmental integrity and/or
public interest impact of the forest carbon offsets
produced under the guidance of the standard
Membership in the Committee has been chosen to be
sufficiently diverse to ensure reasonable stakeholder
balance without dominance by a single interest category
Binational Forest Carbon
Standards Committee (FCSC)
•
•
•
•
•
The Committee will produce a standard (or
set of standards) that will cover the various
types of forestry projects that will be
eligible to produce compliance-grade
forest carbon offsets. Preliminary
discussions identify those project types as:
Afforestation
Reforestation
Forest Management
Forest Protection
Urban Forestry
Binational Forest Carbon
Standards Committee (FCSC)
Four technical task committees:
• Baselines, additionality
• Permanence, Leakage
• Quantification (Measuring, Monitoring,
Verification)
• Sustainability, Co-Benefits, and Environmental
Impacts
An Integration Task Committee will:
• Review Technical Task Committee draft
recommendations.
• Prepare and integrated draft to be submitted to
the Committee for consensus consideration.
Binational Forest Carbon
Standards Committee (FCSC)
Anticipated Timelines
•
•
•
•
Initial Scoping Meeting Oct 23 & 24, 2008
Scope of Work Completed - January 2009
Task Committees named - February 1, 2009
Task Committee draft recommendations - April
1, 2009
• Consensus process completed - July 1, 2009
• Adoption process completed - September 1,
2009
Conclusion
States, regions, and countries are all trying
to figure out how to reduce atmospheric
carbon, primarily focusing on cap and
trade mechanisms. The role forests play
in sequestering carbon is understood and
accepted, but whether or how that should
be rewarded in a cap and trade program is
not!
It’s complicated!
Thank You !
Offsetting vehicle emissions with wood products…?
Linc Cannon
[email protected]
www.ofic.com