Transcript Slide 1
Central Training Plan 2010-11 PROF. DEOKI NANDAN, MD, FAMS, FIAPSM, FIPHA, FISCD Director ([email protected], www.nihfw.org) Need for a National Training Plan • HRD is critical for improving performance, efficiency and effectiveness of health systems and delivery of health services • It has become all the more important as new health programs are introduced. • All the health care personnel need updating of both knowledge and skills. • Focus on in-service training/on-the-job training is necessary to improve content and quality of services to cater to emerging needs for training. • In-service training is necessary for all category of personnel – service providers, programme managers, bio-statisticians, etc. Core Strategies 1. Needs assessment- Review state training plans – PIPs and RoPs, to assess training needs and loads. 2. Develop a Central training plan and strategy to meet the gaps and needs 3. Quality improvement and management of training through standardizing curriculum, resource material and standards (including proficiency certification) 4. Strengthen capacity for training through trainers’ training and infrastructure support 5. Coordinate implementation of trainings in the states with optimal utilization of all available health facilities and human resource. 6. Establish training information management systems, monitoring, supervision and support Review of Training NIHFW reviewed the State PIPs and ROPs for 2010 -11 Progress in 09-10 of in-service training indicated by the states. Training programmes planned by states for 2010-11 Four Thematic Areas Review was conducted on the following four thematic areas and in the context of NIHFW has done in the last seven years in conducting training of trainers since beginning of NRHM ◦ Maternal Health ◦ Child Health ◦ Family Planning ◦ Disease Control Abstract of Training Load (2010-11) • Trainings/Activities covered • Category of staff to be trained • Number to be trained in 2010-11 • Duration of Training • Place of training • Status of TOT • Availability of training modules and teaching aids • Availability of monitoring formats Maternal Health (9 High focus states + 3 NE States) Training Load (Maternal Health) SBA 25 25 3–6 Weeks Identified District Hospitals YES EMOC 48 24 45 24 32 EMOC REFRESHER BEMOC 8 5 Batches 24 64 3 1 Batches 5 15 288 150 40 100 Batches 500 275 Identified Medical 16 Weeks College/ DH YES 15 YES 978 YES LSAS Blood Storage MO's 20 48 15 32 16 36 60 16 72 3 4 Batches 40 90 1774 Identified 18 weeks Medical College Insitute where blood banks are 3 days available Identified Medical Colleges/ 2 Days RHFWTC 9 50 Batches 30 1204 15 days 633 30 214 2133 763 90 10 7111 5 39 324 39 RTI/STI 165 500 324 480 175 YES YES YES MTP/MVA 250 220 120 MTP/MVA Refresher BSU IMEP Core Skill training Other MH Trg. 54 120 184 30 30 200 40 120 1500 90 SUB- TOTAL 771 792 2193 424 1208 234 260 80 256 10 130 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. Identified Training Institutes YES YES YES TOT trained Obstetrician/ MO/ SN& Paed. M.O. Faculty Med. College (Gyn)/ Distt Gynaecologist. Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Jharkhand Chhattisgarh Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Madhya Pradesh STATES YES YES YES YES Faculty Med. Coll. (Anes)/ Distt Anaes I/C of Training Insitutte Oriented team of trainers at state level Gynaecologist from Medical Colleges YES YES YES YES YES YES MTP/MVA Adv. LAP Trg RTI/ STI TOT MTP/MVA (TOT) LSAS TOT CEMOC Refresher CEMOC TOT EMOC TOT 100 51 8 8 SBA RTI/STI SN 8 320 100 30 630 SUB- TOTAL YES YES YES YES 40 10 30 130 40 10 39 466 1120 YES YES YES YES YES YES 1 1 160 420 300 60 56 2 Days 20 20 864 116 1220 2200 RTI/STI LT 223 750 PHCs 160 160 Other MH Trg. 10 BSU SUB- TOTAL RTI/STI GNM MH Training FAMILY WELFARE SBA MO Ayush DAI DAI TRAINING 1000 Others JSY 39 184 368 30 190 10 25 21 Batches 150 120 56 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 10 214 607 25 21 Batches 150 1120 56 YES Oriented team of trainers at state level YES YES YES YES YES 2 Days Identified Medical Colleges/ RHFW TC 3 days Insitute where blood banks are available Blood Storage 184 Identified Medical Colleges/ RHFW TC 30 1730 924 56 ANM 39 Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available 30 20 864 1200 SUB- TOTAL 1200 Trainers 30 20 300 800 Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available YES YES YES YES 800 160 120 MTP/MVA MTP/MVA refresher Place of Training YES 168 168 Duration of Training 151 8 168 8 SPECIALIST Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa 51 SUB- TOTAL SBA IMEP RTI/STI Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Maternal Health) STATES YES YES YES Oriented team of trainers at state level YES YES I/C of Training Insitutte YES YES YES YES YES Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Maternal Health) STATES TRAINING LOAD GIVEN FOR COMBINED GROUPS OF FUNCTIONARIES SBA TOT MO/DRCH/ PRINCIPAL ANMTC/ O&G/ Peads/ ADDITIONAL CMHO/ CS 50 100 SBA LHV/SN/MAST SUPPORTIVE ER TRAINERS SBA Trg. For Ex. Tribal RTI/STI SBA SBA SN/ANM 90 276 YES YES 150 150 YES YES 36 36 1080 1632 YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES 1080 1632 252 RTI/STI 36 554 2000 37 Batches 3000 1200 Mapedir Mapedir Core Skill training SBA RTI/STI BSU MO/ SUPERVISOR ANM/LHV 1200 76 2126 76 2126 1800 1800 1500 160 1500 160 MO/LT RTI/STI RTI/ STI SN/GNM MO/SN RTI/ STI MO/LT/SN RTI/ STI MO/ANM/ HW(M) IMEP 5806 SN/ANM/LHV 120 350 70 Batches 23 Batches 3 Batches BMO/SN/BEE TOTAL 6 Batches 60 8160 1836 6200 7672 4232 3898 3356 510 3862 81 465 Batches 1758 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 60 120 350 70 Batches 23 Batches 3 Batches 41949 2 Days Identified Medical Colleges/ RHFW TC YES Oriented team of trainers at state level YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES Child Health (9 High focus states + 3 NE States) 52 70 120 1226 8 days 480 336 730 FBNBC MO's FIMNCI (TOT) NSSK 18 48 678 60 IMMUNIZATION NSU New Born & Child Stabalization Unit (FRU) 30 1576 5 18 53 50 Batches 48 8 734 60 100 100 SUB- TOTAL 1080 1074 480 730 100 3 98 18 IMNCI FIMNCI 480 120 120 13 Batches 360 FBNC NSU NSSK 70 70 400 S.N. 722 722 SNCU 72 New Born & Child Stabalization Unit (FRU) SUB- TOTAL 480 722 360 400 90 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 72 3 3 70 120 3 2245 YES Faculty of Paediatrics and P&SM Deptt. YES Final Approval Available. Awaited. TOT done NO YES YES District/ Sub-district 2 days Hospital 3 3770 190 840 18 400 18 11 days Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available 432 Trainers 552 FIMNCI National/ State/ District Training Centres Medical College/ District Hospital Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available IMNCI Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Child Health) STATES 11 days Medical College/ District Hospital District/ Sub-district 2 days Hospital SNCUs/ District 4 days Hospital YES YES YES YES YES Available. TOT done YES YES YES YES YES YES YES Final Approval Available. Awaited. TOT done YES YES NO YES YES YES Available. TOT done YES YES Available from NNF YES YES YES Training Load (Child Health) Place of Training Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Trainers Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh 48 Duration of Training NSSK FIMNCI Jharkhand Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh STATES 11 days Medical College/ District Hospital Final Approval Awaited. Available. TOT done NO 8 days National/ State/ District Training Centres 8 days National/ State/ District Training Centres 8 days National/ State/ District Training Centres 8 days National/ State/ District Training Centres 48 SPECIALIST 13 24 SNCU PAEDIATRICS SUB- TOTAL 48 13 24 3 88 3 3 37 IMNCI LHV NSSK 354 354 SUB- TOTAL 50 45 50 45 95 354 449 IMNCI ANM 52 SNCU IMNCI LT 70 120 6 242 6 AWW 70 FIMNCI SNCU ANM/GNM X-RAY TECHNICIAN 30 6 80 150 30 CDPO 39 IMMUNIZATION IMMUNIZATION IMMUNIZATION IMMUNIZATION BASIC PHYSICIAN COLD CHAIN HANDLER COLD CHAIN KEEPER TECHNICIANS (COLD CHAIN) DATA ENTRY OPERATORS/ COMPUTER ASSISTANTS YES YES YES Faculty of Paediatrics and P&SM Deptt. YES YES Faculty of Paediatrics and P&SM Deptt. YES YES Faculty of Paediatrics and P&SM Deptt. YES 6 IMNCI IMNCI YES YES Faculty of Paediatrics and P&SM Deptt. 552 39 552 YES YES 100 100 YES YES 18 18 YES YES 89 89 YES YES Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. Training Load (Child Health) Duration of Training Place of Training Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Trainers Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Jharkhand Chhattisgarh Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Madhya Pradesh STATES 2 days District/ Sub-district Hospital YES Available. TOT done YES TRAINING LOAD GIVEN FOR COMBINED GROUPS OF FUNCTIONARIES MO/ANM NSSK NSU TRG Sick New Born Care 2730 576 160 2730 768 192 96 120 376 YES Available from NNF YES 11 days SCNUs/ District Hospital Medical College/ District Hospital Final Approval Awaited. Available. TOT done NO 2 days District/ Sub-district Hospital YES Available. TOT done YES 8 days District/ Sub-district Hospital YES Available. TOT done YES Available. TOT done YES 4 days MO/SN F-IMNCI F-IMNCI TOT NSSK 96 72 100 Batches 3750 1290 Other CH Trg. IMNCI Child Health Training IMNCI IMNCI 150 Batches 1924 10032 351 15 5040 1924 3840 13872 195 Batches 195 batches ANM/AWW IYCF IMNCI 183 15 LHV/ OTHER SUPERVISOR 500 Batches 984 ANM/LHV/ ASHA 984 1580 Batches SN/ANM 1440 YES 8 days 8 days 1440 ANM/LHV/LS IMNCI IMNCI Supervisory IMNCI 7200 9600 480 ANM/LHV/MO 936 IMNCI ANM/AWW/ HE/LHV District/ Sub-district Hospital District/ Sub-district Hospital 14136 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 16800 8 days 480 2 days 936 8 days 14136 8 days District/ Sub-district Hospital District/ Sub-district Hospital District/ Sub-district Hospital District/ Sub-district Hospital YES YES YES Available. TOT done YES YES YES Available. TOT done YES Yes Available. TOT done Yes YES Available. TOT done YES YES Available. TOT done YES Training Load (Child Health) Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Trainers Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Jharkhand Chhattisgarh Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Madhya Pradesh STATES Yes Available. TOT done Yes YES Available. TOT done YES TRAINING LOAD GIVEN FOR COMBINED GROUPS OF FUNCTIONARIES FOLLOW-UP IMNCI IMNCI IMNCI MO/ PARA MEDICAL/ SOCIAL WELFARE PERSONNEL FIMNCI & SNCU 1392 HE/LHV 1392 552 552 384 384 IMMUNIZATION ANM/LHV/HW( M)/ NURSE MIDWIVES IMMUNIZATION ANM/HW(M)/ LHV Care of Sick Children & SAM 4800 336 4 days 4800 2 days 2 days 96 Batches 4 Batches ANM/MTC INCHARGE MEDICAL AND PARA MEDICAL 20 NSSK 1536 School Health MO/DDM/ DRCHO ANM/LHV/ AWW/ SAHAIYYA TOTAL 235 200 1971 600 3360 970 SCHOOL TEACHERS 15000 7004 13754 YES YES Available from NNF YES Trained Trainers Trained Trainers 2924 2443 405 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 290 759 770 District/ Sub-district 2 days Hospital YES Available. TOT done YES 600 YES YES 3360 YES YES 970 194 Batches 194 Batches 16090 18594 10540 SCNUs/ District Hospital District Training Centers District Training Centers 20 4 batches MO/SN/ANM IYCF IYCF BLOCK LEVEL IYCF YES MO/ANM/SN 336 Care of Sick Children & SAM District/ Sub-district 2 days Hospital District/ Sub-district 8 days Hospital 88573 Family Planning (9 High focus states + 3 NE States) Minilap 240 Minilap Refresher IUCD NSV 152 50 50 30 100 22 12 29 24 733 25 156 90 66 1614 66 480 175 688 190 40 30 100 150 100 48 198 29 30 84 SUB- TOTAL 300 540 342 90 NSV Laproscopic Sterlization 150 40 Specialist 300 834 81 12 25 7 900 Batches 150 1080 266 245 50 20 970 8 915 84 40 77 1540 214 144 4952 81 3 24 Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training 12 Identified working training Gynaecolo days Institutes YES gist YES YES YES MO's NSV Refresher Contrac. Update IUCD TOT Laproscopic Sterlization TOT NSV TOT 24 Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Jharkhand Chhattisgarh Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Madhya Pradesh Training Load (Family Planning) STATES 5 days YES YES Master/ State Level YES Trainers YES YES YES YES YES YES YES 12 Identified working training Gynaecolo days Institutes YES gist YES YES YES 160 307 185 48 108 48 108 YES YES YES YES 30 1120 YES YES YES YES SUB- TOTAL Minilap IUCD Laproscopic Sterlization 30 360 395 175 150 40 SN SUB- TOTAL 150 150 40 435 50 50 20 410 100 100 8 183 150 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 40 368 1518 12 Identified working training Gynaecolo days Institutes YES gist YES IUCD ANM 2400 1482 480 2500 360 SUB- TOTAL 2400 1482 480 2500 360 Other Trg. 175 3870 115 404 80 11866 182 182 175 3870 297 404 80 12048 IUCD LHV 276 IUCD 175 PHN Laproscopic OT Sterlization Technician 150 Contraceptive HEALTH 2 Update Batches CARE PERSONNEL 25 37 40 50 20 8 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 476 37 Identified training 5 days Institutes YES YES YES Identified training 5 days Institutes YES YES Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar Assam NAME OF THE CATEGORIES TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Family Planning) STATES YES YES YES YES YES 12 Identified working training Gynaecolo Institutes YES gist 268 days YES YES YES TRAINING LOAD GIVEN FOR COMBINED GROUPS OF FUNCTIONARIES IUCD 152 MO/ANM Batches IUCD MO/LHV/SN 1200 1000 2236 4436 IUCD SN/LHV 1376 1376 Contraceptive ANM/LHV/ 48 Update MHW Batches Minilap MO/SN 295 295 Laproscopic Sterlization Trg 280 280 Laproscopic SURGEON/SN Sterlization Refresher Trg 72 72 TOTAL 7680 684 4370 2746 6500 3740 2968 1397 12019 751 1598 552 45005 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar Assam NAME OF THE CATEGORIES TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Family Planning) STATES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES Disease Control (9 High focus states + 3 NE States) RNTCP Retraining 1490 150 1640 5 days Identified Central Institute 400 400 3 days STDC YES 50 50 3 days YES 30 150 322 1100 1 day 3 days STDC District TB Center District Level 1650 1 day District Level 2301 2 days YES YES YES YES YES YES YES Medical College YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES DOTS + MDR 292 NLEP NLEP Refresher NVBDCP 950 MO's 1650 300 NVBDCP Retraining NPCB NPCB Refresher IDSP Mental Health 10 25 11 3 11 253 208 334 250 217 452 120 271 290 117 642 145 63 100 120 3089 508 334 4991 2074 462 391 290 16 916 642 145 88 111 16 10952 20 20 3 days SN 120 120 500 500 SUB- TOTAL NVBDCP RNTCP RNTCP Retraining Mental Health 75 250 SUB- TOTAL RNTCP RNTCP Retraining NPCB NPCB Refresher IDSP Mental Health 1891 4 Batches Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available YES YES Master Trainers Available YES Master Trainers Available YES Master Trainers Available YES RNTCP TB/HIV Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Jharkhand Chhattisgarh Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Madhya Pradesh Training Load (Disease Control Programme) STATES 500 120 108 128 250 108 748 250 ANM SUB- TOTAL 250 1765 1765 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 1765 2015 NVBDCP RNTCP Retraining 120 378 5 529 120 HS(M) 2 days 818 5 days Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh 80 60 20 3 Batches 120 40 80 1000 SPECIALIST 180 300 1000 0 0 20 120 240 40 80 YES YES YES YES YES YES 300 250 2180 21 2430 15 21 16 Batches 34 0 15 56 56 Master Trainers YES Available YES 5 1329 300 34 0 6 0 0 100 100 1405 2180 3585 21 6 10 21 66 10 120 186 PMOA SUB- TOTAL DTBC YES 60 146 300 HW(M) SUB- TOTAL RNTCP IDSP 80 60 SUB- TOTAL NPCB NPCB Refresher 160 275 220 146 SUB- TOTAL NPCB NVBDCP 275 60 LTs SUB- TOTAL NVBDCP RNTCP RNTCP Retraining 275 YES RNTCP RNTCP Retraining NVBDCP NVBDCP RNTCP 275 LHV SUB- TOTAL NVBDCP Retraining NLEP NLEP Refresher IDSP Jharkhand Bihar Assam NAME OF THE CATEGORIES TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Disease Control Programme) STATES 120 120 PHARMACIST SUB- TOTAL Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 5 days District Hospital 3 days STDC YES MOTCs RNTCP RNTCP RNTCP RNTCP RNTCP NVBDCP NVBDCP NVBDCP NVBDCP NVBDCP NVBDCP IDSP IDSP NPCB STLS DTO COMMUNITY VOLUNTEERS PRIVATE PRACTICNOR S ASHA ENTOMOLOGI ST MO AYUSH 6 3 3 400 400 100 District 100 2 days Training Center YES 1000 450 550 1 day SPRAY WORKER SPRAY TEAM 32 416 District Training Center YES YES 32 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 4416 1 day Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available YES YES YES 17 7 Batches Batches 4000 Trainers YES YES YES 1 Batch 16 Batches 16 Batches 3 Batches Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Indentified Central 12 days Institute 15 days STDC 6 MTS MEDICAL COLLEGE DOCTORS BLOCK HEALTH TEAM SCHOOL TEACHER Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar Assam NAME OF THE CATEGORIES TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Disease Control Programme) STATES DTC/ Others Places YES Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Jharkhand Chhattisgarh Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Madhya Pradesh Training Load (Disease Control Programme) STATES TRAINING LOAD GIVEN FOR COMBINED GROUPS OF FUNCTIONARIES RNTCP/ Re Training/ TB/HIV RNTCP RNTCP Retraining NVBDCP SN\ANM\LHV 1 day 800 800 1 day 400 400 1 day MPW (M&F) District TB Center District TB Center District TB Center MPHS/ PHARMACIST / NURSING/ BEEO RNTCP 821 821 RNTCP MPHS(M) 10 days STDC NLEP /MPHW(M) IDSP DATA 2 3 2 4 2-3 4 1-2 6 1 27 Batches Batches Batches Batches Batches Batches Batch Batches MANAGER/ Batches Batches DEO SN/ PHARMACIST IDSP 460 740 480 100 600 640 260 1420 320 140 220 5380 MEDICAL COLLEGE PHARMACIST / NURSES/ 2-3 MRT IDSP Batches 24 24 ASHA/AWW/H W NPCB 9600 9600 ANM/HW/ SAHAIYYA NPCB 1200 1200 MPHS(F) / 16 MPHS(M) NVBDCP 500 40 Batches 540 CMO/DMO NVBDCP 33 7 40 ANM/LHV NLEP 2900 2900 MPHS/ MPW/ LT TB/HIV 68 68 PARAMEDICA DOTS + MDR LS 100 100 3 days STDC MO/PARA MEDICALS/ Deafness HEALTH Control WORKERS Programme TOTAL 4216 1408 14940 17729 1146 11462 2011 8671 2704 610 603 1152 37494 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. Master Trainers Yes Available YES Master Trainers Yes Available YES Master Trainers Yes Available YES Master Trainers Yes Available YES Other Programmes (9 High focus states + 3 NE States) Disaster Management Management Training Accountancy Training Gender MO's Sensitization Programme Management Integ Service Delivery (TOT) Accountancy Training TOT SUB- TOTAL ENT Training SPECIALIST Cardiology/ENT /Ortho./ Neuro Training Skills SUB- TOTAL AYUSH HMIS ANM Life Saving Skills SUB- TOTAL W aste Management TOT HOSPITAL STAFF W aste Management Training SUB- TOTAL SENIORS New HEALTHCARE Technology for PROVIDERS Healthcare Training on STATE LEVEL PPP in Health OFFICIALS Sector Public Health STATE & DISTRICT Management/ Hospital Good LEVEL OFFICIALS Practisers Hospital HOSPITAL Management MANAGER Training Family Life School Prinicples Education Foundation Health Education Training Officers Skill ANMTC Tutors Upgradation TOT 200 200 200 200 600 600 100 240 100 240 100 100 240 100 30 630 500 3 30 1470 3 400 403 400 403 4384 4384 4384 3550 3550 3550 25 25 25 25 220 220 100 100 200 200 35 35 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Other Program m e) STATES Accountancy Training Accountancy Training Accountancy Training Programe Management NRHM Programe Management Management Training Management Training NRHM Management Training HMIS HMIS HMIS Name Based Tracking System Name Based Tracking System Name Based Tracking System TRAINING LOAD GIVEN FOR COMBINED GROUPS OF FUNCTIONARIES BLOCK LEVEL ACCOUNTANTS 95 DISTRICT LEVEL ACCOUNTANTS 13 95 13 4 SPMU/DPMU 90 4 90 LHV/ANM CDMO/DY.CDMO DISTRICT LEVEL USERS BLOCK LEVEL USERS ANM/ASHA/ ASHA FACILITATORS/ LHV/BEE/PHC ACCOUNTANTS 7155 213 213 206 batches 75 75 206 Batches BPMU/MO DISTRICT ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICERS/ DIST. HEALTH EDUCATION OFFICERS DISTRICT LEVEL USERS BLOCK LEVEL USERS BELOW BLOCK LEVEL USERS 7155 108 108 447 447 9670 9670 135 135 447 447 41348 41348 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Nagaland Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Jharkhand Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Other Programme) STATES MIS Format MIS Format MFP ProMIS Computer Training BEE/LHV/ COMPUTOR DPMU 100 100 150 150 150 1000 MO/CDPO/LS LHV/NGO 150 1000 150 3500 AWW/ANM CDMO/CS 150 3500 100 STORE KEEPERS/ PHARMACISTS 100 200 660 660 15829 72 2 Batches 86551 COMPOUNDERS MO/ACMO/DIO CIVIL SURGEON/ DPM TOTAL 52885 72 2 Batches 8306 100 1385 108 Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. 4 Form of Monitoring and Achieving Targets Available Trainers Training Modules & Teaching Aids Available Place of Training Duration of Training Total Meghalaya Arunachal Pradesh Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand Rajasthan Orissa Madhya Pradesh Nagaland 550 DISTRICT DRUG STORE MANAGER/ DEO/MO BCC Others Training 550 BPMU DPHN/DHV/ ANM TUTORS IEC/BCC/IPC Administration/ Finance Logistics Management Training on Medicine Preparation Orientation on Referral Transport Jharkhand STATISTICAL OFFICER/ INVESTIGATOR CUM COMPUTOR BCC IEC/BCC/IPC Bihar CATEGORIES Assam NAME OF THE TRAINING/ ACTIVITY Chhattisgarh Training Load (Other Programme) STATES COLOURS -- denotes GREEN - Data has been taken from the information received from the state (it is present in the state ROP as batch size) RED - Data has been taken from the information received from the state (Information is not given in state ROP). ORANGE - Data has not been provided but the budget is reflected in ROP YELLOWISH GREEN - Actual training Load will be higher as some states have mentioned only batches for few of the trainings. State wise Total Number of Training (Category wise) Category of S.No. Participants 1 Assam 2 Bihar 3 Chhattisgarh 4 Jharkhand 5 Madhya Pradesh 6 Orissa 7 Rajasthan 8 Uttarakhand 9 Uttar Pradesh 10 Arunachal Pradesh 11 Meghalaya 12 Nagaland MO 26 17 19 30 21 22 22 17 24 23 20 18 S/N 8 4 7 7 9 9 7 9 11 4 5 4 ANM 8 7 6 19 5 6 4 7 7 8 6 6 Maximum Minimum 30 17 11 4 19 5 LHV 6 4 6 11 4 3 4 3 9 2 3 3 MPW (M) 2 2 2 3 2 3 3 3 6 5 3 4 MPHS (M) 3 1 1 3 2 1 1 2 4 3 3 2 LTs. 5 5 6 7 6 3 6 4 4 5 5 2 11 2 6 2 4 1 7 2 Pharmacist Specialist SPMU DPMU 1 3 2 1 2 2 6 1 2 1 1 2 2 2 2 1 1 2 4 2 13 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 13 1 2 1 2 1 State wise Total Number of Health Facilities S.No. Name of State District Hospital Blood Bank FRUs CHCs PHCs SubCenter 1 Assam #22 25 38 103 844 4592 2 Bihar 25 24 22 70 1641 8858 3 Chhattisgarh NA 13 NA 136 721 4741 4 Jharkhand #24 20 22 194 330 3958 5 Madhya Pradesh 46 28 NA 270 1149 8834 6 Orissa #32 14 NA 231 1279 6688 7 Rajasthan 33 14 365 349 1503 10742 8 Uttarakhand #18 7 10 55 239 1765 9 Uttar Pradesh 71# 48 NA 515 3690 20521 10 Arunachal Pradesh 13 NA 52 44 116 592 11 Meghalaya 6 2 NA 26 103 401 12 Nagaland 11 1 27 21 86 397 TOTAL 301 196 536 2014 11701 72089 •Source: Rural Health Statistics 2008 #Information taken from MOHFW website Number of Health Facilities of other Departments S.No. Name of State Railway s Hospital Armed Forces ESI Hospitals/ Dispensaries Hospital Dispensarie s s 2 28 Army Central Police Forces Navy ITBP CRPF BSF CISF 0 Air Force 1 0 2 4 0 P&T Hospitals 0 Assam Rifles 1 Dispensary + 41 Hospital 4 1 Assam 7 2 3 Bihar Chhattisgarh 6 3 NA 3 24 12 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 4 1 4 Jharkhand 2 3 13 1 0 0 0 3 0 1 0 2 5 5 7 44 6 1 0 2 5 1 2 0 5 6 7 Madhya Pradesh Orissa Rajasthan 3 9 6 5 50 65 0 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 1 3 0 0 3 5 8 Uttarakhand 7 3 0 0 8 1 0 0 0 1 9 Uttar Pradesh 18 16 116 11 3 0 2 6 0 1 0 10 10 NA NA NA 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 NA 11 Arunachal Pradesh Meghalaya NA NA NA 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Dispensary + 1 Clinics 1 12 Nagaland NA NA NA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Hospital 0 State wise Teaching/Training Institutions including CGHS S.No . Name of State Medical College SIHF W RHFWTC ANM Schoo l Nursing College GNM School B.Sc. M.Sc. CGHS P.B.B.Sc Dispensarie Empanelle . s d Hospital 3 3 5 1 Assam 3 1 1 9 17 6 3 2 Bihar 6(G)+3(P) 1 3 27 9 0 0 0 1 9 3 Chhattisgarh 2(G)+1 (P) 1 1 10 11 32 11 8 NA NA 4 Jharkhand 3 0 1 16 16 3 0 1 1 4 5 Madhya Pradesh 5 (G)+3(P) 1 3 76 67 84 20 28 5 28 6 Orissa 3(G)+1(P) 1 2 53 39 14 4 3 NA 4 7 Rajasthan 1 2 11 155 102 5 32 6 24 8 Uttarakhand #6 (G)+2(P) # 2(G)+1(P) 0 2 6 6 5 2 1 1 4 9 Uttar Pradesh 9(G) + 9(P) 1 11 27 116 25 4 6 30 85 10 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 NA NA 11 Arunachal Pradesh Meghalaya 1 0 1 2 7 1 0 0 1 NA 12 Nagaland 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 NA NA TOTAL 60 7 21 240 446 272 49 82 48 163 •Source: Rural Health Statistics 2008 • #Information taken from MOHFW website Major findings of the review 1. Some states (Uttarakhand for some Disease Control Programme) Assam, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh etc. (for RCH) have started giving the Comprehensive Training Plan for planning training at least in some programmes. 2. States like Maharashtra and Orissa have started integration of training for a few categories - Orissa for Lab technicians across both Health & FW and Maharashtra for MO within RCH programme components in 09-10. 3. Tamil Nadu has proposed assessment of skill also in each trainee (using OSCE) at the beginning of the course and focus on training for whatever knowledge or skill the trainee lacks. 4. Haryana, J & K, Assam, Meghalaya and a few other states have proposed to integrate the trainings in 10-11. 4. The ROP reflects only those trainings where there is financial commitment from GOI to the state. This abstract does not include Training of master trainers, PDC etc. as these are done by institutions with funding directly from GOI and not from state PIP. 5. The abstract includes training proposed by states but perhaps not approved in ROP. There are certain trainings for which the funds have been approved but do not meet technical norms.(e.g IMNCI for MO and SBA for MO) 6. The budget has been reduced in the ROP for certain trainings but there has been no proportionate reduction in training load. 7. Many of the functional facilities are not being utilized for training at all or optimally. NIHFW over the last seven years has 1. Prepared the curricula and other details for each category for the integrated training strategy, 2. Incorporated integrated training strategy for training of all state level programme officers, SIHFW faculty, PMU personnel as well as medical college faculty. 3. Most trainees have understood the importance of such strategy as well as the advantages. 4. But the health systems in the state are yet to internalise it as is evident from the training planned in the PIPs. ISSUES & CHALLENGES ISSUES 1. After decades of vertical training, transition to integrated training is difficult and states are taking time to adapt to it. Even under the same programme eg. RCH vertical training occurs even when trainers and trainees are the same eg. Immunization Training done every year. 2. Each category of personnel has a number of training programmes for different aspects of service delivery. 3. Some people go repeatedly for training while others do not get any opportunity for training. Category of participants and No. of trainings available Category of Participants Range of trg prog in ROP 2010-11 MO 17 to 30 S/N 4 to 11 ANM 5 to 19 LHV 2 to 11 MPW (M) 2 to 6 MPHS (M) 1 to 4 DPMU 1 to 2 SPMU 1 to 2 LTs. 2 to 7 Specialist 1 to 13 Pharmacist 1 to 2 Issues (contd) 4. Training Plans are not based on need of the district/state for skilled human resource; Adhocism prevails. 5. Lack of prioritisation eg selection and training of personnel from those centres where facilities and case load exist so that they can become functional. 6. No clear cut plan for developing all the categories of staff for training at defined intervals. 7. Training is theory based rather than skill and programme oriented. 8. Lack of uniformity in duration, emphasis and methodology of training. Issues (contd) 9. Non functional District training Centres/Teams (DTCs), ANMTCs etc 10. Existing trainers may not be equipped with necessary skills to impart the training. 11. In EAG states, where there are large number of untrained personnel and trainers are few, the states feel they cannot complete training; backlogs keep growing and programme implementation suffers. 12. No linkage between training institutions, trainer and trainee and no follow up. Issues (contd) 9. Lack of follow up after any training regarding putting to use the new skills. 10. There is no planned supervision as an aspect of continued education. 11. State ownership of SIHFWs? 12. No appropriate linkage between NIHFW, SIHFWs and HFWTCs & other training institutions. 13. Hospitals not providing services as per norms. Challenges • Human Resource Planning at the national and state level. • Plan for appropriate pre service training so that we get personnel suited to the job- this requires reorientation of medical and paramedical education • Proper induction training at all levels. The new incumbents to be sent for induction before placement. Challenges (cont) • A training plan which takes into account the various categories and some system of time bound training • Proper utilization of the trained manpower • Finally- not to forget the private/NGO sector which provides much of the health care- we should partner with them in capacity building too. • New initiatives of exposing the private sector to national health problems, policies, programmes and contribution they can make is a priority area to be given due consideration. SUGGESTED SOLUTIONS 1. State & district need to prepare training plan based on National Training Strategy – Skilled manpower required for No. of facilities & type of services to be provided – No. of institutions required for imparting training. 2. To identity training institutions and trainers – Identify all available hospitals/institutions in all sectors i.e. govt., PSUs, railways, ESI, Armed Forces, NGOs & pvt. sector with adequate case load – Ensuring that personnel in these institutions are trained and are providing services as per GOI norms and they have necessary equipments and consumables. 3. Institutions: • Each state to have its own apex training institutions linked, on one hand, to NIHFW, and, on the other, to the other training institutions in the state is essential. • Each institute should be supported by appropriate subject experts with adequate field experience; co-opting local medical college faculty would benefit a lot. • Training institutions should have infrastructure support like library, hostel, computers, communication, AV aids etc. • SIHFW/state institutes should also be capable of undertaking training courses in organizational development/Change, leadership skills etc. 4. Coordination between MoHFW (training division), Program divisions, NHSRC and NIHFW for planning, implementation and monitoring, and resource material development. 5. Resource pool of trainers in different areas (including NGOs Experts, Retired Govt. Personnel interested in training, Experts from Corporate Sectors, Universities etc.). 6. Integration of training as far as possible. Horizontal integration at each level • Reduces time needed to train personnel – each category of worker learns skills for all tasks to be performed • The primary and secondary care workers will learn about all the H&FW programmes and may learn to look at the multiple problems people have and learn to provide all needed care to the person/community, • Ever-present problem of retraining of physicians when they get shifted to different levels, or between programmes eg. from RCH to malaria or malaria to TB will not be there. 7. Desk Monitoring: Training information system - Collection, Compilation and analyze of monthly training performance reports submitted by States & providing feed back to States for any deficiency or lacunae for improvement. State wise monthly/quarterly/annual performance reports on training Quarterly and annual report would indicate number trained, how many of these trained came from institutions where that services was not being provided and how many institutions have been made functional with the services by using these trained personnel. Analyses and providing feedback to MoH&FW every month. 8. Field Monitoring: Developing monitoring tools for quality of training for various categories of health personnel. NIHFW, SIHFW & office of the regional Director would undertake monitoring visits to (minimum of 5%): - assess hospitals and training institutions - assess content and quality of training 9. In order to enable routine monitoring GoI may incorporate progress in training in MIS; MIS should not only give numbers trained but also number of facilities where services have been made functional using such trained personnel. 10.Creation of GIS for available trainers in public and private sector for sharing resources and geographic coverage with training. Filling in the geographical gap based on the above exercise. 11. Supervision & monitoring of the trainings conducted by States/districts by the central teams on the lines of NRHM 12. Training Module for all health personnel need to be standardized including: – Core clinical content – Other required knowledge (Management, Finance, Gender, etc.) – Opportunities to practise the skills during training. Summary • There is a need for comprehensive & rational training plan • Trainings to be conducted as per requirement & based on specific facility/district plan • Once the training plan is developed : • Identification of training sites/ centres • Visit by programme officials • Accreditation of training centres & trainers • Send list of such accreted institutions to the state/centre • Prepare schedule of posting of trainees & posting them after training • Timely release of trainees by the states • Prepare Plan for Monitoring of training including budget. • Monitor the quality of training during the training • Follow up visit • Submit the report by facility/districts wise Training should be the priority for achieving the NRHM goals