Transcript Slide 1

FFY2010
EAP Annual Training
Section 1.0 Control Environment
Includes Program Management, EAP Business Strategy Model (BSM), Internal
Control Framework (ICF), State Plan, Policy Development Process (includes PAC
and EACA Input), Local Plans & Contracts, EAP Start up Procedures and Agency &
Coordinators Responsibility
August 12 & 13, 2009
St. Cloud Minnesota
Holiday Inn
1
Program Management
1. Control Environment
 Relates to management & employees
establishing & maintaining an environment
throughout the organization that sets a positive
& supportive attitude toward internal control &
conscientious management.
2
Program Management
Incremental Development Of EAP
Business Models & Strategies
 A number of concepts have been developed over time
 Each added to EAP improvements & made a good
program even better
 Lately we have tried to more fully integrate these
concepts into whole comprehensive approach
 We are not yet done, further work is ahead
3
Program Management
The Minnesota Model Reminder
 EAP employs a “Coordinated Responsibility Model”
 The Model assumes households, vendors, and the program all have a
role in assuring heat for low-income households during the winter.
Program responsibility includes providing heating payment
supplements, case management and advocacy for households, and
maintaining influence with vendors.
Energy Vendor responsibility is to be as flexible as possible so
energy payments leverage the highest possible level of service to
the household.
Household responsibility is to make reasonable and planned
payments for energy service, access government aid when
necessary and communicate with vendors and government service
providers.
4
•
•
•
Program Management
EAP Management Approach
Proven Process Including
 Project Plans
 Tools
 Continuous Improvement
5
Program Management
Formal & Documented Project Plans
 Built with stakeholder input
• PAC
• EACA
• JAD
• State Staff
• Policy makers
 Puts a well-understood and accepted process in place
for reaching the project’s results
6
Program Management
Approach by Advanced Strategies, Inc.
 Used to develop eHEAT
 Trained all EAP State Staff
 Developed Internal Plans
• Master Plan
• Project Plans
 Conducted JADs
 Issues Management
 Broadened application
7
Program Management
Project (Effort) Definitions
 Intentions: Goals or outcomes intended
 Values: Principles, standards and ideals incorporated
into the project or effort
 Focus: What’s included and excluded
 Context: Situations existing around the project, not
part of it but can affect it
8
Program Management
Business Strategies Model (BSM)
9
Program Management
Why Do We Need a BSM?
Provides a Shared Vision
 Gives people a sense we are all serving the same goals
... we are all working together
 Helps build a high-performing team
 Helps provide consistent messages to key stakeholders
 Helps guide day-to-day decisions and actions
10
Program Management
Vision
What happens if we don’t have a shared vision?
 We each have a vision that underlies our behavior
 If it is not shared – we appear to be
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Out of sync
Disorganized
Inefficient
Inconsistent
Selfish
Ultimately not worthy of confidence
Appear unreliable (different responses from different individuals)
11
Program Management
The Business Strategy Model
Handout in Folder
Intentions
Values
• What guides the behavior of
your organization?
Means
• What products or services do
we provide?
• To whom do we provide them?
ir
Env
en
m
n
o
Means
Int
ent
i
on
s
Valu
es
ts
Vision
Offerings Markets External Internal
Definitions
• Why does your unit or
organization exist?
Environments
• What factors outside our
organization must we monitor
and adjust to?
• How should we organize
ourselves to meet our intentions,
within our values?
12
Program Management
EAP & PAC BSM Shared
EAP & PAC BSM are same except means, but share:
 Intentions
 Values
 Means (Offerings & Markets)
 Environments
13
Program Management
PAC BSM - Background
How we got here:
 Developed for the program by the State Staff
 Extracted PAC specific content from a combination
of program BSM and PAC effort definition
14
Program Management
EAP BSM – Intentions
Maintain affordable, continuous, and safe
home energy for low-income Minnesota
households.
15
Program Management
EAP BSM - Values
4 categories:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Overall
Regarding Households
Regarding Collaboration
Regarding Policy Directio
16
Program Management
EAP BSM - Values
1. Overall
a. Affordable, safe, and dependable energy
b. Advocacy
c. Good stewardship of resources
d. Being realistic about limitations
e. Quality
f. Partners and Partnerships (see Coordinated Responsibility
Model)
g. Understanding the program in the context of broader public
policy and other needs of low-income Minnesotans
h. Being the compass but not the map
17
Program Management
EAP BSM - Values
2. Regarding Households
a. Dignity and privacy
b. Participation (see Coordinated Responsibility Model)
c. Empower people to make informed decisions regarding their energy
use and needs
d. Serving the most in need – balancing total number of participants
makeup of participants, and levels of service
18
Program Management
EAP BSM - Values
3. Regarding Collaboration
a. The responsibility to provide a safety net
b. Working towards the same goals
c. Stakeholders personal commitment and accountability
d. Represent our own personal perspective, the views of our
stakeholder group, and the world from multiple perspectives
e. Actively coordinate across programs and departments
19
19
Program Management
EAP BSM - Values
4. Regarding Policy Direction
a. Creative and flexible approaches
b. Consistency
c. Balance of simplicity and fairness
d. Recommendations based on a sound community analysis
e. More strategic than operational
d. Timely and proactive in order to mitigate emerging problems
20
Program Management
EAP BSM – Means Offerings
Offerings (Program Products & Services)
 Energy bill payment
 Furnace repair or replacement
 Energy related crisis intervention
 Advocacy
 Outreach
 Referral
 Information
 Education
 Conservation, coordination and collaboration
 Demonstrate effectiveness of investment
21
Program Management
EAP BSM – Means Offerings
State Staff Offerings
 Oversight, monitoring and quality control
 Compliance with Federal and State requirements
 Policy
 Decision making
 Planning
 Training and Technical Support
 Stakeholder involvement and communication
 Program advocacy and information
22
Program Management
EAP BSM – Means Markets
 Markets (Customers)
•
•
•
•
•
•
Households, emphasizing low-income:
– Families with children under age
five
– Families with members who are
disabled
– Seniors
EAP Director and Staff
Local Service Providers
Policy decision makers
Funders (e.g. HHS)
Energy Vendors
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Mechanical Contractors
PAC members
Weatherization Assistance
Program
Partner organizations
Community
Tax payers
Utility rate payers
23
Program Management
PAC BSM - Offerings
 Direction
 Oversight
 Advocacy, education and outreach
24
Program Management
BSM Environments
 External
 Internal
25
Program Management
BSM Environments Internal
Environmental Consideration
Implications
Unique & necessary role of
Households, Energy Vendors &
Government (Coordinated
Responsibility Model)
Particular consideration to the definition and communication of all
stakeholder roles
Active pursuit of involvement and Increased likelihood of success
partnership by using a shared Increased commitment of time on the front-end for all of stakeholders
business methodology
Devote scarce staff resources to the way we do business and invest in
state staff skills and techniques
Direction: Maximize local knowledge,
control and delivery of services
Contract out to local service providers
State Office actively pursued feedback and adjustments
Our leadership & peers are interested
in and supportive of our efforts
Understand and align needs and expectations of leadership and peers
Keep leadership and peers informed
Understand & align needs and expectations of partners and community
Our partners & community are
interested in & supportive of our efforts Keep partners and community informed
We have custom developed
technology tools to support our
business
We can directly influence what our tools do/not support – constrained
to resources
Increased consistency of the program – less local control
26
Program Management
BSM Environments External
Environmental Consideration Implications
In the Office of Energy Security
Primary state energy policy agency
Not a social service agency – our offerings are unique in this organization
Federal LIHEAP block grant
Constraints and flexibility in how we deliver the program e.g. we determine to
offer furnace repair and replacement
There are other related
programs (e.g. CWR, DHS,
Heat Share and Affordability
Programs)
Effects public understanding,
Resource amounts & timing of
resources are out of our control
Effects availability, delivery and types of services offer at program start up and
dictates end date and carryover.
Weather
Effects demand during seasonal changes and effects consumption amounts
Economy
Increase demand on program services
Fuel prices
Changes impact of benefits and need for services
27
Program Management
Introduction
Internal Control Framework (ICF)
28
Program Management
Why Internal Controls?
 All funds need good controls
 Being good stewards of taxpayer’s funds
 Office of Legislative Auditor (OLA)
• Two years of “No Findings” for EAP
 OLA is requiring the development of an Internal Control
Framework
29
Program Management
Pennsylvania
Other Info
 18 charged with stealing $500,000 in
LIHEAP funds
http://toddelliottkoger.blogspot.com/2009/
07/18-charged-with-stealing-500000in.html
 PA Auditor Urges Action After Philadelphia
LIHEAP Fraud
http://liheap.ncat.org/news/june09/pa.htm
 Auditor General Jack Wagner Urges
DPW to Implement Recommendations to
Eliminate Potential...
http://www.reuters.com/article/pressRelea
se/idUS194062+10-Jun2009+PRN20090610
 State to put safeguards in emergency
heating program
http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.s
sf/2009/06/dpw_to_put_safeguards_in_e
merg.html
30
Program Management
Internal Controls?
 GAO (Government Accounting Office)
31
Program Management
Internal Controls
 Most pieces were already done (incrementally
without regard to ICF)
 ICF provided the framework allowing the pieces to
fit together
 Local Plans, State staff meetings, this training, more
in the future including all aspects of monitoring
32
Program Management
Office of the Legislative Auditor (OLA)
Top Audit Issues (Statewide)
 Significant weaknesses in common internal control
concepts.
•
•
Opportunities for fraud
Common areas of noncompliance
•
Assessing how well an agency identifies its risks, whether it
documents and assigns its control procedures, and how it
monitors the performance and effectiveness of the
procedures.
 Emerging Issue – Internal Control Maturity
33
Program Management
Tone at the Top
Agency management has the primary responsibility to
design, implement, and maintain an effective internal
control system. This goes from:
 Governor
 Commissioner
 Deputy Commissioner
 Program Director
 Service Provider Executive Directors
 EAP Coordinator
34
Program Management
Tone at the Top
(continued)
Management shapes an organization's guiding values,
disciplined business conduct, and operating policies
forming the foundation of an agency's internal control
structure.
35
Program Management
State Directive
Agency head must develop a plan for establishing,
implementing and maintaining an effective internal control
system. This plan at a minimum requires documentation
of:
 Internal control procedures over financial management
activities,
 An analysis of relevant risks,
 Periodic evaluation of these control procedures
To satisfy management that these procedures are adequately
designed, properly implemented, and functioning effectively.
36
Program Management
EAP & ICF
 Why does EAP have a ICF?
• OLA required EAP to have (in one day) or have a Audit finding
• EAP took the “opportunity” to analyze and assess it’s existing
business processes & controls & placed into ICF framework
 What does existing program components, effort definitions,
implementation plans and policies mean?
Asked how existing documents equated to internal controls
Incorporated existing documents into the ICF
Organized structure identified strengths and weaknesses
ICF is a evolving, living document EAP will be advancing in
the coming year and maintain going forward
•
•
•
•
37
Program Management
Internal Control Framework (ICF)
 What is ICF?
 How does it affect EAP?
38
Program Management
What is ICF?
The Framework is used assess the Internal Control
Competency to determine how well an organization:
 Identifies its risks
 Whether it documents and assigns its control
procedures, and
 How it monitors the performance and effectiveness
of the procedures
39
Program Management
ICF outlines criteria EAP uses to:
Frames State Office Operations
 Management approach
Determine competent Service Providers
 Contract with Local Plan
Monitor and evaluate program performance
 Field Monitoring, Routine review, Ad Hoc Review
Build the competency of the SPs
 Training, Support, Corrective Action and T&TA
40
Program Management
Frames within Framework (ICF)
 Federal & State Controls
• Rules and fiscal practices
• GAO, OLA, MMB
 Department of Commerce
• Mission & Fiscal Control
 EAP State Office
• Program Policy & Procedure Requirement
• Risk and quality controls
• Fiscal allocation and auditing
• Monitoring
• T&TA
 EAP Service Providers
• Execute Program mission
• Implementation of policies and procedures with a quality
control environment
• Manage SP specific risks
41
Program Management
Internal Control Definition
Defines internal control as a process, effected by individuals
within an organization, designed to provide reasonable assurance
regarding the achievement of these objectives:
1. Effectiveness and efficiency of operations,
2. Reliability of financial reporting, and
3. Compliance with applicable laws & regulations.
42
Program Management
ICF Structure
The three objectives are supported by the framework. The
Framework, is comprised of five interrelated components that can
react dynamically to changing conditions:
1. Control Environment
2. Risk Assessment & Management
3. Control Activities
4. Information & Communication
5. Monitoring
43
Program Management
EAP Specific Control Examples
1. Environment (or Leadership or Tone at the Top)
Ex: EAP SP’s leadership supports mission, structure and staffing to effectively process EAP
Applications and deliver Crisis, ERR & A16
2. Risk Assessment and Management
Ex: SP has and is aware of Disaster Plan so in case of flood or fire the harm to households reduce.
3. Control Activities
Ex: SP understands, collects & maintains income documentation as a control the services reach the
intended households. SP has proper segregation of duties for payment certification
4. Information and Communication
Ex: SP makes policy & procedural Information is available to agency fiscal staff, mechanical
contractors, vendors etc. to enable the program mission and controls to be consistently performed
5. Monitoring
Ex: SP monitors timeliness of application processing and improves processes when possible
44
Program Management
1. Control Environment
 “Tone at the top" is set set & demonstrated by an
organization leader's actions & words
 It is the foundation for all other components of internal
control. It encompasses:
• Integrity, ethical values & competence of all people in an
•
•
•
organization
Management's philosophy & style
How management assigns authority, responsibility and
organizes and develops its people
The attention & direction executive leadership provides
45
Program Management
ICF Implementations
1. Control Environment
 Local Plan, contracts establish documented understanding of ICF competencies
 SP connects Business Strategy Model (BSM) & SP Mission
 EAP Manual is use to guide SP policy and procedures development
 SP participates in EAP management methodology including joint approach to
development through EACA, JADs, training etc. and :
• Understands Effort Definitions used to assure understanding of intentions and values
• Understands and adopts administrative policies and procedures documentation
 Service Providers participates in EAP training and trains staff to:
• Promotes program compliance and consistency
• Shares common mission, intention, goals, values and approach to program delivery
• Assure policies are understood
46
Program Management
2. Risk Management
 Involves the identification and analysis of relevant risks to
achieve desired objectives
 In the risk assessment process, management identifies:
•
•
•
•
Internal and external risks
Assesses the impact and the likelihood these risks might occur
Selects whether to avoid, reduce, share, or accept various risks
Considers controls to mitigate risk or to contain it to an acceptable
level
Risk Management detailed later in this training
47
Program Management
ICF Implementations
2. Risk Management (Risk assessment & Mitigation)
 SP conduct risk assessment & mitigation activities
 State and SP conduct oversight activities including:
• Data, file and other checks
• Data & Technology practices (eHEAT user management)
 SP make a maintain disaster plans
 SP designs processes with proper segregation of duty in key
areas
 SP uses incident reporting process
 SP uses error & fraud processes
48
Program Management
3. Control Activities


Consists of policies & procedures to help ensure management
directives are carried out
Control activities occur throughout the organization at all
levels in all functions.
49
Program Management
ICF Implementations
3. Control Environment
 SP processes have approvals & authorizations for benefit
determination & payments
•
Separation of incompatible duties
•
•
Income eligibility and documentation
vendor registration & sound payment process for ERR contractors.
 SP conducts analytical procedures like quality controls including timely
service
 SP conduct and support verifications like:
•
Household check points:
– Benefit notification to assure accountability of service delivery
– Appeals and compliant process
 SP conducts reconciliations like allocation and FSR
 Reviews of operating performance
 SP assures security of assets
50
Program Management
4. Information & Communication
 Addresses how an organization identifies, captures &
communicates pertinent information in a timely manner to the
right people to enable them to carry out their responsibilities
 Information systems within the organization are key to this
element of internal control
 Internal information, and external events, activities &
conditions must be communicated to enable management to
make informed business decisions and employees to perform
their assigned duties
51
Program Management
ICF Implementations
4. Communication & Information
 SP has communication plan for dissemination of program information
 SP has routines like meetings to inform staff and partners
 SP conducts appropriate and effective outreach
 SP retains information overtime
 SP is up to date with routine EAP communication:
•
•
•
•
•
Weekly newsletter The Energizer
Ad hoc email distributions
Web information and program tools
T&TA
Association meetings including Agency Executive Directors &
Coordinators
52
Program Management
5. Monitoring
 Is activities to evaluate whether components of the internal
control system are operating effectively
 Is performed by management and supervisors sometimes with
internal auditors on a continuous or periodic basis
 Includes identified internal control deficiencies being reported
to top management and remedied in a timely manner with
appropriate corrective actions
 Is periodic follow-up on corrective actions taken to ensure
control weaknesses are strengthened and no longer exist
53
Program Management
ICF Implementations
5. Monitoring



SP and DOC conduct routine oversight and monitoring designed to facilitate:
• Staff review of data for quality and performance controls
• Review financial transactions
Onsite Monitoring including State Monitors conducting two scheduled Service
Provider visits including:
• Formal and observational assessment including random file selection
• Fiscal and audit requirements
DOC is working with the Minnesota Office of the Legislative Auditor (OLA) and
implementing recommendations and suggestions and SPs will help develop and
implement improvements
54
Program Management
Our Responsibility
 Advance our understanding ICF
 Understand how existing EAP controls fit ICF
 Continue to implement new ICF activities
 Strengthening controls when weaknesses are detected
 Providing adequate supervision necessary to ensure internal
controls are operating effectively as designed
 Obtain information & training on internal controls for ourselves
and staff, necessary to meaningfully take responsibility for
internal controls
 FFY2010 EAP Manual Chapters 1 & 3 have ICF integration
55
Program Management
FFY2010 State Plan
 Due September 1, 2009
 Public Hearing on June 24, 2009
 Input included PAC, EACA and on-going gathering
of issues
 Major changes-
• Average grant: $600
• Maximum grant:$1400
• ROFW date extended to September
56
EACA
Recommendations
EAP Issues Log
Maintain Core
Activities Core
PAC
Recommendations
Other Issues
EACA
(Not from Log)
Recommendations
Deferred/Round up
Issues
Other
Issues
This model represents the process the
EAP Manual for FY 2008 do be executed
the summer of 2007
Resources
availability
PAC Recommendations
VisioDocument
Specifications
of the change
& tasks to do
& Regression
3.0
Conduct Analysis or
draft implementation
of decisions
Policy
&
Procedures
Solutions
With
Resourced
Assignment
5.0 Assign
Realizer
5.0 Specify
Solution
Candidate Policy
& Procedure
Analysis
assigments
Analysis
2.0
“Round Up”
Produce /Implement
Conduct 2009 Efforts
2.2.3.4
Vendor Agreement &
Chapter Draft
Vetting is part
of all solution
Implementation
Decisions
Mine Energizers
4.0 Assess and
decide on
changes
Define reason to make
change (Solution Free)
Discovery and Analyze
Policies determine
via EZ
2.2.3.4
Manual
2.2.3.4
Training
Implementation
Adjustments
Non Round Up
considerations
Realize & Design
Changes
Tracked to
Issues Log
FFY2010 Policy Making Concept
Business Process Model
Planning Model
1.0
Mine for Candidate
Policy & Procedure for
next FYY
Determine Need/Define
1.2
Determine/Qualify/
select 2009 Efforts
Change Tracking
Sheet
Changes
5.0 Track
Changes
Final
Resolve and Implementation details
Information
EAP Issues Log
2.2.3.4
Application
Program Management
Contracts and Local Plans
Doug Burns
Office of Energy Assistance Programs
58
Program Management
EAP Grant Contract
“Service Providers represent that they are duly
qualified and agree to perform all services described
in the contract to the satisfaction of the State.”
 Perform duties and expend funds as stated in:
• State Plan
• EAP Policy Manual
• SP Local Plan
• NFA (funds available)
59
Program Management
EAP Grant Contract
 Timelines
 Payment
 Government Data Practices
 OMB – Federal Circulars
 Monitoring
 Fiscal Responsibility
•
•
•
•
(continued)
Financial Records
Corporate Audit
Program Income
Repayment
 Drug-free
 Cooperation
 Termination
60
Program Management
EAP Contract Due September 11
Assist your executive director
 Two Contracts and Certifications Document signed
by Board Chair or Authorized Designee
• If signed by designee, send documentation conveying
signature authority
 EAP Local Plan signed by executive director
 eHEAT Security Administrator Agreement signed
by the eHEAT security administrator
61
Program Management
New ICF Format - EAP Local Plan
Intentions: To ensure:
 Incorporation of Internal Control Framework (ICF)
 SP’s mission and values are attuned to EAP’s and are
personified by SP leadership and communicated to staff
 SPs have the ability and resources to administer EAP at
the local level
 SPs are prepared to fully implement the program
 SPs assess risk and implements plans and controls to
mitigate loss, error, fraud and uncontrollable situations
 SP’s Local Plan describe local EAP delivery
 SPs comply EAP with policies/procedures at the local level 62
Program Management
EAP Local Plan
(continued)
 DOC views your Local Plan as the guiding
document for administering EAP at the local level
 SPs have started the ICF process by completing
their Local Plan
 SPs should refer to their Local Plans
 The Local Plan is utilized to review, monitor and
assess competency/performance
 Reviewing the Local Plan with the EAP Coordinator
will be part of Initial Monitoring by Field Reps
63
Program Management
Service Provider Startup Procedures
 Funding for Admin, A16 and ERR will be provided
prior to October 1st for FFY 2010
64
Contract for
Services
Approved Contracts
(Including Local Plans etc.)
Feds distribute Fund
or Years Starts
Enter
Agreement
Info into MAPS
& eHEAT
Fromula
Distribute
State Level
EAP Budget
Policy Round Up
SP’s Begin
to Make
Payments
Executed
NFA’s
Allocated
funds
Allocate
funds By
SP
EAP
Budget
Fund
Allocation
Amounts
4.4 Enter
Allocation
into eHEAT
eHEAT Rollover
FY2008
PreLog Apps &
Consumption Requestd
Completed
agreements
4.3 Issue
NFA
(For Admin
& ERR)
Federal
State Allocations
Data
FFY2010
Program Prep &
Start
Vendors
enter
consumption
2.8 Develop
Benefit Tables
FY2008
Consumption
Manual
New or corrected Policy
and Procedures
Excel
Matrices
Upload
Matrices
into eHEAT
EAP Annual Mailing
(RO & PreApps)
New or corrected Policy
and Procedures
Determined
Benefits
SP’s Begin
Determine
Eligibility
Benefit Matrices
and
Activated Determine
Eligibility Button
HHD
Applications
EAP Annual Training
Complete
Apps
Receive
and enter
Apps
Trained
Staff
Policies
&
Procedures
Train Staff
Open door
Enter Apps
Program Management
Agency & Coordinator Repsonsibility
66
Program Management
Coordinator’s Responsibility
 Ensure eligible households have access to all EAP benefits and
services
 Meet all of the requirements of the EAP contract to include;
•
Application of State policies and procedures correctly and consistently
to ensure
– Effective and efficient operations
° Train staff
° Follow directives from the DOC
° Vendor monitoring
– Reliable financial reporting such as
° Financial Status Reports (FSR)
– Compliance with applicable laws and regulations
° Data Practices
67
Program Management
Coordinator’s Responsibility
Effectively & continuously communicate with SP administration:
 Ensure EAP has agency support to;
• Maintain an ethical work environment and establish a
positive and supportive attitude
• Build competency through the use of effective “Internal
Control Framework” (ICF) designed to enable prudent
management of public funds
Adhere to rules and regulations regarding Data Practices
• Manage and mitigate risk
•
68
Program Management
Coordinator’s Responsibility
Assure organizational roles are understood in relationship to EAP:
 Train to ensure staff is effective, proficient and reliable
by;
• Conveying EAP values, beliefs and priorities and providing
training on:
– Application processing
– Data entry into eHEAT
– Crisis and ERR
– Assurance 16 activities
– EB and EBA
69
Program Management
Coordinator’s Responsibility
 Data Practices Policies and Procedures
• Security of records
• Risk Planning
• Identify risks
 Record retention
• Over three years is a potential security risk
 Record accessibility
• Third party “informed consent”
70
Program Management
Coordinator’s Responsibility
Ensure essential reports are run through eHEAT:
 Train personnel or request assistance from DOC
 Ensure up-to-date information is entered into
eHEAT
 Correlate expenditures reported on the FSR and
activities reported in eHEAT
71