Transcript Document
Dividend
Re-Investment
Plans
Andre J. Trottier
1
Introduction
Individual Investor, Retired 1997
Invested from 1975-82
Canadian Moneysaver Articles
Leveraging
Split Shares
Frictional Costs
2
Topics of Discussion
Frictional Costs
DRIP
Power of Dividends
Efficiency
Simplicity
Getting Started
3
Taxes, Loads & Fees
Most certain components
Negative components
Effective management will do most
to enhance returns
Goal be avoiding them…..No
Do they really matter?….Yes
4
Taxes
Ontario $30,754, MTR 28.16%
Tax Factor = 1.00
= 1.39
1.00 - 0.2816 (MTR)
Earn $1.39 to keep $1.00
18.9% VISA = 18.9 X 1.39 or
26.27%
5
Federal Personal
Tax Rates
$30,754 or Less----------16%
$30,754 to $61,508------22%
$61,629 to $100,00------26%
$100,000+------------------29%
6
Tax Avoidance
Strategies
Defer income
Arrange income to be Tax Efficient
Capital gains & dividends
Interest instruments in RSP
7
Management Expense
Ratios (MERs)
Canadian average 2.50%
Was 2.30% in 1997
US Average 1.35%
8
Rule of 40
Take 40 and divide it by the MER
number of years to consume 1/3 of
your investment
40 / 2.5% = 16 yrs
front end load of 33%
9
Your Mutual Fund
Manager Really
Charging You?
True Cost per $100,000.00 invested
MER
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
3.0%
10 yrs
$9,250
$13,930
$18,130
$25,920
20 yrs
$18,130
$25,920
$32,970
$45,120
30 yrs
$25,950
$36,240
$45,120
$59,340
Fee Impact calculator http://strategis.ic.gc.ca
10
Diminishing Returns
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
43 Top Quartile Mgrs
14 out the 43
5 out the 43
2 out the 43
0 out the 43
11
Mutual Fund Facts
“Outperformance” will "Regress
to the Mean"
the 1990s 80% of Canadian Funds
"Did not beat the averages"
Efficient investing:
Never pay >2% commission, total
Funds charge 2.5%/yr
12
Regression to the Mean
13
Tradex Equity Fund
-open only to public servants
-since 1961, avg 11% return/yr
-Philips Hager & North
- Globefund top 15 funds for 15
year performance
-"lucky to be a Public Servant“
Reason 1.35% MER
14
John Bogle
The easiest and surest way for a
fund to achieve the top quartile in
investment performance among
peer funds is to achieve the
bottom quartile in expenses.
15
Nortel Employee
BMO Funds 1.5% MER
Year
Amount
2001
2010
2020
2027
$120,000
$332,769
$1,033,531
$2,284,806
1.5% Fee
$1,800
$4,991
$15,502
$34,272
Direct
$120,000
$375,079
$1,330,768
$3,229,041
16
A. Trottier’s Situation
AGF American Growth
AIC Advantage 2
AGF International Stock Class
Fidelity Focus Health Care
2.88%
2.72%
2.85%
2.68%
17
2.80% MER Chart
Year
Amount
2.8% Fee
Direct
2001
2010
2020
2027
$120,000
$299,577
$827,915
$1,706,435
$3,360
$8,388
$23,181
$47,780
$120,000
$375,097
$1,330,768
$3,229,041
2027
$34,272
$3,229,041
$2,284,806
18
MER Effect on Wealth
19
MER and Returns
20
Fund Problems
To equal TSE 300, must beat it by
2.5% to be equal
Cash position earns low returns
Transaction costs
Manager focused on
“Performance”
21
Tax Efficiency
Capital Gains distributed to holders
Holders pay the tax
No control, just tax liability
Unrealized Capital Gains
i. e. MSFT on original IPO
AIC Advantage BRK.A at $3500
4th Qtr purchase = year’s liability
22
10 yr Pre & Post Tax
Returns (US )
Pre-Tax
(%)
Post Tax
(%)
Vanguard
Gwth & Inc
17.92
14.96
Fidelity
Magellan
18.48
15.47
Dodge $ Cox
Income
8.35
5.60
23
Don’t Worry
No big deal, you don’t have to worry about risking your life
savings, “We do that for you.”
24
Gold, Frankincense
and MER
Most certain aspect
Distinctly “negative” aspect
Effective mgmt=enhanced returns
Do Loads & Fees matter?
ABSOLUTELY
25
The Money Machine
How the mutual fund Industry works
Daniel Stoffman
Page 220
Should I buy individual stocks as
well as, or instead of mutual
funds?
If you've read this far, you've
probably figured this out for
yourself.
26
DRIP Defined
Dividends are not paid to holder
Money buys additional shares
Additional shares yield dividend
These dividends create additional
shares
Thus the Dividend Effect
27
Dividend Effect
dividend growth - 4% annually
Year
1
2
5
10
12
Dividend
$5.50
$5.72
$6.43
$7.83
$8.47
28
Effect of Increasing
Dividends
Year
1
5
10
25
Price (8%)
$10.00
$14.64
$21.59
$68.48
Dividend (4%) Yield on Cost
0.25
0.30
0.37
0.66
2.50 %
3.04 %
3.70 %
6.66 %
29
Hawaiian Electric (HE)
Year
Avg
Price
Div Shares
Rate Owned
Value
1988
$29.75
$1.95 358.17 $10,665
1994
$33.20
$2.33 518.20 $17,204
1999
$36.00
$2.48 712.91 $25,665
30
HE, no DRIP
31
HE, DRIP
32
HE Chart
33
HE Long Term
34
Dividends &
Capital Growth
1952, farmer retired with $100,000
Invested in CSBs
1983 son “What if BMO in 52”
BMO, 3400 shares in 1952
1983, with splits 17,000 shares
worth $456,875
Ignoring Dividends of $410,993
35
Dividends &
Capital Growth
Barron’s Article April 1999
$100 invested in S&P 500 in 1925
1999 would be $9,600
With DRIP
$235,000
36
Dividend Growth
Year
BNS
BC Gas
1989
0.44
0.74
1994
0.58
0.90
2001
$1.21
$1.30
37
BMO no DRIP
38
BMO with DRIP
39
BMO with
DRIP+$50/mth OCP
40
BCE no DRIP
41
BCE with DRIP
42
BCE with DRIP Today
43
BCE DRIP with
$50/mth OCP
44
XOM no DRIP
45
XOM with DRIP
46
Cemil Otar’s DRIP
Company
June 1990
April 2001
Alcan
$166.66
$538
BNS
$166.66
$1,624
Aliant
$166.66
$1,104
Nortel
$166.66
$274
TRP
$166.66
$339
TransAlta
$166.66
$782
$1,000.00
$4,706
Total
47
Cemil’ DRIP Summary
Cemil’s DRIP
15.10%
Avg Canadian Dividend Fund
10.40%
Avg Canadian Equity Fund
9.30%
TSE 300
9.10%
48
The 5% DRIP Advantage
Some cos offer a 5% discount on
DRIPs and OCP
netstockdirect.com-115 US cos
Canadian Companies
MDS & W (5% on DRIPS)
TD (2.5% on DRIPs)
TA (5% on DRIPs & OCP)
49
Cdn Cos Paying
Dividends Shrinking
1981 - 100 cos
1991 - 80 cos
2000 - 60 cos
2001 - 57 cos
50
US Cos Paying
Dividends
Over 1,600 cos with DRIPs
40% have DSPs
60%, one share registered in your
name
51
DRIP Advantages
Can invest small or large amount
Compounding dividend increases
Stock price appreciation
Dollar Cost Averaging (OCP)
Basically Fee Free (50% of US co)
Stable Shareholder Base
Inexpensive Source of Equity $$$
52
Dollar Cost Averaging
Fixed $$ amount each wk/mth/qtr
Yields average entry price over a
longer period
53
DRIP Disadvantages
Can be Cancelled by Company
Inability to Time Market
Minimum OCP Amounts
Fees are Increasing (US)
Dividends are Taxable
Tracking Adjusted Cost Base
Odd Lots from mergers
54
Getting Started
Most difficult to do-INERTIA
Once begun-ADDICTIVE
55
Methods
Direct Investing
Single Shares
Stockbrokers (Discount)
Synthetic DRIPs
On-Line Synthetic DRIPS
56
Direct Investing
600+US cos and 280 foreign cos
www.netstockdirect.com
No Canadian companies
Print Enrollment Form (Internet)
Complete and Mail Cheque
“Drawn From US Bank”
AFL, AXP, PFE, PG, XOM
57
Single Share
Most Plans, One Share to Enroll
Buy from a Friend
Deregistered from their name
Registered to your name
Buy as Group of Five
Transfer registration to individuals
58
Adjusted Cost Base
59
Stockbrokers
Buy Shares Through Broker
Pay Commission $28.95
Have Shares Registered to Your
Name - $30.00 Fee
Shares Arrive, Contact TA
Request Drip & SPP Enroll Forms
Complete & Return
60
Synthetic DRIP
Offered by Brokerage Firms
Selected Shares Only (check)
Only Whole Shares (no partial)
TOC quarterly $0.175
TOC $52 requires 298 shares
Additional Purchase = Commission
61
On-Line Synthetic DRIPs
Sharebuider
Buy Shares in Fixed $$ Amount
Weekly or Monthly
Partial Shares Allowed
Selection of 4,000 cos
$US4/Trade
Canadians Not Eligible
NAFTA
62
How Many Companies?
Six to Twelve companies selected
from different Sectors
Buy “QUALITY”
Twelve + is best
Canadian Holdings
AL, BCE, BNS, DFS, MDS, TA
US Holdings
ABT, AXP, JNJ, KO, PFE, XOM
63
What & When to Buy
When $$$ are available
Invest in your “poorest performer”
Buy Low - Sell High
64
In Summary
Frictional Costs
DRIP
Power of Dividends
Efficiency
Simplicity
Getting Started
65